Old hardware guy, new system... opinions?

bruenor

Gawd
Joined
Aug 23, 2005
Messages
674
OK, I've been out of the hands-on computer building for some time since I now focus primarily on networks for work and fun. My current system is actually still doing well, but it is just time to upgrade. My needs are fairly basic: Art (graphics tablet work), Power efficient (runs 24x7), Gaming (infrequent but I like to play when I do and at mid-high settings), and within a fairly tight budget. I have ZERO plans for overclocking or SLI. I was thinking of going with a mATX motherboard to save power, space, and money. I run a 19" widescreen LCD at 1440x800.

I have been scouring Newegg and the items I keep going to are: either the AMD 5000+ BE or 5400+ or the Intel 6750 for CPU. Torn between 8500/8600gt and 2600 pro or XT. I have no clue as to the modern chipsets and which brands are now top... I was guessing P35 on Intel and no idea on the AM2 side. I was looking at Gigabyte, MSI, and Asus... but I like underdogs like Foxconn, ASrock, etc. 2GB of DDR2 800 CL4. and the rest I'm cool on.

I'm up for suggestions and info and anything anyone has to say. There are so many chipsets and models now that it is a bit daunting. I have build thousands of systems though up to about the P3/AMD XP days, but then my system building days ended and I'm behind the times now.
 
OCing right now is dead stupid easy, and not doing it with the C2D line is a lot like throwing money away. When you can get a $90 chip that'll do 3+Ghz happily and rock solid stable or a $220 chip that'll do 4+Ghz the same, why not take advantage of this? With speedstep and halt states you're only drawing more power when you need it. It's literally two settings changes -- bump vcore up a little bit and raise the FSB. You're done.

Better off spending the extra $20 over the E6750 for the E8400. The E6750 is a 65nm part, the E8400 a 45nm part, so it runs cooler and clocks better to boot. Those things seem to be good to 4+ Ghz, from what I'm seeing. You'll need a nice aftermarket heatsink, of course, since the 45nm chips come with an even smaller stock HSF which is pretty much useless for OCing.

AMD is really only good right now if you're going low budget. Intel chips OC better and are faster clock for clock without being a great deal more expensive.

Ideally you're going to want something better than the 8600 or 2600 can offer. The bare minimum I'd recommend for gaming at medium-high settings would be an ATI Radeon HD 3850 at around $150 AR. It's a great deal faster than either of the cards you were looking at for not much more money, and it can normally be overclocked to near Radeon HD 3870 speeds. If you can find a 512MB 3850 within budget, all the better. The price to performance king right now is the Nvidia 8800 GT 512MB, but that's likely more than you were looking to spend.

mATX there really aren't P35 boards, but there are still some fairly good overclockers. You'll have to wait for someone that worries more about small form factor systems for that, though. Mid tower is about as small as I tend to go. ;)


If you do decide to go full ATX, there are a lot of really nice boards in the $90-100 range, such as the Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3L, Abit IP35-E, and DFI Blood Iron P35-TR2L (my personal favorite in that range -- 6 SATA vs the other's 4, RAID support, good OCing options).

Corsair PSUs are very popular right now. The 550VX (non-modular) can get down to $65 or so AR, and the 520HX (modular) $75-80. Depending on GPU you may even be OK with the 450VX, though the price difference between it and the 550VX is very small anymore. They're all Seasonic built units, but most agree that it's worth the small price premium (and in some cases after rebate you actually pay less) to deal with Corsair rather than Seasonic should the supply ever give up the ghost. 5 year warranties on the Corsairs, too.
 
Silent-Circuit gave you some great advice/suggestions.

If you still don't want to OC, no worries... just don't buy a Black Edition AMD X2, lol; since they dont' come with a HSF and are mainly good for OC'ing (unlocked multiplier) -- they still can't OC as well as the Intel counterparts.

As for mATX boards... For Intel, theres the Intel G33 based boards (eg. Gigabyte GA-G33M-DS2R) or the Intel G35 based boards (eg. Asus P5E-VM HDMI (if you plan on turning this system into an HTPC now or later)). For AMD, there's the AMD 690G chipset boards (eg. Gigabyte GA-MA69GM-S2H), and the GeForce 7000 series chipset boards (eg. Biostar TForce TF7050-M2).

What's your budget, and what is included in that budget?
 
Thanks for the replies so far. I am aware of the current state of OC'ing and while it is an option I tend to buy a CPU that is at or around the performance I need stock and go to a mild mid-level OC as it ages. Again, my system needs to run truly 24x7 and much of that time it is idle or low load so OC'ing really buys me nothing.

I have a system mocked up now as follows:

Intel 6750 C2D
GIGABYTE GA-P35-DS3L
pqi POWER Series 4GB(2 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800
HIS Hightech H260XTF256DDN-R Radeon HD 2600XT 256MB 128-bit GDDR3
Rosewill RZS01 BLK Black SGCC Steel ATX Mid Tower Case

(I have the rest... 2x500GB HDD's, A 20x DVD-rw w/lightscribe, and a Thermaltake Purepower 420watt PSU that I think should handle this new system fine, although it has only one 12v rail... but again opinions welcome.)

My price after one rebate is ~$450 and I wanted to stay around $400-500.

I had thought of going with the Intel 2180 CPU instead and a mild OC, or possibly bump up to the Q2C for an extra $50-60 which is still in reach but I'm not sure if the benefit is really there. I kinda like the fact that the Intel 6750 speed is perfectly a match to the FSB.

Thanks to all!
 
Don't buy an E6750 right now. If you buy high end dual core an 8xxx chip is the only way to go right now. Either drop down to the E2xxx, get an E8xxx, or the Q6600. The E6750 is end of life, and it's not substantially cheaper than the E8400.
 
i will edit this post in a sec to elaborate more, however i would like to offer my suggestions as someone who just put a system together last month.

first off scour the hot deals thread, I have saved tons of money that way, i jumped on the 4gb of ocz ram for 55AR. I can't stress the enough especially if you are not in an immediate hurry.

second, this allows you to bump up other areas for the computer. i do mostly 3d work and graphics aside from straight up gaming. that being said i have the 6750 and it runs great... quad core is great for rendering, but honestly, that extra cash may be better spent on an 8800gt for what you like to do.
 
Thanks, I had no idea about the E8xxx line of chips. The 8300 is right in line pricewise with the 6750 and much lower power reqs and a bit speedier. I'm not sold on the quad core chips yet and with the massive adoption of the C2Ds I don't see them being much more than a bonus for number crunching for quite some years.
 
Back
Top