Oh Conroe, how concave thou art.

Arcygenical

Fully [H]
Joined
Jun 10, 2005
Messages
25,066
Upon recently tearing apart my setup, I decided to check for the flatness of my conroe IHS...

Needless to say, I wasn't pleased.

conrave.jpg


Now, I guess it comes down to what I enjoy more, my warranty or my temperatures :p
 
Yeah, they suck. If you are going to 3.6 and beyond with that thing, I see many hours of sanding in your future.
 
How do you check the flatness of the IHS? Also, I can't see the picture, could you repost it?
 
I can see the picture. It shows that the IHS doesnt quite mate with his block. On a fresh IHS, all you have to do is look at it to tell it is not flat. If you are lucky, it will be bowed out (convex)so that mounting your cooling block will squish it in. If you are not lucky, it will be caved in (concave) forcing you to fill it with goop. The process of flattening the surface is called lapping. Its done by sanding / grinding / polishing the surface flat. When the surface is polished it is like a mirror. You can check for flatness by reflecting a known reference (graphpaper) into the mirror finish. If it distorts, it is not flat. For these purposes however, since both the IHS and the block are quite flexible, you only need to get it close, but as supplied by Intel, it is way off.
 
Well, I can't tell much by just looking at it. At the edges, it appears to be convex but I can't say about the center... How can I check it in the center?
 
Yeah, it's not the best pic (the really good ones were too blurry).

It's a terrible IHS though :eek:
 
That's convex ("curved out"), not concave ("curved in").
 
lapped my e4300 to 1200 grit, lowered temps 7.5c on the retail heatsink, well worth the time.
 
Best way to chec is with a razor blade.....

Lapping shouldnt take all that long, unless youre going for a mirror finish which is not neccessay, mine took at most 20 minutes, started with 320grit then when it was flat, I switched to 600grit......

I believe that once a cpu is confirmed to be working, then the warranty is not needed anymore...... so as long as you dont kill your cpu while lapping, you should be ok......
 
That's convex ("curved out"), not concave ("curved in").

Nah, it's actually concave on most sides... That's just the only pic that turned out well, and it's convex on that side. It's more like "rippled" or sinusoidal than either concave or convex. If you don't believe me I can put up more pics when I get back to school on sunday :p

And yes, I'm really considering lapping it, as I've got the equipment. I've never had the balls to lap a CPU. I've done every block/HSF I've ever owned though :eek:
 
Back
Top