NVIDIA Trying To Force Itself On Intel?

The 945 is ancient and eats power. I'm sure that even nVidia could do better.
 
NVIDIA's last good chipset was the nForce2, and what a chipset it was. SoundStorm, baby! I wish Atom had a better chipset, though. 945 is way too old, at least give me a PCIe slot to turn an Atom board into a mini-ITX HTPC, the LGA775/AM2 mini-ITX boards alone cost 50-250% more than an Atom combo alone.
 
I think Nvidia is possibly foundering a bit,

Intel has some serious momentum behind it in the chipset (and chip) market, both on the desktop and in the "Netbook" sphere, and Nvidia has some awesome graphics hardware but is only really keeping pace with AMDs stuff

I think the next couple of years are going to be really rough for Nvidia unless it comes up with something really killer, these new efficient chipsets might be it, but I don't think so. maybe CUDA, maybe not. If Intel is really serious about pushing into the graphics field, I wouldn't be too suprised if this decade ends with Nvidia watching AMD and Intel pulling away.
 
Hi, I am Nvidia. We screwed up a lot of chips for hp, dell and alienware. Can we peas haz you bezaness.
 

Anand -
"However, we have no idea if implementation of 1080P/24 fps support will occur. Speaking of driver quality and features, this is one area where Intel is behind AMD and NVIDIA. In addition, platform cost is a problem when looking at the mid to lower range processor market compared to AMD. "

"However, if we had to choose one chipset for primary HTPC usage, it would be the NVIDIA GeForce 8200. The GF8200 offers 8-channel LPCM output, no hassle 1080P/24 fps playback capabilities, modest pricing, and a relatively low power envelope when paired with an appropriate processor such as the Phenom X3 8750 or Phenom X4 9350e."

And that was vs. nVidia's 8000 series. The 9000 series is even better. Thanks for linking them for me.

This is the only real advantage I've found for the G45:
"The G45 does one thing that NV's 8000 series has trouble with and AMD's 780G can't do: it can send LPCM audio out of their HDMI port. AMD's 780G is stuck with 2.0 channels unless you get the Gigabyte board (which is highly suggested) since it can do "DTS Live" meaning it can take the audio stream, say a TrueHD 7.1 audio track, and decode it and re-encode it on the fly into 5.1 DTS and then send it over to the HDMI port to send out. NV's 8000 series can send LCPM audio but users over at the AVSforum, last time I checked, were having issues getting it working correctly."

Thanks CrimandEvil.

The G45 is fine (although more expensive than similar AMD solutions) for HD playback, and not much else. But that's its intended platform so no foul. The 9000 series still beats it when paired with atom when it comes to performance/power consumption/price all factored together, which is the key in the tiny PC market that's up and coming. I run a P45 based system now, and I'll be darned if I ever base one of my "enthusiast" builds on a stupid nVidia motherboard again, but Anand's review of nVidia's Ion looks mighty impressive. If you wanna say they're nVidiots, fine. The Ion still looks pretty slick, and I cant wait to get one to play with. I would still go AMD for an HTPC, but I don't see any pairings of the 3200 series with Atom processors, and Intel's offerings right now don't match up as well as Ion right now either. I'm sure they will put something out, but for now Ion looks like the best implemented solution so far.

About the 9000 series:
"The benchmarks reveal: Intel's IGP is outclassed by the new Geforce GPUs. The latter ones at least reach the performance level of former low-cost cards like the 8400 GS or Radeon HD 3450. Another problem of the GMA X4500 is the driver quality: Assassin's Creed and Race Driver Grid don't even start at all. But nevertheless the G45 is a bit more power efficient.

Nvidia's new chips do their job as designated low-cost accelerators. Even the power of the Geforce 9300 - even without dedicated VRAM - is enough to beat a Radeon HD 3450 in most game benchmarks. In cooperation with a Geforce 8500 GT the performance is increased by about 20 to 70 percent, but micro stuttering is caused, too. The Geforce 9400 is, regardless of the higher clock speed, only slightly faster than the 9300. There is a simple reason for this: The memory bandwidth and the memory latencies slow both GPUs down. We will deliver tests with higher memory clock speeds and overclocked GPUs soon.

In matters of HD acceleration the IGPs and the low-cost graphics cards deliver a similar quality and a noticeable load removal from the CPU. "
- From PC Gaming Hardware

According to Guru3D the nVidia platform also has this going for it:
"the GF9300 based mainboards will be a flexible solution, and not just for the budget minded. It performs as fast as any modern mainboard, you can make it a gaming rig, you can use it excellently for HTPC and if it floats your boat, it's a nice NET PC as well. I also think it's lovely we can use the integrated GPU, if not utilized for graphics, for CUDA, transcoding, PhysX and whatever new applications we'll see in the future... So I think ECS did a really nice job with this Black Edition version of the GF9300. The design looks great, and you get some extra features which boil down to additional value."

The Cuda and PhysX rubbish is very much YMMV, but what does intel have to offer that competes? The 9300 boards are too expensive now, but we will see them come down, and the Ion is supposedly going to be very cheap. Heavens know the Atom is cheap. I think it's putting two things together that will compliment each other well, and if Intel comes out with something similar that beats it, thanks to nVidia for putting the pressure on them to do so in the first place. Win/win for all.
 
My first choice would be a 9300 based board because Intel has been rather dreadful with their drivers/BIOS updates since the G965 IGP (which was also highly toted by them for it's "great" HD playback ability) but I do have to say that some of the recent updates have finally made the G45 a decent enough board for HTPC use. Not great compared to NV and AMD's offerings but still a decent choice for those looking only at Intel boards.

I'd rather go with a 9300 based board myself.
 
My first choice would be a 9300 based board because Intel has been rather dreadful with their drivers/BIOS updates since the G965 IGP (which was also highly toted by them for it's "great" HD playback ability) but I do have to say that some of the recent updates have finally made the G45 a decent enough board for HTPC use. Not great compared to NV and AMD's offerings but still a decent choice for those looking only at Intel boards.

I'd rather go with a 9300 based board myself.

Especially after seeing this:
http://www.hardwarezone.com/articles/view.php?cid=6&id=2732&pg=11
 

At the time Intel's boards had a bad BIOS on them that disabled hardware acceleration so this is no suprised. It does show what I've been saying though about the older 7000 series boards being shit for an HTPC (due to their single channel memory config).

But yeah, run today with the newest drivers and BIOS and Intel would have a bit lower CPU usage but not as good as the 9000 series.
 
Not a good idea especiallt since evga boards (Which only uses nvidia or as far as i know) has may too many errors.
 
Back
Top