NVIDIA Trying To Force Itself On Intel?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
According to DigiTimes, the general manager of NVIDIA’s MCP business is making the rounds in Taiwan trying to get PC makers to force Intel to allow NVIDIA chipsets for the Atom platform. Does that seem like a good idea to anyone?

Henry pointed out that Atom processors have a high price/performance ratio, but said that, in his opinion, limiting them to 945GSE and 945GC chipsets will only limit future development. Therefore Nvidia hopes to work with PC makers to form a platform combining its MCP7A or MCP79 chipsets with Atom processors to significantly boost the graphics performance of netbooks and nettops.
 
I don't think Intel will allow this quietly.

The Atom is a good performing, inexpensive processor/chipset pair. If allowed to go 'generic' it could cut into Intels profits on more expensive lines.

That's my guess...
 
Death to Nvidia chipsets! They should focus on thier GPUs and quit with thier flaky half ass chipsets.
 
Not sure is it will happen...it might. I can see why nvidia is pushing for it, but me thinks it's a fool's errand. It's like Ford asking Chevy to use their rear axles....oh wait I already have a 9in Ford rear in one of my Chevy's.
 
I can't see anyone forcing Intel to do anything,least of all Nvidia.I think antagonizing them the way they have was a big mistake.
 
Upon reading the actual article, yes, yes it does sound like a very good idea. No reason Intel should force vendors to bundle chips/mainboards when there's plenty of competition.
 
The nvidia chipsets, as mentioned above, have been very problematic for me. I think intel should start making SLI compatible chipsets and let nvidia make GPU's and drivers for them.
 
The last good nvidia chipset I had was the 590 on AMD side. The 680/780I on intel side sucked.

It's time for nvidia to quit on chipsets and move on.
 
Death to Nvidia chipsets! They should focus on thier GPUs and quit with thier flaky half ass chipsets.


totally agree with you.. after my m2n-sli board.. ill never buy a nvidia chipset board again!
 
Wow nvm after reading that anandtech article this actually seems very cool
 
Upon reading the actual article, yes, yes it does sound like a very good idea. No reason Intel should force vendors to bundle chips/mainboards when there's plenty of competition.
On one hand, yes, this might be an example of tying, an anti-competitive business practice. Tying and forcing the purchase of an unwanted product along with a desired product.

On the other hand, it shouldn't be Intel's responsibility to support an nVidia chipset. And if the nVidia chipset sucks, and has stability issues, guess who's Intel Inside sticker is branded on it. The actual CPU gets a lot more notice than the chipset in consumer's eyes. nVidia's garbage could damage Intel's brand image.
 
When your chipset has 4x the TDP of your CPU you know it's time for something better..

The Atom has a TDP of 2.5W and the 945GSE has a 11.8W TDP.

That little Nvidia box is pretty darn smart.

Riley
 
When your chipset has 4x the TDP of your CPU you know it's time for something better..

The Atom has a TDP of 2.5W and the 945GSE has a 11.8W TDP.

That little Nvidia box is pretty darn smart.

Riley
Agreed, the 945G chipset is a 2006 product, like early, as in January 2006 according to wiki. 2 year old tech, being paired with their latest and greatest. Does seem like Intel could have done better.
 
I think intel should start making SLI compatible chipsets and let nvidia make GPU's and drivers for them.

This already technically exists. Intel won't license SLI technology to enable in chipsets but there is nothing saying the crossfire compatible(really just 2x pci-e x16) chipsets wont work for SLI besides nvidia's chipset/key detection.

i7 is a different beast...
 
Intel will eventually integrate everything including graphics and memory controller into the Atom chip itself. This will reduce the power consumption of the platform significantly.

The current Atom platform is just a stopgap solution until this happens.
 
Wow nvm after reading that anandtech article this actually seems very cool

Yes, yes it does. Then again I'm very receptive to this kind of talk about Atom. An Atom 330 paired with a decent H264 acclerating chipset would be an incredible pair and, after reading the Anand article, moving to a two chip design allows the combo to be made even smaller!

Honestly, I wouldn't be surprised now if Apple used NV's Atom platform for their new Mac Mini. :)
 
I don't know what's with the nVidia chipset hate. I've owned nVidia boards for quite some times now with no issue. My current one included.

But while some of you might be against nVidia's chipsets due to bad experiences, I still think Intel should let them in for competitive reasons. Intel boards are enjoying high prices because of lack of competitions. If it wasn't for AMD, their CPU cost would be insane as well.
 
I don't know what's with the nVidia chipset hate. I've owned nVidia boards for quite some times now with no issue. My current one included.

But while some of you might be against nVidia's chipsets due to bad experiences, I still think Intel should let them in for competitive reasons. Intel boards are enjoying high prices because of lack of competitions. If it wasn't for AMD, their CPU cost would be insane as well.

Hell, I want an NV chipset with an Atom for the simple reason that Intel doesn't seem up to the task of giving Atom a damn decent chipset that could at least decode HD video... or at least supports DVI out. :rolleyes:
 
Competition seems like a good thing to me.

I'm okay with Nvidia making Intel chipsets (even if a lot of consumers think they're pretty terrible), because it's the only viable way a half-decent IGP is going to come to Intel platform [before Larrabee]. AMD/ATI certainly isn't making them anymore.

Overall, I like Nvidia products, but I think that's more of a result to several excellent experiences with EVGA than with Nvidia itself.
 
I'd love a Nvidia Chipset for the atom or just a newer more power efficient chipset for the Atom, but GL to Nvidia. After Nvidia didn't let Intel use SLI on the C2D chipsets I'm thinking Intel will want to return the favor this time around.
 
I'd love a Nvidia Chipset for the atom or just a newer more power efficient chipset for the Atom, but GL to Nvidia. After Nvidia didn't let Intel use SLI on the C2D chipsets I'm thinking Intel will want to return the favor this time around.

Turnabout's fair play. Intel won't let nVidia make chipsets for Intel processors. So why should nVidia let them have the SLI technology?
 
Competition seems like a good thing to me.

I'm okay with Nvidia making Intel chipsets (even if a lot of consumers think they're pretty terrible), because it's the only viable way a half-decent IGP is going to come to Intel platform [before Larrabee]. AMD/ATI certainly isn't making them anymore.

Intel won't let them make chipsets any more once they merged with AMD.
 
That tiny little box looked awesome. I bet with a die shrink you could have these two in a friggen pocket pc (phone)... yeah baby! 2ghz phone with geforce 9400 graphics.
 
Intel won't let them make chipsets any more once they merged with AMD.

Quite the opposite, AMD forced ATi to stop making intel chipsets, for obvious reasons.

I think nvidia should be allowed to make chipsets for intel processor quite simply for market fairness, let the market determine which product is better.

The reason why I believe Intel won't let NV produce chipsets for QPI processors is the same reason that nvidia AMD chipsets kicked so much ass. Because they don't have to deal with the memory controller, no memory controller, less in the actual chipset that can give you problems, the greater chance of success that nvidia can make a quality chipset and undercut intel with it. That goes double with IGP chipsets.
 
Turnabout's fair play. Intel won't let nVidia make chipsets for Intel processors. So why should nVidia let them have the SLI technology?

I thought it was the other way around. Nvidia makes the 680/780/790 chipsets for Intel C2D, but didn't let Intel use SLI in their chipsets. Good idea since this would force anyone who wants SLI to buy a Nvidia based board. Bad idea because Intel turned around cut Nvidia out of making chipsets for the i7. Now Nvidia is in a tough spot, they can't make chipsets for the i7 and they can't really make chipsets for AMD because ATI is with AMD now. So if they want to sell two or three cards to users they need to license SLI to Intel. Hence the Intel i7 chipset now support SLI.
 
Quite the opposite, AMD forced ATi to stop making intel chipsets, for obvious reasons.
No, after AMD bought ATI Intel said that it would let ATI's bus license expire, for obvious reasons. The last ATI/Intel chipset was the X1250 and pretty much only two companies (that I can remember) made a s775 board using it: Abit and Foxconn.

Intel wouldn't let them buy a new bus license.
 
How quickly we forget about nForce/2/3/4

Man, I loved my NF2 and NF4 boards. I also remember that it took Intel ages to finally grant NV a bus license so that they could release Intel boards too (only remember because I was waiting for this to happen).
 
Wow, Ion is sexy! I want that pico-PC, I don't care how ugly they think it is! It's actually small enough that I could just tape it on the side of my TV, and I'd never have to see it!

Beats the hell out of 780G+ITX... :(
 
Wow, Ion is sexy! I want that pico-PC, I don't care how ugly they think it is! It's actually small enough that I could just tape it on the side of my TV, and I'd never have to see it!

Beats the hell out of 780G+ITX... :(

And at a fraction of the price of it too!
 
And at a fraction of the price of it too!


I'm going to build one of these into my car. It already has an integrated LCD screen in the dash. Screw optical media, too. Everything's going on an SSD for the OS and music collection. 30GB drives are to be found on the cheap nowadays. I'll attach bluetooth, a PC based GPS receiver, wifi, and integrate a USB port in my dash (or SD slot) for movies. This thing is gonna be AWESOME.
 
I'm going to build one of these into my car. It already has an integrated LCD screen in the dash. Screw optical media, too. Everything's going on an SSD for the OS and music collection. 30GB drives are to be found on the cheap nowadays. I'll attach bluetooth, a PC based GPS receiver, wifi, and integrate a USB port in my dash (or SD slot) for movies. This thing is gonna be AWESOME.

I gotta post an afterthought since there's no edit button. The wifi will work straight from the driveway, so I can just stream the whole entire library, or selected music wirelessly from my HTPC where all the music is shared. Since it will be connected to the internet, I'll just authorize my new car PC to play the whole iTunes library. Vista networking will make syncing a snap. This thing is going to freaking ROCK. We hop in the car and warm it up for a trip. While we're packing and letting it warm up, we click on the TV shows/movies we want to sync for the trip. They wirelessly (via my excellent N router and Gigabyte ethernet to the HTPC/media server) copy to the 30GB SSD and boom, we're ready for the trip. My son can watch movies and my wife can watch her TV shows and listen to the internet. Screw optical media and USB/flash ports! WiFi FTW. Would still be nice to have a card reader so when we're on a trip we can see pictures on the screen after taking them.

I haven't been so excited about something like this in a long time. This is going to be one of the funnest projects in the world, and not even expensive. My CAR will freaking run Windows Vista and I will play HD and SD movies in 640x480 (I think ... might be a little lower ...) on the integrated LCD display. It will have bluetooth for my cellphone, WiFi, a GPS ... OMGosh.... I can't wait for these to come out.
 
Same as the new Macbook huh? Match that with the Inq's article today about the reliability of nVidia's manufacurering...
http://www.theinquirer.net/inquirer/news/052/1050052/nvidia-chips-show-underfill-problems

And no wonder Intel wouldn't want their name to closely associated...

Please repeat 100 times "I shall not quote Charlie Demerjian on anything to do with Nvidia because he's probably talking C**P".

I have no idea about the reliability of nvidia's manufacturing, but I am very confident any article written by Charlie about nvidia will have a huge negative bias.
 
no more nvidia for me as well. i prefer ati/intel chipsets from here on out.
 
NVIDIA can blame themselfes for this.
They hardball'ed Intel regarding SLI.

Now Intel returns the favour.
No NVIDIA chipset for Intel's i7.
No NVIDIA chipset for Intels Atom.
Larrabee next year.

Intel is just "repaying" NVIDIA...
 
Hey I don't agree with what NVIDIA is trying to do here but I gotta say that Nvidia did come out with a decent chipset in the 650i. It has run pretty damn well and I can still overclock the newer dual core wolfdales. Its been stable even with SLI enabald. Good cheap overclockable buggers the 650i was and still is :D
 
Hey I don't agree with what NVIDIA is trying to do here but I gotta say that Nvidia did come out with a decent chipset in the 650i. It has run pretty damn well and I can still overclock the newer dual core wolfdales. Its been stable even with SLI enabald. Good cheap overclockable buggers the 650i was and still is :D

No NVIDIA chipset comes close to Intels counterparts in stablity IMHO.
 
Back
Top