NVIDIA GTS 240 - This is getting old

Would you buy a GTS 240?

  • Yes, as long as they make it cheaper than before

    Votes: 25 15.0%
  • Yes, it is still a good card even though it is old

    Votes: 10 6.0%
  • No, give me real innovation

    Votes: 86 51.5%
  • No, was good when it came out, but not now

    Votes: 46 27.5%

  • Total voters
    167
Bah, hoping the gts240 will have a FTW edition for more immersive game play and a bit more performance for the true gamer's eye. As long as Joe the plumber can play his games well, i don't think he loses sleep at night if he can't use full 24xAA and 64xAF in games at 5120x2400 resolution on his IMAX monitor. So I agree, average Joe won't care, but average computer geek would.
 
So wait...first you claim that 9800GTX is a straight up die shrink of 8800 GTX and now you're trying to evade this whole argument all together because 24" LCD owners represent a small percentage of the market and nv/ati don't have them in mind when they release these type of cards. Sure 8800GTS when it first launched brought some serious performance for a lot lower price vs 8800GTX/ultra but its still not the same card/chip with the same capabilities. And with the 65nm die size and smaller memory interface Im sure nvidia made a boatload of money of those cards when they launched.

If you dont get it by now, you wont ever. Move along.

The naming scheme makes sense in terms of performance, but Joe might think he's getting new tech when he buys his GTS 250, since it sounds as if the card is related to the GT200, no one would ever guess it's related to the G92.

Does it really matter?
No, since he's probably going to be paying the same price (or less) for the GTS 250 when compared to the 9800GTX, but he might be under the illusion that the GTS 250 is "new". And that's where the problem is, some people will think the GTS 250 is a new card.

What does it matter what he thinks hes getting? Hes not getting ripped off, in any way, shape, or form.
 
I see no valid reason for them to rename a GPU with a new number when for all intensive purposes it's the same thing.
 
What does it matter what he thinks hes getting? Hes not getting ripped off, in any way, shape, or form.
Because the GTS 250 looks like it's part of the same family as the GTX 280?
It's misleading.

Sure, it makes sense in terms of performance.
Sure, the customer isn't getting ripped off (Same price as the 9800GTX).

Personally, I'm split on the issue.

On one hand, it's nice to help the uneducated customers decide which card's performance is right for them, based on a simple 3-digit number. On this issue, I'm giving Nvidia the benefit of the doubt, because a card's price should be a good indicator where the card stands in terms of performance. You don't necessarily have to look at a naming scheme to figure out where the card stands relative to other cards.

On the other hand it's not right, because the cards aren't related in the way the name implies.

However, just because you support the idea of rebranding the cards, don't ignore the cons just to help prove your point. People will buy this card thinking it's new tech, and it's not. That's bad, period. If you're going to pretend that concept isn't a problem, then you shouldn't be involved in this discussion anyway. Misleading the customers is definitely not appropriate, regardless of which side you stand on.

I'd rather Nvidia just leave the names alone, since having one card with three names (8800GS, 9600GSO, GTS 130) is unacceptable.
 
well at least with ATi's simple and straight forward

you have the 1x00 cards, the 2x00 cards, the 3x00 cards, and the 4x00 cards..,

with series of card you know exactly what technology it is based upon and what you are getting......

Nvidia is trying to get their cards all lined up by ATi but they are mixing in cards that really should not be.......
 
its just a way to get the semi-enthusiast into buying the wrong card... not everyone reads tech articles every day.

Er...no. It's just a way to rename existing products, with the new naming scheme, so that it isn't even more confusing to browse for graphics cards and have "GTX 280, GTX 260, 9800 GTX" into the wild and guessing which one is better. With these renames, every single card will have the GTX xxx, GTS xxx suffix and no longer use the old naming scheme.
 
The naming scheme makes sense in terms of performance, but Joe might think he's getting new tech when he buys his GTS 250, since it sounds as if the card is related to the GT200, no one would ever guess it's related to the G92.

Does it really matter?
No, since he's probably going to be paying the same price (or less) for the GTS 250 when compared to the 9800GTX, but he might be under the illusion that the GTS 250 is "new". And that's where the problem is, some people will think the GTS 250 is a new card.

LOL, these arguments are hilarious :p

"Joe" IS getting something new. It's not like a GTS 250 is a used card, that will be sold as new. The fact that the card uses a chip that's over a year old, only says that even today that chip is potent enough to compete with the current cards in the same price range, which is excellent for the manufacturer (in this case NVIDIA), because the lead they had over ATI, when they launched G80 and G92, was tremendous. It doesn't matter how old the chip in the card is. What matters is performance and in the price range of the GTS 240 and GTS 250, the performance is there. No one is being deceived. The fact of the matter is that G92 is quite capable against any RV770 chip with GDDR3, so there's no problem here, except for those that like to make a storm over a glass of water...
 
Because the GTS 250 looks like it's part of the same family as the GTX 280?
It's misleading.

A naming scheme doesn't necessarily define a "family" of cards, that use the same chip. It basically just defines performance hierarchy...Which one is easier for "Joe" (and everyone else actually, enthusiast or not):

This ?

GTX 295 > GTX 285 > GTX 280 > GTX 260 216 > GTX 260 > 9800 GTX > 9800 GT > 9600 GT...etc

Or this ?

GTX 295 > GTX 285 > GTX 280 > GTX 260 216 > GTX 260 > GTS 250 > GTS 240 > GTS 230...etc

UtopiA said:
On the other hand it's not right, because the cards aren't related in the way the name implies.

But they are, because again, a naming scheme defines performance hierarchy and not necessarily correlate with the codename of the chip inside the cards...

UtopiA said:
However, just because you support the idea of rebranding the cards, don't ignore the cons just to help prove your point. People will buy this card thinking it's new tech, and it's not. That's bad, period. If you're going to pretend that concept isn't a problem, then you shouldn't be involved in this discussion anyway. Misleading the customers is definitely not appropriate, regardless of which side you stand on.

Because you say it's misleading, doesn't make it misleading. It's a name change, to be consistent with the new naming scheme. That's all. You and others seem to be mad that a chip over a year old, is still able to compete today, with cards in the same price range. I find that hilarious, because one thing has nothing to do with the other. If the performance is there and there are absolutely no down sides in terms of image quality, Joe Average (and everyone else) is getting what they're paying for.

Also, I don't think anyone supports rebranding, but it's a common practice in the industry. Everyone does it, from NVIDIA; to ATI and AMD to Intel, so we have to live with it. People just often forget about their favorite companies practices, in order to bash other companies doing the same.
 
yeah it's old but their strategy still works. We all know when a refresh occurs so those that keep in the "know" SHOULD overlook these minor marketing ploys. They will continue to happen as long as people need cards at these price segments.
 
Nvidia fan club spin : 'here's last year's model car, with 2009 sticker slapped on it."

Just fyi to anyone getting the misinformation in this thread from Nvidia fan clubbers, ATI renamed the r600 to the HD2000s line and another which I forget after the 9000 era, ATI has NEVER I repeat has never rebranded the same product and slapped a new sticker on it and released as something else. Let alone 3x from 8 series, to 9 series, to GTS 240 awesomeness. All the spin in this thread and downplaying is pretty revealing ....:p/popcorn.

Found this in another forum haha enjoy : http://largon.wippiespace.com/recidia_final.svg
 
Nvidia fan club spin : 'here's last year's model car, with 2009 sticker slapped on it."

Just fyi to anyone getting the misinformation in this thread from Nvidia fan clubbers, ATI renamed the r600 to the HD2000s line and another which I forget after the 9000 era, ATI has NEVER I repeat has never rebranded the same product and slapped a new sticker on it and released as something else. Let alone 3x from 8 series, to 9 series, to GTS 240 awesomeness. All the spin in this thread and downplaying is pretty revealing ....:p/popcorn.

Found this in another forum haha enjoy : http://largon.wippiespace.com/recidia_final.svg

Yes...never :rolleyes:

http://ati.amd.com/products/MobilityRadeonhd2300/specs.html

This is NOT r600 based, yet it received the new naming scheme. Wow, we should create a gazillion threads to complain about that...:rolleyes:

And you did mention the 9000 era too, so there you go.

http://techreport.com/articles.x/12458/9

The rest of the Radeon HD family is slated to join the 2900 XT on store shelves on July 1. AMD also has plans for a full mobility lineup based on Radeon HD tech, and those parts are due in July, as well. You may see the Mobility Radeon HD 2300 kicking around before then, but it's not a DX10-capable part. Kind of like the Radeon 9000 back in the day, it's an older 3D core being pulled into a new naming scheme.

It wasn't "NEVER" after all...take the red glasses off...

The difference between the two situations, was that there weren't any extreme fans making a big fuss about something like this. But whatever, keep going at it. It's hilarious to see some people reaching at straws...and for what exactly ? Who knows...

Signing off.
 
We're talking about Mobility chips now ?
ATI chips:
7000,8000,9000,x800,x1000,x2900,HD3800,HD4800
What do you see there? a slight difference in technology to warrant a name change yes? Not the same card rebranded 3x with a 3 different generation names.
Statement still stands. Good day.
 
How many of these threads are enough??

if the card plays your res at the fps you want, then who cares what those crazy chinamen (/or worthless marketing pukes most likely) want to call these things?

I don't think they are trying to trick people, i think most likely they have idiot marketing people who cant make up their mind. Like at many many companies these idiots get so much influence on how a company is presented to the public.
This does not diminish the quality of a product though, and people in this forum should be smart enough to figure it out.
I have an 8800 gt and it still plays every game fine since I dont have a 32 inch monitor. So if they want to call it something else its more their loss than ours, cus they have to sell off the old named stuff cheaper to get it off the shelves.

Bottom line is this card is still fine for 90% of gamers who use 1680 or lower res.

Go outside and stop thinking so hard about someone elses card being named something you don't like. Or lets kill some zombies in left 4 dead, and get down to why most of us build these things anyway!!
 
I remember when ATi's partners, not ATi itself were allowed to lower clock speeds but continue to name the cards the same as the full clocks/reviewed versions.

The buyer had to beware of what he was buying then also. People were not happy about that either.

Do your research and buy or advise based on the user's needs.
 
*Looks at her GF4 MX which is actually a rebadged GF2*

Nothing to see here, move on now :D
 
Back
Top