Nvidia Exec Says Consoles Will Die

What you see these days in the business in general is when wallstreet runs companies (or executives looking to appease wallstreet) instead of people from those industries running those industries. Wallstreet doesn't understand fps. They do understand patents, copyright, lawyers, and buzz words. And that they want to be like Apple.
 
Consoles will die but it won't be due to cloud based gaming, it will be due to phones and tablets.

And I say good riddance. Consoles are pieces of proprietary, locked down garbage that restrict your freedom.
 
Consoles will die but it won't be due to cloud based gaming, it will be due to phones and tablets.

And I say good riddance. Consoles are pieces of proprietary, locked down garbage that restrict your freedom.

Phones and tablets can't do what consoles can, physically anyways.
Their specs just aren't good enough to match them; kind of sad considering the current consoles are on hardware from 2005 and 2006 at best.
 
Phones and tablets can't do what consoles can, physically anyways.
Their specs just aren't good enough to match them; kind of sad considering the current consoles are on hardware from 2005 and 2006 at best.

It is only a matter of time. You should see Dead Trigger on my Infinity Tablet. My tablet already has a better CPU; the PowerPC CPUs powering all three of the major consoles may have a faster clock speed but they are power-hungry, inefficient chips that are limited to in-order execution.
 
"Consoles will die" sounds like he's threatening to go postal at gamestop and take out all the filthy Xboxes with their filthy AMD chips! :D

But cloud based gaming is shitty. He missed most of the main issues:

  • Latency (in the real world is waaay above what they suggest with "evidence"),
  • not owning games,
  • not being able to mod games,
  • losing your entire collection when another cloud service dies,
  • not being able to play anything because your connection died/your bandwidth cap is reached,
  • not being able to play because your housemates are watching Netflix, or are playing a game/downloading porn.
  • not being able to use custom hardware
  • not having access to savegame files to store locally
  • etc. etc.

Great reasons, I think the most effective thing for me is in bold. :p
 
It is only a matter of time. You should see Dead Trigger on my Infinity Tablet. My tablet already has a better CPU; the PowerPC CPUs powering all three of the major consoles may have a faster clock speed but they are power-hungry, inefficient chips that are limited to in-order execution.

LOL, no, your tablet does not have a "faster" processor than Cell, and by faster I mean that it can handle more computations at once, not clock speed.
Maybe you already know this, but there is much much more to a processor than clock speed, and clock for clock ARM and PPC are very different.

Yes, the Cell is very power inefficient, but considering it is from 2006, that's not really a big shocker.
Also, all three consoles have very different processors and though they all may derive from PPC at some point, they all technically are using different variants of that architecture.
 
I'm sure that (supposedly) AMD winning the contracts for all three major next gen consoles has nothing to do with his assessment.
 
LOL, no, your tablet does not have a "faster" processor than Cell, and by faster I mean that it can handle more computations at once, not clock speed.
Maybe you already know this, but there is much much more to a processor than clock speed, and clock for clock ARM and PPC are very different.

Yes, the Cell is very power inefficient, but considering it is from 2006, that's not really a big shocker.
Also, all three consoles have very different processors and though they all may derive from PPC at some point, they all technically are using different variants of that architecture.

The cell may be faster *on paper* but in the real world, it is very different. The PowerPC architecture has always been big on promise and low on actual results precisely because it is a very difficult architecture to write optimized code for. The cell architecture and the SPEs do not make the job of writing optimized code any easier; they, in fact, make it more difficult.
 
The PowerPC architecture has always been big on promise and low on actual results precisely because it is a very difficult architecture to write optimized code for. The cell architecture and the SPEs do not make the job of writing optimized code any easier; they, in fact, make it more difficult.

I fully agree with you on this.
One of the unfortunate aspects of the Cell processor itself.
 
The cell may be faster *on paper* but in the real world, it is very different. The PowerPC architecture has always been big on promise and low on actual results precisely because it is a very difficult architecture to write optimized code for. The cell architecture and the SPEs do not make the job of writing optimized code any easier; they, in fact, make it more difficult.

Add to the fact that what you got from Apple was superior to Cell. There's no Altivec, and the Cell chip is In-Order, unlike X86 chips which have been Out-of-Order for over 10 years. Remember people were able to run Linux on PS3, and benchmarked it to be comparable to low end PowerPC G5. That is of course only the PPC core, and not taking into consideration of the SPE cores on the chip.

Without an easy way to use the SPE's, you might as well have been using a IBM G5, and for a lot of developers that's what they did. They relied more on the Nvidia graphics chip then the Cell chip. Only in extreme and rare situations where the SPE's were actually used well.
 
Add to the fact that what you got from Apple was superior to Cell. There's no Altivec, and the Cell chip is In-Order, unlike X86 chips which have been Out-of-Order for over 10 years. Remember people were able to run Linux on PS3, and benchmarked it to be comparable to low end PowerPC G5. That is of course only the PPC core, and not taking into consideration of the SPE cores on the chip.

Without an easy way to use the SPE's, you might as well have been using a IBM G5, and for a lot of developers that's what they did. They relied more on the Nvidia graphics chip then the Cell chip. Only in extreme and rare situations where the SPE's were actually used well.

QFT
Also, if I remember correctly x86 has had out-of-order execution since the Pentium II, so that would make it over 15 years. ;)

But yes, it was, and still is, unfortunate that the Cell processor is so difficult to code for.
 
According to Eisler, the biggest barrier to cloud-based gaming has thus far been network latency. But the Nvidia exec claims cloud gaming is on the cusp of achieving latency times well below today's average console game.

Now if we could just remove data caps, the 1st world would be a better place.
 
I might've let my console hate get the better of me here, but I decided to post this little tongue-in-cheek rebuttal anyways.
"Consoles will die" sounds like he's threatening to go postal at gamestop and take out all the filthy Xboxes with their filthy AMD chips! :D

But cloud based gaming is shitty. He missed most of the main issues:
  • Latency (in the real world is waaay above what they suggest with "evidence"),
    We're talking about consoles here, where the controls are so terrible you can't even notice the lag
  • not owning games,
    Have you read a EULA lately? You don't own any software.
  • not being able to mod games,
    You can't mod console games anyways, that might eat into DLC sales
  • losing your entire collection when another cloud service dies,
    But you also don't have your favorite game disc become scratched and unreadable after 6 months, forcing you to purchase another copy because your console requires a physical copy to play.
  • not being able to play anything because your connection died/your bandwidth cap is reached,
    It's not like they turn off your internet at the cap, they just charge you more, console users are used to be charged more
  • not being able to play because your housemates are watching Netflix, or are playing a game/downloading porn.
    Console users are used to poor resolution rendering and crappy textures, they will hardly notice the youtube quality compressed video
  • not being able to use custom hardware
    Consoles...
  • not having access to savegame files to store locally
    You sound like a cheater, I bet you use a keyboard and mouse in Halo!
  • etc. etc.

Clearly, cloud gaming is a viable alternative to console gaming, just replacing one pile of crap with another!
 
Add to the fact that what you got from Apple was superior to Cell. There's no Altivec, and the Cell chip is In-Order, unlike X86 chips which have been Out-of-Order for over 10 years. Remember people were able to run Linux on PS3, and benchmarked it to be comparable to low end PowerPC G5. That is of course only the PPC core, and not taking into consideration of the SPE cores on the chip.

Without an easy way to use the SPE's, you might as well have been using a IBM G5, and for a lot of developers that's what they did. They relied more on the Nvidia graphics chip then the Cell chip. Only in extreme and rare situations where the SPE's were actually used well.

The P6 architecture was the first x86 architecture to feature out of order execution. The first chip using the P6 architecture was the Pentium Pro in 1995.

For the longest time, I had to listen to Apple people go on about how their PowerPC chips were supposedly so much better than the x86 chips in PCs (despite the fact that basically every benchmark said otherwise). The look on their faces when Steve Jobs got up on the stage and announced Apple was switching to Intel was priceless.
 
Of course, Nvidia will say cloud based gaming.

Didn't Nvidia announce a cloud based-video graphics/GPU rendering sometime ago?

And, I know AMD mentioned about investing in more cloud server technology.

But, I highly, highly, HIGHLY doubt cloud based gaming is going to kill off consoles. Until ISPs stop putting bandwidth limits and caps, and improve both quality of service and speeds to all customers, then maybe cloud gaming may take a bigger foothold. Until then, it's laughable to even consider consoles dying anytime soon.

has nothing to do with limits or anything else. Every decent game now days has massive client side prediction to make the games responsive, if you offload that all to some cloud based service every low input lag monitor, high end GPU, and every single other thing we aspire for will become useless with the input lag induced.
 
Honestly, I wish consoles would die.

Had a console in the 70's - had a PC in the 80's ---- I think it is pretty funny how you selfish bastards hate console gaming because it isn't good enough for you or that it takes away from the consumer base of your preferred platform.

Kids like consoles and they are easy for a family to buy.
 
I might've let my console hate get the better of me here, but I decided to post this little tongue-in-cheek rebuttal anyways.

  • Latency (in the real world is waaay above what they suggest with "evidence"),
    We're talking about consoles here, where the controls are so terrible you can't even notice the lag
  • not owning games,
    Have you read a EULA lately? You don't own any software.
  • not being able to mod games,
    You can't mod console games anyways, that might eat into DLC sales
    You can mod (at least some) steam games. Don't count on modding origin games
  • losing your entire collection when another cloud service dies,
    But you also don't have your favorite game disc become scratched and unreadable after 6 months, forcing you to purchase another copy because your console requires a physical copy to play.
    Who knows what Valve's next owners will do. When EA dies, you know origin gamers will be screwed.
    [*]not being able to play anything because your connection died/your bandwidth cap is reached,
    It's not like they turn off your internet at the cap, they just charge you more, console users are used to be charged more
    Bad enough with steam (I've been kicked out of Skyrim over a bad connection). Afraid of origin.
    [*]not being able to play because your housemates are watching Netflix, or are playing a game/downloading porn.
    Console users are used to poor resolution rendering and crappy textures, they will hardly notice the youtube quality compressed video
    [*]not being able to use custom hardware
    Consoles...
    [*]not having access to savegame files to store locally
    You sound like a cheater, I bet you use a keyboard and mouse in Halo!
    Steam save synchronization is irritating. Anyone know how origin works?
    [*]etc. etc.


Clearly, cloud gaming is a viable alternative to console gaming, just replacing one pile of crap with another!


PC current "cloud servers" are almost all the way there. Bow to your DRM overlords!
 
Add to the fact that what you got from Apple was superior to Cell. There's no Altivec, and the Cell chip is In-Order, unlike X86 chips which have been Out-of-Order for over 10 years. Remember people were able to run Linux on PS3, and benchmarked it to be comparable to low end PowerPC G5. That is of course only the PPC core, and not taking into consideration of the SPE cores on the chip.

Without an easy way to use the SPE's, you might as well have been using a IBM G5, and for a lot of developers that's what they did. They relied more on the Nvidia graphics chip then the Cell chip. Only in extreme and rare situations where the SPE's were actually used well.

I really doubt out-of-order is an issue with SPEs. Note that the things have no cache, so all loads happen exactly as planned. You can't re-arrange instructions around branches, but this shouldn't cause too much issue (on failed staticly predicted branches you can just ignore the now useless registers. Failed branches are far more painful than missing a few out-of-order instructions, and from memory SPEs only have static prediction.

I always thought that the SPEs were brilliant in that they got essentially all the benefits or out-of-order "for free" (out-of-order processors typically eat transistors as in-order) due to using what would normally be L2 cache as main memory. IBM/Sony bet that programmers could write threaded code, and that it could fit in 256M of memory. My bet is that those coders are out there (probably doing DSP code for NASA/satellite communication) but they just won't work for peanuts over 80-hour+ weeks that EA and friends demand.

PS: Pentium Pro (200MHz): released November 1, 1995. Time flies.
 
PC current "cloud servers" are almost all the way there. Bow to your DRM overlords!

I was going to bow to my DRM overlords but the cloud server was unresponsive / gave me a corrupt save-game / found no traces of my stored saves.

/GFWL
 
I was going to bow to my DRM overlords but the cloud server was unresponsive / gave me a corrupt save-game / found no traces of my stored saves / I hit my ISP's data cap.

/GFWL
Fixed that for you. You forgot to appease the ISP data cap cry babies (puts on flame retardant suit).
 
Seems like Nvidia didn't make it into the hardware for the future consoles. Guess the PhysX monopoly isn't as profitable as they thought.
 
I really doubt out-of-order is an issue with SPEs. Note that the things have no cache, so all loads happen exactly as planned. You can't re-arrange instructions around branches, but this shouldn't cause too much issue (on failed staticly predicted branches you can just ignore the now useless registers. Failed branches are far more painful than missing a few out-of-order instructions, and from memory SPEs only have static prediction.

I always thought that the SPEs were brilliant in that they got essentially all the benefits or out-of-order "for free" (out-of-order processors typically eat transistors as in-order) due to using what would normally be L2 cache as main memory. IBM/Sony bet that programmers could write threaded code, and that it could fit in 256M of memory. My bet is that those coders are out there (probably doing DSP code for NASA/satellite communication) but they just won't work for peanuts over 80-hour+ weeks that EA and friends demand.

PS: Pentium Pro (200MHz): released November 1, 1995. Time flies.

The problem is, making parallel workloads is not as easy as it sounds. There aren't really a whole lot of things with games that can easily be parallelized. The biggest one is graphics and that is handled by the GPU. Physics could possibly make use of the SPEs. AI is simply too complicated and has too many branching instructions; the SPE's lack of branch predictors and small cache size would make it incredible difficult to economically use them for AI.

Once again, we have a situation where something is faster on paper but is later trumped by the supposedly "slower" x86 processors. All of the speed in the world will not help you if your processor requires doctorate-level computer science knowledge in order to extract reasonable performance. It is also hard to justify the expensive of "fine art" programming in a cost-benefit analysis to the bean counters.

The x86's biggest strength has always been it's ability to gracefully handle unoptimized code in a way that Register-Register chips like ARM and PowerPC have never been able to.
 
I think it is, for now, another case of a company trying to get ahead in the game and an exec making prophetical statements based on bias over an insecure optimism for their brand. He wants to become a player in the future and desires the future to conform to his product.
 
I always thought that the SPEs were brilliant in that they got essentially all the benefits or out-of-order "for free" (out-of-order processors typically eat transistors as in-order) due to using what would normally be L2 cache as main memory. IBM/Sony bet that programmers could write threaded code, and that it could fit in 256M of memory. My bet is that those coders are out there (probably doing DSP code for NASA/satellite communication) but they just won't work for peanuts over 80-hour+ weeks that EA and friends demand.

It's a lot like the Sega Saturn situation. It's a really fast machine, if you had the right programers. Also, nothing is free. Sony was able to make the Cell chip cheaper and clock higher by removing things that they'd rather have the developers deal with. In the end, Sony made a product that they could use technobabble to create mystery and magic.

The SPE cores were probably going to be the original graphics processor rather than the Nvidia chip. When Xbox 360 announced their specs, Sony grabbed Nvidia for graphics and called it a day. Without Nvidia, Sony's PS3 couldn't hold a candle to the 360.

BTW the 360 has a very similar PowerPC setup, except 3x more PPC cores. So the 360 is 3x the power of a IBM G5 chip, but that's not saying much when you realize how much faster x86 are in comparison. Which is why PC gamers are so upset when games are made for these consoles first.

3.2 Ghz CPU Xbox 360 PS3 =/= 3.2 Ghz Intel or AMD
DX9 (assuming) Xbox 360 PS3 =/= DX9 Nvidia or AMD graphics

You have CPU's that run probably at best 1/2 the speed of x86 chips from 6 years ago, at best. Graphic chips that must share bandwidth with the CPU. Extremely limited memory, even for 6 years ago. These consoles are much slower then people realize. The only saving grace is that developers can take better advantage of console hardware then PC hardware, but that doesn't make miracles.
 
You have CPU's that run probably at best 1/2 the speed of x86 chips from 6 years ago, at best. Graphic chips that must share bandwidth with the CPU. Extremely limited memory, even for 6 years ago. These consoles are much slower then people realize. The only saving grace is that developers can take better advantage of console hardware then PC hardware, but that doesn't make miracles.

If AMD did get x86 into the big two consoles then it may be a saving grace for PC gaming, not to mention much better for their business in PC gaming as well due to the inherent bump in performance AMD will get from developers coding software and optimizing it specifically for their architectures (provided they're using GCN or VLIW5/VLIW4)

Cloud gaming won't take off due to the same reasons that cloud-based computing won't take off. In an era where ISPs are throttling speeds and capping data usage, these tech companies must be living in LaLa land in order to believe that cloud-based anything will survive and flourish. Unless high speed bandwidth penetration accelerates and data caps are a thing of the past, cloud anything is a certain failure.
 
Oh boy, gaming as a highly restrictive walled garden service model...yippee, that's EXACTLY what gamers want. :rolleyes:
 
consoles will die, but not any time soon. Unless google is fast and give everyone in the world their google fiber internet.
 
Cloud gaming won't take off due to the same reasons that cloud-based computing won't take off. In an era where ISPs are throttling speeds and capping data usage, these tech companies must be living in LaLa land in order to believe that cloud-based anything will survive and flourish. Unless high speed bandwidth penetration accelerates and data caps are a thing of the past, cloud anything is a certain failure.

Cloud computing has been cruising at 30,000 feet for quite some time.

Case in point, I've been paid my meager salary for the past decade thanks to cloud-based computing and it's only getting larger. Cloud computing isn't some brand-new buzz tech; it's been around for quite some time, takes many forms (mine being Citrix) and with the advent of a few billion potential 'thin clients' out there with ever-increasing layers of integration, won't be going away, ever.

That said, cloud gaming can kiss my ass, and yes, tech must change considerably before it will ever be viable.
 
Cloud computing has been cruising at 30,000 feet for quite some time.

Case in point, I've been paid my meager salary for the past decade thanks to cloud-based computing and it's only getting larger. Cloud computing isn't some brand-new buzz tech; it's been around for quite some time, takes many forms (mine being Citrix) and with the advent of a few billion potential 'thin clients' out there with ever-increasing layers of integration, won't be going away, ever.

That said, cloud gaming can kiss my ass, and yes, tech must change considerably before it will ever be viable.

I played WoW through VNC. It worked okay for sitting around chatting, which is pretty much the only thing I do in MMOs anyhow so it covered like 90% of my gaming needs when I was at a hotel with a laptop that was too old to run it. Of course, as soon as you started trying to move around or something it got kinda iffy (read: impossible and awful).
 
I think cloud gaming will be better than console gaming, but still not as good as PC gaming, which is odd, because PC gaming lately has been nothing but ports from console games.
 
I think cloud gaming will be better than console gaming, but still not as good as PC gaming, which is odd, because PC gaming lately has been nothing but ports from console games.

You have strange thoughts sometimes. :)
 
Back
Top