nvidia 7600gt vs. x850xt pe

frankyk

Gawd
Joined
Jan 30, 2004
Messages
891
which is better? it looks like the x850xt pe is cheaper but i heard this is better, i dunno though.
 
it depends on the game, but they will perform equally or at least close to equal in all games. the 7600gt is also an amazing overclocker, and hte only reason i would pick the 7600gt is because i own it and it is a great card in my opinion. o and also they dont produce as much heat as the ati cards do.
 
The XT PE is slightly quicker, though I think you could argue that the 7600GT would have more headroom in terms of overclocking (especially if you hit up the voltmod). The 7600GT also has SM 3.0 hardware, and also HDCP depending which model you select.
 
quadnad said:
The XT PE is slightly quicker, though I think you could argue that the 7600GT would have more headroom in terms of overclocking (especially if you hit up the voltmod). The 7600GT also has SM 3.0 hardware, and also HDCP depending which model you select.

Sure head room but your not going to get too much out of the memory since it's only 128bit can get you so much...
 
Marvelous said:
Sure head room but your not going to get too much out of the memory since it's only 128bit can get you so much...

that only has a bearing at higher resolutions or with tons of AA/AF. With either of those midrange cards, you aren't going to be playing with either set very high or at a high resolution (in my opinion it's a similar issue with the x1600s shipping with 512mb of RAM).
 
quadnad said:
that only has a bearing at higher resolutions or with tons of AA/AF. With either of those midrange cards, you aren't going to be playing with either set very high or at a high resolution (in my opinion it's a similar issue with the x1600s shipping with 512mb of RAM).

sweet spot is 1280x1024 today yes? Then memory speed is going to get you so much more out of it at that resolution ... Core speed.. So so for the 7600gt...
 
Marvelous said:
sweet spot is 1280x1024 today yes? Then memory speed is going to get you so much more out of it at that resolution... Core speed.. So so...

I'd agree, and 12x10 is more than fine for the 7600GT. If you try anything higher (16x12), or try adding 4xAA/16xAF, then it'll strain. Also, it's the core speed that will get you respectable framerates at those resolutions and the memory bandwidth that will allow for the extra AA/AF.

Moral of the story is this: the X850XT PE is the quicker card, but comes with a smaller featureset. If you want HDCP and SM3.0, then grab the 7600GT, if you want the quickest card grab the X850XT PE.
 
quadnad said:
I'd agree, and 12x10 is more than fine for the 7600GT. If you try anything higher (16x12), or try adding 4xAA/16xAF, then it'll strain. Also, it's the core speed that will get you respectable framerates at those resolutions and the memory bandwidth that will allow for the extra AA/AF.

Moral of the story is this: the X850XT PE is the quicker card, but comes with a smaller featureset. If you want HDCP and SM3.0, then grab the 7600GT, if you want the quickest card grab the X850XT PE.

Moral of story.. Pickup the fastest card you can afford that isn't limited by bandwidth.. :p

HDCP, SM3 and all that if you're going to keep your card for more than 2 years...
 
Marvelous said:
Sure head room but your not going to get too much out of the memory since it's only 128bit can get you so much...

bitrate on the memory has nothing to do with overclocking.
 
Domini said:
bitrate on the memory has nothing to do with overclocking.

Sure it does...

128 bit = 1/2 of 256 bit... give you less memory bandwidth... :rolleyes:

overclock 100mhz on 128bit... All you need 50mhz on 256 bit to match 128bit...
 
Well for what its worth on Thursday night I bit the agp bullet and ordered the 7600GT for my AXP rig. Should be here Tuesday I imagine. Yes I did get my order thru I have my UPS tracking number and everything and yes my card has left the state of CA. Anyway, as mentioned above at 1280x1024 the 7600GT will perform about on par with the 7800GS and nearly where the x850xt is in most games. I could not find an agp x850xt under $150 so I made this move. In the one review there seems to be for the 7600GT agp it seems at 1280x1024 the card can still hang with the 7800GS even with 4xAA see here. In fact, more often than not its equal or better even at 16x12 with the AA on. Anyway, for those without the huge monitors the 7600GT seems to be a solid choice; hopefully I'm happy with it. My 2.6Ghz AXP is about on par with the 3Ghz P4 in the review about so I can a good idea what to expect my numbers to be. This should tide me over until a massive quad core upgrade in 12 months or so; and also make me one of the few AXP's playing Crysis :confused: well maybe at 10x7 ;)
 
Back
Top