NVIDA Alters Benchmarks for Fastest Mobile GPU Crown

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The crew at eTeknix say that NVIDIA has pulled a fast one with some recent benchmarks that make their mobile part look faster than the competition. Apparetnly old drivers were used in conjunction with a slower CPU in the AMD powered ASUS W90 that was pitted against the Alienware system.

To prove their point nVidia tested both systems and when setting up the Asus they stated that they used the “latest drivers”. However it appears that this is far from the truth and the drivers are more than one year old, hardly utilizing the second 4870 at all. It is unclear if nVidia did this to provide a larger, more impressive lead than they already had in the benchmark or if they had to do this to come out on top.

It also appears that they did similarly under handed with the CPU, with the Asus sporting an Intel Q9000 and the Alienware M17x using the slightly faster Intel Q9300 CPU. Maybe they didn’t expect these omissions to be noticed or they had problems fitting a Q9000 to the Alienware we are not sure, but it is playing a bit fast and loose with the truth.

A follow up to the story has a response from NVIDIA that places the blame squarely on ASUS for having a slower CPU in the W90 and AMD for having one year old drivers.
 
TheSecondArticle said:
A trip to the AMD and Asus website will confirm that the driver tested is the one consumers have access to, which if they were around a year old, go blame AMD. It’s not their fault that nVidia update their drivers and AMD do not. Due to this, it seemed that the second 4870 wasn’t being engaged due to its drivers not supporting it. Whose fault? AMD.

Wow, AMD hasn't given new drivers for thier mobile parts in over a year? Dear god, I thought all that driver support problems were behind us.
 
GeForce GTX 280M 2009 ? 55 PCIe 2.0 x16 1024 585 1463 1900 128:64:16 37.44 60.8 GDDR3 256 10 2.1 562 75 Ultimate Setup 2009 Notebook. SLi.

GeForce GTX 285 [23][24] January 15, 2009 G200b 55 1400 470 1 PCIe x16 2.0 1024 (2048*) 240:80:32 648 1476 2484 20.736 51.84 159.0 GDDR3 512 32x16 10 3.1 1062.720 204 Palit and EVGA launched 2GB versions of this card

Broken up slightly.
Mobile Desktop
Shaders: 128 Shaders: 240
Whatever it is: 64 Whatever it is: 80
w/e it is : 16 w/e it is: 32

This is the specs from wikipedia, they are like that for all nvidia gpu's

Cant you all see that isnt quite right is it ?

IT seems to me that GTX280 is more like 8800GTX :p

Bandwidth 60.8 gb/sec

Really ive seen 4870, 150 mhz lower core speed, thats what there is to it :p

How can that WIN!? some stupid play i guess :p

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nvidia_gpu#GeForce_200M_.282xxM.29_series

Any test of desktop vs notebook parts for nvidia chips ?
 
To Poster Above:

The Gtx 280M roughly equals a 9800gtx+ in performance (mobile vs desktop)
the Gtx 260M roughly equals a 9800gt in performance...

Don't compare mobile parts to desktop parts (they should have named them differently to avoid confusion)
 
The driver thing is BS.

I don't keep up with ATI's mobility drivers, but I just went on their site and the latest drivers for the 4xxx mobility series was released on June 15th.
 
The driver thing is BS.

I don't keep up with ATI's mobility drivers, but I just went on their site and the latest drivers for the 4xxx mobility series was released on June 15th.

Those are the normal 4870s, look under graphics >> vista 64 (for thier laptop, although it's the same for the others >> Mobility Radeon >> (suppose to be here but isn't)
 
ATI needs to catch up in this department. They give their drivers to the OEMs but it's up to the OEM to test the driver with the mobile chipset and place it on their webpage.

You can however modify the INF file and make use of the latest drivers on the mobility radeons.

Nvidia moved away from this method of mobility updating in December, 2008. Before that they did the same thing ATI is doing now. ATI just needs to catch up.
 
This is getting pathetic on nV's part. I mean the mobile line has been re-branded how many times? Come out with something new.
 
"dont compare mobile parts with desktop"

EXACTLY WHAT YOU CAN WITH ATI. naming scheme from ati for the win eh?

THose are just underclocked ones, so how does 9800GTX+ sli beat 4870CF with 400 mhz more clock speed, doesnt happen.

Nvidia has worst naming scheme ever, okey laptop parts = not same as desktop.
Renaming 3 times or something.

Kind of confusing hehe :p

4870 Mobile vs desktop.
800 saders 800shaders
600mhz clock speed 750 mhz clock speed.
800 mhz mem speed. 850 mhz mem speed gddr5 256 bit, or something

Memory for ati parts is unknown, but i guess it is 256 bit since its not thaat hard on mobile chips, however any bigger IS. nvidia does 9800GTX and 256 bit so i bet it works, and they do use GDDR5.

So again, where can this win ?. in a paralell world where less is better ?
I know 260Msli and 4870M CF setups since ive tried both, not GTX280M sli but the nvidia system wasnt at all as good as the ati.
Surely ALL benches made by a manufacture is better than they really are, but this just makes me where is this correct!!?
 
THose are just underclocked ones, so how does 9800GTX+ sli beat 4870CF with 400 mhz more clock speed, doesnt happen. dunno what happened there (meant to say 150mhz less)
 
This is getting pathetic on nV's part. I mean the mobile line has been re-branded how many times? Come out with something new.

This is exactly how I feel. Been eyeing that ASUS with the 4870X2 and I know I could just modify the .inf to get the latest drivers working...

But for the average gaming consumer who puts out a little extra cash for the best performance, it's a shame if true, this whole driver availability without putting in some work nonsense.
 
I remember when Nvidia would do this back when they were failing really hard with the FX line up, and then when they were cought they said there was nothing wrong with the hardware it was their drivers. They never did come out publicly to say their shit was broke and they lied to masses about it.
 
The drivers "RCGodward" linked are only for win7 beta. No other drivers exist for the 4800 series mobility chipsets. Yes you can modify the inf file as someone else posted as you once did with NV drivers, but that was 8-9 months ago and should have been different even before by both NV and ATI.

Sad that neither support their hardware better.
 
It is much easier to blame someone else, just like when people say ATI driver sucks, afterall the problem is actually related the user.

ATIs drivers do suck.

I love nvidias drivers in comparison to ATIs. I just have always had better luck with them and the installer is much smoother. I have used plenty of both, and keep going back to nvidia based cards.

Its not "me" either. Always some stupid ass little problem that I can usually even find talked about online. The latest was a little while back dealing with multiple cards in a single system that the ATI driver did not like.

Its like AMD vs. Intel, just use what you like because there are plenty on either side of the fence with their own experiences.
 
For those who don't know...

AMD is still clinging to the antiquated system of mobile GPU drivers being modified slightly (most to include the laptop's LCD info). This means that AMD gives the chips and the drivers to Dell/HP/ASUS/Apple/whoever, and the OEM is then responsible for modifying the drivers and distributing them. Intel does the same. It's a PITA, because the "latest" drivers for my tablet are 2-year old drivers that regularly crash in World of Warcraft. I cannot use the latest Intel drivers because Lenovo has not repackaged them for my computer.

NVIDIA, on the other hand, moved to a unified system a few years ago where they were the only source for drivers.

NVIDIA can hardly be blamed for this debacle. If you go to AMD.com and download the latest drivers, running the installer will throw an error along the lines of "Your system does not contain a supported graphics card." However, if you go to ASUS, and download the driver, it will install perfect. Conversely, you can take any laptop with a modern NVIDIA chip, download the very latest drivers straight from NVIDIA.com, and it will work perfect.
 
nVidia is not playing fair, but is not lying... ATI does not supply mobile radeon drivers that work with their mobile radeon graphics installed in *all* of the top laptop makers' laptops (Dell, HP, Acer, etc) I have a dell and have to use mobility modder to get the stock ATI drivers to load onto my computer, thus making it an unsigned driver. It is also stupid for Asus to be selling a computer with 1 year old drivers installed on it that don't support the full use of the graphics subsystem that comes with the computer.

So everybody really is at fault, ATI and ASUS for being inept and nvidia for being not disclosing all the details. Such is the world we live in.
 
So when I go to the Asus website, select the 4870, then select Vista64, those drivers posted back in march of this year aren't for the mobile variant? (which I thought the ATI driver would work for both)
 
nVidia is not playing fair, but is not lying... ATI does not supply mobile radeon drivers that work with their mobile radeon graphics installed in *all* of the top laptop makers' laptops (Dell, HP, Acer, etc) I have a dell and have to use mobility modder to get the stock ATI drivers to load onto my computer, thus making it an unsigned driver. It is also stupid for Asus to be selling a computer with 1 year old drivers installed on it that don't support the full use of the graphics subsystem that comes with the computer.

So everybody really is at fault, ATI and ASUS for being inept and nvidia for being not disclosing all the details. Such is the world we live in.

this might be a more balanced view here. And this isn't the first time either green or red have ran a lot of spin. but it IS really pathetic on nvidias part here. with all the backlash at their recent behavior I think ATI/AMD is missing a huge opportunity here. I agree with what was said above, a unified driver makes more sense now. maybe what ATI needs to do is start headhunting some of nvidias business managers,
 
So when I go to the Asus website, select the 4870, then select Vista64, those drivers posted back in march of this year aren't for the mobile variant? (which I thought the ATI driver would work for both)

No to both. No, it won't work in the mobile variant, and no, the ATI drivers won't work in the mobile variant either.
 
Ati driver installment for noobs.

ati driver at google.

press top link, and off you goes for dl.

Double click driver install file.
next-next-next-next finish EVERY time.

I have had 1 issue, my friends have had 1 issue.

Thats the infamous 9.2 driver that is.

8.5 to 9.6 is about best there is, and ati DOESNT release beta drivers(on public site, ive never seen one), nvidia does.

I used to hate ati drivers, i used to be soo angry that i'd kill a person using ati under linux.
 
/wonders if any of the hysterical f-boys have read the update
 
Did anyone notice that nVidia is being wrongfully blamed here? The title says NVIDA is behind it all! :p
 
While everything may not have been 100% on the level, ATI's site offers nothing.

Mobility Quadro in my T61p? Available in Vista x64; Betas available for Win7 x64, but Win7 isn't complete.

Mobility FireGL V5700 on my W500? Unlisted in Vista or Win7.

That's something I will miss greatly from my migration from a T61p to W500. The lack of driver issues I dealt with with the Thinkpad X31, T40, T41, T41P, T42, T42P, T43, T60, Dell D600, 600M, D610M, 9300...and likely the Thinkpad W500 as well. Even if I couldn't find the drivers I needed on nVidia's site, I could get them on LaptopVideo2Go. Is there an LV2G for ATI products?
 
So you're saying the average consumer should be running beta drivers?

Go on Asus' website, Look up their drivers.

you will find this one for Vista x64: Version V8.551.2.0
nvidia_cheat.jpg


Not sure how nVIDIA missed that... :rolleyes:
 
Aren't just about every nVIDIA driver BETA (save for the WHQL drivers once in a blue moon).
Good to know when I don't go to THG, it comes here to read. :p

I missed about 8 of blue moons so far this year, I guess. Even excluding the WHQL release(s) that went to manufacturers only, nvidia has posted at least 6 WHQL drivers this year on its web site. :rolleyes:
 
Back
Top