NV. Silencer 5 installed, thanks [H]!

[H]ard On

Weaksauce
Joined
Jan 24, 2005
Messages
80
I just wanted to say thanks to all the [H] members out there. I've been reading and posting aobut getting an NV Silencer 5 (rev.2) for my Gainward 6800GT for several months now. It showed up in the mail, purchased from bigfootcomputers.com (I'm in canada, hence the wait for the product to show up at a Canadian retialer) and I spent about an hour installing it. The difference in audible noise is absolutely indescribable, as everyone who owns a Gainward knows their dual 60mm stock fans are pretty decent at cooling, but they're noisy as hell. The silencer is completely inaudible over my other case fans (Vantec Stealths and the fan in my Neopower 480W), and the install went swimmingly. I could probably drop a handful of degrees more by using AS5 instead of the ceramique I used, but I was super paranoid about shorting out the card. I know AS5 wouldn't be a problem at all in this case unless I literally emptied the tube all over the card, but I wasn't in the mood to replace the card from a botched install, so I was just being careful and going completely non-conductive. Anyway, long story short, the install's a complete success. Lower idle & stock temps, insane reduction in noise, and one happy customer. Thanks guys, I appreciate the help.

Oh, also, I was so focused and excited (and lazy) during the install that I only managed to snap off one pic. I was focusing pretty hard so as not to botch the install, I'm sure you guys'll understand. Behold, my naked Gainward!



....Okay, so the batteries in my D70 just died, I'll post pics of the naked Gainward and the leftover parts, perhaps a ghetto side of the open case pic if i get a chance tomorrow. Thanks again guys!

EDIT: Recharged and feelin' fine. Also, I'd like to mention that my Gainward's stock cooling solution wasn't really set up perfectly. Thermal paste was applied properly, but the GPU block wasn't tightened down on one corner at all, and it was very loose on the opposite corner. The other two corners were tight as hell...odd eh?

my.php
 
Nice work. Any temperature improvements? I sure hope you cleaned the dust off that card before you installed the NV5 :)

I haven't seen too many 6800GT's that use a red PCB... it's kinda cool
 
Nice work. Any temperature improvements? I sure hope you cleaned the dust off that card before you installed the NV5 :)

Idle went down about 10 degrees, load went down 10 to 12 depending on what tool I use to measure (Rivaturner gives 12, Gainward app gives 10, guess who I trust? :p) Idle is 55 degrees C and load is a little over 70. All in all an awesome move on my behalf thanks to the performance increase and sound reduction. I'm running 400/1100 with no problems, and I'll try and bump 'em both up in tiny increments tomorrow. And yes, I gave the dust a good blowjob before I slapped on the NV5 :D The pic was taken right after i Isopropyl'd off the stock thermal compound.


I haven't seen too many 6800GT's that use a red PCB... it's kinda cool

Damn straight. I'll post the stock heatsink tomorrow, it's pretty nifty too. Too bad it sounded like a farm animal being raped in a thunderstorm. Hence the upgrade!
 
what are the improvements over the regilar NV Silencer 5 and the NV Silencer 5 (Rev. 2)?

Now you really make me wish i had taken pics. AFAIK, they fixed the clicking fan noise problem, it now comes with 2 slot brackets: 1) I/O shield for back of graphics card (new) 2) Vented slot cover to allow airflow out of case, and it no longer uses copper pads soldered to the base of the heatsink to cool the memory, instead it uses thermal pads similar to those used on stock heatsinks, but of slightly higher quality. I'd also like to mention how impressed I was with the build quality of the silencer. It's very heavy and sturdy and not at all cheap and flimsy like I thought it would be. I'll try and take some open-case pics when I get home to illustrate some differences, if possible.
 
*PICS UPDATE*

Before someone tells me to clean up my cables, I'm using an Antec Sonata with no window, and any hanging cables aren't impeding airflow to any degree that would effect temps, so I could care less. On to the pics!

Stock Gainward GPU and Memory Sinks (Pretty hot and red too, just like the PCB)
10wu.jpg


Stock fan shroud, equipped with my arch-nemesis: Tiny loud bastard fans. Also in red!
24se.jpg

Just in case you're wondering, that thing's about as big as an NV silencer, just not quite as long. it's pretty Frickin' huge.

Dearly departed....(not really, that shit was loud :p)
39oo.jpg


NV silencer inside the case. Sorry i didn't get any before-install pics, I was too busy trying not to destroy my card.
47ld.jpg


Wide shot of the case. Sorry the case-shots are so crappy, i crawled under my desk and used my outstretched arm because i was too god damn lazy to unplug everything and get out my case.
50cc.jpg


Close-up of the silencer. Man are they ever badass. Anyway, this is for the purpose of checking out the thermal pads covering the memory. They're white-blueish, you can see them clearly.
89zj.jpg


Here are some interesting points. Check out the Gouge just a little less than halfway up the stock GPU heatsink that was not put there by me, it was like that when i took it off. Somethign tells me my shoddy GPU mounting (as mentioned in my previous post) had something to do with my less than awesome OC abilities. Also, another bendy-thing that I didn't do, check out the bent fin on the GPU sink
Also, in no way am I try to say Gainward sucks. This card has been awesome and I've been nothing but happy with it. Like any other 6800GT, it was just a little too loud for me.


69mr.jpg

75nf.jpg


Any questions?
 
[H]ard On said:
Anyway, this is for the purpose of checking out the thermal pads covering the memory. They're white-blueish, you can see them clearly.

Why did you use the thermal pads instead of something better...like AS5?

I just ordered one of these NV Silencers to go with my eVGA 6800GT that I bought yesterday. I'm gonna leave the stock cooler on there for at least a couple weeks to see if the card works as advertised. Then I'm gonna volt-mod it and stick the silencer on there to see how good she can really be :D

EDIT:

[H]ard On said:
I could probably drop a handful of degrees more by using AS5 instead of the ceramique I used, but I was super paranoid about shorting out the card. I know AS5 wouldn't be a problem at all in this case unless I literally emptied the tube all over the card, but I wasn't in the mood to replace the card from a botched install, so I was just being careful and going completely non-conductive.

OIC...you was paranoid.
 
I'm buying an aftermarket cooler soon for my dual 40mm blue LED fan BFG 6800gt card, and I'm considering the NV Silencer 5 but I was actually leaning more towards the Zalman VF700ALCU.
I was wondering, what made you choose one over the other?
 
Yea , Question 1

wasnt the stock heatsink good.. in the first place?

Yes, it was pretty good. Cooling performance was better than the reference cooler, but it was noisy as hell at 100% speed.I like my shit silent, straight up. 'Nuff said.

Why did you use the thermal pads instead of something better...like AS5?

Because in Rev.2 there are no copper pads on the silencer to account for the height difference between the GPU and the memory. If you took off the stock thermal pads there'd be a very, very large gap between the surface of the ram and the heatsink. This is one of the reasons for Rev.2, a lot of people had problems with the height differences of their cards and the silencers they received, so the silencer would often not make good contact with the GPU and RAM. By using thermal pads, which are infintely more compressible than copper (At room temperature at least :p), this isn't a problem. Besides, the RAM would never get hot enough for me to worry about the thermal pads as a cooling solution, even at 420/1150. Also, don't use AS5 on bare RAM chips like that, it's just asking for trouble. Ceramique is okay, for the 1-2 degree difference it's worth the knowledge that you won't f*** the dog on the install. :D

I'm buying an aftermarket cooler soon for my dual 40mm blue LED fan BFG 6800gt card, and I'm considering the NV Silencer 5 but I was actually leaning more towards the Zalman VF700ALCU. I was wondering, what made you choose one over the other?

I was actually insanely close to just going for the Zalman VF700CU instead of the silencer. I was pretty much 50/50 on both of them, because all reviews I'd read showed that they gave similar cooling results and were both pretty much inaudible. I actually was leaning towards the Zalman at one pont since I have the Zalman CPU Sink/Fan, so that would've looked pretty hot. However, since I don't have a queer eye for straight hardware, that wasn't that big of a deal. I think the only thing that pushed it over the top for me was the fact that the silencer throws the air out the back of the case through the second slot bracket. As I mentioned, I have a Sonata, and they're not the biggest of cases. Even though I have 2 120mm case fans cooling it, the more hot air out the better. Then again, it's not like I was at risk of temperaturs that would affect any of my components. Honestly, you really can't go wrong with either cooler, they're both damn quiet and cool really well, so choose based on your taste.
 
[H]ard On said:
Because in Rev.2 there are no copper pads on the silencer to account for the height difference between the GPU and the memory. If you took off the stock thermal pads there'd be a very, very large gap between the surface of the ram and the heatsink. This is one of the reasons for Rev.2, a lot of people had problems with the height differences of their cards and the silencers they received, so the silencer would often not make good contact with the GPU and RAM.

How much of a gap are we talking about between the sink and mem chips? I'd definitely prefer using compound over pads unless the gap is too large. One could always apply a thicker layer of compound to offset the gap, but too much compound is no good either. Maybe I made a mistake and should have bought the Zalman with separate mem sinks instead?
 
How much of a gap are we talking about between the sink and mem chips? I'd definitely prefer using compound over pads unless the gap is too large. One could always apply a thicker layer of compound to offset the gap, but too much compound is no good either. Maybe I made a mistake and should have bought the Zalman with separate mem sinks instead?

Short Answer: The gap's too big to fill up with paste. Check the huge, wide pic to see the pads. They're significantly thick. Having said that, did you get a rev.1 or a rev.2 silencer? The rev.1 has copper plates cooling the RAM (essentially ramsinks), except this causes a shatload of headaches with a good install. On top of that, the thermal pads will give you pretty much equal cooling with the ramsinks provided by the Zalman, since they in fact have thermal pads on the bottom of them. Of course if you removed the pads you could use your own thermal paste, but still, the memory never gets hot enough as it is. Mine's 20% overclocked from stock and it's running just fine right about now.
 
[H]ard On said:
On top of that, the thermal pads will give you pretty much equal cooling with the ramsinks provided by the Zalman, since they in fact have thermal pads on the bottom of them. Of course if you removed the pads you could use your own thermal paste, but still, the memory never gets hot enough as it is. Mine's 20% overclocked from stock and it's running just fine right about now.

The first thing I'd do would be to scrape the pads off those Zalman mem sinks. But I would'nt use them anyway over my OCZ copper flower sinks. As far as the heat, I just can't believe that those DDR3 chips running at 500MHz+ don't get hot enough. I got the OCZ sinks on my R9500 mem chips doing only 315MHz and they get fucking HOT.
 
Paste isn't too great for BGA ram, shorts very easy I've read.

Hence the use of ceramique, and my constant suggestion that people don't use AS5 on their gfx cards.

The first thing I'd do would be to scrape the pads off those Zalman mem sinks. But I would'nt use them anyway over my OCZ copper flower sinks. As far as the heat, I just can't believe that those DDR3 chips running at 500MHz+ don't get hot enough. I got the OCZ sinks on my R9500 mem chips doing only 315MHz and they get fucking HOT.

To be perfectly honest, i've never felt them with my hand, so I wouldn't really know for sure. I've been told this by several people. However, hot to the touch is one thing. Hot enough to start affecting performance or theatening the life of the chip is another thing. Think about how fucking hot a core with a passive sink on it at 120 would feel. That's just the very limit of GPU temps. With the RAM you should still be okay, from the information I've gathered anyway. I could very well be wrong. If ramsinks on a zalman are okay, there's no way this isn't okay, it shouldn't limit performance in any way, as far as I'm concerned.
 
Back
Top