Nudity + Facebook = Banned

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I am not sure why people act surprised when their Facebook account is closed after they post semi-nude pictures on the site. The way this girl is talking (claiming she is losing business), I smell a lawsuit coming.

It is possible that she was not entirely clothed in all the shots. However, no doubt deeply wary of Facebook's Areola Police, who monitor breast-feeding pictures with the latest microscopes, she doctored the pictures on Photoshop. She says she covered all her potentially controversial parts with a barcode--which surely shows a rare artistic bent.
 
amazing how the internet opens up the world for people to want to show people themselves half naked, i wonder if you ask most of these people "would you stand in a mall like that" most would probably say NO WAY, but go right ahead and post almost anything on the internet.


In this case it seems facebook is being extreme, i am sure there are far worse accounts with far worse images.
 
I my opinion facebook should not be held responsible for any loss of income she might or has incured. If she wants a site for her business then she should have started her own.
 
My opinion is that no one should be banned from facebook for nudies (females)... in fact, they should be automatically added to my friends list ;)
 
i think its fine that she got banned.....people are too de-sensitized to nudity and language....in an effort to try and keep it younger people friendly i think its fine to ban them....
 
I my opinion facebook should not be held responsible for any loss of income she might or has incured. If she wants a site for her business then she should have started her own.
I agree. Facebook, MySpace and other social networking sites are not the place to run a "business." Get a real Web site for that.
 
She has clown hair in that photo in the article and she is a model? I agree with the above poster as well if she is a model she should have her own website and not rely on a free website such as Facebook.
 
After reading the article, or at least skimming through it, I think FB is completely over reacting to the situation. Next thing you know you'll be getting banned for posting pics of yourself at the beach in beach attire.
 
After reading the article, or at least skimming through it, I think FB is completely over reacting to the situation. Next thing you know you'll be getting banned for posting pics of yourself at the beach in beach attire.

I kinda agree. However I also agree that it's their website, and they're free to moderate it however they damn well please. Personally, I'd have thought it more prudent to give her say a temp. ban and ask her to link her modeling material externally in the future if they take issue w/ her pics.

But like others have said, it's their site, they can do whatever they want with it.
 
If it's in the TOS agreement, then she wouldn't have a lawsuit simple as that.
 
I agree. Facebook, MySpace and other social networking sites are not the place to run a "business." Get a real Web site for that.
Except that both of them market their services as a place to conduct business, at least in certain regards.
 
They might be Facebook's servers, but they are public property. She should be free to post anything as long as it doesn't break the law. Changing her content is like squelching Freedom of Speech. Although I don't know (or care to know) if FB is on US soil or not. I don't see what harm she did to Facebook anyway. Perhaps Facebook did this just to get free publicity?
 
They might be Facebook's servers, but they are public property. She should be free to post anything as long as it doesn't break the law. Changing her content is like squelching Freedom of Speech. Although I don't know (or care to know) if FB is on US soil or not. I don't see what harm she did to Facebook anyway. Perhaps Facebook did this just to get free publicity?

Just because it's publicly accessible does not make it public property. Maybe this only happens in the boonies or something, but haven't you ever seen a sign in a shop / gas station stating "we reserve the right to refuse service to anyone"?

It's not public property, the owners of the site have the right to do whatever they damn well please with it. I do think they're being prudes, but the sites not paid for by me or my tax dollars so i can stfu. :eek:
 
Just because it's publicly accessible does not make it public property. Maybe this only happens in the boonies or something, but haven't you ever seen a sign in a shop / gas station stating "we reserve the right to refuse service to anyone"?

It's not public property, the owners of the site have the right to do whatever they damn well please with it. I do think they're being prudes, but the sites not paid for by me or my tax dollars so i can stfu. :eek:

That is not quite what I meant. A gas station can deny you service, but they can't keep you from picketing a sign. Because a band put their music on iTunes doesn't mean Apple can "do whatever they damn well please with it". Both of these are poor analogies anyway.

What I don't agree with is Facebook telling her what she can and can't do on a publicly viewable site. If she didn't break the law, I don't see what they can do to her. They changed her content. This could be viewed similarly to if Google decided to start changing and/or sending out emails with your "free" account. It's not yours, they own it and can "do whatever they damn well please with it", right? If she chooses to run a "business" on a free site, I guess that was her choice. There is risk it could be shut down. I know LOTS of people who use free email accounts for their company communication.
 
If you start sending spam with your Google email account, you'll soon have it canceled.

I think Facebook is being a bunch of prudes, but they probably have that right.
 
That is not quite what I meant. A gas station can deny you service, but they can't keep you from picketing a sign. Because a band put their music on iTunes doesn't mean Apple can "do whatever they damn well please with it". Both of these are poor analogies anyway.

What I don't agree with is Facebook telling her what she can and can't do on a publicly viewable site. If she didn't break the law, I don't see what they can do to her. They changed her content. This could be viewed similarly to if Google decided to start changing and/or sending out emails with your "free" account. It's not yours, they own it and can "do whatever they damn well please with it", right? If she chooses to run a "business" on a free site, I guess that was her choice. There is risk it could be shut down. I know LOTS of people who use free email accounts for their company communication.

I see what you're saying but by that logic I am free to post the most disgusting weird p0rn I could never imagine right here on [H], and they would be in the wrong to remove it. Publicly viewable or not, there is only one opinion that matters when it comes to what is or is not appropriate content on a site, and that is the opinion of the owner of said site. In terms of legality, wether anyone else agrees w/ that opinion or not is irrelevant.

They didn't change her content, they removed it. Apple can't do whatever they want with that garage bands song, but the can remove it if they want to. And the gas station CAN stop you from picketing on their own private property (if you stand on the public sidewalk you're good). If you tried to push it they could just have you arrested for tresspassing (given that they've repeatedly asked you to leave).
 
That is not quite what I meant. A gas station can deny you service, but they can't keep you from picketing a sign. Because a band put their music on iTunes doesn't mean Apple can "do whatever they damn well please with it". Both of these are poor analogies anyway.

What I don't agree with is Facebook telling her what she can and can't do on a publicly viewable site. If she didn't break the law, I don't see what they can do to her. They changed her content. This could be viewed similarly to if Google decided to start changing and/or sending out emails with your "free" account. It's not yours, they own it and can "do whatever they damn well please with it", right? If she chooses to run a "business" on a free site, I guess that was her choice. There is risk it could be shut down. I know LOTS of people who use free email accounts for their company communication.


Actually that is not true. A gas station can stop from you posting flyers in their store and they can stop you from picketing on their property. There was a case around me last year, a guy was mad at the price of gas and got ontop of the gas station and was protesting with a sign. They called the cops and had him and his friends down on the ground removed from the property. You can protest on the street if you want, but once you enter the actual gas station property they have the right to have you removed.

Also what are you talking about facebook changing her pics? They didn't alter anything, they banned her account. That is all THEY did. SHE altered the pics to put barcodes where somebody might have a problem, however that didn't help as one of her friends filed a complaint with facebook so they removed her account. They didn't change her content, they deleted it. That is not the same as google sending out an email using your account, that is the same as Kyle or Steve removing part of somebodies post after they post something that is in volation of the forum rules.

You are right she choice to run her business using a free service, and there is a risk that is could be shutdown. However SHE is now bitching that is was shutdown and is sueing for lost money due to her profile not being on the site anymore. If her web pressence is that imporatant that it needs to be there 24x7 without any disruptions then as I stated before she should have had her own site. Sure a lot of bands, artist, movies.. have a page on facebook / myspace. But normally that isn't the only presence they have online and is not the way they plan on making 100% of their money. If it is, they they desire what ever happens to them if the site goes down or their page goes down...

It doesn't matter if she is breaking the law or not, a site can have whatever rules they want. Try breaking about 1/2 the rules on this forum and see if Kyle doesn't ban your ass.
 
This debate doesn't really go anywhere until we (people, the law) redefine electronic property.

To say that websites and property held in cyberspace should be treated the same as physical property is absurd. There's many stark differences between the two and many common sense differences. To hold one by the standards of others just runs people in circles and doesn't get us (the community) anywhere.
 
See what happens when the Democrats take over the US? Everyone starts to practice censorship. Can you say "Socialist world?"
 
Waxman and Genachowski are already in talks to regulate the internet's content in the US. :(
 
See what happens when the Democrats take over the US? Everyone starts to practice censorship. Can you say "Socialist world?"

Ain't gonna fly, they already banned the breast feeding boobie during the Bush administration ;)
 
I don't see whats the big deal here, FB have their own rules, just like any other website does

I'm sure hardforum here would remove post containing inappropriate pictures that is against the rules here while there are certain forums out there that encourage such picture

Same goes for FB. Those who wants to do something against the rules there should take their attention craving to some other sites that allows it. FB didn't guarantee that their site can be use as a place to run a business either.
 
i think its fine that she got banned.....people are too de-sensitized to nudity and language....in an effort to try and keep it younger people friendly i think its fine to ban them....

this is why people can make thier profile private to which people can not see it unless added as a friend.


and too de-sensitized? do you remeber the janet jackson boob fiasco? people are far TOO sensitive about nudity.
 
Also facebook is in no way public, they are a company and you agree to THEIR rules when you sign up, period, end of it, they can do what ever they want to who ever they want for what ever reason they want, if any.

publically accessible has nothing to do with it as others pointed out already.
 
1. Make Facebook Account
2. Make deviantart account.
3. Upload N00dz to DA
4. Link to your deviantart profile on your facebook profile with a disclaimer
5. ???
6. Profit!
 
this is why people can make thier profile private to which people can not see it unless added as a friend.
QUOTE]

But it was one of her 700 "friends" that reported her. So I'm guessing she already had it setup that way.
 
Get it through your heads people. Facebook can ban you for having blonde hair if they want to. It's a private site.
 
See what happens when the Democrats take over the US? Everyone starts to practice censorship. Can you say "Socialist world?"

Not even on topic & straight out of left.....errrr, right field. On top of that in the circumstance of facebook, as has been stated, they did this stuff BEFORE the 'z0mg commie socialists' renamed us the ussa. It's suprises me how desperate some of you guys are to whine or complain that you can't even wait for a remotely relative topic to do it. :rolleyes:
 
LOL, and after yesterdays news, now the Facebook staff is able to fap fap fap over her pictures and she can't do anything about it.
 
Back
Top