NSA Declassifies 200-Year-Old Book

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Chris Carter of the X-Files was right: The truth is out there. In response to a Presidential order for more transparency issued in 2009, the National Security Agency has begun to release declassified documents. The document release will continue over the next two years culminating with the whereabouts of the Indiana Jones Arc of the Covenent. Talk about your transparency :D
 
LOL epic :D I am glad they are staying on top of Obama's transparency demands!
 
So, it took them two years to craft documents that would stand the light of day? No wonder the Chinese are winning the intarweb wars.
 
10:1 it'll be like a Freedom of Information Act request, where you'll see a photocopy of a document with black bars over every other word :D
 
So, it took them two years to craft documents that would stand the light of day? No wonder the Chinese are winning the intarweb wars.

More like it took this long to to take people with a high enough clearance to look at the stuff, away from more useful positions, (budget constraints and all), to go through piles of documents and decide what should be declassified or not.

Declassifying document requires that someone with the appropriate clearance actually reads it to insure there are no bits that damage our security, or just as importantly, damages our relationship with allies and other foreign countries. Even old crap can damage relations with other countries. This is not a quick process without throwing a ton of money at it. And since nobody is willing to throw a ton of money at it, it is a slow process.

What do people think happens when they declassify documents? Do people think that some creepy looking, middle aged guy, that looks disturbingly like he just assassinated the leader of some third world country, walks around a heavily guarded warehouse pointing at 12' tall stacks of document boxes saying "release this, release that, and that"?
 
10:1 it'll be like a Freedom of Information Act request, where you'll see a photocopy of a document with black bars over every other word :D

Definitely.

It'd probably look like:

"During the Roswell, New Mexico incident, we discovered an [================================] with a [================================] inside..."

:p
 
More like it took this long to to take people with a high enough clearance to look at the stuff, away from more useful positions, (budget constraints and all), to go through piles of documents and decide what should be declassified or not.

Declassifying document requires that someone with the appropriate clearance actually reads it to insure there are no bits that damage our security, or just as importantly, damages our relationship with allies and other foreign countries. Even old crap can damage relations with other countries. This is not a quick process without throwing a ton of money at it. And since nobody is willing to throw a ton of money at it, it is a slow process.

What do people think happens when they declassify documents? Do people think that some creepy looking, middle aged guy, that looks disturbingly like he just assassinated the leader of some third world country, walks around a heavily guarded warehouse pointing at 12' tall stacks of document boxes saying "release this, release that, and that"?

Clearly, deciding whether a 200 year old document on cryptography is relevant to our national security or may damage our international relations is a task only the most illustrious and wise intelligence officer could even begin to attempt, and only with the backing of millions of dollars of funding to study the potential ramifications.
 
This will be followed by the location of the island that Elvis and Jimmy Hoffa are on.
 
LOL epic :D I am glad they are staying on top of Obama's transparency demands!

epic comedy for sure

A secretive person demanding other people be transparent, and they comply more than a year later by releasing 200 year old crap.

can't make this stuff up.
 
Clearly, deciding whether a 200 year old document on cryptography is relevant to our national security or may damage our international relations is a task only the most illustrious and wise intelligence officer could even begin to attempt, and only with the backing of millions of dollars of funding to study the potential ramifications.

Make funnies all you want. The point is that someone still has to look at it, to know what it is, prior to releasing it. This is time consuming, and expensive when you start talking about the man hours required from people both, qualified, and having the required clearances, to do it.
 
epic comedy for sure

A secretive person demanding other people be transparent, and they comply more than a year later by releasing 200 year old crap.

can't make this stuff up.
I was just about to post the exact same thing :)
 
More like it took this long to to take people with a high enough clearance to look at the stuff, away from more useful positions, (budget constraints and all), to go through piles of documents and decide what should be declassified or not.

Declassifying document requires that someone with the appropriate clearance actually reads it to insure there are no bits that damage our security, or just as importantly, damages our relationship with allies and other foreign countries. Even old crap can damage relations with other countries. This is not a quick process without throwing a ton of money at it. And since nobody is willing to throw a ton of money at it, it is a slow process.

What do people think happens when they declassify documents? Do people think that some creepy looking, middle aged guy, that looks disturbingly like he just assassinated the leader of some third world country, walks around a heavily guarded warehouse pointing at 12' tall stacks of document boxes saying "release this, release that, and that"?

It does seem like it would be pretty time consuming. I can't imagine how many bags of funyuns and coke they went through.
 
More like it took this long to to take people with a high enough clearance to look at the stuff, away from more useful positions, (budget constraints and all), to go through piles of documents and decide what should be declassified or not.

Declassifying document requires that someone with the appropriate clearance actually reads it to insure there are no bits that damage our security, or just as importantly, damages our relationship with allies and other foreign countries. Even old crap can damage relations with other countries. This is not a quick process without throwing a ton of money at it. And since nobody is willing to throw a ton of money at it, it is a slow process.

What do people think happens when they declassify documents? Do people think that some creepy looking, middle aged guy, that looks disturbingly like he just assassinated the leader of some third world country, walks around a heavily guarded warehouse pointing at 12' tall stacks of document boxes saying "release this, release that, and that"?

This, This, a thousand times this. The Regulations covering the Declassifying of ANY information says that it must be declassified by either the originating person or agency that classified the information or by a person with significant enough clearance to verify that the information will not hinder current operations or damage foreign relations.

Clearly, deciding whether a 200 year old document on cryptography is relevant to our national security or may damage our international relations is a task only the most illustrious and wise intelligence officer could even begin to attempt, and only with the backing of millions of dollars of funding to study the potential ramifications.
We still use some cryto equipment as secondary and/or tertiary/emergency systems. So, yes, 200 y/o crypto equip could possible harm current cryptology abilities. But mostly what GORANKAR said. Its a matter of finding the right person with nothing better going on to declassify the information they are experts in, to go into the warehouse and sift through the info that can be released without damaging some operation or relation.
 
What do people think happens when they declassify documents? Do people think that some creepy looking, middle aged guy, that looks disturbingly like he just assassinated the leader of some third world country, walks around a heavily guarded warehouse pointing at 12' tall stacks of document boxes saying "release this, release that, and that"?

No, I think the possibility of any documents being released that could possibly result in embarrassment to a particular government office, let alone national security, seeing the light of day is close to nil. Regardless of current or future laws regarding transparency, the chiefs of our security branches control who will review documents, just as Corporations set their own internal metrics for quarterly bonuses. The fox is guarding the hen house.
 
You are prolly correct. It is unlikely that they are going to release anything that can possibly have any negative effect on the government in the present.
 
What do people think happens when they declassify documents? Do people think that some creepy looking, middle aged guy, that looks disturbingly like he just assassinated the leader of some third world country, walks around a heavily guarded warehouse pointing at 12' tall stacks of document boxes saying "release this, release that, and that"?

Sadly enough this is the way the majority of people on the internet thinks it should go. When the LCD is trying to pull the strings you're in for a world of hurt.

As far as this goes, I'm pretty excited to see what is released.
 
Another thing to remember is that we should not release any information which could expose someone who actually obtained that info...so almost all WW2 stuff will remain under wraps, let alone newer things.
 
Back
Top