Not... Understanding... I HATE NForce2

’m‚³‚ñ

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Jun 20, 2003
Messages
7,300
What the hell is it with NForce2 and RAM? This is an Epox 8RDA3+ running some Geil Ultra Platinum 3200. I can set my RAM timings to 2.5 4 4 11 and get perfect stability, but setting it to either 2.0 4 4 11 or 3.0 4 4 11 results in no boot. I don't understand this... My FSB is currently at 215 mhz and my 2500+ has a 10.5 multiplier (CPU maxes at 2.3 ghz, week 17 stepping, at 1.95v vcore). My VDimm is maxed at 2.9v. This RAM is just a few mhz above it's rated speed... Should it be bogging down already? Why must NForce2 be so freaking picky about RAM? They need to fix that stupid bug where 2 2 2 11 gets better bandwidth than 2 2 2 not 11.

End rant.
 
With my Buffalo PC3200 I can run 11-2-2-2 below 185FSB, 185- 200 I can run 11-2-2-2.5, 200-220 I have to run 11-3-3-2.5 The only RAM I see run over 200FSB at CAS 2.0 fairly consistently is the low-latency sticks from Mushkin, Corsair and OCZ. I also discovered that my Buffalo prefers VDimm set to Auto rather than a specific voltage and I can acheive 15FSB higher with sticks in slots 1 & 2 for single channel, the extra 15FSB negates any small advantage dual offered at a lower FSB setting.

Regards, Szandor
 
It's actually the Geil RAM itself I think.

I have Geil Ultra Platinum PC-3500. When I bought it both Geil and sites like ZipZoomFly, Geil themselves, Newegg, and Directron had it listed as 2-3-3-6. Now all the sites list it as 2.5-3-3-6.

I only have a single stick of RAM so I was looking into getting another stick so i can run dual-channel when I saw that. So I browsed the Geil support forum to find out what the hell was going on. http://www.geilusa.com/forum2/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=136&whichpage=1

Apparently some Geil RAM has stability issues with the NF2 chipset when running in dual-channel. That's why they changed the PC-3500 latencies. 2-3-3-6 proved unstable for most while 2.5-3-3-6 was stable.

S1
 
If you want a safe bet for most ANY motherboard, BH-5 seems to work wonders for people if you can get some.
 
I'd blame the Geil portion for the inability to run at CAS2.

I'd blame Winbond for making chips that are physically incapable of running CAS3.

You probably have CH5, and it was probably speed binned by Geil- i.e. The sticks that could do 3500 were sold as such, the rest as 3200, you bought 3200.
 
Originally posted by I(illa Bee
its not the Nforce2 fault...geli is shit ram...sorry

I don't know if i'd go that far by claiming it's shit.

My single stick runs like a champ at 2-3-3-6. And if I boosted the vdimm i bet 2-2-2-5 would be possible as many others have done it. Plus the RAM works really well in Intel based solutions.

There's just something about running Geil in dual-channel on NF2 motherboards.

Right now I need to decide if I want to stick with this and buy another stick and hope for 2-3-3-6 to be stable which it is for some people, buy another stick and run 2.5-3-3-6 and hope for a higher overclock, or sell it off and go Corsair.

S1
 
As far as I know, the Nforce 2 is incapable of running cas 3.0 stable, so for that, blame nvidia. But the cas 2.0 issue is probably a ram problem :( I can run 222 at 218fsb/436ddr so its probably both that are factors here. Why would you want to run cas 3 anyways?
 
Originally posted by Skull0ne
I don't know if i'd go that far by claiming it's shit.

My single stick runs like a champ at 2-3-3-6. And if I boosted the vdimm i bet 2-2-2-5 would be possible as many others have done it. Plus the RAM works really well in Intel based solutions.

There's just something about running Geil in dual-channel on NF2 motherboards.

Right now I need to decide if I want to stick with this and buy another stick and hope for 2-3-3-6 to be stable which it is for some people, buy another stick and run 2.5-3-3-6 and hope for a higher overclock, or sell it off and go Corsair.

S1

well, your onyl clocked at 200 fsb....my kingston will do 2-2-2-11 (fastest Nforce2 timings) all day long at 200 fsb...
 
I also see that you are running a xx.5 multiplier. Most n-force boards have problems with half multipliers. PLease try with the next step down and try again, hope this helps. How come nobody pointed this out? I thought that was pretty well known...later:)
 
Originally posted by IM [H]ard
I also see that you are running a xx.5 multiplier. Most n-force boards have problems with half multipliers. PLease try with the next step down and try again, hope this helps. How come nobody pointed this out? I thought that was pretty well known...later:)

Because i'm happy with my current speeds. technically i'm at 1.68 not 1.7 vcore. .03 over default to get a ~500mhz oc. No complaints from me.

I always figured I would try to go a little further after I stuck another stick of RAM in. but if it's not broke don't fix it.

S1
 
i think its the ram dude... i dont think its the nforce2 mobo...

i have mushkin pc3500 dual channel ram with Gigabyte GA-7N400 Pro2... and i am running them at 2-2-2-5 i think... probably go with kingston or mushkin dude....

PS. i had GEIL ram (pc2700 512mb stick) and it guaranteed to run at 2-3-something (cas2) but i can never run it at cas2... so i got rid of it and used kingston hyperx and everything worked fine @ cas2....

GL
 
This RAM ran at CAS2 just fine until I hit 210 mhz. It's currently running at the rated speeds of when I bought it at 215 fsb... Mine has 2.5 cas listed. :p

It's not just this board, or this RAM. I have another board with the Ultra 400 chipset and MCP-T southbridge. It has some PC 2700 RAM in it. It will run this RAM (a stick of PNY CRAP and a stick of generic stuff from frys, which I'm thinking is crucial or even corsair, but it is unmarked and does excellent timings) 2 2 2 11, 2.5 2 2 11, but not 3 2 2 11, or 3 x x x for that matter, and this is at 2.53v, 2.7v, 2.9v, auto, and whatever else (this is all at 100 mhz, or 200 DDR). This is in single chan or dual.

I've been thinking about pushing my mult down to 10 and increasing the FSB more, but I'm not sure if the RAM or the chipset will like that. I also have a Mobile Duron 1 ghz at 6 X 167 with the RAM doing 2 2 2 11 (the PNY and generic RAM mentioned above). I've been wondering about 5 X 180 for it... :p I'm not sure if this is an actual Ultra 400 chipset, it might be one of the older ones that is still Ultra but not 400. Ultra 333?
 
Back
Top