Not sure where to post, help?

signmeuptoo

Weaksauce
Joined
Jul 4, 2007
Messages
67
Hey guys, how's it hangin'?

A brief history here: Over the last two and a half years I have lived through hardware hell. Due to the sheer number of parts that I have gone through and changed out, mostly due to bad parts/failed parts and some for upgrades, I have never had a stable system, overclocked, normally clocked, or underclocked. I could list the two motherboards, the two RAM products, the three power supplies, the 2 hard drives, the optical drive, the 2 sound cards, the 2 video cards, and my Mac failure, (and even more), along with a bad CPU, but I am there now, seemingly with good parts, or so I thought...

Then I still kept gettinig BSODs, and after yet another fresh OS install (OMG, the dozens upon dozens of times over the months I have done fresh installs! (No, I cannot afford a good backup solution ATM, I am quite poor, I mean POOR, it has taken everything I have to build this system that is already quite outdated.) After the latest fresh install, less BSODs but now hangs or sudden crashes to POST...

Well, I may finally be on to something with the problems in my latest iteration of my system:

First, the list of my hardware:

DFI LP UT nF4 SLI DR (that replaced an ASUS A8V Deluxe that turned out to test fine by Antec)

AMD Athy 64 4800+ s939 Toledo (3rd processor, started with a good 3200 that I couldn't tell was good, then the bad 4800 that couldn't overclock even 4% and was unstable, now the new one is amazing, it will overclock like an Opty!)

Team Xtreme Cronus Micron 5B-f DDR-500 2x2GB paired RAM sticks, used to have a questionable pair of OCZ sticks that gave errors in memtest86+

Creative Labs Audigy 2 ZS Platinum (I added the front bay box and made it platinum), the previous unit was an Audigy NX that gave me nothing but misery and that Creative had the audacity to refuse to honor the warranty on!

ASUS and NEC burners that are good, replaced a bad Lite On, both the ASUS and NEC are WAY downrev, too, BTW, I need an upgrade, but I also need money, so...

Brand new Seagate drives: 750 Gig 7200.10 & 500 Gig 7200.10 ES, replaced a couple bad drives, one a WD PATA 250 gig that died JUST as it went out of warranty! Also currently using an Excelstor 80 gig, all current drives are SATA, the sea's are SATAII.

Still using an very old but good quality CRT that is starting to get dim.

Samsung 2010 Laser Printer.

HP 7260 color printer with card reader.

Logitech G15, original model.

MS Mouse, Wireless Intellimouse Explorer 2.0 Leather from LONG AGO.

MS VX-3000 Webcam.

Magic Jack VOIP stick.

Saitek Cybrog GOLD USB joystick.

Logitech Game pad, the original fancier one with the six, not four, chicklet buttons, is wireless.

That pretty much sums it up. An old, downrev system that, even IF it is old, I treasure. Sure, I'd love to buy all new stuff, but I am disabled and cannot work and don't even have enough money to eat meat at every meal. Beans and rice for supper here often enough...

Ok, so here is what my most recent discovery SEEMS TO REVEAL:

This motherboard has two network controllers, gigabit, one is a Marvell and the other the nVidia built in to the MCP. I need and use both: One is needed for my own DSL Modem/router, a Westell 327W on Bellsouth DSL on my personal internet account. The other Network interface is needed for access to my roomate's boxes via my older, and very old Linksys router connected to his single port Westell 6100 (IIRC) modem router (which has been set to NOT run as a router, BTW, so as to allow the Linksys BEFSR41 to work, which is a Rev. 2 IIRC).

I normally leave the network controller attached to the Linksys and HIS network disabled because otherwise while I am running torrents, it loads down HIS, not MINE accounts. This happens EVEN THOUGH I *HAVE* set the controller for MY network as the priority controller.

Well, here is what I think I have discovered, with all that information out of the way: I always assumed that using the nVidia network controller on board, rather than the Marvell on board, was more desireable (just had it in my head, that's all) so I have always used the nVidia one for my priority, personal, network, such as my torrents and webaccess, and left the Marvell off unless I was accessing his network in order to move files between us.

Well:

I have tried so many things and now, finally, seem to be on to something, just maybe (but I can't be certain yet since it's only been a little over a day and a half):

My on board nVidia Network Controller is somehow buggy OR the drivers for it are, because ever since suspecting something, I swapped the two NICs so that the Marvell was used for MY OWN Network and I haven't turned on the nVidia one to access his network for over a day and a half.

So some guys in another forum have told me that they also, indeed, on other, newer motherboards, have discovered that THEIR nVidia on board NICs were indeed also giving THEM misery.

So I have to wonder, I have used 2 different iterations of drivers for my nVidia based mainboard, one old old one and the other is the latest. I long ago discovered that using the nVidia firewall crap caused horrible issues, and remembering that is what made me suspicious here.

So:

How many of you think that it is indeed likely that the nVidia NIC is a culprit? Or how many of you think nVidia just can't make good drivers? How many of you think I should try yet a different iteration of the drivers?

Also, is it indeed true that the nVidia Network controllers are traditionally problematic?

If you were me, would you have DFI replace this board (and what are the chances they even still have one?)

Much thanks!

BTW, I am keeping my MCP cooler with an Evercool VC-RE with AS5, but had this problem before changing from the stock cooler. The Evercool only drops temps, even though it is lapped, about, oh, 5 degrees... Current MCP temps are about 46 degrees with it overvolted ONLY one step (the problem was there with it not overvolted, that's why I increased the Vs)

Opinions? Advice? Discuss?

Thanks!
 
On my old MSI K8N Neo4 Platinum/SLI that I had for nearly two years, I used the nVidia Ethernet port for everything, in XP, Vista, and Linux (forcedeth driver), and never had a problem with anything. No BSOD's certainly. It could be the Ethernet port on your board that's the problem, but it's not a general problem that everybody has. If it does end up being the problem, you could just get a cheap Intel PCI Ethernet card and disable the nVidia port in the BIOS; Intel is known for having the best network cards out there.
 
But I don't have a spare slot PCI Legacy slot, so I don't want that option if I can help it. What you are saying tempts me to want to get the mainboard replaced, but I need opinions here from lots of folks, hopefully from fellow LP owners.
 
No plain PCI you say? Does that imply that you have an extra PCI Express slot? ;) If so, then Intel has a PCI Express version too. Anyway, I agree that having more feedback would be good too.
 
I'd switch the system out for an Intel C2D setup ;) . otherwise, find a PCIe ethernet card. The ethernet card would be the cheapest option.

By the way, I sympathize with you about the hardware hell thing. In the past 3 years, I've gone through 2x Asus P5LD2's (retail and RMA), 1x Abit IB9, and 2x AW9D-Max (retail+RMA), 4 power supplies (x-clio, antec, and hipro -> 2 units, both the retail and RMA died), 5 purchases of RAM from 4 different manufacturers (1 RMA to GeIL), 7 graphic card purchases, 2 of which were returned due to problems, 3 RMA's to seagate w/ 5 purchases of hard drives, purchased 2x heatsinks (scythe ninja and GeminII). Lots of shit go wrong =(
 
Bad luck there on the hardware front, and I can feel for the $$ shituation.

I just wanted to add that I am using an Intel Pro 1000 PT PCIe ethernet card and it is VERY nice. It has TCP offloading (a features claimed by nVidia's ethernet cards) and even teaming if you have another one, all without buggy drivers (another big feature for nVidia ethernet cards unfortuneately).

I also looked up your mobo and you should have two PCI slots...unless you have a double width VGA cards in the bottom slot. I hope that you get your stuff resolved. If it BSODs with the nvidia ethernet enabled, and it doesn't with it disabled, and it is still under warrantee, I would RMA it personally as I am a pretty patient person and I have a backup laptop machine.

Jason
 
I am surprised others aren't offering opinions here. Here's what bothers me a little:

I bought this board brand new. Now, the Marvell NI is a separate chip, but the nVidia NI is integrated into the Chipset MCP, I believe. If that part of the MCP is flaky, what's to say more of it won't fail later?

I am really torn, I don't know if I should call DFI and ask them to replace it, and send it in and they don't test it as bad and return it and all that time I am without a computer... But if I don't get it replaced, and it dies on me, crap!
 
I have a westell 6100 modem.. it is never suppose to be dialed up as it should always be on.. however, mine keeps disconnecting and needs to be redial/connected to get online. I have tried the default number and followed westell instruction but I can not get into the "managing page" to see or change possible settings.. I used to be able to month ago but can no longer.. what can I do to keep the DSL always on an not disconnecting when it wants and never have to click on dial for connection?

Would appreciate any help and responses to private message, here or my email at trishaconry@outlook.com.

Thanks.
 
Back
Top