Nonfree DRM'd Games on GNU/Linux: Good or Bad?

EULA's are pure BS and the part about we can change it at any time if you don't like it GTF out is the worst part.
DRM is just crazy and the always connected part on a single player game is BEYOND STUPID.

BUT I do like the idea of linux because so many can tell MS to go F themselves BIG TIME
I would like to see them go out of business....overall their heavy handed crap with office and the millions they make in spyware they install is crazy.

What is with Linux supporters being conspiracy nut cases?

Microsoft doesn't install spyware.
MS Office is generally better than other office packages.
MS going out of business would be terrible - less competition is bad not good.

And I work on Linux software development daily....
 
because games you buy on steam are forever locked in steam, and then you're forced to always use steam or you don't get your games.

Steam has DRM. But the DRM is meant to protect the developers, designers, and content creators. It also (for me at least) is one of the only DRMs that actually makes my life as a user EASIER. I can install Steam on any of my machines and have access to any of the games I've purchased through steam. No hassle. Hell it even syncs my save games sometimes.
 
Steam on OSX amounted to little. The releases are a few small time indir/casual games a month with the occasional exception (last major game was in april). Thats for 5% of the userbase...Linux is 1-2%. Unless your game is in a form thats easily translated, it's probably not going to be enough to cover costs.

If you were asked "what OS should I go for to play games", Linux would be a mean answer. :p
 
Linux has to choose. Are they going to be totally free and open, forever relegated to tweakers? Or are they going to accept some closed components in exchange for market acceptance?

It's really quite funny, because I know of plenty of non-free Linux software that has extremely restrictive license requirements.

I mean, the nVidia official graphics drivers for Linux are closed-source, and they're considered some of the most robust drivers (they are free, however).

I used to work in a graduate students' computing lab that had LOTS of multi-thousand dollar software. We had to set up a server whose sole job was to check out the handful of licenses we had to run that software. All that software was closed source and we had to pay to use it. We used MATLAB and lots of computational fluid dynamics software that was developed by commerical entities.

It seems crazy to me that we're having an argument about non-free Linux programs, because plenty of them already exist.
 
[Tripod]MajorPayne;1038996773 said:
It's really quite funny, because I know of plenty of non-free Linux software that has extremely restrictive license requirements.

I mean, the nVidia official graphics drivers for Linux are closed-source, and they're considered some of the most robust drivers (they are free, however).

I used to work in a graduate students' computing lab that had LOTS of multi-thousand dollar software. We had to set up a server whose sole job was to check out the handful of licenses we had to run that software. All that software was closed source and we had to pay to use it. We used MATLAB and lots of computational fluid dynamics software that was developed by commerical entities.

It seems crazy to me that we're having an argument about non-free Linux programs, because plenty of them already exist.

The Intel drivers are considerably better than the nVidia's drivers. Intel's drivers are all free software and part of the mainline kernel tree. Intel is very open about releasing hardware specifications. Intel's drivers use standards and support things like KMS. Intel's Linux drivers are better than their Windows drivers.

nVidia's drivers work by replacing the standard Mesa GL with a non-standard proprietary OpenGL implementation and by using overwrites to replace a lot of the code in the X Server.
 
Linux has to choose. Are they going to be totally free and open, forever relegated to tweakers? Or are they going to accept some closed components in exchange for market acceptance?

I am not sure that is much of a question. I mean, for us non-Linux-but-some-day-hope-to-be folks, we want ease of use of MS wrapped up with the power and freedom of Linux so what you are asking makes sense. But most Linux folks conversations I read on forums don't really care about how much market acceptance their OS has. When I was researching mythTV, I saw a lot of, "This product wasn't designed to fit those needs, you should stick to WMC." given out as advice.
 
When you have time to read the linked article this thread is discussing you'll see that's exactly what he does. Or if you did click through to it make sure to read or skip to the last couple paragraphs where he clarifies his position.

Maybe you should read the thing yourself because it always plays out the same way with him.

Nowhere in there did he say he supported it or that it was a good thing. He said:

I suppose that availability of popular nonfree programs on GNU/Linux can boost adoption of the system.

Then goes into detail about how thats a BAD thing and even sends a message to the community basically telling people to pretend the damn thing dont exist and dont talk about it.

So no, in no way does he do exactly (or even close) to what i said he should.

I have read the article and have listened to a couple interviews with him where he goes into detail about steam on linux.
 
We must be reading different articles then because the last couple paragraphs of the article I read is:

However, if you're going to use these games, you're better off using them on GNU/Linux rather than on Microsoft Windows. At least you avoid the harm to your freedom that Windows would do.

Thus, in direct practical terms, this development can do both harm and good. It might encourage GNU/Linux users to install these games, and it might encourage users of the games to replace Windows with GNU/Linux. My guess is that the direct good effect will be bigger than the direct harm.

(emphasis mine)
 
We must be reading different articles then because the last couple paragraphs of the article I read is:



(emphasis mine)

We must be because nowhere in that is any support for steam on linux whatsoever. :rolleyes:

Its condescending bullshit from a fanatic.

I also like how you bolded that last sentence and ignored everything that followed it. :rolleyes:
 
Stallman talks a lot about freedom yet wants to take away our ability to install what we want drm or not. Just like a religious fanatic he's trying to force HIS idea of freedom on the users and that in itself it's taking away one freedom to protect another.

He's not trying to force anything on anyone - he doesn't have the ability to do that, nor do I believe that he would if he could. It goes against his whole fanatical-love-of-freedom thing.
 
Back
Top