No used games on PS3?

From another forum, for you all to ponder :p
For hardcore gamers, when you floated the base 360 with no hard drive rumor awhile back the impression was "no way" If you would have told me a month ago that Sony would plan to have no unified online experience, that they wouldn't even try with the next generation to compete with Live, I'd have thought you were smoking crack. I (like all of you so far) seriously doubt that they would be dumb enough to lock the console to just new games but with some of the other craziness that Ken and Co have been coming up with, will you truly be suprised if they announce this as a cool new "feature"?

Now I'm going to go play my "dreamcast" :D
 
Dude seriously, re-read this thread with Total Eclipse of the Heart... you wanna fight someone to save the world at the end.

And again, sony does suck. What's their probs nowadays? Rootkits? No fucking rentals? Someone needs to have their shit ruined a few times
 
This is awesome, and I'm calling bullshit.
Kutaragi might be a prick, but I doubt he's this stupid. Sony would be shutting off two outlets that help keep the consumers interested in the platform. They would do this just to thwart piracy? Give me a break, they know anything they do will be circumvented by somebody, somewhere.

If I'm wrong and they do go about this, it will be cracked faster than eggs in a shit-storm.

Damn Sony was so cool in the PSX days, so many new genres popped up and so many fresh and offbeat games were released. That was true innovation baby...does anyone else think gaming is in a serious stalemate right now?
 
actually, as a result of the rootkit shit i've decided to stop buying PS2 games new, used and ebay only for me. not willing to give up the better titles, but deprive them of the revenue? oh hell yeah
 
I bet they will try it in Japan. The pre-played games market there is just getting started and all of the gamemakers hate it. Even if they did implement it here, here's how that conversation would go:

EB Store (Picture Milton from Office Space): Sony, we don't like that we can't sell pre-played PS3 games. If you don't stop it... we'll do something... I...

Sony (Picture Terrance & Phillip from South Park): PHHHHRAPPPPPT! I just fahted on him!!!!!! In his mouth!!!!!!! I bet it tasted like Elsinore Beer!!!!

EB Store: I mean it... I'll quit selling your system... I will...*walks off like a bitch*


Wal-mart doesn't sell pre-played games, Toys-R-Us doesn't either. Best-Buy was thinking about it, but the people at ours said that they weren't moving any of that used product. Quote: "People come to Best Buy to get new stuff, not somebody else's old shit." What leverage do the mall stores have? Sony will tell them to eat a dick if they bitch. They can't not sell the PS3. That would be suicide.
 
I just don't like the fact that Sony is telling me how, where, and if I can play their games which I spend my hard earned money on. I know piracy is a big issue but they will definitely piss off a bunch of gamers if they go that route. Maybe I will buy a 360 instead.
 
Actualy at this point i've got such a huge back log of games to play i think i'm gonna wait a year or more for all this to settle out, i'll probably snag a Revolution at launch though, unless it is disclosed that it sucks too for some reason
 
Don't worry, I'm sure tomorrow somebody will find a reason. lol
Like I said in my previous post, it sounds insane, but considering the other things that happened, it wouldn't surprise me at all. After all, Bluray is still not 100% done, and it is a new format, so the possibilities for DRM are endless at this point. Look out EB/gamestop.
 
I just dont see this happening.

Each disc unique?

That means they need to press each disc individually.

uh huh

or modifying the discs? That would mean that the discs are re-writable. I see this lasting about 10 seconds, some hacker gets a disc before he slaps it in his ps3, takes a image of it, chucks it in the ps3, pulls it out again and takes another image.

Yep, that'll work.
 
The King of Pants said:
actually, as a result of the rootkit shit i've decided to stop buying PS2 games new, used and ebay only for me. not willing to give up the better titles, but deprive them of the revenue? oh hell yeah
Lol you decied to start buying used?

Man my entire console collection has been used after my Dreamcast. Used Xbox, PS2, and GameCube. Plus of course the games are used.

My PC takes up half my gaming time and the other half I use on my consoles. If a really nice game comes out on a console system my PC will be more then enough to keep me busy until the games are cheap enough to buy used. :)

If you own a console system you do two things with it. Either you keep everything in a place like a dusty gaming museum or you sell or trade it for a new system.

I say let the fools preorder. All the more sweeter it'll eventually be for me.

Only fools are satisfied with things brand new.
 
Yeah, I call shenanigans.
In Japan they already settled a case about selling used games, the Japanese Government says it's OK...and since they say it's OK, I don't see how Sony will make totally different games and hardware for the US version so they can do this 'No Used Games' thing.
 
BigFuzzyArchon said:
if any of you actually believe that, you really do not deserve to continue to waste the earth's resources, so just stop.

You do realize this is the same company that puts malware on your PC, when you buy an audio CD such as I did with Foo Fighter In your Honor. If the company had not used harsh piracy protection measures in the past, then you may have a point. As it stands now, they have already shown they don't give a damn about the paying customer, they only care about reaping as much profit as necessary, even if it means inconveniencing paying customers. It certainly is possible that Sony would try this measures, but "continue to waste the earths resources" ? I would say you ill thought post accomplishes that very well.
 
Draax said:
You do realize this is the same company that puts malware on your PC, when you buy an audio CD such as I did with Foo Fighter In your Honor. If the company had not used harsh piracy protection measures in the past, then you may have a point. As it stands now, they have already shown they don't give a damn about the paying customer, they only care about reaping as much profit as necessary, even if it means inconveniencing paying customers. It certainly is possible that Sony would try this measures, but "continue to waste the earths resources" ? I would say you ill thought post accomplishes that very well.

But the problem here is simple. Sony knows they are fucking up, just look at their profit margins. I just can't see them doing something like this in a time when the company is in utter turmoil. Sony isn't going to cut off any viable means for them to sell product, and the rental industry is just that. How many of you guys rent games?
 
Rich Tate said:
But the problem here is simple. Sony knows they are fucking up, just look at their profit margins. I just can't see them doing something like this in a time when the company is in utter turmoil. Sony isn't going to cut off any viable means for them to sell product, and the rental industry is just that. How many of you guys rent games?

Sony has fucked up on everything from Star Wars Galaxies, to BMG Sony products, to PlayStation read errors. There have been public outcries and petitions every time, yet they buldozed through. I believe that Sony really believes they will see higher profit margines, by forcing consumers to buy a product, instead of renting, borrowing, copying, replacing, etc.
 
Draax said:
Sony has fucked up on everything from Star Wars Galaxies, to BMG Sony products, to PlayStation read errors. There have been public outcries and petitions every time, yet they buldozed through. I believe that Sony really believes they will see higher profit margines, by forcing consumers to buy a product, instead of renting, borrowing, copying, replacing, etc.

I see your point here, but have to disagree. I would HOPE eventually Sony is going to realize that they cannot dictate the entire market anymore. The iPod is putting thier devices under, and so will the Xbox if you try and pull this kind of shit.

Being that we have another year until the PS3 launch, I'd be willing to bet the 360 numbers are going to dictate alot of changes, or at least alter some paths of thinking.
 
Rich Tate said:
I see your point here, but have to disagree. I would HOPE eventually Sony is going to realize that they cannot dictate the entire market anymore. The iPod is putting thier devices under, and so will the Xbox if you try and pull this kind of shit.

Being that we have another year until the PS3 launch, I'd be willing to bet the 360 numbers are going to dictate alot of changes, or at least alter some paths of thinking.

I think you are correct that Sony will have to, out of necessity, change some of there business practices. I think the launch of the XBOX360 is going to be a real wake up call for Sony. To me it seems like Sony always has to learn the hard way, hopefully they will not have to go that route this time.
 
Draax said:
I think you are correct that Sony will have to, out of necessity, change some of there business practices. I think the launch of the XBOX360 is going to be a real wake up call for Sony. To me it seems like Sony always has to learn the hard way, hopefully they will not have to go that route this time.

Agreed as well. I hope MS pushes the limits with the 360, maybe Sony will wake up and start to innovate a little. Say what you want about it, but Nintendo is trying. If everyone gets on board, it only helps us to have a better gaming experience.
 
Sony and MS are both in for a rude awakening this time around. And honestly it serves them both right for trying to so highly commercialize gaming to the point where all we will see is Sports, Racing, Homie Simulator, Movie Licenses, and other "mainstream" homoginized crap. Gaming is not about horsepower, or money... it is about fun. And fun is something that has been sorely missing from about 90% of the releases these days.

I'm wishing all the best to Nintendo, I truly hope they can pull a rabbit out of their hat and bring gaming back to it's roots of gameplay and fun.
 
bruenor said:
Sony and MS are both in for a rude awakening this time around. And honestly it serves them both right for trying to so highly commercialize gaming to the point where all we will see is Sports, Racing, Homie Simulator, Movie Licenses, and other "mainstream" homoginized crap. Gaming is not about horsepower, or money... it is about fun. And fun is something that has been sorely missing from about 90% of the releases these days.

I'm wishing all the best to Nintendo, I truly hope they can pull a rabbit out of their hat and bring gaming back to it's roots of gameplay and fun.

I agree with that totally. We play games at the core of it simply because we enjoy the experience. That's why I have replayed my FFs and MGs, I simply love those games and the gaming experience they give me.
 
I've been thinking more about this. I still can't see Sony going through with it, it would definately hurt sales of the console, as the 360 seems to be a lot nicer than anyone in their right mind would've expected it to be. Still, even if Sony does do this, I will still buy a PS3, if only for the game, there are no 360 titles that look appealing to me, while I am lusting after several of the announced PS3 titles already... Then again, I only buy my games new, as buying pre-owned you usually save like $5 at most, and oftentimes there are little scratches (that could become deeper later on) or the packagin/manual/etc. is damaged or missing. Even if I never actually touch the manual, I want it to be perfect damnit.

I actually see a potentially nifty use for this tech that could benefit Sony and the consumer.

Anyone remember DIVX? Not the MPEG-Codec but the old Digital Video Express concept that CC pushed years back. If not, basically it worked like this: You could buy a new-release DVD for like $4-$5, take it home, put it in a DIVX enabled DVD player, and it would play for 48 hours as much as you liked. Basically it was a rental that you never had to return, and you could pay to 'unlock' the disc to have it work normally in your DIVX enabled player, just as if you had bought the regular DVD. It ended up failing for a couple reasons: 1, the DIVX releases were full-screen, less special features, less options than the regular DVDs, this was still when DVD players were $300+, it was still an enthusiasts market, and enthusiasts don't want full-screen DVDs. 2, DIVX players were more expensive, 3, $4 - $5 for 48 hours is more expensive than most DVD rentals from a local shop.

However, I could see this new tech becoming handy for Sony to release it's own direct game 'rental' system. I doubt Sony would set up all discs with this system, but they might release a 2nd version of the games as well, one that you can put into the machine, have it be recognized, remembered, and unlocked to play for a certain period of time, then locked again, and since the code on the disc was erased, you can't just pop it into another machine and get to play it again free. Think about it, you go to best-buy or wherever, and as you are checking out, there is a rack of a bunch of hot new PS3 games, full releases, but only playable for 1 week each, and costing only $4 or $5. You get to check out the game beyond a demo without spending a bunch of money, and then go buy a real version if you want it. Plus, don't have to worry about returning it like a rental, just toss it.
 
superostrich said:
I just don't like the fact that Sony is telling me how, where, and if I can play their games which I spend my hard earned money on.
It was a quote in a SPONG article. Geez. If you think that this is an official feature announcement, well... that's up to you . It's doubtful this will end up in the PS3.
 
Holy shit, I just had a long post made for this to end the rumor and shut the haters up, but this damn mac faaked up.

Anyhoo, bottom line, Sony makes killing selling games to the rental companies. You really can't believe they buy each of those games for 50 dollars can you? You really think after 10 rentals from an 8 year old kid and they turn a profit? You know how much a dvd cost BB? Try 120 dollars a piece, and thats on any of them, and some companies/producers demand more for each. I don't remember how much each game was when I worked for a BB, but it was more then 50 bucks. I am very sure of it. And this is prob the only used game market sony doesn't care about becuase they already made a shit load off the company for each copy. If they do it, they will special flag it like they did the rental copies of movies etc.

As for the used market for games... This is a thron in all 3 console producers and the company game industry. Why do you think they are cracking down on piracy and how you register your games. They lose a ton of money to both piracy and used game sales. Is it so bad that the developers want to be paid for their works? You have a pretty large staff producing these games and they want to be able to eat too you know. Granted the game industry netted a few bill last year and the next 2 years will be more then that. Just think of their profits if they dind't have to fight this. I honeslty feel that Gamestop and EB should have to pay back slight royalities to the publishers for used game sales. In all my time of buying games, I have bought 1 or 2 used games. Everything was either a rental or a new purchase. The only time I can justify buying a used game is nostaliga or a rare game like Einhander, which I STILL CANT FUCKING FIND ANYWHERE for a decent price or with the god damn case. That and I also don't want someones sloppy seconds. Also, if the game is hard to find and I really reallly reallllllly want it, it's about the only time I'd buy a new game used.

A 10-15 year old used game from like '95 isnt going to hurt sales as much as a '06 game being bought, and then sold back by the guy to get another game. Then person 2 comes in and buys his used game for almost the price of new. Who just got ripped off here?
Guy 1, Guy 2 and The maker.
Guy 1 barely over half for his 1 to 2 week gold game and guy 2 almost payed full price for a used game. The maker saw jack shit off that second sell and The store just made double profits off it, after buying it back for less then the cost of buying it new from Sony to sell it retail.

Sony isn't going to tank and the only part of Sony I want to tank is SOE. They ruined a really good game and ran off the heart of it because they wanted more from them. AKA more games and not work on 1 or 2 and produce those and make them killer and to keep their players playing.

Sony isnt going to do it becuase there is to many legit reasons why someone wouldn't want to be forced to keep their games on 1 system. Now maybe this could work if the game info got saved to a memory card and as long as you had that, you could take it any where and play it.

(btw360blows,ps3forthewin! i had to put my console choice in here, even tho i prefer the PC, sony always has games I want to play. Xbox had only 1 and that was when halo was first out.)
 
For those who are up on blu-ray and hd dvd's, is the transition going to be similiar to the tranistion of cd to dvd? I mean remember how scrathed cd's can get and still play perfectly, then you had to take better care of dvds because the tracks were much, much closer together. Are they blu-ray and the hd roms going to have extremely close tracks? or multiple layers? Possibly that could be a factor in the reason sony isn't going to allow rentals, think about, with all the careless children out there throwing around the disc's not caring because they know its not theirs....It would cost the rental companies alot of money, not to mention possible bad sales from sony buyers. Nothing would make me more mad, coming from blockbuster with a rented game, only to find out a tiny scratch prevented me from playing... :eek:

I guess this little post shows how little I know about the new dvd's

Sry if I took away from op.
 
Viper16 said:
For those who are up on blu-ray and hd dvd's, is the transition going to be similiar to the tranistion of cd to dvd? I mean remember how scrathed cd's can get and still play perfectly, then you had to take better care of dvds because the tracks were much, much closer together. Are they blu-ray and the hd roms going to have extremely close tracks? or multiple layers? Possibly that could be a factor in the reason sony isn't going to allow rentals, think about, with all the careless children out there throwing around the disc's not caring because they know its not theirs....It would cost the rental companies alot of money, not to mention possible bad sales from sony buyers. Nothing would make me more mad, coming from blockbuster with a rented game, only to find out a tiny scratch prevented me from playing... :eek:

I guess this little post shows how little I know about the new dvd's

Sry if I took away from op.


Originally, Blu-Ray was gonna ship in cartridges because the discs were even weaker than DVDs (easily scratched, etc.). However, thanks to TDK and their armor plating technology, Blu-Ray discs are gonna use the AP technology to get a super strong coating, so now Blu rays won't have the cartridges. Not sure about HD-DVDs.

Blu-Ray discs are spec'ed for 25 GB per layer. The spec allows for 8 layers, so 200 GB. I'm not sure, but I think they have 4 layer Blu Rays developed in lab. I think I read on either CDFreaks or Arstechnica that the way Blu-Ray drives are designed, the distance between the reading laser eye and the Blu-Ray disc is the closest any optical technology and scanner has ever been. The BR disc is hovering just ever so slightly above the reading eye.

HD-DVD, on the other hand, allows for 15 GB per layer, and 4 layers maximum, so 15 - 60 GB per disc.

And um...I'm done. /aside
 
Viper16 said:
For those who are up on blu-ray and hd dvd's, is the transition going to be similiar to the tranistion of cd to dvd? I mean remember how scrathed cd's can get and still play perfectly, then you had to take better care of dvds because the tracks were much, much closer together. Are they blu-ray and the hd roms going to have extremely close tracks? or multiple layers? Possibly that could be a factor in the reason sony isn't going to allow rentals, think about, with all the careless children out there throwing around the disc's not caring because they know its not theirs....It would cost the rental companies alot of money, not to mention possible bad sales from sony buyers. Nothing would make me more mad, coming from blockbuster with a rented game, only to find out a tiny scratch prevented me from playing... :eek:

I guess this little post shows how little I know about the new dvd's

Sry if I took away from op.

Blue Ray's laser is less then half the size of DVD and CD rom drive so the pits and bumps are EXTREMELY small, as well as HD-DVD have multiple layers as well. So scratches become even more deadly for these types of discs.
 
bruenor said:
Sony and MS are both in for a rude awakening this time around. And honestly it serves them both right for trying to so highly commercialize gaming to the point where all we will see is Sports, Racing, Homie Simulator, Movie Licenses, and other "mainstream" homoginized crap. Gaming is not about horsepower, or money... it is about fun. And fun is something that has been sorely missing from about 90% of the releases these days.

I'm wishing all the best to Nintendo, I truly hope they can pull a rabbit out of their hat and bring gaming back to it's roots of gameplay and fun.

AMEN!

Sony would be stupid to do this but they still will make money, i dont think if they did do this they would be out of buisness.
 
saturnine2 said:
Hell, this is a company that installed rootkits on audio cds. Anything is possible..

No, it isn't. Sony BMG installed rootkits. Sony Computer Entertainment has nothing to do with Sony BMG besides the Sony name. One cannot influence the other, as they have no authority over each other, not to mention that it's a stretch to imagine how a professional music company could want something to do with a video game hardware company. The PlayStation plays music CDs; that's about all Sony BMG cares for regarding SCE.

That said, there IS a patent relating to this, but it's more anti-piracy (involves reading a code from a disc each time the disc is loaded) than anti-used games (I didn't see anything in the patent that involves locking a code from a disc to a specific console.)

I'm just counting this as a drop in the bucket of negative publicity Sony's suffering lately, between the X360's launch (even though that's starting to falter a bit), lawsuits from the rootkit, and the fact that SCE is the only Sony division to earn a profit lately.
 
I guess I have a different perspective on all of this simply because I've worked in the industry for 4+ years (I've been out of it for a year now, but still have close ties). I've made my basic personal feelings known above, but as far as the used game market goes only Sony is very concerned with it.

I couldn't even count how many times Sony waits too long to release due to copy/piracy issues and then even still their measures are circumvented in days. On top of that they also have no "gaming spirit." Microsoft doesn't either. This is one of the things that caused me to leave the industry, it simply isn't about games any more. That's a shame. When your concerns are so focused in the wrong areas you will fail. Used games are what gaming has always been about. That is in the ethos of a gamer.

What we have are two new systems where the costs of development and timeframes have risen dramatically. This extra cost in both time and money will have a couple effects: Less games being produced over the consoles lifespan, Less risk being taken on non-established games/genre's, and longer gaps between major releases.

Sony and MS have never had real gaming motives. Remember the PS1 was only released by Sony because it was supposed to be a CD add-on for the SNES and the deal went south, Sony wanted revenge and released their system. The PS2 was a system completely sold on hype and most of it unfounded and it showed. The Xbox was a terribly rushed product so that MS could grab a piece of the pie that Sony was gobbling up, they made an entire system out of hype, power, and graphics... except they forgot about gameplay, wide audience, and fun.

Now Sony and MS are in this cold war arms race to just outdo the other with crazy unsubstantiated hype, horsepower, and expense. No attention is being payed to the actual games and it shows, the launch titles for the 360 don't even utilize the features of the system... not even 1st party ones. No attention is being payed to the fact that the target audience demographic is so narrow that it basically doesn't exist. Both systems are based on media that have no standards and that alone could blow up in one of their faces. Quality also has seen no attention payed either... this all adds up to be a huge problem. Now throw the used game market out on its ear, combine EB and Gamestop and this next round of consoles really offers nothing to look forward to. That is sad.

Everything is cyclical, and generally history repeats itself every 25 years... well just about 25 years ago this industry crashed.
 
bruenor said:
Everything is cyclical, and generally history repeats itself every 25 years... well just about 25 years ago this industry crashed.
(My ColecoVision still kicks your 5200/7800's A$$!)
 
Arkham said:
(My ColecoVision still kicks your 5200/7800's A$$!)

Heh, I was a 2600 man myself... crap-ass port of Pac-Man and all! Atari 2600 "Taz" FTW! (played that game from when I was 4 until I was 17... 13 freakin years until I beat it, I actually cried... when is the last time a current game can hold you for 13 months let alone 13 years.)
 
bruenor said:
Everything is cyclical, and generally history repeats itself every 25 years... well just about 25 years ago this industry crashed.

You're claiming a cycle in an industry that isn't old enough to evidence long-term trends? Well, okay, but let us know your opinion on the upcoming crash after all three next-generation consoles launch successfully to a receptive public.

It's hard to believe the industry is going to crash, given its rate of growth. You can argue whether or not MS or Sony care about gaming (and whether that's even relevant, given how third parties create 99% of the games available on the market), or whether or not the next generation is coming too soon, but how exactly does this add up to a crash?
 
Please see "Warren Specter" post if you don't believe what this guy is saying. Bruenor knows exactly what he's talking about. MS and Sony are engaged in a pissing contest, one where flashiness matters more than substance, and where gameplay takes a backseat to how cool you are and how pretty you look. A dangerous road that can lead only to 1 thing, and it may not happen in the next few years, but if Nintendo eventually joins that pissing contest, gaming will turn into exactly what hollywood has turned into.
 
steviep said:
Please see "Warren Specter" post if you don't believe what this guy is saying. Bruenor knows exactly what he's talking about. MS and Sony are engaged in a pissing contest, one where flashiness matters more than substance, and where gameplay takes a backseat to how cool you are and how pretty you look. A dangerous road that can lead only to 1 thing, and it may not happen in the next few years, but if Nintendo eventually joins that pissing contest, gaming will turn into exactly what hollywood has turned into.

"You are entitled to an informed opinion, not this load of rubish."

Sorry I do not really mean this, im just testing how Canadian Steviep is, he should know this quote.
 
Terpfen said:
You're claiming a cycle in an industry that isn't old enough to evidence long-term trends? Well, okay, but let us know your opinion on the upcoming crash after all three next-generation consoles launch successfully to a receptive public.

It's hard to believe the industry is going to crash, given its rate of growth. You can argue whether or not MS or Sony care about gaming (and whether that's even relevant, given how third parties create 99% of the games available on the market), or whether or not the next generation is coming too soon, but how exactly does this add up to a crash?

I'm not trying to rely on my credentials... but I have worked as an industry analyst for a number of major studios. My claims aren't really that outrageous.

Here is some info you may find interesting. Last Christmas do you know what the #1 selling game was? Wrong. It was the "retro" all in one units that plugged into your TV and played Atari/NES/etc. They outsold ALL videogames for the season. That coupled with the fact that one of the most lucrative areas of gaming right now are flash/shareware-ish games on the net.

So what? right? Well, Sony and MS have so narrowly defined their market audience (which was narrow to begin with) by entering into this "arms race." The sheer cost of these systems is a barrier to entry, the limited appeal of the avaliable games, and the marketing is targeted toward the "hardcore" gamer. The "hardcore" gamer market is very small. (I know we hate to hear this and believe we are a big massive force, but we aren't) The mass appeal/family/wide audience is where the money is. Sony is currently on the ropes in a number of areas of their business and hurting financially. MS has lost more money on their Xbox venture than almost anywhere and they *WILL* fail in Japan again. This is a death blow to MS. Microsoft knows this and tried to make a feeble attempt to appeal but in Japan the system is not even a blip on their radar. Here lies the main reasoning behind my prediction. It is a slightly different reason than back in the Atari 2600 days, but the end result will be the same. Add in to this the uncertainty of the media wars, quality issues, price, limited releases, limited content, greed, and a myriad of other issues and you have a recipe for disaster.
 
bruenor said:
So what? right? Well, Sony and MS have so narrowly defined their market audience (which was narrow to begin with) by entering into this "arms race." The sheer cost of these systems is a barrier to entry, the limited appeal of the avaliable games, and the marketing is targeted toward the "hardcore" gamer. The "hardcore" gamer market is very small. (I know we hate to hear this and believe we are a big massive force, but we aren't) The mass appeal/family/wide audience is where the money is.

I'm failing to see how the current console market is oriented towards the hardcore gamer. Microsoft and Sony have both had success in cracking the casual market; their hardware sales numbers evidence this, to say nothing of the cultural phenomena that are Gran Turismo and Halo. You can't sell 120 million PSones, 90+ million PS2s, and 20+ million Xboxes and then somehow believe you're only reaching the hardcore gamers. Let's not forget Nintendo's success in the portable market, and Sony's expansion of that market.

IMO, the trend towards realism in gaming is a direct result of the influence of casual gamers--as in, the mass market--on gaming. Making your game look as realistic as possible makes it more accessible to the casual gamer who may not be willing to suspend his/her disbelief for a fantasy world. So you get real-name licenses (such as the Tony Hawk series, which has always been popular), you improve your console horsepower, and you make up the costs associated with those changes through increased game sales.

The casual gamer is the reason why so many people here are complaining about the gaming industry in the first place. Games like Ninja Gaiden and Katamari Damacy are the notable exceptions to the trend.


Sony is currently on the ropes in a number of areas of their business and hurting financially.

Sony Computer Entertainment is NOT hurting, and that's all that matters to the gaming market. Sony Pictures, Sony BMG, Sony Whatever Else can fail, but SCE is still firing on all cylinders. The losses of those divisions do not affect SCE, especially from a managerial point of view; if it doesn't squeak, it doesn't get greased.


Here lies the main reasoning behind my prediction. It is a slightly different reason than back in the Atari 2600 days, but the end result will be the same. Add in to this the uncertainty of the media wars, quality issues, price, limited releases, limited content, greed, and a myriad of other issues and you have a recipe for disaster.

I don't buy the arguement that game quality is somehow declining. There have always been crappy games, and they have always outnumbered the good games by a significant margin. Gaming hit a slump in the 2001-2003 range, but it's hard to argue that 2004 and 2005 have been terrible. 2006 is lining up to be a great year, especially as the PS2's final year.

As far as price goes... I'm not sure what you're getting at. The dispelled rumors of $5 and $10 price increases on games? Xbox360 games cost $49, not $59. There's nothing on the horizon that indicates a price increase in PS3, Revolution, or PC games either.

There are definitely issues with the industry, but I don't think they add up to a looming crash.
 
NulloModo said:
Everything in PC gaming is competition. OpenGL vs. Direct3D, ATI vs. nVidia, Intel vs. AMD, EAX vs. that other sound algorithm, Mac vs. PC (not that I can think of any exclusive Mac games worth anything), Logitech vs. Madcatz vs. Microsoft vs. Saitek vs. Whoever else makes gaming accessories... etc.

The only difference is that the competition is much more fragmented, there aren't seperate incompatible ISAs competing with each other, but rather tons of companies competing for every dollar on every aspect of your experience, and it just happens to work together (usually).

I mean no competing platforms. yeah there is mac.... but come on, who plays mac games?

If you buy a game made for a computer you can rest assured it will play, doesnt matter if you have intel, AMD, ATi or Nvidia.

If you buy a console game you need to get one for the system you own. It limits what you can buy. I remember having PS2 and seeing a few games on GameCube i wanted to play and a few on Xbox. I missed out because i had one system and it sucks.
 
Terpfen said:
I'm failing to see how the current console market is oriented towards the hardcore gamer....snip

IMO, the trend towards realism in gaming is a direct result of the influence of casual gamers--as in, the mass market--on gaming....snip

Sony Computer Entertainment is NOT hurting, and that's all that matters to the gaming market....snip

I don't buy the arguement that game quality is somehow declining....snip

As far as price goes... I'm not sure what you're getting at...snip

There are definitely issues with the industry, but I don't think they add up to a looming crash.

I, first, would love to know what your authority is in making these claims? Because each and every one of your points is the exact OPPOSITE of reality. I will gladly answer each point by point, but please understand I'm not interested in arguing, I was making my opinion known... an opinion based on years of work, research, and in-depth knowledge of the industry.

1.) The current demographic that MS and Sony is targeting are 18-30 year old male gamers. This is the most dedicated sector, however one of the smallest in number. The family and casual/light gamer is the largest two areas and are not a target in any way shape or form. Also the loss of Japan, as I said, is the downfall of the 360 and MS knows this yet cannot change it no matter how hard they try.

2.) Realism, is the exact opposite of what you state. Realism and effects are only to appeal to hardcore gamers. Family/casual gamers prefer light-hearted, whimsical games such as the many Flash games that top the charts. Families and casual gamers could care less about Mips or Poly's or Bloom or SPE's. In fact the MORE realistic a game is the LESS the player is able to project themselves into the role and it actually detracts from the immersion. That is why successful game characters are fairly generic.

3.) Sony is hurting, therefore SCE is hurting. Sony the company has been failing in a number of areas. here is just one link:http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/3219667.stm it explains the latest move which cuts 13% of Sony's global workforce. It also touches on the valuation of the Yen and the massive problems it is causing Sony. Read up a bit on this, you will see it is not compartmentalized as you think it is.

4.) I never said game quality was declining. There have always been quality issues. The problem is the fact that game development costs have risen exponentially including development timeframes and man hours required. This means that developers CANNOT take a chance and create a niche or quirky title. One majorly flopped next-gen game can take a smaller developer out of business, risks will be minimized... this means that all you will see are "safe" games being made. "safe" games do not push envelopes, they do not do much for a true gamer. You'll see. King Kong is a prime example.

5.) Game pricing is not the major issue at hand, and again I never mentioned it. The console prices are. The bundling requirements are. The forced "shortages" are. The media is, especially for the company sitting on the losing end of the format war. The cost of development is. Then you take the used game market out of play and you now have a bleak market for the average consumer.

6.) You may not think there is a looming crash, you may disagree with me... in the coming months and year we will see how it shakes out. All that I ask is that you remember this conversation.
 
Back
Top