No Shield Law for Message Boards Posters

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The New Jersey Supreme Court says that online message boards don't fit the definition of news media as described by law, so there are no shield law protections.

The New Jersey Supreme Court says people posting in online message boards don't have the same protections for sources as mainstream journalists. The court ruled Tuesday that New Jersey's shield law for journalists does not apply to such message boards.
 
One of the comments pretty much says it all.

Fail court system. USA is dying... my sources tell me!
 
Posting on the internet does not make you a journalist. Imagine that.
 
Why, because you may not be able to get away with anonymous libel much longer? lol

No just Media "Profeshunals" that have "sources" that tell them "stuff". They make shit up all the time, but the gov protects their ability to do so.
 
Why, because you may not be able to get away with anonymous libel much longer? lol

Damn right!

Sometimes things need to be said, but fear of repercussions suppress that. I'm no fan of bs crap like this celebrity does this or that, but seriously, I don't see why this went the way it did.
 
Damn right!

Sometimes things need to be said, but fear of repercussions suppress that. I'm no fan of bs crap like this celebrity does this or that, but seriously, I don't see why this went the way it did.

Best Buy Sucks - brought to you by an EX-Customer.

You're going to jail for that.
 
Damn right!

Sometimes things need to be said, but fear of repercussions suppress that. I'm no fan of bs crap like this celebrity does this or that, but seriously, I don't see why this went the way it did.

If someone is not willing to stand up and state something, and reprocussions be damned, then maybe you should just keep their mouth shut?

As for why it went this way, should someone down the street from you be able to flood a message board saying that it was reported to him that your a child molester and then when confronted they can just say "Well that's what my sources, which I am not at liberty to divulge, told me" and just walk away?
 
So citizen reporters aren't considered journalists because they didn't get a degree in journalism? Way to parse stupidity NJSC.
 
Posting on the internet does not make you a journalist. Imagine that.

Neither does having a journalist degree either. All of us are journalists. For example if I post something on a forum that is newsworthy or may be a breaking report on something, then do I lose my ability to use my pseudonym or have it published because I'm not a journalist? What if I was a journalist and I did it under a different guise? I don't think you thought this through very well.
 
Sounds about right to me. Some douchebag shouldn't have protection for sources if he says, "Hey I know someone is going to blow up a bank." Oh wait I'm a journalist, I posted it on a message board!

Now this case though sounds a bit odd, the linked story didn't have too many details. It is suing a blogger for defamation for sources placed on a message board? Was the defamation on the message board, or a blog post? I think that bloggers protection should be expanded; at this point many of them are no different than what a local newspaper with only a very small distribution would have been a long time ago..
 
I think that bloggers protection should be expanded; at this point many of them are no different than what a local newspaper with only a very small distribution would have been a long time ago..

Exactly this. Bloggers, whether we like it or not are an important part of the "reporting" cycle that happens nowadays.

Long gone are the days Edward Murrows, most "reporters" are hardly anything more than teleprompter vocalizers.
 
If someone is not willing to stand up and state something, and reprocussions be damned, then maybe you should just keep their mouth shut?

As for why it went this way, should someone down the street from you be able to flood a message board saying that it was reported to him that your a child molester and then when confronted they can just say "Well that's what my sources, which I am not at liberty to divulge, told me" and just walk away?

That's defamation of character, which is different than reporting news. Of course, if people believe things like that on a random message board, they probably aren't people who would matter most of the time anyway.
 
Back
Top