Nike Folding Up Wearable Tech Efforts

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
It was learned on Friday that Nike has decided to get out of the hardware end of the wearable tech market handing out pink slips to the majority of the FuelBand project’s staff.
 
I never understood the big push for 'wearable' tech, be it fitness trackers or smart watches or smart glasses. Once you get past the gee-wiz factor it's just another gizmo to worry about charging and losing.
 
Nike is better off sticking to consumables like shoes and fitness apparals where profit margin is higher and without the high support and R&D costs. Plus, wearable market is saturated and their inaccurate pedometer is relatively dumb and expensive compared to the competition.
 
surprised by this, wasn't this a big successes for them?
It was, but then there were about 3 or 4 other similar types of "movement tracker" devices that all came out around the same time, and I think were cheaper. Maybe they figured people were no longer willing to pay a premium just for a symbol that you can't even see :D
 
Sorry about the pink slips. But I wouldn't call Nike's stuff 'wearable tech' in the sense that the phrase is used now. I'd call it 'fitness tracking tech' which is far more niche. I have a fitbit one as a gift one xmas--it's fine, I use it daily, but I also don't really care that much about it. Wouldn't really recommend it to others, or buy one for myself. I still don't care much about 'wearable tech' in the context of Samsung smart watches (and whatever google is going to be pushing on folks).
 
I never understood the big push for 'wearable' tech, be it fitness trackers or smart watches or smart glasses. Once you get past the gee-wiz factor it's just another gizmo to worry about charging and losing.

Definitely using this stuff is a hassle but I think there is some utility in, for example, using this technology to monitor and track physical training results and parameters of cardiovascular fitness and metabolism. For some people, including myself, this is very interesting and helpful.
 
I never understood the big push for 'wearable' tech, be it fitness trackers or smart watches or smart glasses. Once you get past the gee-wiz factor it's just another gizmo to worry about charging and losing.

Every megacorp suddenly thought there was a goldmine and all they had to do was be FIRST!!! Turns out it wasn't and never was a goldmine....like just about every non-whitecollar-CEO cheddar-obsessed person coulda told them.
 
yeah... get back to making those shoes people like to kill each other over just because some rap star told them to.
 
Definitely using this stuff is a hassle but I think there is some utility in, for example, using this technology to monitor and track physical training results and parameters of cardiovascular fitness and metabolism. For some people, including myself, this is very interesting and helpful.

My cousin described it as Tamagotchi for people, it buzzes you when it thinks your being too lazy, gives you happy response when you've done enough? Another cousin was kind of rocking/stepping back and forth because it was counting as "steps", seems that these things while useful still have major flaws in accurately knowing how much activity you are doing.
 
My cousin described it as Tamagotchi for people, it buzzes you when it thinks your being too lazy, gives you happy response when you've done enough? Another cousin was kind of rocking/stepping back and forth because it was counting as "steps", seems that these things while useful still have major flaws in accurately knowing how much activity you are doing.

Any pedometer can be faked out. Nature of the sensors and the activity.
 
Maybe the devices division would have done better if they bothered to support more than just iphones for syncing.
 
Any pedometer can be faked out. Nature of the sensors and the activity.
Sure, but the $4.99 pedometer that clips to your hip should be the base level to how cheap they can get. It's basically a magnet on a very low friction hinge with some feedback (spring or something) so that when the magnet bounces past a sensor it registers. However we're talking $100 clip on toys, I would like to think maybe they up the tech level on the accelerometers, or at least the hardware/software side of things that detects a "tap" vs. a step or a running stomp. Otherwise you're what? Buying that same $4.99 pedometer but oooh it has blue tooth!
 
surprised by this, wasn't this a big successes for them?

They were flawed. The first one was horrible with quality control. The second one was overpriced by about $50. Polar and Garmin entered the market recently and kicked their ass design/feature wise.
 
Sure, but the $4.99 pedometer that clips to your hip should be the base level to how cheap they can get. It's basically a magnet on a very low friction hinge with some feedback (spring or something) so that when the magnet bounces past a sensor it registers. However we're talking $100 clip on toys, I would like to think maybe they up the tech level on the accelerometers, or at least the hardware/software side of things that detects a "tap" vs. a step or a running stomp. Otherwise you're what? Buying that same $4.99 pedometer but oooh it has blue tooth!

Any workout tool can be faked out if you think for 30 seconds. As an avid cyclist, my Garmin Edge bike computer too can catch false data...there are safeties in place that make it hard. But that gadget costs $300USD and you still can. And it uses a sensor suite a hell of a lot more advanced than this thing.

Even an accelerometer based pedometer can be faked out. To make one that doesn't fall prey to erroneous input, you'd need a GPS location sensor based software safety....and probably sensors in the shoe soles as well. That way you only count steps when your feet hit the ground while moving. Anything less and you can get phantom input.
 
Maybe the devices division would have done better if they bothered to support more than just iphones for syncing.

This too.

My cousin described it as Tamagotchi for people, it buzzes you when it thinks your being too lazy, gives you happy response when you've done enough? Another cousin was kind of rocking/stepping back and forth because it was counting as "steps", seems that these things while useful still have major flaws in accurately knowing how much activity you are doing.

Some of the more advanced ones try and detect if you're sitting or laying. That allows them to more accurately track "steps". But yes, it's designed as an estimate.

All of these devices used "goals" as motivation. Garmin flipped this and decided to tell you you're being lazy. You can do a 5mile run. But if 2 hours later it thinks you're sitting watching TV for too long, it tells you take a quick walk. The meter is not how far you need to go for your goal like everyone else, it's how lazy you've been - moving about will reduce that meter. Interesting twist. They're also the first (that I know of) to offer a cheaper model designed strictly for enterprise (corporate wide use). There's a lot of companies interested in employee health so it may pay off. MGM Resorts is one of them, they reduced healthcare costs by opening their own insurance company for employees, doing yearly free health checkups, and free vaccinations.
 
A division operated by idiot MBAs most likely. Color me surprised that they failed.
 
Anyone who's serious about fitness has a stand-alone Garmin GPS watch of some sort plus the ~$160 Forerunner 210 GPS watch prices the Fuelband SE pedo out of the market. Useless gimmick for the niche iPhone market.
 
Anyone who's serious about fitness has a stand-alone Garmin GPS watch of some sort plus the ~$160 Forerunner 210 GPS watch prices the Fuelband SE pedo out of the market. Useless gimmick for the niche iPhone market.

I am pretty sure I and many other people were able to be Serious about fitness long before these stupid devices came out. All of this crap is useless gimmicks for the lazy. The problem is marketing has convinced all the suckers that they aren't getting a quality workout unless they achieve certain milestones only able to be measured by this junk. I can tell you more about someone's quality of workout with a stop watch, my eyes and a piece of paper than any of this crap can.
 
If you do long distance like marathon or even half marathon, want to improve your PR and don't have a dedicated support team to monitor your stats then a Garmin GPS watch is a valuable tool.
 
I am pretty sure I and many other people were able to be Serious about fitness long before these stupid devices came out. All of this crap is useless gimmicks for the lazy. The problem is marketing has convinced all the suckers that they aren't getting a quality workout unless they achieve certain milestones only able to be measured by this junk. I can tell you more about someone's quality of workout with a stop watch, my eyes and a piece of paper than any of this crap can.

Coaches can be great. But unless they're your spouse they cost more money than a one-time gadget purchase...and you have to find one you get along with.
 
Sure, but the $4.99 pedometer that clips to your hip should be the base level to how cheap they can get. It's basically a magnet on a very low friction hinge with some feedback (spring or something) so that when the magnet bounces past a sensor it registers. However we're talking $100 clip on toys, I would like to think maybe they up the tech level on the accelerometers, or at least the hardware/software side of things that detects a "tap" vs. a step or a running stomp. Otherwise you're what? Buying that same $4.99 pedometer but oooh it has blue tooth!
The underlying principle, it's true, it's the same; however, the quality difference between $5 and $100 devices is huge. Of course, all have their inaccuracies based on how they measure. I'm not at all advocating people go and buy a fitbit one--in fact, I don't think it's anything special--but what you don't get with the $5 pedometers that you do get with high-profile branded 'fitness' trackers is a lot of device features, plus a software/service. If you care about that sort of thing, great. If not, then the device is not for you. I can also say from personal use, you don't rack up steps on a fitbit one by tapping the device. It's much smarter than your $5 step pedometer and has more sensors that work in conjunction to more-accurately reflect your activity. Yes, not always accurate, yes, there are ways to 'cheat' it. Doesn't mean it's not better than cheap-o versions. And likewise, just because there are expensive models doesn't mean they're better for everyone either.
 
Back
Top