Nexus S Vs MyTouch 4g

bastage

Pics of your wife?
Joined
Mar 4, 2010
Messages
12,874
So every freaking thread right now people are reccomending the Nexus S over the MT4G.. Why?? Comparing specs of the devices the mt4g seems to be the better choice, & as far as software goes, Who gives a fuck since you can root em & put whatever you want on either of em?

As far as I can tell people are up in arms about the Galaxy S because its new.. I Dont see any real advantage of it over the others. Infact I seem some fairly large disadvantages of the nexus S compared to the mt4g.. Most notably is having 512mb ram compared to 768mb ram on the mt4g..

So why are all you nexus s fanboy's so excited?
 
if you're a frequent visitor to xda developers and you want to fat-ruck and re-install a custom rom on a phone in order to get the most out of it, i would recommend the mytouch4g over the nexus s only because it has hspa+ (which isn't available everywhere) and removable storage. if you want to just buy a phone and have it good-to-go with the latest bells and whistles without tinkering, with guaranteed os updates, the nexus s is the way to go. the nexus s gets the nod for asthetics imo as well
 
while the nexus S is more aesthetically appealing, the cheap feel of all the Galaxy S series would turn me off.
 
if you're a frequent visitor to xda developers and you want to fat-ruck and re-install a custom rom on a phone in order to get the most out of it, i would recommend the mytouch4g over the nexus s only because it has hspa+ (which isn't available everywhere) and removable storage. if you want to just buy a phone and have it good-to-go with the latest bells and whistles without tinkering, with guaranteed os updates, the nexus s is the way to go. the nexus s gets the nod for asthetics imo as well

Nexus S will be getting OTA updates by Google. That has already been announced. Plus since it is replacing the Nexus One as the developer phone from Google it will most likely be completely unlocked just like the Nexus One. With those in mind that means Nexus S is the better option unless you need a microSD card.
 
Nexus S will be getting OTA updates by Google. That has already been announced. Plus since it is replacing the Nexus One as the developer phone from Google it will most likely be completely unlocked just like the Nexus One. With those in mind that means Nexus S is the better option unless you need a microSD card.

Are you agreeing with me? You're saying basically the same thing I just said.
 
Nexus S will be getting OTA updates by Google. That has already been announced. Plus since it is replacing the Nexus One as the developer phone from Google it will most likely be completely unlocked just like the Nexus One. With those in mind that means Nexus S is the better option unless you need a microSD card.

The only advantage you have listed is that it will get OTA updates from Google.. Being unlocked is a null point since anyone who can simply read a walk through can subsidy unlock a smartphone. Its also not like you can use the 3g/4g on any other carrier anyway so that goes one step farther into being a null point.

I Guess I just don't get it.. I Historically Root & put on a good stable rom that does what I want & don't touch shit again until I decide I want something new.. OTA Updates to me arent really a selling point.

I But my phones with the same philosophy I do my computer.. I Want the best hardware for the money.. The Software can be replaced & massaged to my liking later, because there will ALWAYS be something I want to change.
 
Are you agreeing with me? You're saying basically the same thing I just said.[/QU
OTE]

I believe he is saying the nexus s would be the best choice for custom roms etc mainly because it should have an unlocked bootloader out the gate. Mt4g still requires you to manually root it install a custom bootloader etc... that's not even mentioning gauranteed dev support similiar if not more than the n1

Not a nexus s fan boy. Just have been spoiled by dev support from the g1 and the n1. I've no intention of upgrading anytime soon. When I do though it will be to whatever is the current nexus iteration.
 
Last edited:
The only advantage you have listed is that it will get OTA updates from Google.. Being unlocked is a null point since anyone who can simply read a walk through can subsidy unlock a smartphone. Its also not like you can use the 3g/4g on any other carrier anyway so that goes one step farther into being a null point.

I Guess I just don't get it.. I Historically Root & put on a good stable rom that does what I want & don't touch shit again until I decide I want something new.. OTA Updates to me arent really a selling point.

I But my phones with the same philosophy I do my computer.. I Want the best hardware for the money.. The Software can be replaced & massaged to my liking later, because there will ALWAYS be something I want to change.

Being unlocked is not a null point. Droid X and Droid 2 aren't unlocked. Their bootloaders are encrypted meaning no custom kernels. While the developers have done a great job hooking into the subsystem in order to insert a "custom" ROM it's not the same as with Nexus One or the original Droid. Droid X and Droid 2 are hamstrung by not having custom kernels.
 
Being unlocked is not a null point. Droid X and Droid 2 aren't unlocked. Their bootloaders are encrypted meaning no custom kernels. While the developers have done a great job hooking into the subsystem in order to insert a "custom" ROM it's not the same as with Nexus One or the original Droid. Droid X and Droid 2 are hamstrung by not having custom kernels.

It is a Null point because the thread is about a Droid X, or Droid 2 vs the Nexus 1.. Its about the MT4G.
 
Question is, do you want an sd card that bad and do you live in a 4g area or do you want to be on the leading edge of software releases fire the next year. Sounds like you already have your answer before you asked here.
 
I'm really torn between the mytouch 4G and the nexus S. Thanks to the underwhelming specs of the nexus S the decision has not been made any easier (blah was hoping google was going to build something more farsighted to guide the rest of the hardware makers i.e. next gen stuff).
 
I'm really torn between the mytouch 4G and the nexus S. Thanks to the underwhelming specs of the nexus S the decision has not been made any easier (blah was hoping google was going to build something more farsighted to guide the rest of the hardware makers i.e. next gen stuff).

Google isn't a manufacturing company. They can only sell a phone somebody else can make, and nobody can make Tegra 2 phones yet. The extra amount of RAM the MT4G isn't going to be a big deal at all.

If you want a MT4G, buy it. If you want an improved Galaxy S, get the Nexus S (which has things like a working GPS, the curved screen, and NAND flash - plus the NFC thing, but who knows when/if that will become interesting). Again, the big bullet point for the Nexus S is a pure Google experience (no cell provider crapware, nothing disabled), updates straight from Google (meaning you'll get the newest versions of Android before anyone else), and Google develops and tests Android internally on that phone (meaning the best experience out of the box). Even if you run custom ROMs that still matters, as things like the drivers aren't in the open source tree. So many many phones will be stuck waiting for Gingerbread to officially come out for their phone of choice before you'll see custom ROMs worth installing. Before then you'll end up with 2.2 drivers with 2.3 framework sitting on top of it, not ideal.
 
Question is, do you want an sd card that bad and do you live in a 4g area or do you want to be on the leading edge of software releases fire the next year. Sounds like you already have your answer before you asked here.

I already knew what I was getting and that's the mytouch (the nexus isn't even an option based on no contract pricing as I am on a tmobile employee account and I get a discount on there phones). I am trying to get what the hype over the nexus s is about.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
Google isn't a manufacturing company. They can only sell a phone somebody else can make, and nobody can make Tegra 2 phones yet.

I know Google isn't a cell phone manufacturing company; however, they can lay a heavy hand in the development of a newer headset like they did with the Nexus 1 in conjunction with HTC. The Nexus 1 was great because it pushed the hardware standard for android handset makers.

I don't see Google pushing up the hardware standards as much with the Nexus S. If anything, I see the Nexus S has a hamper for better spec phones. Google is basically telling the rest of the android makers to stick with 800x640, single core, 512MB, for Google won't officially support anything better. Thus makers of next gen phone hardware are going to be left out in software support. The only new thing being pushed is a front facing camera this time (tri axis gyroscope?), which I find highly disappointing.

I seriously hope the Nexus S is just a quick place holder for the true Nexus successor, aka the Nexus 2.
 
I know Google isn't a cell phone manufacturing company; however, they can lay a heavy hand in the development of a newer headset like they did with the Nexus 1 in conjunction with HTC. The Nexus 1 was great because it pushed the hardware standard for android handset makers.

I don't see Google pushing up the hardware standards as much with the Nexus S. If anything, I see the Nexus S has a hamper for better spec phones. Google is basically telling the rest of the android makers to stick with 800x640, single core, 512MB, for Google won't officially support anything better. Thus makers of next gen phone hardware are going to be left out in software support. The only new thing being pushed is a front facing camera this time (tri axis gyroscope?), which I find highly disappointing.

I seriously hope the Nexus S is just a quick place holder for the true Nexus successor, aka the Nexus 2.

I agree completely.. The Nexus One was the freeking shiznit when it 1st came out.. If there was anything to match its hardware there wasnt much.. Now the Nexus S is a Cookie Cutter of the damn Galaxy S series so its nothing really new to me.. Yea the FFC is cool, But hardware wise the phone as a whole is lackluster.

Hopefully they do another one when 3.0 is released & then push the envelope again.. rather then sit comfortable inside it.
 
hardware wise I see the G2 as being just slightly behind both of the other 2.. but still no slouch by any means. Its still got 512 mb ram, but the CPU is clocked a little slower at 800 Mhz. I also have to admit I do love teh fact that there is no crappy manufacturer skin on top of android.
 
I agree bastage, these manufactures are very good. I have the G2, unfortunately it did not come with any manual, I know how to use it...but I woulld like to find more details on it, but I cant find anything on the web on it....any ideas?
 
This review on at has some benchies of the 2.. Looks like gengerbread offers some performance gain. Will be interesting to see these dont again later. And unfortunitly Samsung hasnt released a 2.2 update to the galaxy S series so we cant even use the fascinate as a comparison point hardware wise.
 
This review on at has some benchies of the 2.. Looks like gengerbread offers some performance gain. Will be interesting to see these dont again later. And unfortunitly Samsung hasnt released a 2.2 update to the galaxy S series so we cant even use the fascinate as a comparison point hardware wise.

The biggest improvement is the concurrent garbage collection, which won't show up in benchmarks. What it means is that the small pauses in animations and navigation and stuff are most eliminated, making everything much smoother.
 
Being unlocked is not a null point. Droid X and Droid 2 aren't unlocked. Their bootloaders are encrypted meaning no custom kernels. While the developers have done a great job hooking into the subsystem in order to insert a "custom" ROM it's not the same as with Nexus One or the original Droid. Droid X and Droid 2 are hamstrung by not having custom kernels.

I went from the Droid Incredible to the Droid X for improved battery life and screen size. I'm very happy with my choice (I traded, no cash exchange). The only thing I miss is the number of custom ROM's and the ease with which I could flash them. However, it's a good thing because I was flashing a new rom at least twice a week on the Incredible to try the latest and greatest. Now I'm running Apex 1.3 and really enjoy it. Even had I not gone this route, being able to root and remove the bloatware was enough to make me happy.

I don't think there is a wrong choice between the mytouch4g or Nexus S. Both are going to be awesome phones, so pick and enjoy.
 
Back
Top