newish at raids have a question

bobstone

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 3, 2005
Messages
361
Hey all

this is a long term project ( tech never ending ).

I want to setup an 8 drive raid that can handle 1 or 2 drives being down at a time(raid 6 i think right ?), I would like to have the option to replace/upgrade the drives like the drobo can ( is there a raid level that supports this?), but I don't want to spend 1600$; which is what a drobo 8 bay cost, when I can build a raid computer for well under 800$ ( minus hdd cost) depending on how I build it.

at first for testing and to get familiar ( I plan to use a linux based os ) I am going to use 3 250gb and 2 500gb drives. then I will add whatever controler card is recommend and restart the raid, then once I feel comfortable with the os, raid controller, and settings I will start to replace the drives with what ever is the current price per gig leader ( 1.5tb now i think )

keep in mind I have not used a raid for 4 years, and even then it was a cheap 2 drive raid 0 on my built in raid controller. ( had a scsi raid way back in the day also )

what I would like to know is what would be a good card to control the raid, is adaptec still a safe bet or are there better cards out, also what would be a good hdd to work with, I was thinking the WD green line but again I am not sure.

any help would be nice :)

Thanks
Bob
 
'RAID' only works with like-sized disks (or rather, it will use only the size of the smallest disk). Anything else is something other than RAID. FlexRAID sort of accomplishes this. UnRAID too. I haven't used either of these solutions but they might be what you're looking for; not sure if they support dual parity though.

If you're using Linux anyway I would just use Linux software RAID, you just have to use like sized disks.
 
ya after I posted this I did some more looking and I am thinking of just having the file server not even use a typical raid.

however for simplicity sake ( cause some of the data that will be on the server is sorted and some of the sorted item take a combined space of over 2 tb )maybe some sort of implantation of a jbod/span where I can add drives, and if I remove a drive from it; the jbod/span will still work just fine, and the individual disk can be accessed as a normal drive with data on it.

is such a thing possible ( fyi part of this is to learn so if it is overly complicated that is not a bad thing) and have it be a reliable setup. not reliable as in redundant, but reliable as in technologically sound and safe.

Thanks
Bob
 
I think it would be possible, but it'd probably be basically a roll-your-own solution out of the existing component parts. There might be an integrated solution to this, but I'm not aware of one.

WHS, OTOH, apparently does a good job of this kind of thing, but you'd have to run Windows...
 
hehe, I am searching the web while monitoring this, just saw WHS myself but that defeats Idea of learning from it since WHS looks to be a plug, play, and ignore type of setup.

one thing I found mentioned in windows is that you can mount a ntfs vol to a folder, but it only allows one vol for one folder,.

something like this but with a smart back-end ( for data distribution, so I can tell it divide the data equally on each drive, or to fill the biggest hdd first, ect... ) and allows for mounting multi drives to one folder/logical location, would actually be a setup I would like to work with.

have you seen something like this ?
 
something like this but with a smart back-end ( for data distribution, so I can tell it divide the data equally on each drive, or to fill the biggest hdd first, ect... )

WHS does drive balancing automatically, and will copy files to two different drives at once, all without user intervention.

and allows for mounting multi drives to one folder/logical location, would actually be a setup I would like to work with.

I have 20+ drives in my WHS right now, and one music, one video, one documents folder. I don't have to worry about resizing them. All of that is transparent.
 
ok nother question.

just so I know does WHS allow me to remove one of the drives and just plug it in to another computer and access the files on that drive ?
 
Yes, and no. I have gotten impatient with WHS and before the OS could remove the drive I powered it down and basically screwed the drive over. I mean, nothing. I plugged it into a usb external drive and placed it on another pc, and nothing, this may have been an isolated case, and it could have just been that drives time to go so take that for what its worth.


On the other hand, I was goofing with WHS one day and majorly screwed the registry over and a bunch of other stuff ( totally my fault ) and was able to pull the drives individually, and read the files that were on there, and have since done that a few times just to see how it works. ( I tried my damndest to break and fix it before I put 4.5 Tb of data on it, just in case ;) )and havent had any problems. the other pc sees the drive once its in my external enclosure, and can read from it just fine.

Edit : One more thing, say you have 5 1 Tb drives. And 4.5 Tb of data. You need to add another drive before you can remove one.
 
Back
Top