NewEgg drive packaging still sucks...

night_2004

2[H]4U
Joined
May 31, 2007
Messages
2,229
<soapbox-rant>

Got a drive in from NewEgg yesterday, lo and behold it is wrapped in bubble wrap with a full 50% of the wrapping completely popped. It wasn't even a decent amount of bubble rap either. Drive was laying right on the bottom of the box, ready and waiting for bumps and bruises.

Thought you might want to know that they still suck in this area.

Now since I need to get another backup drive up an running within the next few days, I'm pretty much stuck with Best Buy and their overly high prices.

Never again. NEVER again, will I buy a hard drive from NewEgg.

</soapbox-rant>
 
Last edited:
Hard drives from Amazon ftw (except for the frustration-free drives....stay away from those)

Also, if you have Prime you can get cheap 1 day shipping for those times you need something quick :) As for the frustration-free drives, even if Amazon screws up they make it right. In my RMA of my badly packaged drive they sent the replacement via next day. I was impressed to say the least.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the heads up. Another good vote for Amazon here.
 
I just bought (2) 2TB Samsungs for the Egg a couple of weeks ago and they were packed fine. The drives were in their anti-static bags inside tightly sized cardboard boxes (think PCI card style boxes) inside a larger box filled with peanuts (very full).
 
yea, I ordered a 1TB WD SATA 6GB drive and it was in a white box packed in with paper around it. It was definitely better than before.
 
I just received 12 Western Digital RE4-GP 2TB drives from newegg, and they were individually boxed in WD recommended packaging: each drive in a small box with two plastic endcaps on the drives to keep the drive suspended in the middle of the little box. These 12 boxes were packed in a larger box with peanuts, but really each little box was good enough to ship by itself. Nice!
 
I just bought (2) 2TB Samsungs for the Egg a couple of weeks ago and they were packed fine. The drives were in their anti-static bags inside tightly sized cardboard boxes (think PCI card style boxes) inside a larger box filled with peanuts (very full).

That's been my experience as well. I've ordered a about a dozen of drives over the last year without any issue.
 
I depends on whether you order OEM or Retail. If you order retail drives, you get the full retail box and everything that comes in the box as if you were to purchase it at Best Buy or similar.

If you order OEM, then all you get is the drive in the anti-static packaging with bubble wrap. You don't get the cables or anything like that with it though. This option should also be cheaper.

You do realize I hope that whether the drives are shipped in the box with foam or in bubble wrap, the hardware is going to get bounced around by the shipping carrier no matter what. The same amount of force will apply to the boxes with foam as with the boxes with bubble wrap. The bubble wrap and foam is just to keep the drive from jarring violently against the sides of the box.
 
I depends on whether you order OEM or Retail. If you order retail drives, you get the full retail box and everything that comes in the box as if you were to purchase it at Best Buy or similar.

If you order OEM, then all you get is the drive in the anti-static packaging with bubble wrap. You don't get the cables or anything like that with it though. This option should also be cheaper.

You do realize I hope that whether the drives are shipped in the box with foam or in bubble wrap, the hardware is going to get bounced around by the shipping carrier no matter what. The same amount of force will apply to the boxes with foam as with the boxes with bubble wrap. The bubble wrap and foam is just to keep the drive from jarring violently against the sides of the box.

They might receive the same total force, but the force over time is going to be different. That's what's going to kill a drive. Would rather have a 20lb weight dropped on your head, or have 20lb weight slowly lowered onto your head?
 
I'll agree with the above. The 2x WD Greens I ordered a few weeks ago one was in good shape, the other was in popped bubble wrap that had been crushed against the cardboard box wall.

I'm basically only buying retail boxed drives from online and B&M these days. I didn't believe that it was worth the price premium two years ago, but now I am 100% on board.
 
well did the drive still work? If it's going to die from the package it will do so soon after installing it. Otherwise I wouldn't worry about it. I get all my drives from newegg and they all still work. 13 drives in my server, 5 more in my other computers all OEM and all in bubble wrap. No issues.
 
I've never bought a "retail" drive from the Egg. That being said, I've also never had the issue of having the bubble wrap popped on OEM drives either.

Seems like whoever is handling those packages that rough during shipping needs to be fired.
 
In the past, I have often had poorly bubble-wrapped drives from newegg. The problem is that they wrap the bubble wrap fairly tight, and then wrap the packing tape tight. That usually results in at least one or two corners having the bubble wrap popped. All it takes is one corner in direct contact with the box side, and then the box dropped during shipping to kill a HDD.

The only way to do a good job with wrapping an HDD with bubble wrap is to double wrap it at right angles (like once around the length, then another sheet around the width), being careful to extend the bubble wrap about an inch past the both ends. But that uses a lot of bubble wrap, and takes up a lot of space, and I have never seen newegg do that.

But as I wrote before, my most recent shipment of RE4-GPs had the drives in individual small boxes with suspending plastic end caps. That might be specific to the WD RE drives. newegg seemed to stop carrying the RE4-GPs for a couple months, and this is the first time I have ordered some since newegg started stocking them again. I'm guessing newegg worked something out with WD so that the packing met WD standards (it is now identical to what WD uses to ship their drives for RMA). By the way, my recent shipment came from the LA-area warehouse.
 
Last edited:
They might receive the same total force, but the force over time is going to be different. That's what's going to kill a drive. Would rather have a 20lb weight dropped on your head, or have 20lb weight slowly lowered onto your head?

The forces would be different... if it's slowly lowered onto your head then there's no gravity... if it's dropped then it depends on the distance... a drop from 1 inch is going to hurt less than a drop from 10 feet.

I've ordered probably 40-50 HDD's from Newegg over the past 4-5 years and have yet to receive one that was DOA. A friend of mine received one that was DOA but no big deal, we setup an RMA, they paid for shipping and he got a refund. Instead we ran over to best buy and picked up a retail drive so we could finish building his system. And yes all of those drives are still running to this day. I've had to RMA some used drives I've bought... but that's about it.

I think people are a little over worried. I worked at a computer shop and we had brand new drives directly from Seagate or WD and they arrived DOA even with their amazing "proper" packaging. The thing is, people who have problems with drives from newegg voice their complaints. But people that have no problems don't say anything. There are probably 1,000 working drives to every DOA drive if not more.
 
I depends on whether you order OEM or Retail. If you order retail drives, you get the full retail box and everything that comes in the box as if you were to purchase it at Best Buy or similar.

If you order OEM, then all you get is the drive in the anti-static packaging with bubble wrap. You don't get the cables or anything like that with it though. This option should also be cheaper.

No

I know the difference between retail and OEM and the drives I bought from Newegg were OEM and the were packed exactly as I described. The packaging I described was not retail packaging.
 
The forces would be different... if it's slowly lowered onto your head then there's no gravity... if it's dropped then it depends on the distance... a drop from 1 inch is going to hurt less than a drop from 10 feet.

The force of gravity always exists and is always a factor. It's the rate of acceleration that makes a difference. He was saying that packages get bumped and that it doesn't matter what's wrapping them because the drive still experiences all the force of that bump. So my point was that even if the drive experienced all of that force, it the time over which it's applied that makes a difference if you have a drive that's damaged or not. Bubble wrap and foam work to slow down the force so that the drive moves gently despite the box being bumped.

F=MA and all that.....
 
Whoa, this thread has exploded towards off topic just a bit :p.

The drive sounds like it wants to spin up, it seems to spin up, but then it doesn't communicate with my computer. It's definitely has a noise to it that I would think is abnormal...

I've definitely had OEM drives packed better than this before, and I thought NewEgg had addressed the issue a while back. Guess they didn't. I usually order most of my drives from Amazon...it seems like every time I take a chance with NewEgg I get the short end of the stick. It's about the second or third time I've had this issue with them in the last few years, and will definitely be the last.

The only other thing that might make a difference is where the drives are shipped from. This one came from their NJ facility.
 
The OEM drives I ordered recently from Newegg were bubble-wrapped and inside the white cardboard box which was inside the box of peanuts instead of just sitting on the bottom. I thought all of the complaints had finally gotten somewhere, sorry to hear that's not the case. I agree with Amazon, have had good experiences there. However so far the best for me has actually been Ewiz. I received two separate drives from them last week and both were packed impeccably in form-fitted foam. By far the best I've seen. I also received a drive from Zipzoomfly recently that was inside a foam box that was inside a box with peanuts. As it turns out that drive was dead anyway though and there RMA policy seriously leaves something to be desired.
 
Ordered a 2TB drive from Provantage recently. They had the best price on it at the time and the packaging was very well done. Plastic endcaps, foam fitting, bubble, etc.

I've never had a DOA drive from Newegg but I don't order HDDs that frequently. The 150GB Raptor I ordered from them a few years back worked perfectly and still works today. I don't remember what kind of packaging it came in but everything I've gotten from the egg usually has those foam noodles and has foam around the drive itself.
 
Perhaps simple, but not plain.

Why is Zip Zoom Fly a joke?

I'd have to find the posts I had, but the first time I dealt with them they shipped me a faulty product and completely screwed up the RMA. After a few days of going back and forth I just let PayPal handle it for me. It basically went like this...

First they wouldn't take it back, then they would take it back with a 15% restocking fee if I ordered another drive from them immediately (by then the price had done up a decent amount). If I did not purchase the same item again at the higher price and take the ~$45 hit from the restocking then I was SOL. Then maybe they would not charge the 15% fee but the price was still higher than what I had originally paid for...whatever...by then they'd burned all their credibility with me.

IDK, maybe some people have fine experiences with ZZF. I didn't, and the massive FAIL that was their CS when they sold me a defective product ensured that I would never do business with them again.
 
I'd have to find the posts I had, but the first time I dealt with them they shipped me a faulty product and completely screwed up the RMA. After a few days of going back and forth I just let PayPal handle it for me. It basically went like this...

First they wouldn't take it back, then they would take it back with a 15% restocking fee if I ordered another drive from them immediately (by then the price had done up a decent amount). If I did not purchase the same item again at the higher price and take the ~$45 hit from the restocking then I was SOL. Then maybe they would not charge the 15% fee but the price was still higher than what I had originally paid for...whatever...by then they'd burned all their credibility with me.

IDK, maybe some people have fine experiences with ZZF. I didn't, and the massive FAIL that was their CS when they sold me a defective product ensured that I would never do business with them again.

That's basically sums up what I've read about ZZF. If what you get is good then they're a great company but if there are any issues their CS and treatment of customers is rather....disappointing.
 
It's water under the bridge. It is kind of sad that I have a list of companies that I refuse to deal with (ZZF), or refuse to buy specific stuff from (NewEgg HDD's).
 
Back
Top