Newcastle vs Clawhammer Info needed

etexjc

n00b
Joined
Nov 11, 2005
Messages
27
I'm putting together a mATX gigabyte mobo and 512mb pc2700 kingston ram and a ATI AIW 9k AGP card, and i'm going to buy atleast a 2.0 GHZ processor and wonder which to get in the lower to mid line socket 754 cpu's.

Thanks for any and all help
JC
 
You might consider getting a Sempron. They would run cooled and give comparable performance for a lower price point.
 
Sempron? comparable to a newcastle or clawhammer..?

The lack of Cache on the semprons make them slugish in windows, there are very cases I would even think about a sempron..
-hammer is older, has 1mb cache.. stock will run faaster that a newcastle when clocked the same.
-newcastle, cheaper, more avabile, 512k cache, overclcoks well, runs a tad cooler...


I say go Venice...
 
Unless you can get a ClawHammer on the cheap (I got my 3700+ for ~$150 in Nov), get a Sempron 2800+, 3100+ or 3400+ and OC the heck out of it. Forget a Newcastle - it might have more cache, but you generally won't be able to OC it as high.

This should give you a rough idea how they'll compare.

The Sempy 3400+ has been handed down to the 'lil bro (running @ 2.7GHz) :cool:
 
i got all i need except for a SATA drive(oh i found one.... but need the cpu more), i have a T-bird now and found a buyer for $150 for the "old" system i'm using now, so i know how slow is... atleast for the last 2 years. Income Tax check coming in 2 weeks and i would like to have something to move SL DVD burning faster and smoother running DVD, DivX and Mpeg4 to show without hiccups in recording or viewing....

New Specs
CPU - ?
Mobo - Gigabyte K8 Triton Socket 754 mATX
Mem - (1) 512 Kingston PC2700
HD - 80GB Maxtor 7200 8MB
Vid - AIW 9000 Pro
DVD - Iomega SL DVD+/- RAM
 
i'll add another endorsement for the sempron, im running a 2800+ at 2.7ghz prime stable and for the 85 cad i paid for it i couldnt be happier. it runs cool, and has everything the a64's have except the added l2 cache. as an above poster said, unless you can find a claw for cheap, i would go with a sempron.
 
I(illa Bee said:
I say go Venice...
NEWARK FTW ;)

seriously. 90nm, revE, 1mb cache... it's hard to go wrong, esp since i can get one that runs at 2.6ghz stock for ~$300 ;)
 
2nd for the newark!!! ;) dont know about the new 4000, but i can vouch for the 3700.
 
so on the egg.... here's what i see

2800+ Claw -> $113
3000+ Venus $123
3000+ Newcastle $124 (weekend special)

which is the better of the three?
 
3000+... venus? venus is the name of the core used in the single core opterons :p
i bet you meant venice :D

personally? i'd go with a mobile clawhammer... just because i tend to like 130nm more. the 3000+ venice will probably hit the highest clocks though
 
You prefer 130nm? If it's the ClawHammer, I understand, but probably not the Newcastle right? Palermos whup them something bad ;)
 
I(illa Bee said:
Sempron? comparable to a newcastle or clawhammer..?

The lack of Cache on the semprons make them slugish in windows, there are very cases I would even think about a sempron..
Dude, my Sempron 2800+ was just as good in Windows as my Opteron 146, even 400mhz faster, it still feels the same, unless you benchmark a lot, you shouldn't notice that little difference, it's not a Celeron afterall.
 
WhoBeDaPlaya said:
You prefer 130nm? If it's the ClawHammer, I understand, but probably not the Newcastle right? Palermos whup them something bad ;)
takes abuse in a stride.. 90nm doesn't as much :(
 
the highest overclocks were done on the clawhammers... but Old and over priced these days.

newcastles dont overclock well unless you get the 3000+s... the 3400+'s dont go much higher... ehh... I had it, but wasn't that impressed.

Venice is better cause it is .90nm and runs on lower voltage, can over clock higher, has newer instructions like SSE3... and it's cheap. I say go with this one for the win!!!
 
noobtech said:
the highest overclocks were done on the clawhammers... but Old and over priced these days.
i've yet to see a clawhammer do 3.1ghz on air ;)
 
noobtech said:
Venice is better cause it is .90nm and runs on lower voltage, can over clock higher, has newer instructions like SSE3... and it's cheap. I say go with this one for the win!!!
Wow.. 0.90nm! That's incredibly small! Where do I find this?
 
noobtech said:
the highest overclocks were done on the clawhammers... but Old and over priced these days.
I thought the Venice generally goes higher? eg. my CH 3700+ can't really push past 2.7GHz (stock is 2.4GHz).
Not that I'm complaining though, since the current top end is only 2.4GHz w/512KB L2 on Socket-939 :p
 
Eclipse, where are the best prices on Newarks? Shentech is outta stock on the 3700, but they have the 3400 for $180. Whats your take on a 3400 Newark?
 
mathot said:
Eclipse, where are the best prices on Newarks? Shentech is outta stock on the 3700, but they have the 3400 for $180. Whats your take on a 3400 Newark?
i have a friend who can get 4000+'s for around $300, i'm sure the lower models are equally cheap. the 3400+.. if you can find one, why not? :p
 
Back
Top