New Vid Card (ATI or Nvidia)

skrypts

n00b
Joined
Nov 26, 2006
Messages
41
I'm looking for a great bang for my buck video card for my system. My current video card died and now I'm looking for a replacement. I'm not biased toward ATI/Nvidia, I just want a good deal that would match up well with my system's specs.

My system is:
c2d e6600 @ 3.4ghz
4gigs corsair 1066
intel badaxe 2
corsair 620HX
1920x1080 resolution on LVM-37w3

I used to have an 8800GTX and it worked out pretty good for most of the games I played.

Looking forward to your input....
 
first things first: can you rma your 8800GTX? that video card is still very good to this day, and if you can rma it I would advise you to wait until summerish when ati is supposedly releasing their 5800 series.
 
Unfortunately I can't, I broke the rule of not registering the product through thier webpage within 30 days and they declined me. The card is 2.5 years old just about now.
 
ouch. Well i would suggest the 4870 1gb or the gtx260. These cards should have the performance "boost" over the 8800gtx, and they are pretty cheap (around $160). They should be able to last you until rv870/gt300
 
Pick this 4850 up, after the 12% off and the mir you are looking at $86...pretty much best bang for your buck right now. Should tide you over for a while.

Do you have a budget in mind?

Can always go up if you need to.
 
4850 wouldn't really be an upgrade from an 8800gtx.

No but he didn't list a budget, and it is a cheap, solid, reliable, temporary solution to hold off for the new refresh of cards coming out this summer.

Plus he asked for the best bang for the buck for his system, and I think that's pretty close to it myself...
 
Last edited:
I was kind of leaning towards a 260. I figured it would pop up the most but I just wanted to see what everyone else thought. I'm not really interested in spending $350+ for a video card. I looked up the invoice for my 8800GTX and saw that I spent $600 for it roughly, that's pretty crazy. I'll probably keep my eyes open for a good deal on a 260. What flavor and brand of 260 do you all think would be good? There's so many versions out now. $160 bucks seems reasonable.
 
I'm looking for a great bang for my buck video card for my system
GTX 260 - Core 216
4870 1GB

The cheapest deal you can find on either of the above. That is the "magic" point in the price/preformance curve. Everything above that and you'll pay 2 or 3 times the price/preformance of those.
 
Looks like a nice deal on that card Hossdaddy, is the warranty lifetime? I was thinking of going with a new BFG card after reading a little bit in that other thread where the rep was helping the guy out with his BFG RMA.

Edit: looks to only be a 192.
 
You could always crossfire 2 of the 4770's for even better performance than the 260's or 4870's, even the 4890 and GTX 280...and spend just a little more, $200 or so. Plus less power consumption and heat, and they overclock great too.
 
Even though it's $70 more than the GTX 260, I think the GTX 275 scores pretty high on the bang for buck scale - most of the performance of a GTX 285 for $90 less, and about the same price as a 4890. Remember, OP is running at 1920x1080 with a decent CPU, so they'll see all of the extra power from a 275 over a 260.
 
Even though it's $70 more than the GTX 260, I think the GTX 275 scores pretty high on the bang for buck scale - most of the performance of a GTX 285 for $90 less, and about the same price as a 4890. Remember, OP is running at 1920x1080 with a decent CPU, so they'll see all of the extra power from a 275 over a 260.

Yes, the extra 10-15% more fps for 50% more.
 
Yes, the extra 10-15% more fps for 50% more.

50% more??

$169-$189 average for afore mentioned cards vs $200 for 2 4770's

How is that 50% more? Besides it is better performance, less power, less heat, only needs 2 6 pin PCI-E total instead of 4...I'm just giving another viable option, a decent one too.
 
You could always crossfire 2 of the 4770's for even better performance than the 260's or 4870's, even the 4890 and GTX 280...and spend just a little more, $200 or so. Plus less power consumption and heat, and they overclock great too.

I was thinking about this as well, seeing I have an Intel based board that can crossfire. Let me look into those video cards.
 
That's some pretty sweet performance. I wonder if my non dual 2.0 pci-e slots will bottleneck it. I'm definately going to consider x-fire on my bad axe 2 for sure. Those budget cards seem to be quite powerful together. I wonder how the memory would affect me playing at 1920x1080.
 
Ordered two Sapphire 4770s. We'll see how X-fire works out. Looks to be a nice bang for the buck.

Edit: Do they come with the crossfire cable to connect them together?
 
50% more??

$169-$189 average for afore mentioned cards vs $200 for 2 4770's

How is that 50% more? Besides it is better performance, less power, less heat, only needs 2 6 pin PCI-E total instead of 4...I'm just giving another viable option, a decent one too.

Do you even read? Seriously. Learn to read. I quoted someone (not you) who was recommending paying 70$ more for a 275.

Please, learn to read. The world doesn't revolve around you, you need to learn this, otherwise it's going to be a rought world out there.
 
IMO ati has slightly better numbers, but at most price points they are about equal.

I prefer ati right now, but before the HD4000 series the last ati card I used was a 9700 Pro.
I like that nvidias linux drivers are much better.

At the 100 dollar level the new ATI HD4770 is unmatched in performance for the dollar and power usage though. Coming in only a hair behind a 4850 that still runs 130-150
 
Do you even read? Seriously. Learn to read. I quoted someone (not you) who was recommending paying 70$ more for a 275.

Please, learn to read. The world doesn't revolve around you, you need to learn this, otherwise it's going to be a rought world out there.




LOL calm down buddy, I was walking out the door to go to work and missed the quote my bad. I was kind of hoping you weren't that dense when it came to math, glad to see I was right...sorry for the mispost heh

All better now?


To the Op, if the rumors are true about the new cards not coming out til near end of year, then I think you made the right choice in cards, and should be quite happy with the performance. I'm thinking about picking up a pair for the rig I'm building for my son too.

Let us know how they turn out for you, and shoot us some of your benches :)
 
LOL calm down buddy, I was walking out the door to go to work and missed the quote my bad. I was kind of hoping you weren't that dense when it came to math, glad to see I was right...sorry for the mispost heh

All better now?


To the Op, if the rumors are true about the new cards not coming out til near end of year, then I think you made the right choice in cards, and should be quite happy with the performance. I'm thinking about picking up a pair for the rig I'm building for my son too.

Let us know how they turn out for you, and shoot us some of your benches :)

Sorry, I tried not to be an ass*, but you we really harsh in your post. No worries. :)

*I was totally an ass, I said I tried, not I was :D
 
Sure thing, I'll post a couple benchmarks. I think it might be interesting to see the performance from my standard machine as compared to the super rigs the other guys use. However, it looks like I'm going to have to buy a crossfire bridge and I might not be able to put it all together this weekend which is really a disappointment. Do I need two of them and does it matter which ones I get?
 
Should just need 1 for 2 cards, and I don't think it matters. If you got the retail package, it should (I think) come with a bridge.
 
That's some pretty sweet performance. I wonder if my non dual 2.0 pci-e slots will bottleneck it. I'm definately going to consider x-fire on my bad axe 2 for sure. Those budget cards seem to be quite powerful together. I wonder how the memory would affect me playing at 1920x1080.

It will bottleneck it fairly significantly. I moved up from my 4850cf setup with bad axe 2 to a x48 and the difference was very noticeable. It still ran great on the bad axe 2 but it was a solid 20% faster on the x48 board.
 
It will bottleneck it fairly significantly. I moved up from my 4850cf setup with bad axe 2 to a x48 and the difference was very noticeable. It still ran great on the bad axe 2 but it was a solid 20% faster on the x48 board.

Doesn't the Badaxe knock it down to 16x 4x? If so, even a P45 would be much better at 8x 8x.
 
Back
Top