New system, please critique

medbot

n00b
Joined
Jul 19, 2006
Messages
50
Hey guys, I'm thinking of updating my my computer and have picked out these parts. I'd appreciate any feedback. I'll be using it for gaming and audio work, though probably more for gaming heh. I'm gonna skip the vid card for now and plan to pick up one of the new nvidia cards in November. I had originally planned to wait a while to see how x38 and penryn and all that came out but after seeing the previews of penryn I don't think its worth waiting for six months or so for, and I can't think of any reasons why I'd need the x38 considering the price it will likely be set at. Anyways...

intel Q6600 http://www.clubit.com/product_detail.cfm?itemno=CA1938452
abit ip35 pro http://www.clubit.com/product_detail.cfm?itemno=CA4841007
corsair hx620 http://www.clubit.com/product_detail.cfm?itemno=CA6200027
seagate 500gb http://www.clubit.com/product_detail.cfm?itemno=CA3476919
g.skill 4gb ram http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16820231122

I was going to put this into either an antec p180 or p182, if I could find a good deal on the latter.

I'm having a tough time deciding on my cooling solution. I'm torn between high end air cooling, like a tuniq tower or thermalright, and a lower budget water cooling setup, such as this swiftech h20 120 kit http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16835108075
I'm just not sure if wc would be worth it since I imagine it being my ram, not the processor, which will hinder my oc. If anyone knows of any 4gb with some oc potential please let me know.
Also, since I'm going to be getting 4gb ram I was going to get vista64; are there any weird driver issues still going on with that? I'll likely be bringing over an xfi card from my current system but its not a deal breaker if creative still hasnt gotten their stuff together. Also, would I be better off with the 4gb kit or would two sets of something else, such as these ballistix http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820146565 do just as well, do it cheaper, and have more oc headroom?

Thanks so much for your help everyone!
 
Looks pretty good, though you missed out the graphics card. Go with high end air, I wouldn't want to spend that huge amount more on cooling to get roughly similar temps. The memory is fine, you will never reach the limit of those sticks. They will probably go up to around 1050mhz or something like that before topping out. memory on quads is never really an issue. If you get PC6400 you will never run into any problems.
 
Thanks for the input, and good call on the watercooling. I think I wanted to try that more just to try it than anything. e-peen, you know :p. Anyone else have any thoughts or suggestions? I'm still a little leary about the driver situation in 64, but it seems that it's all been sorted for the most part. I'm not too worried about losing a few fps in games. Also, can anyone with this case and power supply confirm whether or not the psu cables are long enough to reach up from the lower compartment or if I need to buy an extension? Thanks again guys
 
I say go with high end air cooling. Less of a hassle and mess than a water cooling setup. You can hit 3.6Ghz on air according to the Core 2 Duo OC database:
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1138241

So the Tuniq Tower 120 or Scythe Ninja will be good enough.

Also, you do not NEED high performance RAM in order to OC ANY Core 2 Duo CPU. Here's what I mean:

Q6600:
9 x 266Mhz (DDR2 533) = 2.4Ghz <== Stock Speeds
9 x 333Mhz (DDR2 667) = 3.0Ghz <== Good OC
9 x 400Mhz (DDR2 800) = 3.6Ghz <== Great OC possible with very good cooling.

So basically any cheap set of DDR2 800 RAM is all you need to OC a quad. Oh and the Corsair's cables are long enough for the P180.
 
I doubt you could get any higher than 3.6 on low end watercooling. I don't even know if high end would help much. I think high end air cooling is good enough.
 
from reviews I read, the swiftech H20-120 against the scythe infinity performed 20 degrees C lower and allowed for 3.66Ghz on Quad while the infinity setup crashed due to heat. Where is everyone getting the info that high end air is about the same cooling as water? Every test on quad seems to show that water is doing a much better job. The difference is negligible on duals since they don't run hot, but on Quads the heat output is much higher and therefore water seems to be the better choice.

another review at 3dgameman showing 57 C load on Q6600 overclocked to 3.4Ghz or something and ninja running 10C higher on the same system.

http://www.vr-zone.com/articles/Swiftech_H20-120_Compact_Water-Cooling_Kit/5142-5.html
 
10°C just isn't worth the added cost and complexity of a water cooling system, imo. Most B3 stepping Q6600s reach around 3.4Ghz, while G0 stepping Q6600s reach around 3.6Ghz... both of those limits are on good air cooling (eg. Tuniq Tower or Thermalright Ultra 120 eXtreme + S-Flex fan).

If you just want to do it for the experience, then by all means, go ahead. If you want to break records... go phase change.
 
10°C just isn't worth the added cost and complexity of a water cooling system, imo. Most B3 stepping Q6600s reach around 3.4Ghz, while G0 stepping Q6600s reach around 3.6Ghz... both of those limits are on good air cooling (eg. Tuniq Tower or Thermalright Ultra 120 eXtreme + S-Flex fan).

If you just want to do it for the experience, then by all means, go ahead. If you want to break records... go phase change.

Not everyone reaches 3.6Ghz with the G0. A lot of luck is involved on what CPU you end up with and how well it overclocks. And his system right now is going to be limited in OC by the CPU imho. Some systems will require higher voltage then others to reach good OC potential and high end air is limited to 1.5 or so volts and that's pushing it (need good ambient temperature which isn't spectacular with p180s). But with the watercooling he should be able to up the volts over 1.55 to get to 3.6 over a 3.4 OC.

Now watercooling isn't for everyone, but for someone interested in having their system watercooled, getting 10-20 C cooler CPU, possibly getting a 0.1-0.2 Ghz increase with an average G0 with high volts, and e-peen factor. I think 70 bucks isn't too bad of a price. It's differences in opinion, but to say that 10-20C is negligible is providing false information, because that's quite a bit more cooling. People here stress over 5C differences. If he wants to run CPU at 60C instead of 75C, then he might want to spend that extra money for it. Then it should be up to him to decide instead of saying that the temps will be the same.
 
Yes, the Swifttech WC setup does cool quad cores better than certain air cooling HSF setups. However, look at the costs: $150-$160 for the Swifttech and $36 for the Ninja, $50 for the Tuniq Tower, and $60-70 for the Ultra 120 Extreme. Like enginurd has said, any of the previously mentioned air cooling setups can help the Q6600 hit 3.6Ghz, a very great OC. The highest OC I've seen so far with the Q6600 has been 4.0Ghz with, what I assume to be, a high-end WC setup. So basically, it's more cost-effective to go with a high-end air cooling setup than a low-end WC setup.

So is a WC setup worth the hassle and money for a 400Mhz increase? Well thats up to you.

EDIT: Man took too long to post a reply. That Switftech H20-120 doesn't cost $70. The lowest I've seen that go for is $150 to $160.
 
Yes, the Swifttech WC setup does cool quad cores better than certain air cooling HSF setups. However, look at the costs: $150-$160 for the Swifttech and $36 for the Ninja, $50 for the Tuniq Tower, and $60-70 for the Ultra 120 Extreme. Like enginurd has said, any of the previously mentioned air cooling setups can help the Q6600 hit 3.6Ghz, a very great OC. The highest OC I've seen so far with the Q6600 has been 4.0Ghz with, what I assume to be, a high-end WC setup. So basically, it's more cost-effective to go with a high-end air cooling setup than a low-end WC setup.

So is a WC setup worth the hassle and money for a 400Mhz increase? Well thats up to you.

EDIT: Man took too long to post a reply. That Switftech H20-120 doesn't cost $70. The lowest I've seen that go for is $150 to $160.

i meant 70 dollars more then high end air. So your saying 10-20 C lower load temps equates to 400 mhz increase? Yea I know its more cost effective to go with high end air cooling setup than WC. But people here buy the ultra 120 extreme which is 34 bucks more then a lower cost ninja for like 5C load temp differences, yet this is 70 bucks more for 10C lower with a low end WC. I think the OP should decide if he's willing to spend extra for WC, but there is a temp difference and that was my whole point. Its great if he gets 3.6 ghz on air and water would not have changed anything, but not everyone hits 3.6ghz and every CPU is different so we don't know the effects until its tested with both options.

People usualy don't upgrade from high end air to WC they chose one or the other, so its hard to quantify exactly how much more OC is possible with WC over high end air, but the trend is that with water most usually can OC higher on average, so some are willing to pay the price so they dont end up wondering "what if". Therefore its really just up to the person and if the cost is worth wanting that much cooler system.
 
Actually the difference between Ultra 120 Extreme and Ninja under load temps is actually 15C to 18C:
http://anandtech.com/casecoolingpsus/showdoc.aspx?i=3068&p=6

Compare the temps between the Ninja (Stock) and the Ultra 120 Extreme under load. So $34 more for a 15C to 18C drop is much easier to stomach than $70 more for a 20 to 27C drop.

So your saying 10-20 C lower load temps equates to 400 mhz increase?

No. I had asked if a WC setup was worth the extra money and time for a 400Mhz increase over high-end air cooling. Did not relate the temps you'd get with the WC setup with an OC increase.

I will concede that a properly done WC setup will cool better than an high-end air cooling setup. But imo, I don't think it's worth the extra money or hassle to do so.
 
Actually the difference between Ultra 120 Extreme and Ninja under load temps is actually 15C to 18C:
http://anandtech.com/casecoolingpsus/showdoc.aspx?i=3068&p=6

Compare the temps between the Ninja (Stock) and the Ultra 120 Extreme under load. So $34 more for a 15C to 18C drop is much easier to stomach than $70 more for a 20 to 27C drop.



No. I had asked if a WC setup was worth the extra money and time for a 400Mhz increase over high-end air cooling. Did not relate the temps you'd get with the WC setup with an OC increase.

I will concede that a properly done WC setup will cool better than an high-end air cooling setup. But imo, I don't think it's worth the extra money or hassle to do so.

Well the test they used was a dual, so temp differences may be different on a quad. But I didnt realize how much difference ultra makes over ninja ( i assumed ninja was nearly as good). But u can see how that 2 degrees difference in temps (ultra to ultra extreme) meant that the CPU could be pushed the extra 600 mhz. So, althought yes WC isn't the most cost effective I could see how some would want to get WC to push the CPU further. And yea I was being a bit lenient on saying 10C difference, because it seems to be closer to 20C or more.

I can see how your disinterest in WC makes it not worth the upgrade, but what you consider hassle to me is fun, so yea its up to the person. The whole point of my thread was to not say its negilible difference when there is a difference. I think the OP should have been given better info to make his own decision. If I was wrong about my info then provide some facts with the same system (quad cpu) showing that the difference in C is small.
 
It's well known that overclocked speeds are never guaranteed, which is why I say "around" such and such speed when speaking of overclocking. Water Cooling is fun... Yah, but wouldn't it suck to go through all that fun and get a Q6600 that won't even reach 3.3Ghz? lol... My opinions are usually from a cost-effectiveness standpoint. So, my point was, WC isn't cost effective.

Oh, and if you throw a better fan (S-Flex) onto the Ninja for another $13, it'll perform nearly as good as an Ultra 120 eXtreme + S-Flex fan. So, the Ninja would be more cost effective for a dual core CPU. With a quadcore, most people have to lap their ninja and use a bolt-through kit to reach nearly the same performance as an Ultra 120x. For a quadcore, I think the Tuniq is the best cost effective solution.
 
everything about overclocking is dependent on a bit of luck. Yes you might end up WC a poor CPU that doesn't hit the OC you wanted, but u also might have one that hits 3.8 on water with a bit of voltage increased that wouldn't have gone up that high on air or unstable on air. For some 70 dollars is worth the peace of mind that if you end up with a good CPU you'll get the most out of it and not have to worry about how hot the CPU is running.

Air cooling has its benefits in being the most cost efficient and easiest setup, but there are downsides to air. In the summer when ambient temperature rises, sometimes air cooled systems have to be downclocked a bit due to heat problems, but with WC you wouldn't have to do this. Since with WC water is transfering the heat directly out of the case, it keeps ambient temp low which helps with vid card cooling on air while with high end air your moving hot air within the case (unless you have a duct system). Also with large HSF it becomes more dangerous to move them around while WC aren't putting as much stress by weight and just need to have water drained out before moving. S-flex is a good fan, but I dont think it beats one with more CFM which outputs more noise, so WC in terms of cooling can run quieter.

There's are cost and benefits to all choices and it's up to an individual as to what they consider worth getting. I'm not trying to say that everyone should go water in fact I'm running air cooled system atm, but considering how hot Quads run I can see why a lot of people do go water.
 
Back
Top