New system or new video card?

kent

2[H]4U
Joined
Apr 8, 2001
Messages
2,603
Rig:

Mobile 2500+ @ 2.3GHz
1GB DDR400 in dual channel
Radeon 9800 SE (4 pipes with same clock as Pro, 256bit mem)
A7N8X DLX


Should I get a new machine or just a new video card. New games hurt me!
 
Heh, I was in the exact same postion. I went with a 3000+ Venice at E-Wiz for $118 and a DFI Ultra-D refurb for $85 at the Egg. Not bad for $203 shipped. All I have left to decide on is a video card, not sure if I should just get the 6600 GT or dish out a little more for a 6800 GT.
 
Shane_c82 said:
Heh, I was in the exact same postion. I went with a 3000+ Venice at E-Wiz for $118 and a DFI Ultra-D refurb for $85 at the Egg. Not bad for $203 shipped. All I have left to decide on is a video card, not sure if I should just get the 6600 GT or dish out a little more for a 6800 GT.

Depends on what resolution you play at and what AA modes you want to use. That's where the 6800GT shines vs. the 6600GT. At 1280x1024 no AA or AF you'd be hard pressed to tell the difference.
 
kent said:
Rig:

Mobile 2500+ @ 2.3GHz
1GB DDR400 in dual channel
Radeon 9800 SE (4 pipes with same clock as Pro, 256bit mem)
A7N8X DLX


Should I get a new machine or just a new video card. New games hurt me!

new card and then a new cpu when u can afford it...
 
Sir-Fragalot said:
Depends on what resolution you play at and what AA modes you want to use. That's where the 6800GT shines vs. the 6600GT. At 1280x1024 no AA or AF you'd be hard pressed to tell the difference.

what about 1280x1024 4xAA 8xAF?
 
i would go for a new video card.. I think your processor can last 6+ months easily and by that time u will have quite a few better options to upgrade.. and moreover currently your video card is pretty slow in comparison to your processor.
 
Yeah, you don't need a new CPU right away. You're 2500+ is clocked above that of even a Barton 3200+ so it's probably not too far behind the performance of an Athlon64 2800+ in gaming. I don't exactly hear anybody with Athlon64 2800's being told to upgrade their CPU before getting a new video card so I'm sure you'll be fine with your mobile for at least another generation.
 
Shane_c82 said:
Heh, I was in the exact same postion. I went with a 3000+ Venice at E-Wiz for $118 and a DFI Ultra-D refurb for $85 at the Egg. Not bad for $203 shipped. All I have left to decide on is a video card, not sure if I should just get the 6600 GT or dish out a little more for a 6800 GT.

I am in the same position too...

Abit AN7
2400+ mobile xp @ 2400
1 gb OCZ pc 3200 dual channel
ATI 9700 pro

Let us know what the difference is when you get your new machine together.
 
Well if you are sticking with an agp system (which if you don't get a new one you plainly have), I would get a 6800NU (regular). That one for $189 seems a good deal. Since it's AGP you can unlock it, getting a much better performance increase than any other card's simple overclock. Unlock + Overclock would obviously be the best solution, and paired with some good cooling, even water maybe, you could easily clock it to about 6800GT specs with the unlocked pipes and such, if you are lucky. If you aren't and it doesn't clock that high or unlock, RMA it until you get one that does.
 
Is this recommendation universal? I'm running the following and looking to upgrade myself. The longer I can push back the full system upgrade the longer the new system will last, in theory. My specs

XP 3200+ (Socket-A Max)
ATI 9700 Pro
1GB Ram
Asus A7n8x Deluxe with dual channel or whatever.

Nothing overclocked. I play typically at 1024x768 on LCD and 1280x1024 on CRT if it looks better. AA when the FPS allows.
 
Get a 6800GT and wait for prices to come down on modern CPUs or wait for M2 all together. I have a 2.5ghz Mobile barton and 6800GT and not one game gives me issues. I'm running most games at 1920x1200 to boot.
 
I recently purchased a e-VGA 6800 Nu for my nephews system. Theirs is an XP2800+(Barton, no OC) with 1GB PC2700 and a 5700Ultra. The 6800nu made a big difference. They could actually run games with 4xAA+8Aniso on 1024x768. BF2 with everything at high detail other than lighting at medium was damn smooth. The 6800nu was unlocked for 16pipes and 6 vertex engines. 3dmark05 had major artifacting with the pipes unlocked, but games did not.(for some unknown reason) So the pipes were left at 16 since it has no effect on gaming.

I would get a 6800nu or X800XL but not a GT for that system. Not worth the investment. Also,CompUsa has the X800XL for $249 if you do not want to worry about unlocking pipes on the 6800nu.
 
(313)dnoyeb said:
Is this recommendation universal? I'm running the following and looking to upgrade myself. The longer I can push back the full system upgrade the longer the new system will last, in theory. My specs

XP 3200+ (Socket-A Max)
ATI 9700 Pro
1GB Ram
Asus A7n8x Deluxe with dual channel or whatever.

Nothing overclocked. I play typically at 1024x768 on LCD and 1280x1024 on CRT if it looks better. AA when the FPS allows.


Your Compusa their in Southfield showed as having the X800XL in stock for AGP at $249. Get if you can.
 
Another vote for a new video card. My bro has a mobile Barton at 2400 MHz. He got a 6800 GT first (which I took over), and then a X850XT. Both cards were a significant upgrade over his old 9800 Pro in terms of playable settings. I doubt he would have seen the same gains had he upgraded his cpu/mobo.

EDIT: 6800nu looks like a fine choice.
 
Yup. Graphics card is the way to go here - just don't get too good of a card since, because of the AGP-PCIe shift, you won't be able to take it with you when upgrading the CPU/Mobo. A 6600GT or 6800NU are probably about the sweet spot here.
 
Back
Top