New System Advice and where do I post ?'s?

Stevarian

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 13, 2002
Messages
502
I have been a member of HardForum since 2002, but haven't been on here much the last few years as my system has been working fine and doing everything I have needed it to do....gotta love that Abit IC-7 motherboard!!

Anyway, it is time for a new system, and I have been very much out of the hardware loop. I recently read the article in Maximum PC in which they outlined a $1500 PC, and started to think of that as my template.

I first of all need to know if I should post a thread in each individual forum for each part of the system (which probably makes the most sense if I want specific advice) or if I can post in one forum, such as here....

My basic thoughts on a system are as follows:
I would like an Intel based system, and am definitely thinking quad-core. The article recommended the Q6600 Core 2 Quad proc (2.4 ghz), and that does seem to be a good chip. They then listed the following parts:

XFX Geforce 8800 GTS 512 Alpha Dog Edition vid card
MSI P35 Neo2-FR motherboard
4GB of Patriot DDR2/800 RAM
A cooler Master CM Stacker STC-T01-UW case
PC Power & Cooling Silencer 610 power supply
Windows XP Pro
Seagate 750 GB Barracuda AS 7200-10 hard drive
An optical drive
and finally the Creative X-Fi Xtreme Gamer soundcard

I already have XP Pro, and would probably get Vista, and do a dual boot system.

I already have 2 optical drives, they are a few years old, but seem perfectly capable.

I am having trouble finding the CM Stacker case, and wonder if there are better options out there?

I do a lot of gaming, and have done some overclocking in the past with my Abit board. I don't know how important it will be to OC in the future, but would like to be able to do some.

If I can build something with similar or even better results than the above for less than $1500 I would be ecstatic.

I currently have a 19" Mitsubishi Diamond Pro 900u monitor that is working ok, but I would like to enter the world of larger monitors, and have absolutely no idea where to start with that....that will be down the road a bit.

I would welcome feedback on the above, and if I need to post questions in individual forums for each of the specific parts, I can do that too. It kind of saddens me that when I built my last system, Abit had one of the best boards out there with the IC7, and now it seems their reputation has slid quite a bit....

Thanks in advance!!!

Steve
 
Bump....maybe I put a bad title on this thread?? I did some further reading here last night, the Prelude soundcard with X-fi has very positive reviews, but would I notice much difference over the Creative Xtreme gamer X-fi card? It is like $69 after MIR at newegg....
 
I would welcome feedback on the above, and if I need to post questions in individual forums for each of the specific parts, I can do that too. It kind of saddens me that when I built my last system, Abit had one of the best boards out there with the IC7, and now it seems their reputation has slid quite a bit....
Actually, Abit's P35 boards have a very good reputation. Your thread fits well in the General Hardware forum, but I'd recommend reading the sticky at the top to get a better idea of what kind of information you should give to really help other users provide good feedback.

That said, your component selection looks good, but you don't necessarily have to be so picky with brands for your video card, memory, motherboard or case. There are probably cheaper factory overclocked 8800GTS cards than the one you listed. An 8800GT would be sufficient for a 19" monitor.

You should keep an eye on the hot deals forum and watch for good deals on memory. There have been some really great prices on A-Data and G Skill memory recently, but I can understand if you want to support Patriot.

If you're happy with your current Abit motherboard, you'd probably like the Abit IP35 Pro. Otherwise there are less expensive P35 options without RAID and dual LAN such as the DS3L from Gigabyte which is a popular choice.

You'll have to decide for yourself which case you want to get. There are other nice CM Stacker models that might be easier to find, but I wouldn't pick that case just because a magazine said to.
 
In addition, the FAQ has a list of online retailers... you may be able to find a CM Stacker at another place.

Onboard sound has progressed to the point that it's good enough for most users. Try it out first, then consider a sound card if you're otherwise disappointed.

The MSI is actually a good choice as far as motherboards go.

Here are a few CPU coolers to consider:

Scythe SCNJ-1100P Ninja HSF - $36
Xigmatek HDT-S1283 120mm Rifle HSF - $37
Tuniq Tower 120 HSF - $45
ZEROtherm Nirvana NV120 120mm HSF - $50
Thermalright Ultima-90 HSF - $46 & Panaflo FBA09A12M 92mm Fan - $3
Noctua NH-U12P HSF - $60
Thermalright Ultra-120 Extreme HSF - $57 & Scythe S-Flex SFF21E 120MM Case Fan - $14
 
That said, your component selection looks good, but you don't necessarily have to be so picky with brands for your video card, memory, motherboard or case. There are probably cheaper factory overclocked 8800GTS cards than the one you listed. An 8800GT would be sufficient for a 19" monitor.

I would recommend the GTS anyway, since it's fairly cheap these days and has better dual-slot cooling. Other than that, the build looks pretty good. I don't know offhand if that PSU is modular, but I would also recommend the Corsair 620HX as a great modular PSU. As was said, go with Abit, Gigabyte, or Asus over MSI.
 
Thank you for your feedback! I apologize for not putting links in my initial post.

After reading your comments, and the FAQ, and some other build threads, I came up with this build list.

CPU: Intel Core 2 Quad Q6600 Kentsfield 2.4GHz
http://www.newegg.com/product/product.aspx?item=N82E16819115017

Motherboard: ABIT IP35 Pro LGA 775 Intel P35 ATX Intel Motherboard
http://www.newegg.com/product/product.aspx?item=N82E16813127030

Power supply: CORSAIR 620HX 620W ATX12V v2.2 and EPS12V 2.91 Power Supply
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817139002

**The 750W Corsair is less money, but from what I can tell, the 620 is the better, more efficient power supply??

Then I get confused by all the options for the remaining parts.

Video Card: XFX PVT88GYDD4 GeForce 8800GTS (G92) 512MB
http://www.newegg.com/product/product.aspx?item=N82E16814150267

This card still looks like a good choice, it is factory over-clocked, has a good warranty, has really good reviews at Newegg, and I could only find one card that was significantly less expensive and that was the MSI card. (These are after rebates, naturally). Is there much difference in these 8800 GTS 512 MB cards?

Case: I am totally confused here. I only put the CM Stacker in my initial post because Maximum PC had it in their article. Apparently that specific case is discontinued, and I see there are a lot of cases from Coolermaster that are "CM Stackers". I currently have an Enermax/Antec/Chieftec case that was very popular 5 years ago, it is a full tower. Do I need a full tower? It seems to me that a full tower is easier to work with, more room and better cooling.

These cases were highly rated at Newegg, but some of them are mid-towers. I would appreciate some advice on getting a good, well-made, QUIET case, that is easy to work with.

Gigabyte 3d Aurora 570
http://www.newegg.com/product/product.aspx?item=N82E16811233013

Antec Performance One P180 Silver cold rolled steel ATX Mid Tower
http://www.newegg.com/product/product.aspx?item=N82E16811129154

Antec Twelve Hundred Black ATX Full Tower Computer Case
http://www.newegg.com/product/product.aspx?item=N82E16811129043

Antec 900
http://www.newegg.com/product/product.aspx?item=N82E16811129021

**No special reason I included so many Antec cases, it is just a name I am very familiar with. I would really like a case that is quiet, easy to work with and keep clean, and would also like to keep the price below $200 if possible.

RAM: Again, lots of choices here. The only reason I put Patriot in my first post was because of the magazine, and they indicated that it had better latency than other memories in the same price range. How important is the latency? It looked to me that the better memory was 4, and most of the others were 5. I see that G. Skill gets a lot of recommendations here and at Newegg. I currently have Mushkin RAM, but am open to the best bang for my buck. I will be doing some overclocking, but that is not my main concern. I see that Mushkin, Corsair, Patriot, OCZ, G. Skill are all highly rated at Newegg, I would like to get 4 GB for now.

I currently have a Creative Audigy 2zs card, and Klipsch 5.1 Ultra speakers. I could always put the Audigy in the new system if I don't care for the onboard sound. Otherwise, I read about some of the crappy things Creative has been doing, and found the Auzentech Prelude and the Asus Xonar are highly rated sound cards if I want to put in a separate card later.

I have a BenQ 1640 burner and a LiteOn 166s DVD drive. They both seem to work fine for what I need.

Operating System: I have Windows XP Pro OEM version from when I put my current system together. I plan to buy Vista Home Premium, 64 bit version. However, after reading, I am concerned about the OEM versions. I wonder I will be able to put XP on my new system, since apparently Microsoft's licensing practice limits that. I would only have VIsta on the new system, but I may move it to a new system in the future. Should I buy the retail version of Vista? Any need to get anything more than Home Premium?

I read the review posted above about 24" LCD monitors, and I was pretty stoked to get the Dell, until I started reading some more here, and apparently it is not as great a monitor as the review suggests, and that the lag mentioned in the article is very noticeable to some, but not others. I would like to get a 24" widescreen, and it seems the 8800GTS card should handle it ok....Though someone indicated that at 24" it would be best to go SLI....which would require a different motherboard, etc. Would one card be sufficient? I also read that in July there may be some new cards from both ATI and Nvidia. There is always something new coming down the pike....Plus I am still confused as to which 24" monitor to invest in....

Is there any need for 3.5" drives anymore? It doesn't appear so.

I hope this wasn't too long. Thanks in advance for the advice!!!

Steve
 
Ignore NewEgg reviews... most of them were made by people who have no clue what they're talking about. Rely more on reviews from hardware sites such as here and... (check the list in the FAQ).

With the Q6600, virtually any DDR2 800 kit would do fine. All of the brands that you've listed are good choices, so pick the cheapest set (with heat spreaders!) you could find.

Onboard sound has progressed nowadays to the point that it's an acceptable option. Try it out first, and then consider a standalone sound card if you're otherwise disappointed.

For NVIDIA video cards, XFX, BFG, and EVGA offer (limited) lifetime warranties. XFX also offers a "double" lifetime warranty that transfers over to whomever you sell the card to. BFG and EVGA offer 90-100 day "step up" policies where you can trade in your (registered) card for a newer/better card for the difference in (retail) price between the two cards.

If you can, wait for the new cards to arrive. If not, the 8800GTS can handle most games fine (Crysis and Supreme Commander are the glaring exceptions) on a 24 inch monitor. While you do see a benefit from having SLI/CrossFire at that resolution (1920x1200), it's a lot easier to deal with one high-end card than a multi-card setup (including the motherboard).

For most people, Vista Home Premium has all of the features that they need. The OEM EULAs prohibit transfer of an activated license from system to system (but there are exceptions, and workarounds...). If you anticipate keeping this system for several years, then stick with an OEM copy. Many people keep their systems for at least a couple of years.

Cases are a matter of personal taste, so I won't comment much on them. However, you want one that provides plenty of space for your needs while still providing adequate cooling for all of your components. (We recommend cases that use primarily 120mm fans for the latter reason.) Full towers are great if you have a lot of stuff you plan on placing inside your computer, but with your current setup, you could get away with a midtower case. The Antec P18* series cases are known to reduce noise output, as does the Antec Solo case. (Not to influence your choice much, but people here hate the Antec 900 because it doesn't provide enough space for proper cable management. But again, the choice you make is based off of your own personal tastes.)
 
Back
Top