New PC or a PS3?

Kuo

Gawd
Joined
Jun 7, 2001
Messages
641
So in September I plan on making a purchase (I move physically in September, so I don't want to get any additional stuff before I move to my final location).

I can either buy/upgrade my current desktop or buy a PS3.

My desktop is currently a old AMD TBred 1800 w/ a GF4 TI4200 vid card. (rig in sig actually).

Prices off the top of my head from previous sytems I've built....
If I upgrade my desktop, I'm looking at about 150-200 on CPU, 80-100 on motherboard, 100-120 on RAM (want 2 gigs), 200 on a new graphics card, 60 on a good reliable 400-450W PSU, 40-50 on a new case, and another 50 on a new SATA HD. I'll actually be giving the bulk of the machine to my brother, so I can't really strip everything. I will carry over my dvd burner, monitor, keyboard, mouse, floppy drive, and HDs (but they're all PATA drives, so I want 1 SATA as the main OS drive).

That puts me at around 700-800 on a new desktop. Not that cheap to mel. (I'm not rich). Not sure I really need it either - I guess I'll mostly be getting it so I can play FF11 w/ my vid settings not set on low the whole time. And one day Spore.. whenever that comes out. Don't really have time anymore to explore new games, but there's somethign to be said about having a machine that can :D ... maybe try out Oblivion too. But it's out on the PS3 too..

The alternative is not to get it. To bring my old PC back down to me (or just use my laptop, which is what I've been using so far). But in turn... buy a PS3.

Now if I make the decision to buy the PS3, I can wait till the 80 gig versions come out in teh US. Or pick up the 60 gig ones for cheaper if stores still stock them. I actually consider this to be almost the same cost as the PC because I'll need to buy an initial set of games for the PS3, so I factor it into the cost.

Either way, once I buy one, I won't get the other for a long while (at least until mid 2008, if not late 2008).

Some additional things to consider:
- Whichever one I buy 2nd can potentially be "better." If I wait till '08 to get a new PC, for the same cost, I get a better machine. Similarily, if I want till '08, perhaps the PS3 price will drop yet again.
- An argument for delaying on the PS3 will be the price drop, but also that not too many games are out for PS3 yet. Lots of the ones I'm looking at (I'm more of a RPG/Adventure gamer rather than FPS) don't come out till '08.
- I considered just upgrading parts of the PC. Potentially grab a used barton off the for sale/trade forums. But vid card hits a limitation in that my mobo only supports AGP... and if I think long run, I'll want to get a PCI-E card.
- I do some video encoding stuff on my PC. But I'm at work or asleep for a large part of my day, so typically I just queue up a job or two then leave. So a faster PC can speed up the process, but if i'm not home, it doesnt really matter how much faster a job process just got finished.
 
If it were me I would upgrade my PC.. The only redeeming quality I can see in the PS3 is the BluRay player.. definitely not the game selection.. If you want good console games now buy a 360.. I havent even considered buying a PS3 till I get my 1080p LCD.. The idea of waiting till 08 to upgrade is ok but keep in mind that if you wait for something even better in 6mos to a year you will be waiting forever to buy a new machine!! I say buy a mobo that will support the upcoming 45nm Intel chips then you can simply upgrade to a different cpu or one part at the time etc.. I wouldnt waste money on parts for your current rig.. Throw Linux on it and make a file server or throw media center on it for a dvd/mp3 box..
 
If i were you... I would stop playing games and earn some cash.
 
We got a 360 recently, and I've been enjoying having a next gen console quite a bit.

However, your computer is old enough you'd see an enormous boost in performance for even day to day stuff on even a low end modern machine, so that's something to consider as well. You didn't mention (unless I'm deaf/dumb/blind, which is possible as I am rather good at pinball) how recent your laptop is, so if it's fairly modern it could offset that effect.

Honestly you'd probably be pretty happy either way...do you have an HD tv with which to enjoy the extra features of a console fully?
 
Val said:
If i were you... I would stop playing games and earn some cash.

I work full time already. Get up at 7 am, in office by 8:15/8:30 am... work till 7/7:30 pm. I just don't spend as freely as some others. Not to mention I have over 100k in student loans to pay off and I invest heavily into my roth ira's and retirement plans... so I try to keep my outgoing money within a tight constraint.

enlightenedby42 said:
However, your computer is old enough you'd see an enormous boost in performance for even day to day stuff on even a low end modern machine, so that's something to consider as well. You didn't mention (unless I'm deaf/dumb/blind, which is possible as I am rather good at pinball) how recent your laptop is, so if it's fairly modern it could offset that effect.

Honestly you'd probably be pretty happy either way...do you have an HD tv with which to enjoy the extra features of a console fully?

The laptop is actually a 2 yr old laptop. I don't actually memorize the specs off the top of my head... I use it primarily for work thus far.

I do not currently have a HD tv. But once I move into my next place, my roommate and I are seriously considering it. Currently, my "TV" is my 20.1" dell WS, heh.
 
Back
Top