For 3 years now i'm using a NAS system i've built myself, and over time I came to learn what features I want/expect from my next NAS build, time has come to put things together.
so i've started doing research on parts, but still, I lack a key component to my build, and I hope this community can help or have a new idea for me.
first.. i'll say what I expect from my NAS :
1. Low signature (both space and power usage)
2. 6 drives support (5 storage pool, 1 OS Drive)
3. Media files storage only, no need for transer speed greater that 60MB/S, also no need for redundancy.
4. 1 Large drive pool created from all these drives (i'm mapping this drive later to my Office PC and to my HTPC)
5. KVM over IP - i'm not connecting a monitor and keyboard/mice, came to appreciate this feature with my previous built
6. OCE (Online Capacity expansion) - since this build will be limited to 5 hard-drives, I want to have the option to replace 1 drive, with a larger drive in the future.
now I allready idea about most of the parts :
Motherboard :
option 1 : Super Micro X7SPA-HF (Mini ITX) with KVM Over IP support & Atom D510 -
http://www.supermicro.com/products/motherboard/ATOM/ICH9/X7SPA.cfm?typ=H&IPMI=Y
option 2 : any Q57 chipset based motherboard with Core I5 (these two combined support KVM Over IP as well), MicroATX Only -
http://www.intel.com/Products/Desktop/Motherboards/DQ57TM/DQ57TM-overview.htm
Chasis : Lian Li PCQ-08 (Mini ITX with 6 drives support)
Drives : 5x WD RE4 2TB, 1xSSD for OS
Now as for my biggest issue -
I would have just satisfied with Windows 7 Software raid if it was easy to expand, but i'm afraid that it really isn't so. yes the OS supports volume shrinking, but inorder to replace a speciefic drive I need to Shrink my dynamic volume all the way up to my drive, happened to me when I replaced a 1TB drive with a 2TB one, it was a nightmare trying to find a temporary storage for my files.
Intel Raid solution on the Q57 Chipset supports OCE, but doesn't support JBOD, I can use Raid 0, but that just seems silly I can lose all my data with just 1 of my drives failing, specially when I don't really need that speed benefiet of raid0.
the Supermicro board also have ICH9R , so same deal with this board raid-wise.
I've checked some raid card solutions, the cheapest I found with OCE & JBOD support is 3ware 9550SXU-8LP for 443$
http://www.amazon.com/3ware-9550SX-...ie=UTF8&s=miscellaneous&qid=1273606619&sr=8-3
but that seems just silly to buy this card just inorder to use it for OCE & JBOD, but I would buy it if it will be my last resort.
Does anyone here have a better solution than using this expensive Raid controller ? i'll be happy to hear.
and Thanks for reading all this text, I really did not know how to explain my situation better than just to write my needs.
so i've started doing research on parts, but still, I lack a key component to my build, and I hope this community can help or have a new idea for me.
first.. i'll say what I expect from my NAS :
1. Low signature (both space and power usage)
2. 6 drives support (5 storage pool, 1 OS Drive)
3. Media files storage only, no need for transer speed greater that 60MB/S, also no need for redundancy.
4. 1 Large drive pool created from all these drives (i'm mapping this drive later to my Office PC and to my HTPC)
5. KVM over IP - i'm not connecting a monitor and keyboard/mice, came to appreciate this feature with my previous built
6. OCE (Online Capacity expansion) - since this build will be limited to 5 hard-drives, I want to have the option to replace 1 drive, with a larger drive in the future.
now I allready idea about most of the parts :
Motherboard :
option 1 : Super Micro X7SPA-HF (Mini ITX) with KVM Over IP support & Atom D510 -
http://www.supermicro.com/products/motherboard/ATOM/ICH9/X7SPA.cfm?typ=H&IPMI=Y
option 2 : any Q57 chipset based motherboard with Core I5 (these two combined support KVM Over IP as well), MicroATX Only -
http://www.intel.com/Products/Desktop/Motherboards/DQ57TM/DQ57TM-overview.htm
Chasis : Lian Li PCQ-08 (Mini ITX with 6 drives support)
Drives : 5x WD RE4 2TB, 1xSSD for OS
Now as for my biggest issue -
I would have just satisfied with Windows 7 Software raid if it was easy to expand, but i'm afraid that it really isn't so. yes the OS supports volume shrinking, but inorder to replace a speciefic drive I need to Shrink my dynamic volume all the way up to my drive, happened to me when I replaced a 1TB drive with a 2TB one, it was a nightmare trying to find a temporary storage for my files.
Intel Raid solution on the Q57 Chipset supports OCE, but doesn't support JBOD, I can use Raid 0, but that just seems silly I can lose all my data with just 1 of my drives failing, specially when I don't really need that speed benefiet of raid0.
the Supermicro board also have ICH9R , so same deal with this board raid-wise.
I've checked some raid card solutions, the cheapest I found with OCE & JBOD support is 3ware 9550SXU-8LP for 443$
http://www.amazon.com/3ware-9550SX-...ie=UTF8&s=miscellaneous&qid=1273606619&sr=8-3
but that seems just silly to buy this card just inorder to use it for OCE & JBOD, but I would buy it if it will be my last resort.
Does anyone here have a better solution than using this expensive Raid controller ? i'll be happy to hear.
and Thanks for reading all this text, I really did not know how to explain my situation better than just to write my needs.
Last edited:
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.