new NAS Built - need assistance

Nir

n00b
Joined
May 2, 2010
Messages
38
For 3 years now i'm using a NAS system i've built myself, and over time I came to learn what features I want/expect from my next NAS build, time has come to put things together.
so i've started doing research on parts, but still, I lack a key component to my build, and I hope this community can help or have a new idea for me.

first.. i'll say what I expect from my NAS :
1. Low signature (both space and power usage)
2. 6 drives support (5 storage pool, 1 OS Drive)
3. Media files storage only, no need for transer speed greater that 60MB/S, also no need for redundancy.
4. 1 Large drive pool created from all these drives (i'm mapping this drive later to my Office PC and to my HTPC)
5. KVM over IP - i'm not connecting a monitor and keyboard/mice, came to appreciate this feature with my previous built
6. OCE (Online Capacity expansion) - since this build will be limited to 5 hard-drives, I want to have the option to replace 1 drive, with a larger drive in the future.

now I allready idea about most of the parts :
Motherboard :
option 1 : Super Micro X7SPA-HF (Mini ITX) with KVM Over IP support & Atom D510 -
http://www.supermicro.com/products/motherboard/ATOM/ICH9/X7SPA.cfm?typ=H&IPMI=Y
option 2 : any Q57 chipset based motherboard with Core I5 (these two combined support KVM Over IP as well), MicroATX Only -
http://www.intel.com/Products/Desktop/Motherboards/DQ57TM/DQ57TM-overview.htm

Chasis : Lian Li PCQ-08 (Mini ITX with 6 drives support)

Drives : 5x WD RE4 2TB, 1xSSD for OS

Now as for my biggest issue -

I would have just satisfied with Windows 7 Software raid if it was easy to expand, but i'm afraid that it really isn't so. yes the OS supports volume shrinking, but inorder to replace a speciefic drive I need to Shrink my dynamic volume all the way up to my drive, happened to me when I replaced a 1TB drive with a 2TB one, it was a nightmare trying to find a temporary storage for my files.

Intel Raid solution on the Q57 Chipset supports OCE, but doesn't support JBOD, I can use Raid 0, but that just seems silly I can lose all my data with just 1 of my drives failing, specially when I don't really need that speed benefiet of raid0.

the Supermicro board also have ICH9R , so same deal with this board raid-wise.

I've checked some raid card solutions, the cheapest I found with OCE & JBOD support is 3ware 9550SXU-8LP for 443$
http://www.amazon.com/3ware-9550SX-...ie=UTF8&s=miscellaneous&qid=1273606619&sr=8-3

but that seems just silly to buy this card just inorder to use it for OCE & JBOD, but I would buy it if it will be my last resort.

Does anyone here have a better solution than using this expensive Raid controller ? i'll be happy to hear.
and Thanks for reading all this text, I really did not know how to explain my situation better than just to write my needs.
 
Last edited:
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I would have just satisfied with Windows 7 Software raid if it was easy to expand

This is where you have gone wrong. Use WHS, linux, freebsd, freenas, opensolaris ... instead and you will not have this issue.
 
This is where you have gone wrong. Use WHS, linux, freebsd, freenas, opensolaris ... instead and you will not have this issue.

I've used WHS for sometime, but I ditched it since I've noticed my drives to be working really hard for several hours after I copied 10-20 GB's into my server, I guess it was the OS trying to optimize data across all drives, also the lack of options for the more advanced user, the lack of 64bit (and with that hopes for >2TB HD) really annoyed me.
I May revisit it with Veil if things get some improvement.

I've also tried freenas when I first started 3 years ago, had compability issues with my motherboard, but even though it's fixed now, I'm really curius if it supports OCE, or any other of the linux solutions, also can I map a drive from the FreeBSD/FreeNAS into a windows 7 based system ?
 
It does support JBOD
They just dont call it that.

When you are in the Intel RAID BIOS, just dont assign the drive to a RAID group and it will just be passed through.

I have this currently on an ICH10R.
1x 120gb vertex - passthrough/jbod/whatever you wann call it
2x 120gb vertex RAID0
 
I know for a fact that you can map drives from linux to windows 7. Have not tried with the other choices.
 
BTW why do you want JBOD if you are just going to run hardware RAID?
OTOH why does it matter if the card/chipset supports OCE, if you are going to use software raid?

you need to

1) figure out how much money you want to spend
2) What OS you want to use

If you want to use a windows based OS beside WHS then you should spend money on a good hardware RAID card because windows software raid sucks for RAID5.

If you are comfortable with linux/bsd then software RAID will work, but then your chipsets RAID capabilities dont matter.
 
It does support JBOD
They just dont call it that.

When you are in the Intel RAID BIOS, just dont assign the drive to a RAID group and it will just be passed through.

I have this currently on an ICH10R.
1x 120gb vertex - passthrough/jbod/whatever you wann call it
2x 120gb vertex RAID0

that's good to know, i'll be going for the Q57 solution then, really weird Intel dumped JBOD from the list allthough it's not exactly raid, but every other manufacture place it under supported raid levels.
 
BTW why do you want JBOD if you are just going to run hardware RAID?
OTOH why does it matter if the card/chipset supports OCE, if you are going to use software raid?

you need to

1) figure out how much money you want to spend
2) What OS you want to use

If you want to use a windows based OS beside WHS then you should spend money on a good hardware RAID card because windows software raid sucks for RAID5.

If you are comfortable with linux/bsd then software RAID will work, but then your chipsets RAID capabilities dont matter.

well I really want to use software raid and not hardware raid, but as I explained Windows 7 software raid does not support future expansion really well, and whenever I'm building a new PC I think of how'll I use it 3 years from now.
Linux solutions may work well here, less appealing since I have no clue on linux, but I'm capable of learning, i'll do some more research on FreeBSD/NAS.

Thanks for all the posters here..
 
If you want to use the powerful RAID engines and filesystems available on Linux/BSD, but still want an easy interface, FreeNAS is your best choice. Though it packs an older version of ZFS, you can upgrade the array as soon as newer FreeNAS versions come out with newer ZFS versions.

The FreeBSD route would offer you the most features, latest versions and the ability to do other things besides a NAS. However, it does require you to learn and spend time on setting up the server; not really recommended if you want something that works with a few clicks and never bother to look again. It would be a good opportunity to get to learn alot about storage, so if you like a challenge and broaden your horizon the FreeBSD route would be appealing.

I wrote some guides on how to install FreeBSD and setup ZFS. If you're interested, here's the guides:
http://submesa.com/data/bsd

Nothing on FreeNAS though; perhaps i'll write a nice guide for that as well, but really its not that hard to setup. FreeBSD is alot harder. ;-)
 
Stupid question, but why i5 versus i3-530? Are you doing encryption? Otherwise, that's a good place to save a few bucks.
 
If you want to use the powerful RAID engines and filesystems available on Linux/BSD, but still want an easy interface, FreeNAS is your best choice. Though it packs an older version of ZFS, you can upgrade the array as soon as newer FreeNAS versions come out with newer ZFS versions.

The FreeBSD route would offer you the most features, latest versions and the ability to do other things besides a NAS. However, it does require you to learn and spend time on setting up the server; not really recommended if you want something that works with a few clicks and never bother to look again. It would be a good opportunity to get to learn alot about storage, so if you like a challenge and broaden your horizon the FreeBSD route would be appealing.

I wrote some guides on how to install FreeBSD and setup ZFS. If you're interested, here's the guides:
http://submesa.com/data/bsd

Nothing on FreeNAS though; perhaps i'll write a nice guide for that as well, but really its not that hard to setup. FreeBSD is alot harder. ;-)


Thanks for your post m8.
spent the last 3 hours on FreeNAS forums, trying to gather info on ZFS, RaidZ.
i'll be honest, most of the stuff are discussed about adding drives to a pool, or replacing existing ones are way beyond my understanding, and I know i'm facing a long learning curve, so at the moment i'm leaning more towards a Windows based solution (either Veil if it turns up a proper OS, or W7 with a controller supporting OCE)

to be honest it kinda sucks, I knew I should have got familiar with linux os's when I was younger and had more time, i'm really a minimalist kind of guy, don't like much of the idea of installing a bloated OS just for a file server, i'll go sleep on it and try to understand FreeBSD / FreeNAS a little more tommorow.
thanks
 
Stupid question, but why i5 versus i3-530? Are you doing encryption? Otherwise, that's a good place to save a few bucks.

yea it's only for "option 2" where I use the intel Q57 KVM solution, the problem is, KVM will only work on Core I5 / I7 vPro cpu's.
 
Could always try Nexenta.

Nexenta project, which combines the OpenSolaris kernel with the GNU/Debian user experience to provide a versatile and powerful ZFS-based server platform.
 
You could download Virtualbox (virtualbox.org) VM solution and install FreeNAS there; then check out the web-gui and ZFS interface yourself. If you want simple basic functionality that should not be hard to setup.

The FreeBSD route would require you to learn a new environment; the unix shell. That feels like DOS, but is actually a convenient interface as long as you get your bearings and build up experience on what you can do with the shell.

If you have any ZFS or RAID-Z questions, you can ask them here, but i also wrote this ZFS guide on OCP forums:
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1500505
 
Back
Top