new gen vid card for SoftTH

dystopic

Limp Gawd
Joined
Dec 10, 2007
Messages
509
hiya [H]ers.

i've been watching the reviews and reactions to the new generation GPUs unfold with a mix of interest, amusement, and trepidation. i was surprised and pleased to see ATI's offerings doing so well this round. but i'm still unsure what i'm going to buy.

all these reviews are wonderful, and if i planned to stick with my 24" monitor, i'm pretty sure i'd go with an ATI card without question. however, i plan to buy two more 24"ers and span a few games across the three of them (oriented in portrait mode) at a resolution of 3600*x1920. *(it might be a bit higher than 3600 in some cases, due to bezel management). here's a link to the SoftTH website, if you're unfamiliar with it:
http://www.kegetys.net/SoftTH/

obviously there isn't really a comprehensive review or bench out there for a setup like this. based on my admittedly limited knowledge, it seems like an nVidia card might be a wiser choice here. until nVidia can get its act together with its chipsets, or decideds to release SLI for intel chipsets, i won't be doing SLI, unless i'm building a system for someone else with money to burn. that said, i'm not so hot on multi-GPU rendering in general, so the prospect of 48xx's in crossfire isn't ideal for me either. i've also read that crossfire introduces a limitation on maximum resolution, but i can't tell if that was only the first version of crossfire, or if a merely higher limitation still exists in CrossfireX.

my reasons for thinking one of the nVidia cards might be better for my intentions rest with the large memory capacities and buses. based on my understanding, these should allow the cards to handle higher resolutions better than their counterparts. the limiting factor seems like it would be their GPU's overall efficiency, but i think i primarily say that in comparison to ATI's current efficiency. they certainly are powerful chips in and of themselves.

luckily i'm not in the greatest rush on earth. i can always spend my money on the monitors and wait on the card (and then i could bench my 8600GTS 512 against the new card for S's and G's). at present i've loosely decided to wait for the 55nm refresh of the GTX's, but i'm not strongly committed to this decision by any means. i thought it might make a worthy topic of discussion and a good opportunity to get some feedback or even advice from more experienced folks. hell, this is [H], and i wouldn't be surprised if someone's already done this (with 30" monitors, to boot :D )

oh also, i'll probably be upgrading to an X38 motherboard since it's better built to handle lots of traffic over the NB, though we'll see what other P45s come out in the coming months. additionally, i don't really play first-person shooters, and they tend to be the most GPU-intensive games. Oblivion, X3, and World in Conflict are probably the most graphically intensive titles i play or have shelved at the moment.

thanks in advance for any advice or insight :)
 
Three monitors @ 3600x1920 and no sli? You currently have only one choice for a long time - the gtx 280.
 
guess this wasn't as interesting a topic as i thought, but thanks for your reply Mega666.

i was leaning towards the 280, for the memory volume and bus bandwidth. the core clock is a little disappointing, but i'm not too worried about it. the 55nm refresh should lower the cost and improve the clock speed a bit.

in any regard, a number of games i play (or plan to play when released) aren't (or wonn't be) very graphics intensive. StarCraft II, Galactic Civilzations II, Civ 4, heck i'm still playing SimCity4 from time to time. i find strategy games tend to benefit a great deal more from high resolutions than other games do (seeing more of a map or battlefield at once really helps).

i'm sure there will be games and situations where using only one of the monitors in the standard 1920x1200 will provide a more enjoyable experience, and it'll be easy enough to set up separate user profiles based on different system configurations.
 
Back
Top