new dell workstation, need some advice

ZippZopp

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 30, 2007
Messages
380
I'm looking at buying a dell workstation. I do a lot of 3d graphics, rendering etc with maya. I was looking through the Dell systems and saw that they offer the Xeon Processor 5060 3.20GHz for considerably less than the 3ghz 5160. I've found some reviews saying that the 5160 is quite a bit better. Does anyone have experience with these chips, is the difference that noticeable?

i was thinking of putting 2 of these chips in the system. the difference in price is almost 1500 dollars for the chips. is that really worth it?

my ideal setup is
2 dual core xeons
4 gigs of ram...possibly 8
quadro graphics cards (unsure about which one yet)

what do you think about these procs?
 
IF you are referring to the Dell Precision 690, I had one.

If had Duall 2.0's 5130's.

The machine was heavy and the responsiveness seemed slow for what it had. The Dual video is only available with the 1KW power supply.

I tried it and was disappointed. I returned it.

I ended up going with a QX6700. If has 4 cores at 2.6 and has the benefit of using DDR2 non ECC which is cheaper and runs ALOT cooler than the FB-DDR2.

Just an idea. You would be better off building it yourself. You could do it for cheaper and have a taylored machine for your needs. Dell is fine for basics, but has slipped in the area of cutting edge.
 
the thing is that I'm totally over building my own systems. I have a nice system now, but its the biggest hassle. just recently i've been getting blue screens and it keeps resetting and I have no idea how to fix it. I'm just fed up with building my own systems and if anything goes wrong i'm pretty much screwed:)

i'll keep looking at the different dell options for now
 
Welcome to Dell INDIA.

That is the big problem. I hate dealing with Dell if I have any problems,

Dell works if you do BASIC things, when you customise the software and have problems, you are on your own.


I like Dell, Don't get me wrong, BUT if you are doing it to help it solve all of your computer problems, they will not.

I own all Dell systems for the simple fact of their easy warranty replacement and price on Dell outlet.

I recently ordered an Intel Mobo for my gaming system. But you can customise a home brew system for half the price of the Upgrades. My System would be $3500 if I had Dell make it.

If you really want if cheaper, try Dell outlet.. They change the assortment daily
 
Welcome to Dell INDIA.

That is the big problem. I hate dealing with Dell if I have any problems,

Dell works if you do BASIC things, when you customise the software and have problems, you are on your own.


I like Dell, Don't get me wrong, BUT if you are doing it to help it solve all of your computer problems, they will not.

I own all Dell systems for the simple fact of their easy warranty replacement and price on Dell outlet.

I recently ordered an Intel Mobo for my gaming system. But you can customise a home brew system for half the price of the Upgrades. My System would be $3500 if I had Dell make it.

If you really want if cheaper, try Dell outlet.. They change the assortment daily

I'm almost positive that Support for Dell Presisions is US based. We use a lot of them and all the tech support I've ever talked to is US based.
 
I'm looking at buying a dell workstation. I do a lot of 3d graphics, rendering etc with maya. I was looking through the Dell systems and saw that they offer the Xeon Processor 5060 3.20GHz for considerably less than the 3ghz 5160. I've found some reviews saying that the 5160 is quite a bit better. Does anyone have experience with these chips, is the difference that noticeable?

i was thinking of putting 2 of these chips in the system. the difference in price is almost 1500 dollars for the chips. is that really worth it?

my ideal setup is
2 dual core xeons
4 gigs of ram...possibly 8
quadro graphics cards (unsure about which one yet)

what do you think about these procs?

The 5160 is a conroe-based chip. The 5060 is netburst. The 5160 at 3GHz is faster than 90% of the machines on the planet. The difference would be night and day, assuming you know how to configure a machine.

Get a 5130 (about the same price on newegg) It's "only" 2 GHz but it should be about as fast, if not faster than the 5060s.

Or, as suggested above, build it yourself. Cheaper and definitely faster.
 
The 5160 is a conroe-based chip. The 5060 is netburst. The 5160 at 3GHz is faster than 99% of the machines on the planet. The difference would be night and day, assuming you know how to configure a machine.

Get a 5130 (about the same price on newegg) It's "only" 2 GHz but it should be about as fast, if not faster than the 5060s.

Or, as suggested above, build it yourself. Cheaper and definitely faster.

Fixed :)

The 5130 is faster then the 5060s in most apps. I had a set of 5060s and I would go with any 1333 fsb woodcrest over it any day of the week, you can't go wrong with them.

The Precision is a great workstation as well, I have one and pretty much use it for everything from work apps to gaming. You'll have U.S. based support aswell. I'd also spring for the 3 year onsite warranty, although I've never needed it and don't expect to, it's just for piece of mind, especially if you don't want to work on it yourself. Let me know if you have any questions.
 
damn! looking at your sig, that is one beast of a system you have. I was looking at getting something very very similar, but probably with a lower end quadro, or maybe just get a new directx 10 card.....how long have you had that system? no issues at all with it? what about upgrading? does opening up the case void your warranty?
 
damn! looking at your sig, that is one beast of a system you have. I was looking at getting something very very similar, but probably with a lower end quadro, or maybe just get a new directx 10 card.....how long have you had that system? no issues at all with it? what about upgrading? does opening up the case void your warranty?

I've had mine since September, been folding on it 24/7 as well and it stays pretty quiet and cool considering the load folding puts on it. One thing to note, if you do want to ever run dual video cards, you need to order it from dell with dual video cards, I don't think you can purchase the riser card separately. Also, the riser card uses an nVidia switch chip, so you can't run dual ATI cards in it. I think dual ATI cards might work without the riser, but then your limited to 4x bandwidth on your second card.

Opening the case will not void your warranty. I've had mine open serveral times switching out video cards to see what combos work and what doesn't. In terms of upgrades, I'm waiting on my 5355s to get here, they've been "ordered" for a while but I had to wait until they became an actual upgrade part before they could actually be ordered. I'm Dell warranty parts direct certified, so I'll be doing the upgrade myself, I'm pretty sure as long as you purchase the upgrade from Dell it won't void your warranty. Things like putting in additional memory or video cards won't void it as well, as long as they don't cause the issue.
 
very cool. That was actually my next question...how loud or quiet the box is....seems as though you're pretty happy.

so you're popping in 2 quad cores? wow! what sort of work do you do on it? what video cards had you experimented with in there? I do a lot of 3d work in Maya, but I'm not so sure I'd need an SLI setup do you notice a huge difference with the SLI quadros?
 
very cool. That was actually my next question...how loud or quiet the box is....seems as though you're pretty happy.

so you're popping in 2 quad cores? wow! what sort of work do you do on it? what video cards had you experimented with in there? I do a lot of 3d work in Maya, but I'm not so sure I'd need an SLI setup do you notice a huge difference with the SLI quadros?

I run a lot of VM/Virtual server boxes for testing different things. I mainly got the Quadro's because I could ;) That's why I'm looking forward to 8 cores as it will give me some more horsepower for multiple virtual boxes. I've tried both single and dual X1950XTXs in the box, single card works fine, dual ATI cards will not run with the riser board (tried a X800GTO2 and X600 as well). I really don't know how much better an SLI setup performs in Maya, but I imagine it does give it a pretty good boost, it certainly gives BF2142 a nice boost.
 
cool, thanks again for the info. having some experience with those procs, how about getting 2 dual cores vs a single quad core? any advantages or disadvantages to those options?
 
cool, thanks again for the info. having some experience with those procs, how about getting 2 dual cores vs a single quad core? any advantages or disadvantages to those options?

You're going to have more memory bandwidth with the dual processor system. Personally, if you just want a single quad core processor system I'd go with a lower end precision (390) because it will be alot cheaper. But, you'll be giving up the ability to run quad channel memory and a 1333 FSB. But it all comes down to your needs. I've never run the 690 or a PE2950 with a single processor, i'm not sure what you're going to sacrifice with that setup but I imagine the dual dual cores will still have better memory bandwidth then a single quad core in identical systems.
 
cool, thanks again for your help. I'm thinking I might go with 2 dual cores. I'd really like to get the 5160's, but they are pretty expensive. the one thing I'd thought of was getting a single quad core and then upgrading later to another, but by the time i'd upgrade the proc, it would probably be time for a new system anyway.

thanks again
 
so i decided to go with a precision 490 and the specs are

2 x Xeon Processor 5150 2.66GHz
4 gigs of ram
quadro 3450 256mb
146 GB SAS Hard Drive (10K RPM)
 
Sounds great, let us know how it performs when you get it. Should be a really nice system.
 
Back
Top