New Core i7 "workstation" build advice

thekernel

Weaksauce
Joined
Apr 11, 2008
Messages
75
So I'm putting together a new workstation for my dad, and I want to run this by everyone here to see what they think. This is a pretty high spec machine, and I wanted to see if I'm going the right way with it.

Background: My dad wants a machine that will last a while and he typically does a lot of multi-tasking scenarios with office and productivity apps (including photoshop) and also wants to do some video editing and encoding (although he also has an 8 core dual proc Xeon server for that). He doesn't do gaming, but given the bill on this machine as is, I didn't see the harm in a decent GPU.

CPU: Core i7 940
Cooler: Vigor Monsoon III LT
Motherboard: Asus P6T Deluxe
RAM: 3x2GB G.SKILL DDR3 1600
Video: MSI Radeon 4870 1GB
Storage Cont: 3ware 9650SE-8LPML
Boot Drive: Intel X25-M 160GB
Media Array: 6x Seagate 7200.11 1.5TB
Case: Lian Li V1200
PS: Antec 800W
OS: Vista Ultimate 64-bit SP1
Monitor: Samsung 305T 30"

So a couple of questions come to mind:

1) On the RAID array, I was thinking of doing a RAID 5 or a RAID 50 for the media array. Any advice on this?

2) I've heard of some mounting problems with the Vigor Monsoon and the Asus P6T...anybody have any experience with this? Should I be looking at a different cooler? Overclocking isn't in the cards, but I want a nice cooler I can run at low RPMs and still get good temps out of it (in addition to Turbo mode kicking in when needed).

3) Any other issues I should be aware of?
 
Is the i7 940 really worth it? The 920 should hit 3.2GHz with ease. But maybe this isn't an overclocking setup from the sound of it.

Seagate 7200.11 1.5TB drives, check the firmware revisions, some revisions needed flashes for timeout and bricking issues. Perhaps you'd like the new WD 2TB "green" drives?
 
i personally would grab WD 1TB Black drives, and the RAID 5 will be perfect.

I thought about it, but the Seagate drives offer a lot more storage for almost the same amount. And yes, I'm aware of the issues with them (which explains the price) but they seem to be okay with the latest firmware and this isn't going to be the OS drive.

Is the i7 940 really worth it? The 920 should hit 3.2GHz with ease.

It's for a 60 year old man, he's not really the sort of guy who wants his system overclocked. I get that it's not a big deal to do so, but I don't want to deal with him blaming every hiccup on his CPU being overclocked.

Besides, given that the $200 upgrade was a drop in the bucket on this system given that most of the money is going into storage. The 965 would have been excessive, but I think the 940 is okay.

Seagate 7200.11 1.5TB drives, check the firmware revisions, some revisions needed flashes for timeout and bricking issues. Perhaps you'd like the new WD 2TB "green" drives?

The cost/benefit on the WD 2TB drives just isn't there given that the Seagate drives are $129. Good point on the firmware thing though, and I've been reading up on it--shouldn't be a problem to flash them considering the boot drive is going to be on the Intel SSD.
 
4870 isn't exactly breaking the bank these days.

Second the 12GB for a workstation. You'll probably run at DDR3-1333 for that (with the 1600 modules), if I understand correctly.

Doesn't the i7 940 only officially support 800/1066? You're overclocking the qpi/uncore section to achieve 1333/1600 speeds. Might need a voltage bump for uncore.
 
but he is the sort of guy who wants a MSI Radeon 4870 1GB

There are more reasons than gaming to have a decent GPU, especially when future proofing a system.

Second the 12GB for a workstation.

Yeah, I'm leaning that way too at this point.

You'll probably run at DDR3-1333 for that (with the 1600 modules), if I understand correctly.

Doesn't the i7 940 only officially support 800/1066? You're overclocking the qpi/uncore section to achieve 1333/1600 speeds. Might need a voltage bump for uncore.

Even if it doesn't support 1333/1600 speeds, it still makes sense if I want to prepare the system for a drop in upgrade to a future CPU like Westmere or (maybe) Sandy Bridge.
 
Back
Top