New build: quiet and reliable

Araanor

Limp Gawd
Joined
May 28, 2005
Messages
207
It's finally time for a new computer, I've been dragging around this Athlon XP 1700+ box for 3½ years. I will order the parts within two weeks.

Themes: Reliability, durability, low-noise.

I want to build this computer and have it running for years with minimal fuss. Since fans have a tendency to go crap sooner or later, I'm aiming for either passive cooling or low-speed fans for parts. This build will at most see a video card or hard drive replacement, the rest can be assumed to be left static.

Athlon 64 X2 3800+

Abit KN8 SLI

HIS Radeon X800GT IceQ II

4x512Mb PC3200 A-Data, Corsair, Crucial or Kingston. Value.

Seasonic S12-430

Seagate 7200.8 250, 300 or 400 Gb

Some DVD-burner

Antec P180

CPU: Seems like the only X2s around are bundled with cooling. I don't want to mess with the warranty. How is it?

Motherboard: I don't care in the least for SLI, what I'm looking for is passive cooling. The Asus A8N-SLI Premium is another choice but it's 50% more expensive. I haven't yet seen one single opinion on the KN8 SLI so I'm assuming it's just an update on their older boards.

GPU: HIS for their IceQ cooling. I'm looking for a card in this price class. A GTO would be nicer, but I can't find one with good cooling atm. This choice is subject to change, the video card market is on the move currently. I wouldn't say no to a passively cooled card, but most of them are either low-end or expensive.

RAM: Crucial is the most expensive, the others are roughly on the same level. I'm not aiming for overclocking here, the differences between the brands appears small to me.

Case: I've heard of the connector problems with the P180 and some PSUs and motherboards.

http://www.abit.com.tw/page/en/moth...ail.php?pMODEL_NAME=KN8+SLI&fMTYPE=Socket+939

The 24-pin connector looks like it has a good placement. The 12V auxiliary connector lies on the other side of the CPU socket, but it shouldn't be too hard to route the cable, aye?

I'll have a total of four hard drives installed, I'm of the impression that the fan in the Seasonic S12-430 will be enough to ventilate the lower chamber (with some of the venting holes blocked).

I *might* consider overclocking when I have it up and running and can see the temps. It's not a great concern for me.


Note: I'm swedish, there are some restrictions on the stuff I can find.


What do you think of my choices? Any possible problems?
 
Woohoo, another seasonic fan. I really wouldnt worry about the stock HSF included with retail cpus. I also have built my pc with a seasonic and a retail x2 3800. First off, let me tell you, you will not be disappointed by the seasonic, its is AMAZINGLY quiet, second the retail hsf with the cpu is not loud at all, its definatley low enough where youll forget its even running. And thirdly, please dont restrict yourself to that specific GPU just because the cooling. Stock gpu cooling is not loud at all, I think you would be happier to find a better bang for your buck and if you need absolute silence, water cool it down the road. Either that, or you can buy a zalman gpu cooler. Oh another thing, if you can find it, go with a 16mb cache maxtor hdd instead of that seagate. They are supposedly faster than the 10k raptors.
 
Yeah, the Seasonic sounds great. Glad I won't have to mess with the CPU hsf.

I don't need absolute silence. My (admittedly limited) experience with GPU stock cooling tells me that the fans go crap sooner than I'd like it. Thus I was looking for either passive cooling or other elaborate setups. Am I wrong?

Seagate has a steady reputation for reliable drives, that's why I'm going for them. It'll be my system disk.
 
Araanor said:
Yeah, the Seasonic sounds great. Glad I won't have to mess with the CPU hsf.

I don't need absolute silence. My (admittedly limited) experience with GPU stock cooling tells me that the fans go crap sooner than I'd like it. Thus I was looking for either passive cooling or other elaborate setups. Am I wrong?

Seagate has a steady reputation for reliable drives, that's why I'm going for them. It'll be my system disk.
TBH, I never hear of anyones stock gpu fan failing, but maybe I dont visit the video card section too often. I would strongly consider a video card of your liking, then replace the stock fan later down the road. Your stock gpu fan has to last a few months at LEAST. Unless thats the card you want, by all means go for it. Just dont restrict yourself because of the cooling.
 
I love the Antec P180 pair that baby with the right fans and you wont even know its there. My friends thought mine was a refrigerator at first :D
 
paintb4707 said:
TBH, I never hear of anyones stock gpu fan failing, but maybe I dont visit the video card section too often. I would strongly consider a video card of your liking, then replace the stock fan later down the road. Your stock gpu fan has to last a few months at LEAST. Unless thats the card you want, by all means go for it. Just dont restrict yourself because of the cooling.
Aight, I'll probably take your advice. There are some good prices on the GTOs...
 
Araanor said:
Aight, I'll probably take your advice. There are some good prices on the GTOs...
You can buy that same Arctic Cooling Silencer fan that the HIS IceQ video cards have seperatedly. Newegg has them. So do other places. I like them because they exhaust hot air outside the case.

I would definately recommend 2x1GB of RAM instead of 4x512MB. 2 sticks of RAM are much easier to setup and are more reliable. Crucial, OCZ, Mushkin, and Corsair are some of the companies you might want to look into that all have good 2x1GB kits.

As a computer tech I can honestly say that I see just as many Seagate hard drives fail as any other brand I service (when a drive fails there seems to be a pretty even spread... although having said that, the last hard drive I had to replace was an 80GB Seagate SATA drive that died after 2 days usage) Just get a drive with at least a 3 year warranty. Any brand.
 
I was going for 512-sticks because they are slightly cheaper - but you've probably got a point - half as many pieces are half as many that could go wrong.

2x1024Mb A-Data or TwinMOS $296
2x1024Mb Crucial $335

Think it's worth the extra $40 for Crucial?

As for the hard drive, Seagate has that 5 years warranty. The other disks I've been gleaning at are: Samsung SpinPoint P120S 250GB and Hitachi Deskstar T7K250 250GB. The Samsung is probably quieter and the Hitachi probably faster, but they're all at the same price point.
 
I got a good deal on an X800 vanilla so I went ahead and ordered everything.

Went for Crucial PC3200 DDR-DIMM 2048MB CL3 KIT for ram, picked a Sony for DVD-burner.

Thanks for the advice.
 
Back
Top