New build - HD needed - is my thinking correct?

DayTrader

Weaksauce
Joined
Feb 13, 2008
Messages
90
I hate to murder you guys because I know there's a ton of information I need to read through in the "ANSWERS" section and elsewhere but I need to get the drive(s) ordered as quickly as possible since everything else is on the way. I also have to confess to a much higher degree of ignorace than I'd like to...lol.

In the past, I've formatted my main HD and reinstalled the OS somewhat frequently so I always kepy my music, videos, movies and so forth on a seperate hd so I wouldn't lose those files.

Is this still the recommended approach? If so, then I'll just get a 250Gb 32MB cache drive like this $80 Seagage and only use it for the os and any info I need quickly and/or don't mind losing or moving to my other storage drives later on.

The best bang-for-the-buck seems to be in the 500GB - 1TB drives so I'd like to go with one of these but don't want to waste $ on a something like a 1TB drive for the OS and storage if I'll lose all the "stored" files should I need to format and reinstall the OS.

I'm also intrigued by RAID-0 for the OS but I don't know that there would be that much of a gain in speed nor do I know what drives (other than raptors and I'm trying to keep my system quiet) to use.

Thanks in advance.......and I promise I'll do a lot more reading before I ask anymore questions. ;) For now, I need a quick drive suggestion that will get me off on the right foot. I can always add a second for RAID (for example) down the road.
 
Newegg charges a restocking fee, but you can get that waived if you re-order the same part from them... but its another gamble. The eBay link in that thread is guaranteed, btw. Also, if you have a Fry's near you, or any B&M comp store, you should be able to pick out the drive if they have any.
 
Wouldn't a pair of 320GB drives (if/when I go RAID) be way too big if I'm just planning on putting my OS on it/them....Well, not too big but far bigger than I need?

Or, is the suggestion to abandon RAID for my OS because this single drive would be "fast enough" for most applications/games given the single platter design and so forth?
 
Longer answer:

If you want to do any kind of raid for your OS/Apps drive, raid 1 (mirroring) would be preferable, but for "recreational use" it's basically overkill. Another thing that everyone will tell you is that true raid of any level isn't to be relied upon for data security... raid doesn't replace backups, and raid 0 (which really shouldn't be called raid because it's the exact opposite of redundant) is more than twice as bad as just a single drive, because not only are there 2 drives to fail, there is also the chance the controller the array is on can just decide to up and walk away.

That being said, in the 10 or so years that consumer level raid has been around, I’ve never had a disk walk away, or the controller tell me to get stuffed, so YMMV.


Bottom line:

Don’t bother.


EDIT: Raptors arn't loud, at least, I can't hear my 150gig making any noise over the regular air movement comming from the quiet fans I have in my case. Of course you can hear it when it's really thrashing, but I havn't noticed any difference between it and any other HD in my system. I actually prefer it's thrashing sound to the 750 Seagate in my Home Server.
 
Just go with a single drive and use a secondary drive as your dump drive for other non essential things.


Raid0 isn't going to do anything for you in desktop computing, it may actually slow down your system.
 
Awesome. Exactly the type of responses I was hoping for. Looks like I'll go with the WD6400AAKS 640GB version and, when the new raptors come out, move the OS to the raptor and keep this as storage.
 
Back
Top