Networking n00b question

OldBuzzard

Gawd
Joined
Jun 6, 2004
Messages
911
I'm getting ready to setup a newtwork for the house, but am not sure which hardware I'm going to need. Currently I'm on a 3M/1M ADSL connection with a Cisco 675 router.

From what I can find, I 'think' that I can use either the Linksys WRT54G Wireless-G Broadband Router, or the Linksys WAP54G Wireless-G Access Point.

I would like to have:

Desktop A 'hardwired' to the router/access point. This is my main system and I do a lot of online flight simming on it.
Desktop B wireless. This would be #1 son, and he does some online gaming.
Laptop A wireless. This is wife, and she does mostly email, and web surfing

Which of the above hardware would work best for what I want to do, and if both would work, what would be the Pros and Cons of each. I'm especially concerned on what impact that this would have on the online gaming.
 
Quick question about that cisco 675 and general questions about your internet
(we used to have 677's but phased them out)...

Can you already hook up multiple computers to that 675 and have it "work" ?
yes) Purchase the Access Point. The cisco 675 is already acting as a NAT router. Actually, purchase a 5/8/12/24/etc port switch and the AP. Plug switch into the 675, your desktop into switch, AP into switch, go to town.
no) Your 675 could be bridged with a static IP to your desktop. You need the Linksys WRT54G Wireless-G Broadband Router to have a shot at working.

2nd question if the first was answered with a "no"
Did you have to input special settings into your current computer to get it to work?
yes) Obtain those settings from your ISP and use those to set up the Linksys WRT54G Wireless-G Broadband Router.
no) plug Linksys WRT54G Wireless-G Broadband Router into the 675 and play. Might require a reboot of the cisco 675 first.

RAF_OldBuzzard said:
I'm especially concerned on what impact that this would have on the online gaming.

If you are the only one gaming, zero. You are still hardwired and you probably will not see one ms of difference. If someone is gaming across the wireless, they _might_ see 2 (yes 2ms) ping increase. The con's of the wireless for gaming is that unless you have good signal strength they might get connection dropouts. The ping difference is almost non existant as I cannot differentiate between a 75 or a 77 ping.
 
OK....the 675 will only run one system. No special settings required for it to work.

SO....it looks like I need the WRT54G Wireless-G Broadband Router.

Which means: Cisco 675 hard wired to the WRT54G.

Then:
Desktop A hardwired to the WRT54G.
Desktop B wireless to the WRT54G.
Laptop A wireless to the WRT54G.

Would this be correct?
 
When I install wireless for clients I always use the wrt54g, in whatever the current release is. For the price you can usually find a deal or rebate to make it comparable to just getting a wap. Except for when they put them next to the microwave or their cordless phones, I usually only need to service them when the clients reset all the security stuff and then cant connect. I hate to pimp a brand but I have found the linksys wrtg54g to be reliable in real life.

your wire setup is correct.
 
OHTAY....Picked one up at Best Buy. Had $30.00 worth of rebates on it :)

Now I'm running into a problem, and this is going to get REALLY complicated...I think.

I'm running HyperOS on Desktop A, and I have 12 seperate operating systems on it. 5x Win98SE, and 7x XP Pro SP2.

Laptop A is running Win98SE, and I currently have it HARDWIRED.

I ran the Linksys 'Setup Wizard' on one of the Desktop A XP partitions, and all went (apparently) well. .

I booted into each of the other XP systems, and set up the networking thru the Windows networking wizard. I make the setup diskette that they told me to make. To use for setting up 'non-XP systems"

I then used the Linksys 'wizard' on Laptop A. Again, all seemed to go well.

I then tried to run the 'setup diskette' on Laptop and got a 'program exception eror', and then a popup window saying that I didn't have authorization. :(

At this point Desktop A and Laptop A are happily sharing the net connection (and I've tried different XP partitions for Desktop A as well), but Laptop A can not 'see' anything on Desktop A.

I have yet to try setting up networking on any of the 98SE partitions on Desktop A.

It's obvious that it's harder setting up file/print sharing in 98SE than XP, and I'm now trying to find out if:
A. I really need to run the 'setup diskette', and,
B. How to setup 98SE for file/print sharing.

Edit:
I setup a 'sacrifical' 98SE partiton on Desktop A, and just ran 'netsetup.exe' from the diskette. I did not run the Linksys wizard first this time. Same thing happened as on the Laptop..
A. Got message: This program has performed an illegal operation and will be shutdown. If the problem persists contact the program vendor.
B: After clearing that, I got the "RESTRICTIONS" popup window and it said "This operation has been cancelled due to restrictions in effect on the computer. Please contact your system administrator."

As far as I can tell I AM logged on as the Admin (and was also on the laptop earlier), so this is somewhat puzzling.

Anyne have any ideas?
 
the networking should be ok... you are probly running into permission problems. Do youlog onto the WIN98 box with a password? Set it up so you log onto an account on the win98 box using a password. XP has tighter file sharing restrictions. Here is a helpful link.

Networking can be set up without using the linksys disk or the XP nertwork disk the wizard makes. In fact I prefer not to use them.
 
Well...Finally got all the XP partitions on Desktop A 'talking' to Laptop A, file/printer sharing is working, and all is well (almost) :) Sure would have been a bit faster if some dummy (who shall remain nameless, but whose initials are R_OB) would have remembered to set the workgroup name on the Lappy to the same as he was using on the Desktop OSs :eek:

It was late when I finally got it all the XP partitions working, so I haven't started on getting the 98 partitions working with the Lappy yet.

One thing I noticed is that my D/L speed has been cut roughly in 1/2, even when the Lappy isn't turned on. Any reason why this is?

I'll update later on this current battle of man vs. computer :D :D

Using HyperOS is great for managing multiple OSs, and all, but it sure makes doing something like this a lot more time consuming, since you have to make the same changes to each seperate OS. Good thing is that I can use a 'test' OS and if I bugger it up, it only takes 3-5 minutes to re-clone the original, and try again.
 
RAF_OldBuzzard said:
One thing I noticed is that my D/L speed has been cut roughly in 1/2, even when the Lappy isn't turned on. Any reason why this is?


Are the other machines turned on when you get the crummy d/l speeds? Have you unplugged all other devices from the network and tested speeds? Basically you will need to isolate the culprit.

Start with 1 machine hooked up via your network, test speeds. Add a single machine each time and re-test speeds. If the tests with 1 machine on the router show the crummy speeds, its probably the router and settings like duplex must be investigated (10Mbit half-duplex will kill throughput but above 3Mbit in my experience. If your internet speed is less than 3Mbit, duplex mismatches will be less likely). If the speeds crap out when you add machine X to the mix, then that points to a service on Machine X hogging the internet or otherwise occupying it. Check machine X for malware, spyware, trojans, virii, and most importantly, FILESHARING apps like bittorrent, etc.

Also with the addition of the wireless AP device you now have, be sure that you have changed the SSID (station name) and enable some sort of encryption to prevent the casual neighbor from leeching your wireless signal. This may or may not be an issue.

edit: check your download speeds with your ISP's tools (website, etc). Basically, publicly available bandwidth checking sites are notorious for false readings since they could be under load or your ISP could be bottlenecking or the ISP's upstream provider might be bottlenecking. Also, with DSL try a modem reboot. Unplug the power from the modem, wait 20 seconds, turn it back on. DSL is cool, but it sometimes needs a retrain.
 
I think I've isolated the problem to the WRT54G.

In my main XP partition which is networked, and in my main 98SE partition which I haven't setup yet, when I'm connected thru the WRT54G my speed test (from my ISP) is roughly 1/2 of what I expect it to be. This is with no other computer connected to the WRT54G.

I powered down, connected directly to the Cisco 675, and now the speed (in both partitions) is back up to what I am used to getting.

That tells me that it's the WRT54G.

Question at that point is: Is there a setting for the WRT54G that I'm overlooking, or don't know about ?
 
Fixed the D/L problem.

Upgraded the firmware :)

Firmware 1.00.4
- Resolves issues with slow downstream speeds ;)
- Resolves issues with certain web sites not loading or loading slowly
- Resolves issues with obtaining an IP address from Windows 2000 Server
- Resolves issues with certain Internet video streaming
- Resolves issues with playing PSP games online
 
Yup Cisco 675 ---> WRT54G ---> hardwired Desktop A & hardwired Laptop A.

I'll be changing that eventually to Hardwired Desktop A, wireless Desktop B and wireless Laptop A.
 
RAF_OldBuzzard said:
Yup Cisco 675 ---> WRT54G ---> hardwired Desktop A & hardwired Laptop A.

I'll be changing that eventually to Hardwired Desktop A, wireless Desktop B and wireless Laptop A.
Get rid of the Cisco 675. You're using two routers in series for no reason.
 
Doh, i missed the cisco, 2 routers on the network is a problem. Unless you are using the wrt543g as a wap/switch, NAT and dhcp shut off.
 
I'm not sure why you have the cisco router in the mix. But I would recommend putting a switch behind the router. Either do DHCP from the cisco to everything that is wired or do static addresses. I like static that way nobody can just plug into your equipment. Then plug your wan on the WRT into the switch so you aren't sending gaming stuff through two boxes.

I originally had a wireless linksys as my main interface to my ISP and then my ipcop box was behind that, web server behind that and man what a headache. I ran like that for a solid year before I couldn't stand the headache and just rewired the house(reason for the funky setup in the first place).

For my above solution to work, you'll need to turn on nat overload or something like that. It's been a while since I messed with nat on a cisco box.
 
RAF_OldBuzzard said:
Yup Cisco 675 ---> WRT54G ---> hardwired Desktop A & hardwired Laptop A.

I'll be changing that eventually to Hardwired Desktop A, wireless Desktop B and wireless Laptop A.

You should only go wireless if you have no other options. Wireless is a pain and it's slow. I would never have a wireless desktop, wire is too cheap.
 
Well, like I said, I'm by no means a networking guru. However after the firmware flash on the WRT54G, the download speeds are back to normal.

I'm pretty sure that the Cisco is acting as something of a firewall too, as I've checked at a security site, and I'm pretty will 'buttoned up' from outside probing & ect.

I'm definately going to be going wireless, as going wired will be a a problem.

LaptopA, is an OLD Toshiba with a P133 in it, and the local lappy store says that it can't go wireless anyway :( BUT, I have a co-worker that has an older Sony Vaio with a K6-III 550 in it. He offered it to me for $100.00 so I bought it, since the local lappy store wants 3-500 for lappys with pretty much the same specs. and another 50.00 for a wireless card for it. It won't replace LaptopA (now called Lappy386 :D ), but will be Laptop B. The big reason for this is that the wife has a geneology program that works with WIN98 but not with anything newer than that. So she can us the Lappy386 for that, and the Vaio for her major surfing research.

DesktopB will be #1 son's and he doesn't do any gaming that will require a fast connection.

Right now it all seems to be working well, so unless I run into any major problems, I think I'll leave my trusty old 675 in the mix.
 
I'm not convinced the 675 is running in router mode. It can run in router or bridged mode, but since it only worked on 1 system at a time, I'm not convinced its running in router mode.

Just my $0.02. I think ROB is cool with his setup.
 
Back
Top