Nehalem - Waiting Likely to Backfire?

Maybe Nehalem will be uber expensive at launch, maybe not. If this is accurate:

http://en.expreview.com/2008/06/10/intel-roadmap-update-nehalem-to-enter-mainstream-market/

...then we may see somewhat affordable Nehalem chips by the end of this year. It looks like in Q4 the 2.66 Nehalem will be taking the place of the Q9450, which is now selling for $329 at Newegg. Sure, that's not cheap, but it's nowhere near the $1k mark lots of people are saying it will be. Assuming the prices will stay approx. the same, that may be a decent option for some. Then again, paired with 3-6Gb of DDR3 with good timings and an X58 board (knowing how Intel chipsets run $-wise), it may be a different story.

Still, OP, if you've made it this far, you can probably wait another couple of months until some hard data regarding Nehalem performance comes out. At least, I hope we'll be seeing that in a few months time...

Look at the release timing on Penryn, and I bet it won't be that far off from how Nehalem plays out. The chip you're talking about IS NOT replacing the Q9450. That chip is being replaced by the Q9400. The non-extreme Nehalem will slot in ABOVE the Q9550 which is currently $550.

natermeister said:
I'm thinking that relatively affordable Nehalem chips will depend solely on intel's yields. If they have bad yields, you'll see a $1k Extreme chip for the desktop and Xeons ranging from affordable to ultra-expensive. If their yields are good, on the other hand, you'll probably see a couple speed bins on the desktop side and prices at roughly $350-$400 for the bottom bin. I'm just guessing here.

You're not even guessing. What are you basing this on? I'm willing to bet, just like C2D Intel will have no problem producing all the chips they need; they will price and manufacture chips based solely on market demand as they currently do. They are in no hurry to rush out a chip using a poor manufacturing process that won't give them profitable yields.

IMO, it won't be practical (in terms of price/performance/availability) to build a Nehalem system until well into 2Q '09. Nehalem is going to be expensive to begin with, and mainstream CPUs will take time to get here. You will likely save money by building a cheap rig now and upgrading around this time next year over waiting for Nehalem release and buying a bleeding edge computer.
 
IMO, it won't be practical (in terms of price/performance/availability) to build a Nehalem system until well into 2Q '09.
I agree. March 2009 is the target date for first mainstream systems. Wait until summer for newer processors and first price drops.
 
Look at the release timing on Penryn, and I bet it won't be that far off from how Nehalem plays out. The chip you're talking about IS NOT replacing the Q9450. That chip is being replaced by the Q9400. The non-extreme Nehalem will slot in ABOVE the Q9550 which is currently $550.

Not quite accurate; looking at the diagram, it looks like the lowest-end 2.66 GHz Bloomfield will be in the same slot as the Q9450 is in now, i.e.: $316. Keep in mind we're still in Q2 2008.

In Q3, the Q9450 will indeed be discontinued and be replaced...by the Q9550 at the same $316 price point. The Q9400 will be instead at the $266 price point replacing the Q9300 and Q6700 that are there now.

And finally, in Q4, the Q9400 and E8600 will occupy the $266 slot, and the Q9550 along with the 2.66 GHz Bloomfield will occupy the $316 slot. Now, if you want a 2.93 GHz Bloomfield at stock, be prepared to be around $550, but it looks like "upper mainstream" Nehalem will actually be here later this year at a reasonable price ($316). That said, I would count on retail price gauging unti at leastl Q1 2009, and I doubt the early motherboards will be cheap. So waiting until Q2 2009 for a Nehalem build might be smart regardless.

Past that, even Intel is guessing, as there are lots of greater-than-or-equal-to signs.
 
Look at the release timing on Penryn, and I bet it won't be that far off from how Nehalem plays out. The chip you're talking about IS NOT replacing the Q9450. That chip is being replaced by the Q9400. The non-extreme Nehalem will slot in ABOVE the Q9550 which is currently $550.

Huh? There are *two* non-extreme Nehalem chips on that diagram, and one does indeed occupy the $300-$330 slot. Farfromhome said it exactly right above. The real killer, pricewise, on the upgrade will most likely be an X58 board and 3-6Gb or DDR3. That's where people have been saving money now, and will be expecting, whether they know it or not, to do so on the Nehalem upgrade...but it probably won't happen. This is still speculation, of course, but I'd be surprised if it turned out to be otherwise.
 
It's called a Q9650 I believe.

Negative, that's just a plain Core 2 Quad, basically just like the QX9650 but multiplier-locked and half the price. Either Intel hasn't come up with the marketing name for Bloomfields yet, or they're good at not leaking it out (I would tend to believe the former). I would guess that the names will be much different than current Wolfdales/Kentsfields though.
 
Great responses all - thanks - still reading 'em and more and more sure about my decision to build soon (pretty much as soon as I decide on a video card...waiting for the dust to settle on this new gen).
 
Nehalem will almost certainly launch as the new $1K Extreme chip, so keep that in mind as well if you are thinking about being an early adopter. Your chances of getting a "value" Nehanlem system in the next 6 months are slim to none. I would say instead of getting an X48 board, just grab a cheap P35 or one of the new P45 boards, a Quad CPU, and 4GB of DDR2 800 for less than $400. That should definitely hold its value until Nehalem is mainstream, all of the kinks will be worked out, and you can buy a great price/performance setup.

I was told by forum members this is L33T [H] ard Web site

and people will less that 5k systems are not welcome here.... so price means nothing
 
I was told by forum members this is L33T [H] ard Web site

and people will less that 5k systems are not welcome here.... so price means nothing

I don't think you should let a website decide how much you spend on your system. Personally, I use it as inspiration to see what gear rocks, and how much the new cpu's oc. Of course, if you follow the recommendations, your system might soon cost you $5K :)
 
if your spend less than 500 on a vid card... then u are not [H]

u should goto anandtech forums

*** the above comment was satire .. and not an attempt to troll or derail the thread
 
I was told by forum members this is L33T [H] ard Web site

and people will less that 5k systems are not welcome here.... so price means nothing

No need to take the argument from the GTX 260/280 thread here, and play devil's advocate no less. The [H] is for anyone that finds it useful or interesting; let's leave it at that.
 
yea a proper troll indeed. wtf has that got to do with anything. this forum is not for people who spend over 5k on a system. what a retarded dumb thing to say
 
What I think about when some new technology is coming out, unless it's targeting the average customer like ATI's strategy right now, if you buy a mid range computer before it comes out, you can purchase the 2nd or 3rd generation of this new technology which will be more optimized, hopefully fixes performance glitches and stuff like that, and also, game technology won't benefit from the new processors until at you would probably upgrade anyway. Unless some company tries to redo what Crytek did and instead plan on new technology instead of creating for current technology. Crytek realized that they made a mistake however.
 
You know, I'd like to reiterate that I've gotten along just fine with dual core K8s since the summer of 2005. My CPU has survived all the new games I've thrown at it, survived a new version of Windows, and probably still has a lot of life left. When Nehalem comes out, CoD4/CS:S/yourgamehere won't suddenly decide your system is no longer worthy.
 
True. I think I'm just about decided on the safe bet (the known great stuff out now). Hoping to order in the next week or two.
 
surely the issues or bugs wont be has bad has people think when nehalem comes out?surely the best solution IF your so anxious to get nehalem straight away is to wait 2-3 weeks after its initial launch and find out what bugs/issues there are. at that time many if not all of the bugs should have been identified by them. heck i can bet a shit loads of money that within days of it being released we will know the issues and bugs from review sites such has [H].

if the bugs/issues are minor then its still worth upgrading to a nehalem system has that will last you 3 years at least without upgrading the mobo ram and possibly the cpu for gaming/general use. Intel have basicly got a working nehalem chip already produced. they have a shit load of time from now till end of the year to iron out the bugs and issues that may be related. dont forget, recent benchmarks on a VERY buggy mobo and i imagine, cpu shows 50% gain over the fastest quad core processor out now!. i imagine it being more faster when most bugs/issues have been resolved and could infact be nearly double the speed of todays top end quad core.

Yes it will cost you an arm and a leg to buy nehalem but once you go nehalem you wont have to upgrade for a couple of years at least FOR GAMING.

You can either buy a mid range pc now for £600 and a nehalem 2nd gen mid range for £700. here is the catch, both systems will cost you £1300. Now if you wait till jan next year and spend £1300 on one macine, it will last you the whole generation of nehalem.

Point is, weaver you wait for nehalem 1st gen or build now and build again for nehalem 2nd gen, it will still be the same price wrongly. In my case i have only one chance to build a decent pc because next year i am going to go into the property ladder and buy my own house and once that's done i wont have the funds to buy a new pc for a very long time hench i cannot afford to buy one now and then later on
 
First - I don't think anyone has asked this yet - what do you use your PC for? You mentioned work and gaming, but didn't get into specifics.

I tend to approach decisions like this the same way as any other decision with a definite time horizon. With fixed time horizons, define your current needs and minimize expenses - because you know you're going to have major changes at the time horizon. In your case, you want Nehalem. You might estimate your Nehalem purchase is 9-12 months away (once inventories and prices stabilize). So your time horizon is 9-12 months. What steps can you take now, to inexpensively satisfy your current needs, and ease the transition to your wants 9-12 months from now?

It's much easier to make purchase decisions when you define your needs. In a corporate environment, needs are very easily defined (we need redundancy in our servers, for example). It's a little more difficult for gaming systems, because our decisions are more influenced by wants.

In my case, I'm still running a single-core A64 in my gaming PC. Over the years, upgrading my video card (now a 8800GT) has always satisfied my needs better than starting over with a new platform.
 
WolfpupNX said:
Thanks for the great replies!

As to current specs - lol:
Pentium 4 Northwood 2.6 GHz (400 MHz FSB)
ASUS P4T-E Motherboard
1 GB RDRAM
GeForce 6800 Ultra AGP
Sound Blaster Audigy 2

Though it's been upgraded along the way, the core system, including mobo, is almost 7 years old. lol.

To be honest, I've been planning a pretty high-end build (DDR3 included and quad-core, possibly extreme), so I understand Nehalem will probably be only the highest end when it initially releases. Let's say for the moment that's fine - is it likely there are going to still be unanticipated problems and changes? (I do realize this question is somewhat unreasonable as it's asking to essentially predict the future...but I suppose I'm asking based on some expert experience over several chipset launches - I've never really been an early adopter before.)

Thanks again for the feedback! I've already come close to building and put this off...well...it's been over a year at this point I think. lol. And I realize I can't keep doing this forever.

Sure, Nehalem will be awesome. But then, should you go for 10x your current performance now or 15x next year? That's the question you need to ask yourself.
 
I'm personally waiting for more concrete numbers before I decide to make a dent in my wallet. And by then whats out now may be even cheaper or there could be something with a better performance/price ratio. Back in 2002 I took the plunge and spent top dollar on all new tech. The more I think about it I wasted a shitload of money for a minimal improvement in performance than what was already available at the time. Maybe 5-10% if that. Definitely didn't make me feel too good at all.
 
surely the issues or bugs wont be has bad has people think when nehalem comes out?surely the best solution IF your so anxious to get nehalem straight away is to wait 2-3 weeks after its initial launch and find out what bugs/issues there are. at that time many if not all of the bugs should have been identified by them. heck i can bet a shit loads of money that within days of it being released we will know the issues and bugs from review sites such has [H].
Tell that to the people who ran out and bought Phenoms and ended up with the infamous (perhaps even overhyped) Translation Lookaside Buffer bug.
 
You mean the one Kyle said had never been seen in standard desktop use?

http://www.hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1031824555&postcount=54

Perhaps. I will admit, I am not the most knowledgeable about these issues, and I haven't been around as long as some, but I don't remember a single error, such as being suggested here, in a mass produced CPU that was reason enough to avoid buying. Am I missing something?
 
A few points I'd like to make:

It was asked specifically what I'll use it for. I actually work from home, so a lot of that will be done - mostly using Office applications, bit of web editing, e-mail and Internet related stuff. I also want to play games (single player ones mostly) like Mass Effect, BioShock, Crysis (may wait on that for a video card that really plays it well on the highest settings), Assassin's Creed, & the upcoming Fallout 3 for example. (Oh how I wish they still made the mech and space sims I used to love with modern technology...) Also, I do a lot of personal web surfing, listen to music, work with video, burning of CD's/DVD's, etc.

All in all I use my PC a lot so I'd like a nice one. Reliability is also key as it's my main work. (Which is why, along with really wanting something now, I'm leaning towards the current gen - it doesn't usually look better than this.)

Finally, and probably my fault, I think I've given the impression that I'm worried about Nehalem being buggy as in a showstopper, which really isn't my concern as I doubt that'll happen. It's more the case that there's so much new going on with this next generation, I'm worried about socket changes (there's already supposed to be 3 different ones I guess) in addition to the risk of early revisions of motherboards being incompatible with future processors.

Thanks again for all the great comments!
 
im gunna use my pc for programing in java and c# desktp apps such has office 2007.

For gaming i want to play all the latest games in full detail maintaining 50-60fps at 1680x1050 for at least a year before a new gpu card is needed.

i also want to watch 1080p HD videos from my system and encode them to put them on dvd's.

can i my current system do the above? well i can use it for programing, watching SOME 720p videos and run office 2007 with no issues but the rest i cant do so.

For gaming i decided to buy a ps3 to keep my gaming needs occupied for another year untill i am ready to build a new pc capable of running the latest pc games
 
You mean the one Kyle said had never been seen in standard desktop use?

http://www.hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1031824555&postcount=54

Perhaps. I will admit, I am not the most knowledgeable about these issues, and I haven't been around as long as some, but I don't remember a single error, such as being suggested here, in a mass produced CPU that was reason enough to avoid buying. Am I missing something?

You mean the one that some reviewers have found in their standard testing? And a type of bug that may not happen for many desktop users not buy could get triggered by new software at anytime? And the bug that gets fixed with Vista SP1 and gimp's people performance and they rarely even realize it, and when they do realize it, they gotta download third party apps just to fix it?
 
I'm with many of the guys here. If you have the money go ahead and build now. Computers parts at the moment are dirt cheap, so it's a great time to build a system. You can't keep waiting for whatever else is coming out because you'll hear about all the new things that's expected after Nehalem comes out. Yeah, its going to be faster than current stuff, but unless you're doing some benchmarking or just for e-penis bragging rights there is no reason not to go ahead and build a system now. You can now build systems that run Crysis beautifully and every other game maxxed out. Just do it and ditch that old computer. :D
 
Back
Top