needs more MUXes

matman

n00b
Joined
May 30, 2013
Messages
59
I'm slightly frustrated by the lack of motherboards with what I consider to be a sensible mix of features. There are only so many ways you can weave the various IOs supplied by the CPU and chipset. My preference is to avoid crowding the motherboard with additional SATA and USB3 controllers that add hardware and driver complexity and are a poor second in performance to the stock controllers anyway.

MUX chips are used on a lot of midrange boards to allow switching PCIe slots between x16/x0 and x8/x8 modes. I'd love to see more inventive use of MUX chips as seen for example on the ASRock Z87E-ITX. It has a full six SATA 6G ports for internal drives (hello NAS box :) and it also has an eSATA port on the rear and an mSATA slot. It makes 8 SATA interfaces available from the total of 6 available from the chipset by rerouting ports 4 and 5 if an eSATA or mSATA device is connected.

Sometime soon I'd like to see a board with a proper m.2 (NGFF) key M support. Using a MUX it could have a BIOS option to run PCIe 3.0 x4 to the m.2 using the CPU's x8/x4/x4 mode or alternatively switch to PCIe 2.0 x4 from the chipset.
 
You are confusing multiplexing and switching.

It seems you're the confused one. In these types of applications multiplex chips are used to switch the signal from one output to the other. You've confused multiplexing with using a multiplexer as a switch. An easy mistake. Multiplexer and Multiplexing are two separate Wikipedia articles for good reason.

Perhaps I could have been clearer in explaining that the mux switches one port off to enable the other.
 
You're spot on. This has nothing to do with multiplexing except that MUX chips can also be used for multiplexing. I'll see if I can help you out here. Firstly, have a look at the two Wikipedia links I shared. I am not talking at all about multiplexing. I am talking about using a multiplexer as a to statically reroute (switch) a signal path.

An easily visible example:
line.jpg


Observe the small rectangular chips between the first two x16 slots. These are MUX chips and their purpose is to switch 8 lanes from the first x16 slot to the second. This provides a full x16 slot or 2 x8 slots. Observe the complete absence of multiplexing in this application of MUX chips.

The 'switches' that you refer to are MUX chips that switch based on presence of a device in the eSATA or mSATA ports.
 
Back
Top