Need upgrading for cheap advice.

narsbars

2[H]4U
2FA
Joined
Jan 18, 2006
Messages
3,357
Current, 570, 64gig 3600, 5900x, Vid 3070. Conditions, no OC beyond PBO, I game but limited by the 3070. I have an unused Peerless assassin 120 so my cooling is no problem. I can't afford new vid card. Can I find a used AMD MB, CPU and Mem that would be a noticeable upgrade at or under $300.00? No question of selling the old stuff, wife will inherit to replace her 16 gig, and 3600XT. I won't get chump change for those so it doesn't matter. I haven't been in the market for a few years so I have no idea if anything used would be available, or would make much of an upgrade except on paper.
 
If you can find an used 5700x3d on the cheaper side (https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_fr...=NVIDIA+L40&_osacat=0&LH_Complete=1&LH_Sold=1) there one that went for $130, it seem..... that could make it possible at the ~$250 price tag, but they often go around $180 which could with a $70 matx mobo + $50 ram kit fit before tax, easier if you still go 16GB.

That should be the cheapest CPU road (ddr4-b550 that can be find on the quite cheap by now) that would be an upgrade in game over a 5900x but nothing that special outside the Flight simulator type title that benefit from the extra cache a lot...

Average-p.jpg


at 1080p with a massive 4090 in those 10 games in average average and 1% min got 17%-20% faster from a 5800x.
 
Last edited:
As an eBay Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
If you can find an used 5700x3d on the cheaper side (https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_fr...=NVIDIA+L40&_osacat=0&LH_Complete=1&LH_Sold=1) there one that went for $130, it seem..... that could make it possible at the ~$250 price tag, but they often go around $180 which could with a $70 matx mobo + $50 ram kit fit before tax, easier if you still go 16GB.

That should be the cheapest CPU road (ddr4-b550 that can be find on the quite cheap by now) that would be an upgrade in game over a 5900x but nothing that special outside the Flight simulator type title that benefit from the extra cache a lot...

View attachment 670635

at 1080p with a massive 4090 in those 10 games in average average and 1% min got 17%-20% faster from a 5800x.
Thanks for the graph. Doesn't look like much of an overall boost is in my price range.
 
As an eBay Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
So I'm trying to decipher OP's post, am I to read that he has an X570 motherboard with 64GB of DDR4 3600, a 5900X and an RTX 3070? And he's trying to pass the combo over to his wife and keep the GPU?

I don't think much can be done for $300, certainly nothing would be faster than what he has because the limiting factor is already the GPU. Can we get some actual specs? Like what motherboard is the wife using? Might be cheaper just to get her a 5700X3D and better RAM if the board supports it which can easily be done for that budget.
 
If you can find an used 5700x3d on the cheaper side (https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_fr...=NVIDIA+L40&_osacat=0&LH_Complete=1&LH_Sold=1) there one that went for $130, it seem..... that could make it possible at the ~$250 price tag, but they often go around $180 which could with a $70 matx mobo + $50 ram kit fit before tax, easier if you still go 16GB.

That should be the cheapest CPU road (ddr4-b550 that can be find on the quite cheap by now) that would be an upgrade in game over a 5900x but nothing that special outside the Flight simulator type title that benefit from the extra cache a lot...

View attachment 670635

at 1080p with a massive 4090 in those 10 games in average average and 1% min got 17%-20% faster from a 5800x.
Can you post graphs with 1440p and 4k with the 4090. the above graph just shows cpu bottleneck speeds.
I have a similar system to the OP but with a 3080Ti with a 3440x1440p monitor and it games great. Maybe grab a used 3080Ti and give your wife the 3070 maybe? you didn't mention what GPU she has.
 
As an eBay Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
So I'm trying to decipher OP's post, am I to read that he has an X570 motherboard with 64GB of DDR4 3600, a 5900X and an RTX 3070? And he's trying to pass the combo over to his wife and keep the GPU?

I don't think much can be done for $300, certainly nothing would be faster than what he has because the limiting factor is already the GPU. Can we get some actual specs? Like what motherboard is the wife using? Might be cheaper just to get her a 5700X3D and better RAM if the board supports it which can easily be done for that budget.
Yeah, I'm also trying to get it figured out...


System #1
mobo=x570
cpu=5900x
ram=64gb
gpu=3070
resolution=?
used for some games.


System #2
mobo=??
cpu=3600xt
ram=16gb
gpu=??
resolution=?
used for??
 
Current, 570, 64gig 3600, 5900x, Vid 3070. Conditions, no OC beyond PBO, I game but limited by the 3070. I have an unused Peerless assassin 120 so my cooling is no problem. I can't afford new vid card. Can I find a used AMD MB, CPU and Mem that would be a noticeable upgrade at or under $300.00? No question of selling the old stuff, wife will inherit to replace her 16 gig, and 3600XT. I won't get chump change for those so it doesn't matter. I haven't been in the market for a few years so I have no idea if anything used would be available, or would make much of an upgrade except on paper.
Microcenter bundle new
https://www.microcenter.com/product...l-flare-16gb-ddr5-6000,-computer-build-bundle
 
Doesn't seem like OP needs an upgrade....
I mean.. X570, 5900x, 64gb DDR4 and RTX 3070 is still a fairly loaded system.
$300 doesn't get you much, if the idea floating around in your head is to upgrade... Seems like a waste of $300

IF anything.. use the $300 to upgrade the wife's system .. if it is indeed a 3600xt w/ 16gb system memory..
 
saw that, though of posting it, but would that really be an upgrade though? half the cores, 1/4 of the ram....
I put it up there too since it was new not used gear, some play the advert propaganda game i.e. 7xxx better than 5xxx CPU etc. DDR 5 vs DDR4 too.
 
One possible way to go

Used/new 5700x3D or 5800x3D
5900x into wife 3600xt (outside the rare scenario that the mobo support 3xxx but not 5xxx, maybe that exist I am not sure)
add 16GB of ram in that machine if ram can be an issue.

Relatively side upgrade in both case, depending on what you do (for some games can be and if the otyher computer can use more than 6 cores -16gb of ram can be nice)
 
So I'm trying to decipher OP's post, am I to read that he has an X570 motherboard with 64GB of DDR4 3600, a 5900X and an RTX 3070? And he's trying to pass the combo over to his wife and keep the GPU?

I don't think much can be done for $300, certainly nothing would be faster than what he has because the limiting factor is already the GPU. Can we get some actual specs? Like what motherboard is the wife using? Might be cheaper just to get her a 5700X3D and better RAM if the board supports it which can easily be done for that budget.
He is just late to the ball game, I got a b650 / 7600x /Starfield combo for $289.
 
One possible way to go

Used/new 5700x3D or 5800x3D
5900x into wife 3600xt (outside the rare scenario that the mobo support 3xxx but not 5xxx, maybe that exist I am not sure)
add 16GB of ram in that machine if ram can be an issue.

Relatively side upgrade in both case, depending on what you do (for some games can be and if the other computer can use more than 6 cores -16gb of ram can be nice)
My wife's MB can handle 5900 and will take the 64gig from mine. She does no gaming on hers. I realize the CPU limitation but a (used) 670 or 670E which is probably out of even dreaming range would give me some long term expansion range.
 
but a (used) 670 or 670E which is probably out of even dreaming range would give me some long term expansion range.
At this day with your situation (on a 5900x), I would consider waiting for the x870 to come out, late September, bunch of new boards maybe they are better, bunch of used x670e getting on the used market... well obviously the wait for what upcoming game is never ending, but I am not sure how much of a nice update at that price point you have right now, specially if you go 64gig or more of DDR5.
 
At this day with your situation (on a 5900x), I would consider waiting for the x870 to come out, late September, bunch of new boards maybe they are better, bunch of used x670e getting on the used market... well obviously the wait for what upcoming game is never ending, but I am not sure how much of a nice update at that price point you have right now, specially if you go 64gig or more of DDR5.
I wasn't thinking about the X870 at all...........thanks. Same strategy I will be following to pick up a 4070 or 4070TI in a few months. Even now I can get one for less than a well used 3090 and get better performance.
 
Back
Top