Need suggestions on 4220 hardware ...

young_einstein

Weaksauce
2FA
Joined
Jun 20, 2010
Messages
102
Hey guys,

I've been reading these forums like crazy for the last week or so, but now I'm at the point where I need to ask some questions and try and get a little bit of help from some of you.

Long story short I'm just starting to build a DIY file server / NAS, and I'm after a little bit of help/advice on the best hardware to try and meet some of my goals.

I've used plenty of 'off the shelf' NAS devices before, but this is my first time building one from scratch, so apologies if I miss out or say anything stupid!

I'm figuring out all this as I go along! ;)

Here's the story so far:

* I've got a Norco 4220 chassis on the way, which I want to use for 2 x RAID6 @ 10 disks each.
* It's a dedicated file / media server, so I really don't need anything super powerful in terms of CPU etc. [What sort of CPU speeds do you think I can get away with, without compromising the RAID performance too much?]
* I'd like to make sure that the drives can do a staggered startup, and also make sure that they can spin down / sleep when they're not being used.
* I want some good quality RAID cards, preferably taking advantage of the miniSAS ports on the 4220.
* Cost isn't an issue ... I'm more than happy to pay for good quality equipment ... but it DOES actually have to be WORTH the money!


So ... over to you guys then.

Is there anything you can suggest / recommend which might help me on my way a little bit?

Much appreciated! :)

--David
 
You are about to take a specific course: hardware RAID.

Before you commit to this and spend a lot of money, please think about your future upgrade path. If you ever want ZFS, your hardware controller is useless, your 32-bit CPU is useless, your PCI interfaces useless, your RAID edition harddrives useless (disable TLER/CCTL).

You can adjust your configuration so you can swap to a ZFS setup in the future; by chosing a 64-bit CPU with enough memory, and making sure no PCI bus is used for anything; onboard SATA is highest performance possible; PCIe SATA controller is next.
 
I've done a fair amount of reading on ZFS in the last couple of weeks, and I've certainly given it some thought, but I'm still not entirely convinced that it's my cup of tea just at the moment.

It's something that I'd certainly like to play around with when I get a chance, but I'm a bit of a hurry to get this build up and running - since my latest NAS is rapidly running out of space - and good old fashioned RAID is whit I'm most familiar with right now.
 
Alright, but my suggestion was that you change some of your plans so you can do both: have conventional RAID now and switch to ZFS in the future. Ultimately i think that's a better choice.

It would mean you buy a HBA-capable SATA/SAS controller, such as the SuperMicro USAS-L8i (Intel has a comparable controller with normal form factor).

If you want RAID6, you could use md-raid6 (software RAID) instead. That means still a conventional RAID setup, but fully able to run ZFS in the future.

If you really don't want to prepare for ZFS, then buy a hardware RAID controller, 32-bit atom cpu and 1GB RAM and let it run windows. But you better not change your mind in the future about ZFS because then your hardware will not be suitable. And hardware RAID is getting obsolete very quickly as well.
 
Back
Top