Need some Opnions . . .

IeU

n00b
Joined
Oct 20, 2004
Messages
48
Hi ppl . . .

im going to buy a new pc . . .

and after a lot of research and reviews reading and and and PRICE . . .

i got this, and im going to buy it in 1-2 weeks.

Code:
Processor – 
   - AMD Athlon 64 3000+ (Boxed, OPGA, "Winchester")

Heatsink and Fan – 
   - Included 

Motherboard – 
   - Asus A8N-SLI Deluxe (Sound, 2x G-LAN, FW, 2x SATA RAID)

Hard Drive – 
   - Maxtor 6B250S0 (Kapazität 250GB , Cache 16MB)

Memory – 
   - Kingston HyperX DIMM 1 GB (DDR400, 2x512MB, KHX3200ULK2/1G)

Video Card – 
   - Leadtek WinFast PX6600 GT TDH (Retail, TV-Out, DVI)

Sound Card – 
   - Creative SoundBlaster Live! 24BIT (Retail)

DVD-RW Drive –
   - NEC ND-3500A (Bulk, 16fach DVD brennen, schwarz)

Network – 
   - Included

Case – 
   - Chieftec Big Tower DA-01BLD ATX, blau-metallic, ohne Netzteil

Power Supply - 
   - Fortron FSP-60THNP 400 Watt (ATX12V 2.0, leiser 120 mm Lüfter)

k u guys know my question . . .

ive seen a lot of people with problems with the MOBO :
Asus A8N-SLI Deluxe (Sound, 2x G-LAN, FW, 2x SATA RAID)

so in my config, am i going to have problems ?
is it a good choice ? ( performace/possible upgrades in the future )

if not, which would be the another good option to an AMD-Proc ?
 
IeU said:
Hi ppl . . .

im going to buy a new pc . . .

and after a lot of research and reviews reading and and and PRICE . . .

i got this, and im going to buy it in 1-2 weeks.

Code:
Processor – 
   - AMD Athlon 64 3000+ (Boxed, OPGA, "Winchester")

Heatsink and Fan – 
   - Included 

Motherboard – 
   - Asus A8N-SLI Deluxe (Sound, 2x G-LAN, FW, 2x SATA RAID)

Hard Drive – 
   - Maxtor 6B250S0 (Kapazität 250GB , Cache 16MB)

Memory – 
   - Kingston HyperX DIMM 1 GB (DDR400, 2x512MB, KHX3200ULK2/1G)

Video Card – 
   - Leadtek WinFast PX6600 GT TDH (Retail, TV-Out, DVI)

Sound Card – 
   - Creative SoundBlaster Live! 24BIT (Retail)

DVD-RW Drive –
   - NEC ND-3500A (Bulk, 16fach DVD brennen, schwarz)

Network – 
   - Included

Case – 
   - Chieftec Big Tower DA-01BLD ATX, blau-metallic, ohne Netzteil

Power Supply - 
   - Fortron FSP-60THNP 400 Watt (ATX12V 2.0, leiser 120 mm Lüfter)

k u guys know my question . . .

ive seen a lot of people with problems with the MOBO :
Asus A8N-SLI Deluxe (Sound, 2x G-LAN, FW, 2x SATA RAID)

so in my config, am i going to have problems ?
is it a good choice ? ( performace/possible upgrades in the future )

if not, which would be the another good option to an AMD-Proc ?

Okay, I'm going to answer this in a kind of odd way.

I have that motherboard. It does have it's quirks, but they can be worked around.

I do see two major problems with your build though, one I would change, one I'd consider changing.

1) Don't get that hard drive! The Maxtor with 16mb cache is going to be a SATA NCQ drive. The ASUS A8N-SLI Deluxe has a lot of problems with NCQ drives, especially the Maxtor. I know, I had two Maxtor 250gb w/16mb cache drives, and with any BIOS past 1002, they would literally get dropped by the NVidia SATA ports so that they would no longer be seen. Even with BIOS 1002, one couldn't actually use NCQ in Windows without getting massive data corruption apparently, I never tried turning it on. If you stick with the ASUS A8N-SLI Deluxe, get any hard drive that doesn't use NCQ, you can always get one with NCQ later when they work the bugs out a bit more.

2) You only have 1 graphics card, a 6600GT, so you're powersupply is probably okay for now...but if you go 2 video cards, especially if you got for 6800 GT's or Ultras in the future, you'll want closer to 500 watts and IMO at least 30 amps on the 12 volt rail. MAKE sure the power supply is 24 pin on the main motherboard connector also, a 20 pin will possibly have problems even if it has the wattage to power you system. So...unless you know you're not going to go two video cards, or figure you can get a new power supply if you go with two video cards later, get a bit higher wattage PSU in a brand you trust.


Now as for the motherboard, I'll give you a list of known issues that I encountered:

1) Poor overclocker with BIOS 1002, but any newer BIOS (so far) then 1002 rejects NCQ drives, especially Maxtor NCQ drives.

2) Chipset fan on the northbridge is kind of weak, mine might be going out, others suspect it is also, I've ordered in a replacement heatsink/fan for my northbridge chip just in case.

3) Only seen two posts, but POSSIBLY this board has some problems with IDE hard drives too, but one guy might have solved his problem by changing around the jumper settings on his hard drive, so this might not be a real issue.

4) This motherboard is a power hog, as stated above you'll want a hefty power supply. Seen a lot of people with PC Power & Cooling and OCZ power supplies have good luck, especially the PC Power & Cooling 510 SLI and the OCZ units with 520 watts and more. I think some people using the Antec Neopower 480 have done well with it also.

There's other minor issues, but that's it for the major ones that I've hit personally, or in the case of #3 seen posted here.

The Gigabyte SLI board has JUST come out, haven't seen a lot of posts, praise or complaints on it, so don't know one way or another. One flaw I have seen is that the memory sits very close together, anything with heat spreaders is almost touching. The MSI K8N Neo 4 Platinum (might be called K8N Diamond in Europe) JUST came out here in the USA, probably a good board but too new to see any posts. If you just want to use one video card and don't care about SLI, there's are boards by Chaintech and MSI that have been out for a tiny bit, (I don't like Chaintech but I know a few people who do), and Gigabyte has some single slot boards, although stay away from the NForce 4x chipset one, it's a very stripped down version, go NForce 4 Ultra for single slot chipset, NForce 4 SLI is the only dual slot chipset.

Oh, the DFI boards should be good, even the DFI NForce 4 Ultra is dual slot and can run in something somewhat like SLI despite not being a true SLI board, and they have two SLI boards coming out soon, probably early Febuary...seen a reseller in North America clain Feb 5th for instance.
 
fwiw thanks alot for that post arvig, you just answered alot of my questions i've had on a similar setup.... I've been searching this forum for hours and using the search feature everyone is so up tight about.....everytime i search and find a question I have its some ass saying "USE THE SEARCH" and doesnt answer my questions.....which imo renders the search button useless....

/rant off
 
CynicX said:
fwiw thanks alot for that post arvig, you just answered alot of my questions i've had on a similar setup.... I've been searching this forum for hours and using the search feature everyone is so up tight about.....everytime i search and find a question I have its some ass saying "USE THE SEARCH" and doesnt answer my questions.....which imo renders the search button useless....

/rant off

Hey, not a problem. :)

For an update, I ended up dumping my ASUS board for the MSI K8N Neo 4 Platinum SLI. MUCH more stable board. Only minor quirks I've seen:

1) This didn't happen to me since my power supply is okay, but if you get the MSI make sure your 24 pin motherboard connector has a -5 volt wire. Should be pin 20. I think all 20 pin connectors already have this wire. Some 24 pins don't. On every PSU I've seen that has the wire (including mine), the wire is either white, or in the case of mine, black with a white stripe running down the length.

EDIT: Reason you need the -5 volt wire in the connector is for the Creative Labs onboard sound chip on the MSI SLI boards. The MSI Ultra boards just use an AC/97 sound chip like most everyone else, so not needed for them, and of course if using a PCI sound card you won't need it. So only worry about it if you're going to use onboard sound on a MSI SLI board. (END EDIT)

2) Had a 7-1 Mitsumi card reader/floppy combo drive that connected to an internal USB header. With it connected it caused Windows to lock up right before the splash screen literally every other time. No idea why, the card reader worked on my ASUS, and even the board that was replaced by my ASUS, a MSI NForce 3 board. So, went back to a normal floppy (I installed a RAID 0 array so needed it) and figured even Wal-Mart has cheap external Compact Flash card readers that plug into a USB port. ;) Best of my knowledge I'm the only one who's had a problem like that, so could be just an odd quirk with my card reader, or it needs a firmware update or something else. Did test it on other internal USB headers, and all the headers with normal internal USB plugs, so I know it's not the header it was plugged into. It would read my Compact Flash memory, just did that weird lockup. Oh well.

Haven't seen or heard of any minor quirks with the DFI SLI board, but also haven't looked nearly as much since I've had the MSI and been perfectly stable other then item #2 above...guess I do less research when I'm happy with everything. ;)
 
U might want to up to a 3200+ to get a multi more...

And also have a look at the DFI nF4 mobos. If so Id look into other RAM as well the DFI MoBos seem to work VERY well with TCCD modules.
 
Back
Top