Need some input

fogcutter

n00b
Joined
Feb 25, 2005
Messages
3
Hey gang,

New to the boards so be gentle ;)

I'm building a companion rig to set up next to my gaming rig. I'm going to use it for mostly playing DVD and watching TV while I play/work on my other rig.

I'm sort of on a budget but I don't mind paying for quality and since this is the only hobby I spend money on I don't get too much grief from the spousal unit as well.

My plan:

Generic case - will be mostly out of sight.
Asus A8N SLI
AMD64 3500
ATI ALL IN WONDER X600 PCI 256meg
1024 3200 ram

I'm getting this board mainly for its upgradability. I need some adivce on PSU though.
Is this a good enough rig for what I intend? I'm thinking it might be a little overkill since the CPU is actually faster than my gaming rig but I have a better video card.
Any suggestions?
 
fogcutter said:
Hey gang,

New to the boards so be gentle ;)

I'm building a companion rig to set up next to my gaming rig. I'm going to use it for mostly playing DVD and watching TV while I play/work on my other rig.

I'm sort of on a budget but I don't mind paying for quality and since this is the only hobby I spend money on I don't get too much grief from the spousal unit as well.

My plan:

Generic case - will be mostly out of sight.
Asus A8N SLI
AMD64 3500
ATI ALL IN WONDER X600 PCI 256meg
1024 3200 ram

I'm getting this board mainly for its upgradability. I need some adivce on PSU though.
Is this a good enough rig for what I intend? I'm thinking it might be a little overkill since the CPU is actually faster than my gaming rig but I have a better video card.
Any suggestions?


I personally think this is overkill for watching movies and TV. I would think about going with an AMD 3000+ which can overclock to 3500+ speeds with no problem, and then spend the difference on a better video card. I would also suggest at least an Antec case, they are a little more expensive, but you at least get a decent power supply with them.

That's my .02 cents,

Novensu
 
Novensu said:
I personally think this is overkill for watching movies and TV. I would think about going with an AMD 3000+ which can overclock to 3500+ speeds with no problem, and then spend the difference on a better video card. I would also suggest at least an Antec case, they are a little more expensive, but you at least get a decent power supply with them.

That's my .02 cents,

Novensu


Kind of agree, motherboard is overkill if you going one video card, let alone ATI, unless something really changes, SLI on the NForce 4 chipsets are NVidia card only. You can find some decent NForce 4 Ultra chipset boards out there already that are a bit less expensive, yet still have decent features.

IMO the Antec case idea is good. Since this will be for DVD's, will it also be in a living room? Something like an Antec Sonata (mid-tower) or Antec Overture (desktop case) would maybe be good, each have a decent quality 380 watt PSU. They are 20 pin PSU's, but a 20 pin will work with a PCI-E board, they fit into the connector, worst case you may need a 20 to 24 pin adapter plug. Antec Super Lanboy is IMO kind of a decent little case too, small and light, you'll need to get a PSU though.

I'm tired, but that's my semi-quick suggestion. If I think of more, I may edit the post, or may check tomorrow and add to it or something. ;)
 
Thanks for the replies....those are all valid points. My thinking was/is that I wanted that board because I could later convert it into my gaming when I can afford twin BFGs or similiar video cards. I want to buy a board that's at least 939 pin to be able to upgrade.

I'm not a big fan of converters so I'm definitely going to by a serparate power supply with a 24 pin connecter. Any suggestions on a not-too-noisy unit for around $100?

That ATI card is about perfect for what I want it to do and the price is low enough to make it reasonable. This is going to be my DVR as well.

I guess my last concern is the CPU. I've priced the 3500 at around $275. Do y'all think I can get the power I need from a 3000? I guess since this is not an exclusive gaming rig I can save some money on some cheaper ram as well.
 
I have overclocked my 3000+ to 2.34Ghz. It is rock solid and still stays cool, and to boot you can pick up a retail one for around $150.00.

Novensu
 
ok...after further review....I decided on a different MOBO....the ABIT AV8 3rd Eye...

It prices out at around $150.....the AN8 SLI can be bought for $177 at Zipzoomfly so wouldn't just make more sense to spend the extra $25 or so on the overkill MOBO?
 
Back
Top