Need Rock Solid, No OC, just stability

narsbars

2[H]4U
2FA
Joined
Jan 18, 2006
Messages
3,357
I can build a PC for my job and the last one, a Dell XPS 600 has been on for about five years but is now a complete dog.
What do you think would be a good buy for something to just run, run, run? Need basic RAID, 64 bit OS, great temperature control and no BSOD due to temperamental hardware.
Feel free to chip in on the suggested HDs to match. I will only need max 750 Gig as I have not completely, filled up the 160 yet.
I bring in my old stuff from home to upgrade the pc at work over time and this one is now running an old 4850, 8 gig of 6400 and of course the DVD drive is new. You can't upgrade a Dell on the inside so it is time for to go become a media server somewhere.
 
IIRC Intel boards have been the most reliable but they don't offer very good overclocking, which would be perfect for you.
 
IIRC Intel boards have been the most reliable but they don't offer very good overclocking, which would be perfect for you.

That they do. They aren't the most feature rich solutions I've ever seen, but they are solid and everything on them works well. Stability is number 1 with those things. Some models do offer some bare bones overclocking, but never anything hardcore. Usually they are cheaper than alternatives from ASUS, DFI, etc. as well.
 
They aren't the most feature rich solutions I've ever seen, but they are solid and everything on them works well.

Well, yeah, but hey. I'll take the onboard Intel NIC over the shitty VIA FireWire, dual Yukon NICs, etc. of their competitors!
 
The only Intel board I've built a system with (a DAS for work) was a DP35DP. Personally, I thought it was crap... took a lot of fidding with BIOS options for proper operation with good performance. Interestingly, it was very picky with memory, of all things...

Personally, I'd take a good workstation board built by Supermicro or Tyan over the (usually) Foxconn or Pegatron built Intel stuff. Both companies were packing their boards with solid-state caps, MOSFET coolers, and other stability-enhancing goodies for their mid-range and high-end boards while everyone else was going cut-rate... yes, even Intel. Workstation boards are the "nuke it from orbit" solutions - they're the only way to be sure. ;) I'm sure ASUS makes dynamite WS boards, too, but I've never been hands-on with them, so I don't have any experience to rely about them.

I've got a dual-Opteron BOXX system built with a Tyan board that I wouldn't dream of ever getting rid of. It's just simply never done anything wrong, and it's a machine that's had a very, very long and hard 6 years so far (computational fluid dynamics, 24/7 essentially) and never missed a beat unless our Aero Thermal guys would blow something up on the OS (Linux) or CFD (Fluent) side of things. Hardware-wise, that machine is a tank, and I've no doubt 95% of run-of-the-mill PC motherboards or OEM machines would have faltered at some point, if even for little things.
 
The only Intel board I've built a system with (a DAS for work) was a DP35DP. Personally, I thought it was crap... took a lot of fidding with BIOS options for proper operation with good performance. Interestingly, it was very picky with memory, of all things...

Personally, I'd take a good workstation board built by Supermicro or Tyan over the (usually) Foxconn or Pegatron built Intel stuff. Both companies were packing their boards with solid-state caps, MOSFET coolers, and other stability-enhancing goodies for their mid-range and high-end boards while everyone else was going cut-rate... yes, even Intel. Workstation boards are the "nuke it from orbit" solutions - they're the only way to be sure. ;) I'm sure ASUS makes dynamite WS boards, too, but I've never been hands-on with them, so I don't have any experience to rely about them.

I've got a dual-Opteron BOXX system built with a Tyan board that I wouldn't dream of ever getting rid of. It's just simply never done anything wrong, and it's a machine that's had a very, very long and hard 6 years so far (computational fluid dynamics, 24/7 essentially) and never missed a beat unless our Aero Thermal guys would blow something up on the OS (Linux) or CFD (Fluent) side of things. Hardware-wise, that machine is a tank, and I've no doubt 95% of run-of-the-mill PC motherboards or OEM machines would have faltered at some point, if even for little things.

The word "good" and "Tyan" should never be used together. They are crap. Their boards used to be good and somehow they survive on a reputation that they built over a decade ago that they haven't deserved since. Supermicro makes damned good stuff and outside of Intel boards, they are my preferred server board brand. Usually I prefer them over Intel or ASUS offerings. ASUS does make some good workstation boards, but really their designs seem to be modified gamer/enthusiast boards. This is sometimes good or bad depending on how you look at it.

As for the Intel DP35P, it was never meant to be a serious workstation board. It is more geared toward HTPC and desktop use in the OEM markets. I had one in my HTPC and it worked flawlessly. No issues with memory or anything else.

Well, yeah, but hey. I'll take the onboard Intel NIC over the shitty VIA FireWire, dual Yukon NICs, etc. of their competitors!

Agreed.
 
The word "good" and "Tyan" should never be used together. They are crap. Their boards used to be good and somehow they survive on a reputation that they built over a decade ago that they haven't deserved since.

That's interesting. I was actually looking at some older (P2, P3 era) boards and there are quite a few Tyan boards for decent prices. Up until what point was Tyan considered decent?
 
I built my first new system (K6 when they first dropped) with a Tyan board and it was amazing. Loved that board. Even as a kid I knew the one thing I should never skimp on was good mobo. The one thing I didn't know was that I needed to put the motherboard on spacers. It actually booted and ran for a while, and even after it died, it was still brought back to life by installing it properly. Long live Tyan, Tyan is dead.

I vote for Gigabyte. Most people have found the 'Ultra Durable' remark to be spot on.
 
The word "good" and "Tyan" should never be used together. They are crap. Their boards used to be good and somehow they survive on a reputation that they built over a decade ago that they haven't deserved since. Supermicro makes damned good stuff and outside of Intel boards, they are my preferred server board brand. Usually I prefer them over Intel or ASUS offerings. ASUS does make some good workstation boards, but really their designs seem to be modified gamer/enthusiast boards. This is sometimes good or bad depending on how you look at it.

Agreed. I build several 1 and 2 U servers using tyan boards, I forget the model but they were s478 and cost a pretty penny, EVERY single one of them died. The loops that the northbridge heatsink retainer clips hook on to popped out of several of the boards, causing the NB to fry, and the others just started locking up randomly and then stopped working altogether after wards.

As for the OP, Intel manufactured board sounds like what you're looking for.
 
I just wish Intel made a 6 memory slot Core i7 board. I'm seriously looking at an i7 build but Intel's X58 board has only 4 sockets. This leaves me at a loss of what board to get :p.
 
You mean boards that Intel have had someone manufacture for them...

No, I mean that there are Intel manufactured boards with Intel chipsets and there are boards that are not manufactured by Intel that use Intel chipset. Like ASUS for example.
 
Last Tyan I had was a Tiger I believe from the xp mobile dual cpu days. Fried on me with no overclocking and good cooling. Haven't used one since. It would be easier if you could tell me what cpu or cpu range youll be getting?
 
No, I mean that there are Intel manufactured boards with Intel chipsets and there are boards that are not manufactured by Intel that use Intel chipset. Like ASUS for example.

Intel branded boards are made by other manufacturers (such as Foxconn), as stated above.
 
no to mention, if you're an intel partner, you get free overnight priority RMA, which no one else can touch. (that's why we use them!)
 
No, I mean that there are Intel manufactured boards with Intel chipsets and there are boards that are not manufactured by Intel that use Intel chipset. Like ASUS for example.

Sorry but Intel doesn't manufacture motherboards. They design them and contract manufacturing out. The only thing on a motherboard they make that is actually part of the board are the chipsets themselves.

Intel branded boards are made by other manufacturers (such as Foxconn), as stated above.

Right.

They are still manufactured to Intel's specification, and Intel provides support.

Exactly.

no to mention, if you're an intel partner, you get free overnight priority RMA, which no one else can touch. (that's why we use them!)

This is also true. Intel's support and RMA service is virtually unequaled in the industry. I've never needed their services but I know some people who have and each person raves about the experience. For the record I own and have owned a ton of Intel boards. Not a single one of them has died on me. Three of the four desktop machines at my house are running Intel boards and have been for some time.

Among the boards I've owned.

  • Intel PR440FX Providence (Dual Pentium Pro motherboard)
  • Intel 440BX (I don't remember the exact model.)
  • Intel DP35P
  • Intel DX48BT2 (x2)
  • Intel D5400XS (x2)

The DX48BT2's and one D5400XS are in use and run 24/7 and have been doing so for over a year without issue. Intel branded boards are excellent. If you need stability and a flawlessly executed feature set, they are hard to beat.
 
Ok, well you're still not going to call it a foxconn board. If you go to a store, you're going to ask for an Intel board, if you go to newegg, you're going to choose Intel as the manufacturer. What douche is going to walk into a store and ask for a foxconn manufactured board with Intel branding and packaging? Are you? I don't and there's never been any confusion as to what I'm talking about.
 
Back
Top