Need Recommended PC Hardware. Budget:$2500

Joined
Mar 15, 2006
Messages
38
Hey everyone,

I am looking to build a new comp, I have been out of things for the last year or so I am way behind on things...

Can anyone recommend a good system, my budget is $2500, I would like to run the new nvidia cards that are coming out in June, so I will use my 7800gtx until then.

Purpose: Gaming, and Development.

Thank you all in advance.
 
First, the usual questions:

- Is the $2500 budget only for the computer, or do you also need to buy peripherals with it? Does shipping/taxes have to be included within that budget amount?
- Where do you live? Where are you going to buy everything from?
- Which monitor(s)/resolution(s) are you going to use?
- Which games are you going to play on it? Which "development" software are you going to use?
- Which features do you want the motherboard/computer to have?
- Are you going to overclock? Use water cooling?
- How long do you want this build to last?
 
- Is the $2500 budget only for the computer, or do you also need to buy peripherals with it? Does shipping/taxes have to be included within that budget amount?

I already have the peripherails listed in my sig. Yes shipping included

- Where do you live? Where are you going to buy everything from?
Irvine, CA- I will buy from online retailers.

- Which monitor(s)/resolution(s) are you going to use?
dell 30"

- Which games are you going to play on it? Which "development" software are you going to use?
AoC, Crysis, TF2, WoW, CoH, BF2
Photoshop, Eclipse, Flash, etc- All Graphic and All Memory Intensive apps


- Which features do you want the motherboard/computer to have?
I like the features my current ASUS board has. I think SLI is a must with the 30"

- Are you going to overclock? Use water cooling?
Yes I will OC, I would like to use air cooling.

- How long do you want this build to last?
I would like the comp to last 2-3 years
 
$2500 hmmm......

Intel® D5400XS SkullTrail Motherboard - $575
Intel Xeon E5430 Harpertown 2.66GHz 12MB L2 Cache LGA 771 80W Quad-Core Processor x 2 - $940
OCZ Vendetta 2 x 2 - $76
Kingston 4GB (2 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR2 FB-DIMM ECC Fully Buffered DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) Dual Channel Kit Server Memory x2 - $452
ENERMAX Galaxy EGX1000EWL 1000W ATX12V/ EPS12V/ BTX Power Supply - $253 AR (good enough for dual SLI, Intel recommends 1400W for quad SLI/Crossfire)

If you reuse your case and HDs that only leaves you about $100. So you'd need to scrounge up a bit more for the new Nvidia cards :eek: Should hit around 3.4GHz on the CPUs depending on how far the RAM will overclock as that is your limiter.


1. Yeah if gaming is more important to you than an E8500/Q9450 system coupled with an X48 mobo and one of the new Nvidia GPUs or a few 4870(x2s) would make much more sense and I'm sure someone will come up with a good setup like that.
2. Well I was bored and I wanted to see if I could come up with a nice Skulltrail system for under $2500. 8 cores of Harpertown goodness and 8GB of RAM makes me happy in pants :D
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Skulltrail is a waste. Go with a Core 2 Extreme, 4-8GB of DDR2 Memory, a 9800GX2 or HD 3870 X2
 
Skulltrail /is/ a waste, but so are Extreme Edition Core 2s. They almost always top out around the same place as their non-Extreme, locked multi cousins.

SHIFT_nismo, here you go:

$300 - Lian Li V2000B Plus II or similar case, buy used to save money if you want
$100 - Corsair TX 750 PSU (Provantage, Buy.com)
$100 - Samsung F1 750GB 7200RPM SATA HDD
$30 - Samsung 20X SATA DVDRW
$200 - Q6600 G0 CPU, OC to ~3.6Ghz (from wherever)
$50 - Xigmatech Rifle 120mm S1283 HSF ($37, Newegg) + Thermalright Bolt-Thru kit ($6 + s/h, Jab-Tech)
$90 - 4GB (2x2GB) DDR2-800 CAS5 RAM (G.Skill, A-Data, OCZ, Mushkin, Corsair, Crucial. Doesn't matter.)
$200 - EVGA 750 SLI FTW motherboard (Newegg or elsewhere - arguably the best SLI board out there, or the only good SLI board out there, depending who you ask. ;))
$550 (2x $225) - 2x 8800 GTS 512MB (your 30" needs all the power it can get; use Step Up on both to 280 GTXs once they're available, or just wait and buy the 280 GTXs instead. Get EVGA brand only, for this reason!)
$20 - Sunbeam Rheobus fan controller (Newegg or elsewhere)
$20 - 4x Yate Loon mid speed 120mm fans (Petrastechshop.com)
Optional:
$200 - Asus Xonar D2X PCIe sound card (onboard has come a long, long way -- I would try it before spending $100-200 on a soundcard)

+ shipping. Call it $50.
~$1750. $2000 with the soundcard + misc expenses.

There is no reason to spend more than that. Period.
 
Here's a reasonable setup. I didn't use the full $2500 because I'm assuming that part of the money is going towards the video cards. You can reuse the case (but you'll need a bit stronger PSU for your plans), along with your other peripherals, and onboard sound nowadays has progressed to the point that it's good enough for most people.

I gave you a couple of options regarding the CPU, motherboard, and HDD, based on what you may need or want. You have options as to whether or not you want to go dual-core or quad-core and whether or not you want to go SLI (NVIDIA) or CrossFire (AMD/ATI).

$190 - EVGA 750i FTW -or-
$235 - Gigabyte GA-X48-DS4
$195 - E8400 (free shipping) -or-
$360 - Q9450 (free shipping)
$37 - Xigmatek HDT-S1283 (free shipping)
$85 - G.Skill 4GB (2x2GB) DDR2 1000 kit (free shipping)
$26 - Samsung SH-S203B (free shipping)
$100 - Western Digital 640GB HDD (free shipping) -or-
$110 - Samsung F1 750GB HDD
$105 - Corsair TX750 (free shipping & $10 mail-in rebate)
=======
$738 - $931 (Subtotal, not including shipping, taxes, or rebates)
 
Thanks for the suggestions... I noticed nobody recommended any DDR3 motherboards any reason for that?
 
Cuz there isn't much of a performance difference right now between the two and ddr3 is wayyyyy to expensive.
 
Thanks for the suggestions... I noticed nobody recommended any DDR3 motherboards any reason for that?

DDR3 is immature. The timings are so much looser than quality DDR2 that you get zero real world performance increase from the higher clocks -- that, and current Intel platform CPUs don't seem to benefit much if at all from RAM clocks running higher than FSB speeds. Take the quoted FSB for a chip, divide it by four as it's "quad pumped" in Intel-speak, and if you aren't OCing the CPU, RAM faster than 2x that number (as true clocks are 1/2 rated clocks on DDR2) nets you zero performance gain.

Sure, you can run benches all day that say you have x% more bandwidth, but in the end, if nothing is substantially (or in many cases, /any/) faster, it doesn't matter.

Or, to put it another way... if you had two video cards that got the same average FPS in a bunch of games, both were playable just fine, but one got 3x as many 3DMarks but cost 2-8x as much as the other, which would you pick? The cheaper card that performs the same in games but gets lower 3DMarks? That's what I thought. ;)

By the time DDR3 is worthwhile, it'll be a requirement, because Nehalem will be here. There will be cheaper, higher quality, more mature DDR3 by that point.

Buying DDR3 so you can use it in your next build now (which I've seen many people doing, unfortunately) is shooting yourself in the foot; a $600 kit today is likely to be beat out by a $200 kit in 2 years, and a $80 kit of DDR2 will give you the exact same performance as the $600 kit of DDR3 today... so you've effectively thrown out $300+, for no reason at all.
 
Ultimatly I think people are saying spend half...save the other half for in a few years when you will want the upgrades.
 
What are your thoughts on running 2xSamsung F1 750GB HDD in raid 0? Is raid0 not worth it now days?
 
The issue with RAID 0 is that when one drive fails, all of your data is lost.

Why are you even considering RAID 0?
 
What are your thoughts on running 2xSamsung F1 750GB HDD in raid 0? Is raid0 not worth it now days?

Generally speaking a single high end 7200RPM like the F1 should be plenty fast -- all RAID 0 will do is somewhat reduce loading and potentially startup times (which will already be quick). If you're willing to keep regular backups that's one thing... but keeping 1.5TB backed up can be a pain.
 
The issue with RAID 0 is that when one drive fails, all of your data is lost.

Why are you even considering RAID 0?

I have always been using it, so its just something I am used to doing... I figure by running a raid 0 with these drives would essentially make them twice as fast and because they are my OS drive it would speed that up as well.

Generally speaking a single high end 7200RPM like the F1 should be plenty fast -- all RAID 0 will do is somewhat reduce loading and potentially startup times (which will already be quick). If you're willing to keep regular backups that's one thing... but keeping 1.5TB backed up can be a pain.

If these things are already fast and there is no significant gain then I may just run a raid 1.

In-fact 750gb is probably a lot more then i would want to run as my main drive which my os is installed to, because i reinstall the os a lot. I like to keep all my data and installs on a separate drive. I guess now days you dont really need to worry about this.
 
Skulltrail is NOT a waste of money as long as you don't buy two QX9775. For example, look at this build I made a few months ago:
(2X) $246 - Intel E5410 XEON 2.33GHz 1333MHz 771 12MB CPU OEM.
(2X) $30 - Kingwin Revolution H.D.T. (Heat-pipe Direct Touch) CPU Cooler RVT-12025, for Intel LGA775 and AMD Socket AM2/754/939/940 CPUs
(2X) $96 - Qimonda D2-800 2GB/256x72 ECC FB-DIMM Original Memory
$582 - Intel D5400XS LGA 771 Max-8GB ATX 1600MHz FSB 12MB Cache
(4X) $180 - GIGABYTE GV-RX387512H Radeon HD 3870 512MB 256-bit GDDR3 PCI Express 2.0 x16 HDCP Ready CrossFire Supported Video Card - Retail
$60 - Razer Barracuda AC-1 Gaming Sound Card - RZ05-00130100-R2M1
$140 - SAMSUNG Spinpoint F1 HD753LJ 750GB 7200 RPM 32MB Cache SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - OEM
$34 - SAMSUNG Black 20X DVD+R 2MB Cache SATA 20X DVD±R DVD Burner with LightScribe - OEM
$120 (YMMV) - Rocketfish Aluminum Full Tower Case--BestBuy Clearance
$130 - Rosewill RX950-S-B ATX 12V v2.2 & EPS 12V v2.91 950W Power Supply - Retail (use code EMCADAEAB)
$210 ($40MIR) - Logitech Z 5500 Digital - PC Multimedia Home Theater Speaker System - 970115-0403
$$$ - Monitor
$110 - Windows
------------------------------------
TOTAL= $2850 - $40MIR
------------------------------------

You can't go wrong with a 2.8GHz octa-core + quad CF setup
Edit: It should work theoretically, but I never tried it.

You OC the CPU from 333*7=2333 to 400*7=2800. The motherboard allows it. The RAM allows it. I see no problem here. And 8*2.8>4*3.6
The budget for the four HD3870's can go towards buyng two of the next-gen cards.
The build is outdated, but you get the idea on what can be done with this kind of budget...
 
Skulltrail is NOT a waste of money as long as you don't buy two QX9775. For example, look at this build I made a few months ago:


You OC the CPU from 333*7=2333 to 400*7=2800. The motherboard allows it. The RAM allows it. I see no problem here. And 8*2.8>4*3.6
The budget for the four HD3870's can go towards buyng two of the next-gen cards.
The build is outdated, but you get the idea on what can be done with this kind of budget...

Yeah, but Skulltrail is a huge waste of money if you are just gaming. A quad core is more than enough now, let alone getting eight cores.

A good spec would be something like this:
  • Q6600 G0 - overclock to around 3.7 or so.
  • Decent case - you choose, I wouldn't personally recommend a CM690 for a build of this price, not great quality. A higher end Coolermaster, a Lian Li or Silverstone, would be a great choice.
  • EVGA 750i FTW board, stable board, probably one of the best around (as everyone else has said).
  • Noctua NH-U12P cooler, silent, great cooling performance.
  • WD6400AAKS hard drive, currently the fastest high capacity drive ATM.
  • 280GTX graphics cards.
  • Corsair TX750, or, if you want a modular power supply, the Thermaltake Toughpower 750 Cable Management.
  • Another vote here for the Asus Xonar D2X soundcard, people are saying that it is great.

The other parts, everyone else has really said, so there isn't much point for me to say this.
 
RAID0 still speeds things up pretty nicely. If you want extreme speeds, waste some money on an MTron SSD instead. :p If you don't mind the possibility of data loss due to a good backup scheme, and want the extra speed, then go for RAID0. If you want something faster, get a hardware RAID card and a bunch of drives into RAID5 or 6.

http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1284410
 
Yeah, but Skulltrail is a huge waste of money if you are just gaming. A quad core is more than enough now, let alone getting eight cores.

Sooo:
Q6600 and E8400 are a waste of money, as current games don't need anything over a $60 E2180 overclocked to 3.2GHz.
X38 is a a waste of money. No SLI. No extra overclockability. No extra performance. No extra longetivity. No need for the excess amount of ports...
4GB RAM is a waste of money. No real improvement in current games in jumping from from 2GB to 4GB.
A $200 sound card is a waste of money, unless he has a $2000 speaker system that can show the difference.
A nice case is a waste of money. He will only bother with it during installing the components. Afterwards, he will keep it beside his desk and never look at it dring usage.
SLI as a whole is waste of money, as a single 8800GTS can handle most games up to 1920x1200, and a single 9800GX2 can handle 2560x1600...

:rolleyes:
 
^^^
Think.

Yes, X38 is a waste. He wants SLI. CrossfireX performance is a joke (3-4 cards = or < 2 cards in SLI?) save for those that want multimonitor gaming setups.

No 4GB of RAM is not a waste. Vista likes it, it allows more multitasking, and that's reason enough.

A $200 soundcard is a waste. A $80-100 card is plenty, and Realtek HD audio has come a long, long way. If he's using digital out, it doesn't matter. If he's using analog out and has quality speakers, yes, a higher quality card will make a difference. All comes down to how good your other equipment is and how well you hear / how much you care.

A nice case is not a waste, as it's a lot nicer to deal with, looks better (generally) and has better cooling. "Nice" is difficult to define. I'd say a Coolermaster RC-590 or 690 for $60-80 is nice. I'd say a $120 Antec P182 is nice. A $250 Lian-Li V2000B Plus II is very nice... but overkill for most.

SLI isn't a waste at 1920x1200 and above -- as you said, "most" games. Most is not all. A 9800GX2 can't take 2560x1600 in /many/ titles, at least not with high settings. SLI is necessary, if you're demanding.


Current games are GPU limited, not CPU limited. As you said, A $60 E2160 is enough -- however, it won't allow much multitasking and will bog down with heavy graphics works like the OP intends. That, and it may well prove a bit too slow in the near future. A Q6600 lets you multitask plenty (cutting costs by ~$600 over a Skulltrail based system, between the other processor and the motherboard cost difference) and is plenty fast per core as well. I am not an E8400 advocate. Paying $200 for 4 cores at ~3.5 Ghz vs. paying $200 for 2 cores at ~4Ghz -- that's a very easy choice.

There's a point of diminishing returns -- you found it and kept going.
 
now now... if i cared about wasting money i wouldn't even by a new computer and just upgrade my video card in my current system... some of us need to waste this money or give the money to the IRS. I would rather upgrade my system then do that :p

There is a guy here at my office that is selling a Q6600 with an X38 for $350. He is also selling some memory and graphic cards. All of it is about a week old. I could give it a shot and if I really want SLI upgrade the board later...
 
Back
Top