Need Recommendations: AGP highest-performing video card?

Soulstice

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jun 26, 2001
Messages
1,104
Okay, here's the situation:

a) I'm still stuck with a system running on socket 754 and 2 GB of DDR3200 (DDR1 spec, obviously!). I have an Athlon64 3000+ in a Silverstone HTPC case, with a 450W Antec PSU (hence, ignore my sig for now until I update it).
b) My system still runs extremely fast. I have absolutely no complaints unless I'm attempting to run a game such as FEAR. My current GeForce 5900 simply doesn't do it.

Hence, I've pondered several options:
1) Upgrade to GeForce 7600GT AGP -- $200 CD
2) Upgrade to GeForce 7800GS AGP -- $300 CD

Now, thus far, my research demonstrates that, at stock speeds, the 7600GT beats out the 7800GS. On the other hand, the LeadTek unit that I was originally considering seems to be a very poor OC candidate, according to reviews.

So, what's your recommendation? Should I go with the GeForce 7600 GT, and, if so, which brand???

or, should I spend the extra $100 and go with the 7800GS??

As it stands now, I'd rather save the extra money and begin saving up for a new dual- or -quad-core system, and I'm leaning toward the 7600GT.


One more thing, if you can think of any other options that will help me save money, while at the same time providing the best bang for the buck, please advise. I'm open to all suggestions. I even read somewhere that ATI was planning on releasing the 1950 for AGP, but I'd like to grab something in the next few weeks.

Thank in advance.
 
After further research, I'm heavily leaning toward the XFX GeForce 7600GT XXX card.

Is this my best choice?
 
cmankit said:
i have a used 6800gt w. artic colling , selling for 150cad~~

I was running a system very similar: Atholon XP 3000+, gig of ram, etc...and my 6800GT could run FEAR nicely on that system, so if your lookin to save up, this 6800gt is an option!
 
Well the title says "highest performing", and if that's what you're looking for then I'd go with the x1950 AGP when it comes out.

However I know if I was in your position a used 6800GT for $150 would probably tide me over.

 
I just bought an eVGA 7800gs co. I like it. Works great over my former 6600GT. I can play most newer games with all settings on high because I still use a 19" CRT with 1280x1024 resolution or lower. Oblivion is very playable with all settings on high and HDR, I may reduce some of the draw distance to raise the FPS a bit more. Half Life 2 engine games have at least 60 FPS with all settings on high, HDR, 8XAA and 16XAF. BF2 all settings on high, high FPS and all DOOM 3 Engine games all settings high, excellent FPS. Good upgrade for the money in my opinion. This will hold me over until I cannot take not having DX10 anymore. Probably 2 years from now.
 
Soulstice said:
After further research, I'm heavily leaning toward the XFX GeForce 7600GT XXX card.

Is this my best choice?
I agree to wait for the emergence of the x1950pro then compare the performance and value
 
Thanks for the recommendations.

My question is why would I spend $150 on a 6800GT, when I can grab a 7600GT for $50 more? The 7600GT outperforms the 7800GS, and if I'm going to spend the money, I'd rather not purchase a video-card that's only one generation better than my current card.

As for the 1950, it sounds great... ...but I have no idea at this point what it's going to be priced at. What if it's selling for like $500 CD? Then it's not even worth the wait, because I'm going to end up purchasing the LeadTek 7600GT regardless.


Anyway, I'd like to make a decision in the next couple of days so that I can get an order placed. If I'm missing anything, please let me know.

Thanks again for the assistance.
 
Soulstice said:
Thanks for the recommendations.

My question is why would I spend $150 on a 6800GT, when I can grab a 7600GT for $50 more? The 7600GT outperforms the 7800GS, and if I'm going to spend the money, I'd rather not purchase a video-card that's only one generation better than my current card.

As for the 1950, it sounds great... ...but I have no idea at this point what it's going to be priced at. What if it's selling for like $500 CD? Then it's not even worth the wait, because I'm going to end up purchasing the LeadTek 7600GT regardless.


Anyway, I'd like to make a decision in the next couple of days so that I can get an order placed. If I'm missing anything, please let me know.

Thanks again for the assistance.
I've got the Leadtek myself and its quite nice
 
meatfestival said:
The forthcoming AGP X1950 will probably be the best.

Agreed wait until the end of November for this gem, assuming ATI does not cripple the card it should offer 15fps or more increase above teh 7800GS. The x1950 is supposed to come in between 200-300 dollars most likely from what I have read / heard
 
Soulstice said:
Thanks for the recommendations.

My question is why would I spend $150 on a 6800GT, when I can grab a 7600GT for $50 more? The 7600GT outperforms the 7800GS, and if I'm going to spend the money, I'd rather not purchase a video-card that's only one generation better than my current card.

As for the 1950, it sounds great... ...but I have no idea at this point what it's going to be priced at. What if it's selling for like $500 CD? Then it's not even worth the wait, because I'm going to end up purchasing the LeadTek 7600GT regardless.


Anyway, I'd like to make a decision in the next couple of days so that I can get an order placed. If I'm missing anything, please let me know.

Thanks again for the assistance.
If you're going to decide in the next couple of days, get the 7600 GT. If they're both overclocked, the 7800 GS will definitely be faster, but not by a sufficient amount to justify the price difference.
 
Thanks again.

I went online today to order the Leadtek 7600GT. NCIX was sold out and had no ETA. TigerDirect doesn't stock it. Canada Computers reported that the new status on the Leadtek 7600GT is unknown, and they haven't received any additional units since they sold out of their last batch. In other words, it looks like Leadtek may not be producing any additional units.

However, the XFX 7600GT XXX (an OC'd AGP 7600GT) is available. It's $240 CD... but it's still an option. :( If I'm unable to purchase the Leadtek 7600GT, I may just wait another few weeks for the ATI 1950.
 
Soulstice said:
Thanks again.

I went online today to order the Leadtek 7600GT. NCIX was sold out and had no ETA. TigerDirect doesn't stock it. Canada Computers reported that the new status on the Leadtek 7600GT is unknown, and they haven't received any additional units since they sold out of their last batch. In other words, it looks like Leadtek may not be producing any additional units.

However, the XFX 7600GT XXX (an OC'd AGP 7600GT) is available. It's $240 CD... but it's still an option. :( If I'm unable to purchase the Leadtek 7600GT, I may just wait another few weeks for the ATI 1950.

Man your doing yourself a disservice by not waiting a few weeks. I mean 15fps in Oblivion over the card your looking at is nothing to sneeze at! It about 1/3 faster then the 7800GS, assuming they don't cripple the card like I stated previously!
 
Good point.... an additional 15 fps in Oblivion is pretty damn impressive.

However, nobody can provide me with any set dates. At this point, it's unknown. I don't want to wait another two months. The 1950 sounds awesome, and if it does sell for $250, then great. But what if they price the AGP version at somewhere around $400? That's a big possibility, considering that the 7800 GS is priced roughly at $300 - $350
 
Soulstice said:
Good point.... an additional 15 fps in Oblivion is pretty damn impressive.

However, nobody can provide me with any set dates. At this point, it's unknown. I don't want to wait another two months. The 1950 sounds awesome, and if it does sell for $250, then great. But what if they price the AGP version at somewhere around $400? That's a big possibility, considering that the 7800 GS is priced roughly at $300 - $350

Weird I got the EVGA Super OC 7800GS shortly after release at $300. It has a nice overclock on it. Two reasons I don't think the price will be that high. 1. ATI has always been aware of price sensitivity. Even their newer flagship cards are reasonably priced. 2. ATI wants to compete with NV over the AGP crowd, I mean the installed base of AGP is probably 80% larger then PCI-e.

I know i'm waiting to upgrade my 7800GS and move that to my 2nd rig and then sell off my 6800nu. Plus honestly the 7800GS has done pretty well with oblivion at 1920x1080. I would be happy for 6-9 mos with a 15fps increase. That would mean on heavy action areas my min would be 30fps and to me that is really good on a game like oblivion with the new 1950 pro.

Hurry up ATI the AGP crowd begs you! But make sure you do it right! No Crippling!
 
Just got my 7800 GS in last night. Picked it up for $230 - $30MIB=$200 from newegg.

6100 in 3dmark05 with a slight overclock...will be messing around with this a bit more to see if i can squeeze a bit more out of my system...but for comparison's sake, i used to get 3100-3200...

playing F.E.A.R. and FarCry is amazing...i can turn on AA and AF!

IMHO, 200 dollars well spent....much faster than my 6600gt...will keep me going until i do a full system upgrade in about 1.5 years.
 
The 1950pro is going to be available really soon, personally I would hold out until it became available. :D
 
You might consider this EPoX 8NPA SLI motherboard as an option (PCIe / SLI / s754) for $77:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16813123257

And this cheaper PCIe 7600GT for $109 (after $20 rebate):
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814130062

That brings the total to about $190, and now you have PCIe and the ability to go SLI in the future.

I have one of those motherboards and used to run it with a 7600GT like the one I linked to (upgraded to a 7900GT later on). Once I volt-moded and overclocked that 7600GT, I managed to get within spitting distance of 8000 in 3DMark05, not to shabby.. :D
 
Seanmounce said:
The 1950pro is going to be available really soon, personally I would hold out until it became available. :D


Both Diamond and GeCube are showing by the end of November to have their cards out. What I did notice is Diamond is offering a 512mb version. I did not see that offering from GeCube, unless I missed it somewhere.
 
Unknown-One said:
You might consider this EPoX 8NPA SLI motherboard as an option (PCIe / SLI / s754) for $77:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16813123257

And this cheaper PCIe 7600GT for $109 (after $20 rebate):
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814130062

That brings the total to about $190, and now you have PCIe and the ability to go SLI in the future.

I have one of those motherboards and used to run it with a 7600GT like the one I linked to (upgraded to a 7900GT later on). Once I volt-moded and overclocked that 7600GT, I managed to get within spitting distance of 8000 in 3DMark05, not to shabby.. :D

Really the best choice if you don't mind a motherboard upgrade. You can get a decent 754 PCI-E motherboard and PCI-E video card for cheaper than a high performance AGP video card.
 
When was a 7600GT better than a 6800GT?

6800GT = 7800GS almost on par.
6800GS = 7600GT

I think.
 
AMDXPCottonFire22 said:
When was a 7600GT better than a 6800GT?

6800GT = 7800GS almost on par.
6800GS = 7600GT

I think.
Nope, the 7600GT romps on the 6800Ultra and 7800GS, and it can get insane overclocks.
 
i'm just not feeling the 7600gt love.

i overclocked the hell out of my 7800 gs...it's stable at 524/1404. this is a card that's supposed to be clocked at 375/1200. it's not terribly expensive...200 bucks after a MIB at newegg...real world performance is great. i can play farcry, fear, serious sam 2 at 1280x720 with all the bells and whistles turned on. 60+ fps.

bottom line is this card has injected quite a bit more life into my somewhat dated computer. i have no complaints. until i see how much the x1950 is priced at, i heartily recommend the 7800gs.
 
mikeczyz said:
i'm just not feeling the 7600gt love.

i overclocked the hell out of my 7800 gs...it's stable at 524/1404. this is a card that's supposed to be clocked at 375/1200. it's not terribly expensive...200 bucks after a MIB at newegg...real world performance is great. i can play farcry, fear, serious sam 2 at 1280x720 with all the bells and whistles turned on. 60+ fps.

bottom line is this card has injected quite a bit more life into my somewhat dated computer. i have no complaints. until i see how much the x1950 is priced at, i heartily recommend the 7800gs.

Mike the 7800GS even insanely overclocked vs a 6800 Ultra overclocked nets you about 5-10fps in a game like oblivion with the same settings. Where the 1950pro should net you another 15fps above that or more. That is a significant increase, and thus is worth waiting a few weeks, imho.
 
Originally Posted by Unknown-One
You might consider this EPoX 8NPA SLI motherboard as an option (PCIe / SLI / s754) for $77:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...N82E16813123257

And this cheaper PCIe 7600GT for $109 (after $20 rebate):
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...N82E16814130062

That brings the total to about $190, and now you have PCIe and the ability to go SLI in the future.

I have one of those motherboards and used to run it with a 7600GT like the one I linked to (upgraded to a 7900GT later on). Once I volt-moded and overclocked that 7600GT, I managed to get within spitting distance of 8000 in 3DMark05, not to shabby..


Really the best choice if you don't mind a motherboard upgrade. You can get a decent 754 PCI-E motherboard and PCI-E video card for cheaper than a high performance AGP video card.


You make a good point, and something I will consider.
Check out my sig for the case... ...SilverStone mATX. Hence, I will need to find an mATX socket-754 board, with PCI-e... ...including a 7600GT or higher card for roughly $250 Canadian. I don't think this is possible. If ATI releases their 1950 for $200 - $250, then I'm set. If not, I'll grab the 7600GT, and begin saving for my next rig. Eventually, I will be turning this machine into my centralized home-video / audio centre, so it's not like I'm completely wasting money by throwing a nice AGP card in there.
 
Sunin said:
Mike the 7800GS even insanely overclocked vs a 6800 Ultra overclocked nets you about 5-10fps in a game like oblivion with the same settings. Where the 1950pro should net you another 15fps above that or more. That is a significant increase, and thus is worth waiting a few weeks, imho.
yah, i agree, 15 extra fps is a pretty big jump. however, when i did my pre-purchase research, it became apparent that a 7800 gs would more than suffice for my needs (and real-world gameplay has exceeded those expectations) b/c i only play at 1280x720 due to a monitor limitation. a 1950 pro would be overkill for me! anyway, different people in different situations have different priorities. i just don't feel the 7800gs get's ANY love around here and I also think it's a pretty good deal at 200 bucks (and i would be the first to say that it's overpriced at $275+)...just my two cents.
 
mikeczyz said:
yah, i agree, 15 extra fps is a pretty big jump. however, when i did my pre-purchase research, it became apparent that a 7800 gs would more than suffice for my needs (and real-world gameplay has exceeded those expectations) b/c i only play at 1280x720 due to a monitor limitation. a 1950 pro would be overkill for me! anyway, different people in different situations have different priorities. i just don't feel the 7800gs get's ANY love around here and I also think it's a pretty good deal at 200 bucks (and i would be the first to say that it's overpriced at $275+)...just my two cents.

Overkill for current level of games? Crysis will be killing your card at that resolution. Oh and trust me I love my 7800GS it is allowing me to play HL2, Oblivion and other games at 1920x1080 with a decent amount of eye candy turned on and sitll be playable 30fpsish.
 
Sunin said:
Overkill for current level of games? Crysis will be killing your card at that resolution. Oh and trust me I love my 7800GS it is allowing me to play HL2, Oblivion and other games at 1920x1080 with a decent amount of eye candy turned on and sitll be playable 30fpsish.
heh, last i checked, Crysis wasn't yet released... :p
 
Back
Top