Need quick advice on E6420 or E6600 (NOT for gaming)

Which CPU should I get?

  • E6420

    Votes: 13 48.1%
  • E6600

    Votes: 10 37.0%
  • Other

    Votes: 4 14.8%

  • Total voters
    27

RavinDJ

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Apr 9, 2002
Messages
4,578
I want to purchase a Dell Dim 9200 and I don't know if I should get the E6420 or the E6600 (the E6600 is $100 more than the E6420). I'm not going to play games (at least not that I know of; who knows, maybe I'll get into gaming a little this Summer when I have more time) and I'm not going to overclock (never got into OC'ing and probably never will).

So... price is definitely of concern (obviously, since if it wasn't, I'd be getting the quad-core CPU or EXTREME this or EXTREME that)... but, the $100 difference b/w the 6600 and 6420 is not that big a deal...

So... what would you get if you were in my shoes?

Thanks!
 
If you don't play games, don't overclock and money is not a problem, why not just get the fastest possible CPU? I would go that route if I were in your shoes.
 
Given your criteria I would go with the E6600 since you won't oc.

The only drawback I see is them skanks at Dell charging you an extra $100 for a cpu that costs us an extra $37 over the E6420. And I'm pretty sure they aren't giving you a better mobo or ram for that $100 either. Unless they are giving you MORE ram, but then again we can buy 2gb for less than $100 these days.

Screw Dell. Build your own box and learn to oc the piss out of it. :)
 
I'm chiming in for a E6600 also because you said a $100 (I thought the difference was much less) , I assume is USD's extra, was no big deal. I have 2x E6600's and 1x E6420 and if the difference is as high as $100 USD and you were on a strick budget I would go a E6420, as with all OC'ing IMO (and the opinion of many more experienced OC'ers than me) it's the "luck of the draw" so you might get a "golden" E6420 or a "dog" E6600 whichever way you went. Being stock I would definitely go a E6600 because it's 2.40 GHz vs a E6420 at 2.13 GHz.
 
Why is overclocking out of the question? I mean the c2d's get such great recognition today because of their high overclocking ability. You can get the cheapest c2d Dell offers, and with just changing 3-4 settings in bios, you can easily run the chip just as fast as the Extreme x6800.
 
Why is overclocking out of the question? I mean the c2d's get such great recognition today because of their high overclocking ability. You can get the cheapest c2d Dell offers, and with just changing 3-4 settings in bios, you can easily run the chip just as fast as the Extreme x6800.

You seems to forget the fact that most Dell cannot be overclocked due to the lack of overclocking options in the bios ;)
 
What do you plan on doing with the rig? If just surfing the net, playing with photos and using word then save the $100 and get the 6420. If you're doing encoding, ripping music and into heavier photoshop stuff get the 6600. Overclocking is irrelevant as it is a Dell and there isn't any way to overclock it. Also it probably has Windows Me-2 (Vista) installed so put that $100 towards extra RAM, you'll need it.
 
put more money into ram, you'll probably need it for vista.
 
E6420, 270 MHZ is not worth $100
correct.

Let's assume Dell is marking up E6420 to $200 and E6600 to $300 = 50% price increase

E6420 @ 2.13 to E6600 @ 2.40 = 12% performance increase

I personally wouldn't pay the premium, just my .02
 
Thanks for the input, guys! Since this is my first new computer for myself since I won the AMD XP contest in 2001 (yes, the mobo + AMD XP 1800+... I can't believe I'm still using the same machine), I decided to go with the E6600.

I'm guessing I'll see a big increase in speed, huh?

Thanks, again!!
 
Back
Top