Need New Router

mZimm

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Mar 19, 2006
Messages
1,070
I currently have a Linksys WRT54GC wireless router, but it is dropping the connection every ten minutes, making me either release and renew the ip or restart the router each time it happens, so I figure it is time for a new router. When I connect directly to the DSL modem, I have no problems.

I really don't have a very complex home network. I have two computers that are wired, and 7 notebooks and desktops that are connected wirelessly. Some of the wireless computers have 802.11b cards, so I need something that has good backwards compatibility. All are PCs, and running Windows XP except for the newest notebook has Vista Basic.

As for the usage, I frequently connect to torrents and game online, so it has to be able to take a lot of connections simultaneously without overheating or dropping packets, etc. I do transfer sometimes large files over the network, but since I do have some b hardware, I don't expect great transfer rates for at least the wirelessly connected computers. It doesn't have to have incredible range, it only needs to cover a 2-story house, ~3000 sq. ft. Needs to have good security, as there are close neighbors who wouldn't hesitate to pirate a connection.

Basically, I'm looking for the best router for my money. I have read about DD-WRT, and some say that any router that uses it is recommended. After that recommendation, I am considering the Buffalo WHR-G54S, but want to make sure before I buy it. I'd like to stay reasonably priced, but if a DGL-4300 or something is going to work much better for me, I don't want to skimp; as that's what got me into this in the first place, I got the WRT54GC for $20, and it turned out to be a pos. Thanks for your input.
 
well in your situation there are 2 options.

option 1. purchase a new wireless router (a netgear.. tho dont get the range max series) install wireless nic cards that use wireless G at least (mine use a, tho i use repeaters in my house) in laptops.

option 2. A wired network router that has spi and nat. then get 2 access points, one being a and the others being wireless g. this will ensure that all laptops will connect at there maximum speeds. this is a better solutions, oh i just remember there are routers that have dual antennas that lets one antenna does wireless a and the other that does wireless g. but please do not get the netgear wireless rangemax routers they blow up often and have many problems.

What about wiring ports in your house?
 
I have thought about wiring the house, but that would take away the point of having a notebook with wireless. There are two desktops that are wireless which I could wire if I needed to, but if I'm going to have to have a wireless setup anyway, I figure why mess with it.

Is it really not feasible to get a router that can provide a decent amount of bandwidth with both b and g devices connected to it? I know that some have problems, some of the B devices have problems connecting to the WRT54GC that I have now. Like I said, I'm willing to spend a good amount on a router (up to $100), but I'd like to not spend more than I need to. If I would decide to go with a router that can send out more than one signal at a time, what would be a good one? I've never heard of one that can do it.
 
I agree with the suggestion of getting a wired router and then adding two seperate access nodes. I usually set up all my personal and work places with a wired router and then add access points seperately, just to eliminate the possibility of failure for either device. Plus it also adds easy upgradability if you chose to go to a new router with more options, or if you want to add something like N. Linksys is a great company... They make good home grade stuff, some netgear devices are good, but most of their new stuff has not worked well for me.
 
What wired routers would you guys suggest if I go this route? With torrenting and gaming, obviously I don't want a crappy one, like I've had in the past? I haven't looked much at wired routers, what are some good ones?
 
I have had really good luck with the Linksys BEFSX41, this is a great low end router that really provides good VPN endpoint access and several firewall options.
 
Your problem sounds a lot like one I was having with my Linksys...

My wireless laptop would sit right beside it and drop the connection constantly...even though it showed good signal strength.

ISP blamed Linksys, Linksys blamed ISP...I blamed them both and my wife blamed me!

Anyway I junked it and got a super-duper D-Link DIR-625 that has been pretty rock solid ever since.

Heard decent things about the D-Link GamerLounge (DGL4300) with the QoS but haven't had a chance to try it.
 
I have the sister modelo, the DGL-4100. I'm having a problem where buffering windows media player files online is much slower than going straight to the modem or with my old router. Not sure if anyone can help me with that.
 
Just picked up a Buffalo WHR-HP-G54 to replace my Linksys SRX200 that was giving me all sorts of problems.
Upgraded the firmware to DD-WRT and it's working great w/ better signal strength and better options. I'm happy :D
 
I used to think that all routers were basically the same, but later realized how stupid that was since they all use different chipsets.

From what I understand, certain Linksys routers use chips from Broadcom which I hear are crap...at least for these Linksys ones. Most D-Link routers use chips from Atheros and Marvell.

Does anyone know if this is valid? Does anyone also know if there is any way to find out the chip manufacturers of routers?
 
Back
Top