NEED HELP X1950PRO VS GeForce 7950GT

rmarpuzon

n00b
Joined
Jan 26, 2006
Messages
2
GeForce 7950GT 512MB 256-bit GDDR3 PCI Express x16 HDCP KO
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814130066

Core clock : 600MHz
Memory : 1450MHz
Pipes : 24 Pipes
Price : $269
Features : HDCP ready


vs

Radeon X1950PRO 512MB 256-bit GDDR3 VIVO PCI Express x16 VIVO
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814131030

Core clock : 600MHz
Memory : 1400MHz
Pipes : 12(36 Pixel shader processor )
Price : $234.99
Features : VIVO , BIG HEATSINK/FAN (potential overclocker) ?


Need help picking between these two.... Only drawback I can think of is that the Radeon only has 12 pipelines but says (36 pixel shader processor?) .. And ofcourse the Radeon is a bit cheaper. But honestly , I'd get whatever will perform better. Help me out here guys ! :) Need to buy it tonight!
 
Still cheaper than the 7950, the 1950XT has the 16 pipes, and most likely out-performs the 7950. Whenever I used to post a choice between 2 things I want to buy, I always wind up buying something someone said I should get.....and its never one of the two. So, I'll answer the question now. I feel that the 1950 you have posted will overclock really well. Go for ATI, no one is really holding a HUGE edge right now.


Uh oh....... here come the flamers!!! "LOL NEWBZ!!!!!@21!!!11!1 teh nvida cards have the DX10 compaterblity lol try reding a weabsite sometime rofl rofl rofl rofl."
 
Google up three or four reviews where the cards are compared to each other, and evaluate them against some games you play or would like to play. Then get some reviews of those specific cards for things like temps, fan noise, and overclockability.

You'll figure it out. Either will work fine.
 
thanks for the insights , keep them coming pls!

if they are really neck in neck in terms of performance, I'd choose the cheaper one. But then the only thing that is holding me back with the radeon is that it only has 12 pixel pipelines ( although it says (36 Pixel shader processor ; no clue what that means.. someone pls explain to me what the drawback is) Also , on the product description it says nothing about it being HDCP ready. But on the contrary , hardforum suggests that it might be ... http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1071342
so confusing!
 
Pipes, shaders, memory, mhz - evaluating cards on these factors alone are like buying your car based on the amount of chrome.

Or something.

Seriously, go find three or four reviews where they use actual games.

Or you could go find a zoo, and ask the monkeys to contribute an answer based on flinging poo.

Which is about what you've done here.

;)
 
nvidia=24 pipes,1 unit per pipe= 24 shader units
ati=12 pipes,3 units per pipe= 36 shader units

two different ways to skin a cat both are good and about equal.

go for the cheaper one
 
7950GT's at stock are about 10-20% faster depending on the game.

7950GT's are decent overclockers usually to about GTX speed 650/1500. The X1950Pro is a poor overclocker so you can't get a lot more out of it.

The X1950Pro is cheaper on the flip side, at those prices the 7950GT is the no brainer.


edit

Just to shoot down those stating the X1950pro might be as fast, I thought I would google a few quick reviews.

http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.aspx?i=2858&p=8

and

http://www.techreport.com/reviews/2006q4/radeon-x1950-pro/index.x?pg=7

The X1950Pro is competion for the 7900GS, no match for the 1950GT, don't know where some of you get your ideas lol.

BTW the 7900GS is a great overclocker and will beat the X1950Pro comfortably if both cards are maximum overclocked, if you want to know what a 7950GT looks like overclocked look at the 7900GTX speeds in those reviews. I would for 7950GT then 7900GS(because of overclock potential) and last X1950Pro.
 
At the prices you quoted, the X1950 PRO is not worth it (the 512MB won't do much, anyway). Get an X1950 PRO 256MB for ~$200 or the 7950GT.

EDIT: Battleneter2 just edited his post and I want to back him up. In every review I've read, the 7950GT is in a class above the X1950 PRO and competes more with the X1950 XT (which is slightly faster). The 7950GT core should overclock to 7900GTX speeds pretty well, although I don't know about the memory (core speeds make more of a difference then memory speeds, though). I really wouldn't pay more than $200 for an X1950 PRO. I've seen 7900GS's for $140 after rebates and 7900GT's for less than $200; if you can find one of those deals (try "slickdeals.net"), they are much better buys.
 
I dunno how many keep an eye on hot deals in general, but that same eVGA 7950GT KO is $200 after an $80MIR at Fry's today. Ditto for Micro Center, the BBA X1950Pro is $200 even with no rebates involved. Both basically end up being $220-230 after tax and whatever. I already grabbed the 7950GT, but it was mostly so I had it before people noticed and it sold out.

I'm having a horribly hard time deciding between the two cards (including rebate hassle v. no hassle, god I hate them), or just getting a cheap 7900GS for $130-140, an aftermarket cooler, and hoping for massive overclocking happiness.

Looking at Arctic Cooling, it's toughish to figure out if they even have a cooler that fits the 7950GT. I'm currently using an X850XT where I'm happy with the ATi drivers, if that matters.
 
I'd go for this card: X1950XT
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814102067

X1950PRO is this card but with one quad disabled. But the X1950XT has the full 16 pipelines and 48 pixel shaders.

[H]ardocp reviewed the 512mb 7950GT and compared it with a 256mb X1900XT, and the ATi card was superior in every situation except for WoW. The X1950XT has even faster memory with the same # of pipelines and shaders, so it should easily beat a 7950GT. And it only costs $250. :D
 
Latest Anandtech article has nice evaluation where they pit 1950pro against 7950gt. It seems that ATI is doing doing bit better with the new Unreal engine used in Rainbox Six: Vegas.

Article

edit:

some grammar cleaned up :)
 
Looks like the X1950PRO equals or beats the 7950GT in R6 Vegas.
The X1950XT is even faster yet !
 
The X1950 PRO has less horsepower overall, it loses pretty consistently to the 7950, but the x1950 does have some nice IQ features...if only the damn thing was available at its MSRP of $199 it would be a far more compelling card...
 
^eMpTy^ said:
The X1950 PRO has less horsepower overall, it loses pretty consistently to the 7950, but the x1950 does have some nice IQ features...if only the damn thing was available at its MSRP of $199 it would be a far more compelling card...

The Pro is compelling for $200 but I agree when retailers push the price up, it loses its luster. But you can buy the 16/48 pixel shader X1950XT for $250 in stock at newegg. A better value than the price gouged X1950Pros and it's consistently faster than a 7950GT with the nice iq features.
 
Stereophile said:
I'd go for this card: X1950XT
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814102067

X1950PRO is this card but with one quad disabled. But the X1950XT has the full 16 pipelines and 48 pixel shaders.

[H]ardocp reviewed the 512mb 7950GT and compared it with a 256mb X1900XT, and the ATi card was superior in every situation except for WoW. The X1950XT has even faster memory with the same # of pipelines and shaders, so it should easily beat a 7950GT. And it only costs $250. :D
you can't unlock the quad? and if you can how does it perform then? (sorry if a stupid question, im not big on gpus)

thanks!
 
Stereophile said:
Looks like the X1950PRO equals or beats the 7950GT in R6 Vegas.
The X1950XT is even faster yet !

lol the X1950pro may beat the 7950gt in a "few" games or resolution. 95%+ the 7950GT will win

The 7905GT Overclocks a much higher percentage also. I do agree the X1900Xt/XTX & X1950Xt /XTX are faster than the 7950GT


this R6 performance review show the 7950GT winning

http://www.amdzone.com/modules.php?...s&file=index&req=viewarticle&artid=279&page=1


**I trust this review more as it uses real gameplay to measure, not the intro sequence.

The X1950pro overclocks like crap,, Not one of ATI's better cards. As my 7950Gt overclocks and benchmarks to the same as the 7900GTX so the X1950 for $30 less as in the original post is a shit buy. The X1900Xt 256MB would be a great option.
 
Yeah, if you want to pay the difference the X1950 XT 256MB is actually a pretty good deal. It's definitely a little faster than the 7950GT, except in games that use the Doom 3 engine. If you like overclocking, though, get the 7950GT. (7950GT + Aftermarket Cooler = 7900GTX)
 
I'd go with Nvidia because I dont think you'll enjoy the ATI's catalyst control center at all. It takes forever to load and slow downs your boot up time. I own a 1900xt and I will no longer purchase ati's products due to poor written software.
 
tbh dont listen to what poeple say here, listen to the reviews people write on like tomshardware, hexus etc etc... cus they have tested the cards on games, and thats what you like to know yes? how they perform in games? :)
 
Battleneter2 said:
The X1950pro overclocks like crap,, Not one of ATI's better cards. As my 7950Gt overclocks and benchmarks to the same as the 7900GTX so the X1950 for $30 less as in the original post is a shit buy. The X1900Xt 256MB would be a great option.

No arguments from me. For $200 it's not a bad card but when they cost more than that, better off to spend $250 on the X1950XT. I don't think you can find X1900XT for sale anymore ? 7950GT OCd may = 7900GTX performance but I know X1900XT OCd = 7900GTX performance too and it offers additional useful features. I know X1950Pro doesn't OC well but what about X1950XT ?

CCC may suck but who uses it really ? drivers + atitool is all you need.
:)

But there is a good argument to be made for something really cheap. i.e. 7900GS
Why drop a lot on a dx9 card at this time ? :confused:
 
Stereophile said:
No arguments from me. For $200 it's not a bad card but when they cost more than that, better off to spend $250 on the X1950XT. I don't think you can find X1900XT for sale anymore ? 7950GT OCd may = 7900GTX performance but I know X1900XT OCd = 7900GTX performance too and it offers additional useful features. I know X1950Pro doesn't OC well but what about X1950XT ?

CCC may suck but who uses it really ? drivers + atitool is all you need.
:)

But there is a good argument to be made for something really cheap. i.e. 7900GS
Why drop a lot on a dx9 card at this time ? :confused:

I agree, there is no need to install the Control Centre on ATI. I believe the X1900XT 256MB would be the slightly better buy than the 7950GT if they are at similar cost based on performance alone.

The 7900GS is a slower than the X1950Pro (stock speeds)
The X1950 Pro is a bit slower than the 7950GT (stock speeds)
The 7950GT is a bit slower than the X1900XT (256Mb version) (stock speeds)

The 7900GS can O/C to within 10% ish of the 7900GT stock speeds and much faster than X1950pro O/C or not.

The X1950Pro can't overclock for crap
The 7950GT can O/C to GTX speed and a lot faster than X1950pro O/C
The X1900XT can O/C to XTX speed wich is a bit faster than GTX in most games.
The 8800GTX is the destroyer of all cards!

Hmm than was kinda fun
 
Actually, from what I've seen with my friend's card and online I think the 7900GS can overclock to a good bit beyond the 7900GT's stock speeds (and surpass a stock 7900GT in performance).
 
Bah. All told, I'm leaning towards grabbing the X1950XT right now. It's like.. $30 more than the 7950GT, all told after tax and shipping. And no waiting on an $80 eVGA rebate that may or may not come in.

The overclocking side of the 7950 sounds fun, but it also sounds like it's a moot point by that time with either card?
 
Good call on the X1950XT. I would have gotten it, but it was a little too expensive and I wanted something silent and especially cool, so I got the Sapphire X1950Pro with the Zalman cooler pre-installed.
 
stealthy123 said:
x1950pro overclocks is a driver issue so people flaming it need to be more patient.


Well by all means once or if it is fixed recommend away. In the mean time the better advice is steer clear as there are better alternatives.
 
ButterFlyEffect78 said:
I'd go with Nvidia because I dont think you'll enjoy the ATI's catalyst control center at all. It takes forever to load and slow downs your boot up time. I own a 1900xt and I will no longer purchase ati's products due to poor written software.


Well bro no one uses the CCC you can just install the drivers and thats all you need. CCC's have always sucked but you don't have to use em so its a none issue for most.
 
stealthy123 said:
Well bro no one uses the CCC you can just install the drivers and thats all you need. CCC's have always sucked but you don't have to use em so its a none issue for most.


Are you sure about that though? I tried that before but I couldnt find a way to access options like AA , AF , etc......or maybe i missed something...
 
ButterFlyEffect78 said:
Are you sure about that though? I tried that before but I couldnt find a way to access options like AA , AF , etc......or maybe i missed something...
I think it's that the card runs fine with just the display driver download, and everybody uses good 3rd-party tools like ATT, ATiTool, or RivaTuner to control the special settings.

They all tend to have more options than CCC would, anyway.
 
The Goose said:
Good call on the X1950XT. I would have gotten it, but it was a little too expensive and I wanted something silent and especially cool, so I got the Sapphire X1950Pro with the Zalman cooler pre-installed.

I got one of eVGA's 512mb 7900GT KO's (factory OC'd to 560/1500) and it easily OCs to 650/1700 (haven't tried higher) with a Zalman VF900 on low (ultra quiet and no game has crashed due to heat besides CoD2, but CoD2 always crashes). It was only $300 at Newegg a few months ago. They also had a 512mb x1900XT I was debating, but now I wish I took it instead :(

I'm also bummed that they're not easy to find since they were only out for a few weeks. I had intended on going SLI. Had I gotten the XT, I could be looking at a CrossFire setup since I've got a 975X chipset. Oh well.

It does play games extremely well @ 1600x1200 though.
 
Pooky said:
I got one of eVGA's 512mb 7900GT KO's (factory OC'd to 560/1500) and it easily OCs to 650/1700 (haven't tried higher) with a Zalman VF900 on low (ultra quiet and no game has crashed due to heat besides CoD2, but CoD2 always crashes). It was only $300 at Newegg a few months ago. They also had a 512mb x1900XT I was debating, but now I wish I took it instead :(

I'm also bummed that they're not easy to find since they were only out for a few weeks. I had intended on going SLI. Had I gotten the XT, I could be looking at a CrossFire setup since I've got a 975X chipset. Oh well.

It does play games extremely well @ 1600x1200 though.

I am in the same situation you are - I have the eVGA 512MB 7900GT KO with a Zalman VF900-Cu on a 975X chipset. Don't feel bad about not getting the X1900 XT 512MB - it's much more than the $300 you paid for your 7900GT. Also, the 512MB 7900GT KO runs at a higher voltage than other 7900GT's, uses the same memory modules as the 7900GTX, and is clocked about the same as eVGA's Signature Series model. Basically, you got yourself a silent, single-slot 7900GTX for $300 plus the price of the cooler.

What temperatures are you getting with that thing? Try turning up the Zalman all the way and seeing how high on the core you can get (I'm away from my computer for a few days, so I can't do it myself). I think you might be able to hit 700MHz, stable.
 
Back
Top