Need help with a new build

DudeItsMe

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Aug 10, 2004
Messages
15,720
Well guys I think it's finally time to replace this aging dinosaur on my desk... I built it in July of 2003. Unfortunately I'm not quite as hardware savvy as I once was (or I just realize I'm not as hardware savvy as I thought I was) so I'm going to need a bit of help.

I want to build something that is fast but keep the noise on the system down as low as possible (using only air cooling though). So the quieter, the better.

CPU - C2D of course, but which one
Mobo - I have no idea where to start here, there's so many... I want something that can handle a 2-4 hard drives and a generous amount of RAM. Possibly with SLI support for future expansion
RAM - Whatever works with the mobo, at least 2 GB, more if needed
Power Supply - ??? Again I want something that will run very quiet but power the system...
Video Card - Something NVidia... not the top of the line but something with a lot of bang for the buck... I imagine this will cost around $400ish
Hard Drive - Seagate 7200.10... probably 2 x 500 GB or maybe 3 x 500 GB if the system will fit it

I have a Antec P180 case I can use for this build, I plan on keeping my speakers, and I might reuse the Audigy 2 ZS Platinum Pro that I have... still undecided on that. I'm open to any suggestions, I don't really have a budget but I'd say keep the total cost under $2000. I also plan to buy another monitor (currently have one Gateway 22" Widescreen, would like another).

I know I don't have much of this worked out yet but I would like suggestions from people who are a bit more up-to-date on computers than I am. Any help is appreciated.
 
Well guys I think it's finally time to replace this aging dinosaur on my desk... I built it in July of 2003. Unfortunately I'm not quite as hardware savvy as I once was (or I just realize I'm not as hardware savvy as I thought I was) so I'm going to need a bit of help.

I want to build something that is fast but keep the noise on the system down as low as possible (using only air cooling though). So the quieter, the better.

CPU - C2D of course, but which one
Mobo - I have no idea where to start here, there's so many... I want something that can handle a 2-4 hard drives and a generous amount of RAM. Possibly with SLI support for future expansion
RAM - Whatever works with the mobo, at least 2 GB, more if needed
Power Supply - ??? Again I want something that will run very quiet but power the system...
Video Card - Something NVidia... not the top of the line but something with a lot of bang for the buck... I imagine this will cost around $400ish
Hard Drive - Seagate 7200.10... probably 2 x 500 GB or maybe 3 x 500 GB if the system will fit it

I have a Antec P180 case I can use for this build, I plan on keeping my speakers, and I might reuse the Audigy 2 ZS Platinum Pro that I have... still undecided on that. I'm open to any suggestions, I don't really have a budget but I'd say keep the total cost under $2000. I also plan to buy another monitor (currently have one Gateway 22" Widescreen, would like another).

I know I don't have much of this worked out yet but I would like suggestions from people who are a bit more up-to-date on computers than I am. Any help is appreciated.

PSU = corsair 620.
Video = 8800gts 640mb will work good and fast with the monitor you have.
memory = pc6400(800) 2-4gb's, gskill? maybe
cpu/mainboard not sure, depends if you are going to overclock.
 
CPU- e6600 - 275$
mobo- asus commando- 230$ (or around that range)
ram- I'd go with the OCZ reapers, My freind has a 2 gig set and cooling/performance wise, they're awesome. - 240$
Power supply- any silverstone ps with the proper wattage.
Video card- BFG 8800gts 640 oc2- I dunno like in the 500 range, more than 400 but it's worth it.
HD- 2x seagate 500gb drives 10krpm- 280$

and with money left to spare.
 
CPU- e6600 - 275$
mobo- asus commando- 230$ (or around that range)
ram- I'd go with the OCZ reapers, My freind has a 2 gig set and cooling/performance wise, they're awesome. - 240$
Power supply- any silverstone ps with the proper wattage.
Video card- BFG 8800gts 640 oc2- I dunno like in the 500 range, more than 400 but it's worth it.
HD- 2x seagate 500gb drives 10krpm- 280$

and with money left to spare.

2gb's for 240? PC6400 is like less then 50 a gig even for gskill. if you overclock/dont overclock the pc6400 will work great. Your friend got ripped off i think.
The OP could wait until july 22 and get a quad core.
 
FYI the earliest I would be ordering this build is two weeks from today, the latest probably four weeks from today. I'm definetly planning on building it though, I'm itching to upgrade.... I could wait if there was a much better deal coming up soon though.
 
FYI the earliest I would be ordering this build is two weeks from today, the latest probably four weeks from today. I'm definetly planning on building it though, I'm itching to upgrade.... I could wait if there was a much better deal coming up soon though.

July 22 is the "big" drop in prices on intel. I am waiting for it. Quad core Q6600 for $266....... Droool.

You could buy the motherboard, memory, harddrives, video card, power supply, and then get an e4300 or something cheap for now. Id get a good aftermarket cooler also. Then when july 22 comes u could see what is available. :)

I wouldnt pay $240 for 2gb's of memory, 2x1gb's of gskill, crucial, etc can be had for less then 100 easily and thats for the 800mhz stuff(pc6400).
I cant say what motherboard to get as i wouldnt spend $200 one. I just got the asus p5b, overclocked my old 2.8 pentium D to 3.36 easily.
 
2gb's for 240? PC6400 is like less then 50 a gig even for gskill. if you overclock/dont overclock the pc6400 will work great. Your friend got ripped off i think.
The OP could wait until july 22 and get a quad core.


Well, that's canadian currency and taxes included. They had cheaper ram with similar timings for a lower price, but he'd heard good things about this ram.


edit: specs on the reapers http://www.pccanada.com/viewitem.asp?id=6109
 
I would have to ask, are those hard drives IDE or SATA? Most new motherboards have 1 IDE slot, so you might wanna watch out.
 
Well guys I think it's finally time to replace this aging dinosaur on my desk... I built it in July of 2003. Unfortunately I'm not quite as hardware savvy as I once was (or I just realize I'm not as hardware savvy as I thought I was) so I'm going to need a bit of help.

I want to build something that is fast but keep the noise on the system down as low as possible (using only air cooling though). So the quieter, the better.

CPU - C2D of course, but which one
Mobo - I have no idea where to start here, there's so many... I want something that can handle a 2-4 hard drives and a generous amount of RAM. Possibly with SLI support for future expansion
RAM - Whatever works with the mobo, at least 2 GB, more if needed
Power Supply - ??? Again I want something that will run very quiet but power the system...
Video Card - Something NVidia... not the top of the line but something with a lot of bang for the buck... I imagine this will cost around $400ish
Hard Drive - Seagate 7200.10... probably 2 x 500 GB or maybe 3 x 500 GB if the system will fit it

I have a Antec P180 case I can use for this build, I plan on keeping my speakers, and I might reuse the Audigy 2 ZS Platinum Pro that I have... still undecided on that. I'm open to any suggestions, I don't really have a budget but I'd say keep the total cost under $2000. I also plan to buy another monitor (currently have one Gateway 22" Widescreen, would like another).

I know I don't have much of this worked out yet but I would like suggestions from people who are a bit more up-to-date on computers than I am. Any help is appreciated.

CPU: E6420 C2D. Will hit 3.2Ghz+ with an aftermarket cooler like the Tuniq Tower ($50ish, very good cooler), which you can reuse should you decide to replace the chip later. I've been very happy with mine. Around $180 USD for the E6420.

Motherboard: eVGA 122-CK-NF68-T1, has a 2 year warranty. the A1 version has a lifetime warranty. If that matters to you, go with the A1. They're pretty much undisputed the best 680i boards right now, and eVGA unlike other manufacturers has confirmed they will support newer 45nm 1333Mhz FSB CPUs via a BIOS update when the time comes. This combined with their awesome customer service makes the choice a no-brainer if you'd like SLI as an option in the future and want a stable, well-supported board that OCs like a beast. $180-250 depending on the model and what deal you get, but well worth it.

PSU: Corsair HX620 or PC Power and Cooling Silencer 750 Quad. All depends on budget here, but either run cool and will handle 8800GTX's in SLI without issue. Higher end Thermaltake Toughpower line or Silverstone Zeus line are also a good option.

RAM: 2GB of G.Skill/Geil/Corsair (non Value RAM)/whatever DDR2-800, cheapest/lowest timings you can find. 4-4-4-16 is better than 5-5-5-18, is what I mean. Will run around $85-100

GPU/video: Geforce 8800 GTS 640MB. It's pretty much a must with a display that size. The 320MB card will be VRAM-limited. Prices fluxuate a bit, check HotDeals. Spring for a GTX if you can afford it, though I know you said not top end. You get 128 as opposed to 96 stream processors and another 128MB of VRAM, so if you don't plan to replace it for a long time, it might be money well spent.

Haddrives: Seagate 7200.10 all the way, whatever size you can afford.
 
Thanks for the informative post, silent-circuit.... that helps a lot in planning my build.

For the power supply, which line do you think would offer the quietest operation? I'm really looking to have this thing be pretty quiet (although it doesn't have to be perfect) and it seems to me that the power supply usually is a big source of noise, so I'd like to get that under control in this build.

As for the video card, I shouldn't say I don't want top of the line, but I don't want to pay a premium price for something that is new and shiny just because it's new and shiny. If it's more expensive but gives a considerable gain over other cards, then I'm willing to buy it. Remember, I will be running two Gateway 22" widescreens, so I need something that will handle that well

RAM - I take it 2 GB is all that is necessary? I wasn't quite sure about what all I would need, but my current computer is running 2 GB and I've never reached full usage.

Also, would it be safe to keep running Windows XP Pro for this build, or should I seriously consider Vista? I can buy Vista if it would be needed or a good idea, but from what I've heard a lot of people aren't sure about it yet.

I'll try to update with general prices and such of all the stuff I'm looking at soon.... I appreciate all the help so far guys.
 
Thanks for the informative post, silent-circuit.... that helps a lot in planning my build.

For the power supply, which line do you think would offer the quietest operation? I'm really looking to have this thing be pretty quiet (although it doesn't have to be perfect) and it seems to me that the power supply usually is a big source of noise, so I'd like to get that under control in this build.

As for the video card, I shouldn't say I don't want top of the line, but I don't want to pay a premium price for something that is new and shiny just because it's new and shiny. If it's more expensive but gives a considerable gain over other cards, then I'm willing to buy it. Remember, I will be running two Gateway 22" widescreens, so I need something that will handle that well

RAM - I take it 2 GB is all that is necessary? I wasn't quite sure about what all I would need, but my current computer is running 2 GB and I've never reached full usage.

Also, would it be safe to keep running Windows XP Pro for this build, or should I seriously consider Vista? I can buy Vista if it would be needed or a good idea, but from what I've heard a lot of people aren't sure about it yet.

I'll try to update with general prices and such of all the stuff I'm looking at soon.... I appreciate all the help so far guys.

Seasonic has a reputation for really good quality and quiet operation. The Corsair units are actually made by Seasonic. Some PC P&C (now an OCZ company) models aren't very quiet. Check out the reviews at jonnyguru.com for more PSU insight.

With dual 22" monitors, you don't need SLI. Go for a single 8800GTX if its within your budget. Its expensive because it has no competition... it isn't exactly new, but it is the most recent incarnation of the high end GeForce GPU from NVIDIA. Both companies have left a huge gap in price/performance in the $150 - $250 range. You basically get what you pay for right now, and the best value would be the 8800GTS. FYI, if you choose to stay with SLI, keep in mind that when you switch to SLI mode, you will only be gaming on a single monitor (unless NVIDIA has updated their drivers).

Yes, 2GB is all you really need right now. To use 4GB or more, you'd need a 64-bit OS to take full advantage of it.

XP would be my choice OS for now. Vista is nice and all, but theres no real need for it unless you want the eye candy. The only reason I would move to Vista is for DX10, which is useless right now since there are hardly any DX10 games (or did more come out already? hehe).
 
I was only planning on using SLI later on when cards became cheaper... say whatever card I buy now drops down a few hundred dollars to where I can buy a second one relatively cheap. I'm not really planning on SLI to be a huge part of the build, just an option for future expansion.

Thanks for reminding me about johnnyguru.com. I completely forgot about that site, but you're right, it would be a good place to check for power supply reviews.
 
Well, I'll personally state that in my P180 my Silencer 750 is inaudible. That's if I turn the case fans /off/ (and they're Yate Loons, so I can hardly tell if they're on or off). Then all I can hear is the whirrr from the pump on the stupid Thermaltake watercooling. It is, however, non-modular, and some people really really don't like that, so there's your heads up.
 
If you want SLI then I agree the only board to get is the EVGA 680i. Otherwise, you're better off with a single GTS 640 meg or GTX card and a P35-based motherboard.

However, I also agree with Enginurd that SLI will not be worth it in your case, even when that second card dips down in price. These days, SLI is only worth it if a) you're planning on getting two of the best card available (sans 8800 Ultra) -- i.e. 2 8800 GTX cards, and b) you're gaming on a monitor with a resolution of at least 1920x1200 (which, in terms of size, usually means 24inch or larger.)

Even if your plan to purchase the second card down the line as a performance boost for your single card setup, you'll be better off just replacing the single card for a similar price (as the boost will be much greater and the setup much simpler.) This is especially true if you decide to get the 8800 GTS now, as two 8800 GTS don't even provide enough benefit over a single GTX card to be worth the extra price and complexity.

Good luck,

Mark.
 
SLI as an upgrade path isn't a very cost effective solution, either, unless you plan on getting a larger monitor (24" or larger) in the future along with two new high end cards to go with it. I'll use myself as an example:

If I wanted to upgrade to an SLI config, I'd need to buy a 7800GT off of eBay for around $150, worst case scenario, since they're no longer available brand new at a reasonable price. Now, instead of buying another GT, I could sell mine for around $150, best case scenario. Add that to the $150 I was willing to shell out for the 2nd GT, and now the budget is $300. I could get an 8800GTS for around $270, and it outperforms a 7800GT SLI setup.
 
OK so it sounds like SLI is not going to be the way to go. I considered getting 24" displays before, but I think I'll be happy with two 22" widescreens for quite some time... they're very large and definetly an excellent display. I would definetly say a card that is $500 - $600 is not out of budget, although it's hard to say exactly how much I'll be spending until I figure out the cost of everything else.

I will likely wait until the Intel price drop before ordering a CPU, although I doubt that would make a huge difference in what motherboard I need. I would definetly like something with plenty of SATA ports, since I'll probably start off with 2x DVD drives and 2x hard drives. Also, I take it DDR2 800 is the best memory I'm going to need?I I see there are boards that allow for faster memory, but if it's not going to give me a performance difference I probably won't bother.
 
OK so it sounds like SLI is not going to be the way to go. I considered getting 24" displays before, but I think I'll be happy with two 22" widescreens for quite some time... they're very large and definetly an excellent display. I would definetly say a card that is $500 - $600 is not out of budget, although it's hard to say exactly how much I'll be spending until I figure out the cost of everything else.

I will likely wait until the Intel price drop before ordering a CPU, although I doubt that would make a huge difference in what motherboard I need. I would definetly like something with plenty of SATA ports, since I'll probably start off with 2x DVD drives and 2x hard drives. Also, I take it DDR2 800 is the best memory I'm going to need?I I see there are boards that allow for faster memory, but if it's not going to give me a performance difference I probably won't bother.

If you're OCing linked and synced with a fairly high multiplier processor (E6420, E6600, Q6600) you're pretty much guaranteed you'll never hit FSB high enough to make use of anything faster than DDR2-800. People have run tests and shown there is little to no performance benefit with the Core2 chips to running with a higher divider (and thusly higher speed for the RAM but looser timings) doesn't give any real performance improvement in most cases.

If you're going single card and don't want SLI, get a P35-based board. Gigabyte is a good option, from what I've read.
 
id seriously consider using windows vista as it has gotten much better, and in the next year you will want it anyways, so why not just take the plunge and not have to spend $150 later?
 
Buy Vista, if you really don't like it then you can use your COA on a XP install.
 
I've been thinking about it for the past few days, and you guys are right, I should go with Vista. Since some game will require it, why shortchange myself now and have to get it later? Plus, it will give me something to play with for a while.

On that note, should I go for 4 GB memory? I think I read somewhere that it's good for Vista, or maybe that was 2 GB.
 
If you're going Vista, go Vista x64, and if you're going that route, then yes, 4GB all the way. If you simply choose not to go the 64 bit route (and I can't see any legit reason not to), then 2GB is fine for Vista x86 (the 32 bit editions). Vista x64 can access and use all the 4GB if you go that route whereas Vista x86 wouldn't be able to "see" and use all of it. There's a "sticky" in the Operating System forum (in the forum FAQs thread) about the 3GB RAM issues with 32 bit OSes, might be interesting reading for you sometime.

If this box is intended to last you a while, I say it's 64 bit or nothing... go for it. :)
 
If you're going Vista, go Vista x64, and if you're going that route, then yes, 4GB all the way. If you simply choose not to go the 64 bit route (and I can't see any legit reason not to), then 2GB is fine for Vista x86 (the 32 bit editions). Vista x64 can access and use all the 4GB if you go that route whereas Vista x86 wouldn't be able to "see" and use all of it. There's a "sticky" in the Operating System forum (in the forum FAQs thread) about the 3GB RAM issues with 32 bit OSes, might be interesting reading for you sometime.

If this box is intended to last you a while, I say it's 64 bit or nothing... go for it. :)

Drivers. That'd be the main reason not to go 64bit Vista.

And compatibility issues. Coming from experience on both counts, here. I ran it for a week, said 'forget this' and went back to the 32 bit version. It was faster, but not worth the regular issues. I'd still be running XP were it not for DX10 -- Vista's been nothing but trouble for me. Also don't like the UI and all my old XP themes don't work, but... that's another issue entirely..

Pay the extra for the retail version if you think you might want to go 64bit. It comes with both 64 and 32bit DVDs, and the key will work for both version. I believe the OEM keys only work for the version they're sold with.
 
The driver situation has improved considerably for Vista x64. I, myself, have had no driver issues with the OS.

Mark.
 
Drivers. That'd be the main reason not to go 64bit Vista.

And compatibility issues. Coming from experience on both counts, here. I ran it for a week, said 'forget this' and went back to the 32 bit version. It was faster, but not worth the regular issues. I'd still be running XP were it not for DX10 -- Vista's been nothing but trouble for me. Also don't like the UI and all my old XP themes don't work, but... that's another issue entirely..

Pay the extra for the retail version if you think you might want to go 64bit. It comes with both 64 and 32bit DVDs, and the key will work for both version. I believe the OEM keys only work for the version they're sold with.

That's your experience, and that's perfectly fine, for you, but the overwhelming majority of people that run Vista x64 nowadays don't have the complaints you're making. More drivers come out every single day, and any games or software period that come out with the the "Vista Ready" or "Vista Compatible" or "Made for Vista" logo on them have passed 32 bit and 64 bit testing and must be completely compatible under both OS platforms; that's a requirement of the Vista logo program now.

That applies to hardware also: if it's got one of the Microsoft Vista logos on the box, it'll be supported in both 32 bit and 64 bit versions of Vista.

Also, the only way you get both 32 bit and 64 bit install DVDs at the time of purchase is to buy Ultimate in the Retail box. That's it. Of course you could buy an OEM 32 bit version and an OEM 64 bit version at the same time, cost twice the money basically but still cheaper than a Retail Vista Ultimate box. :)

One last thing: If you buy any Retail box edition other than Ultimate you can order the 64 bit DVD from Microsoft (they do not sell Retail versions of Vista x64 - that's only in the Ultimate Retail box) for roughly $10, cost of shipping and handling.

If you get a 32 bit OEM "system builder" version of Vista, any edition, you are not entitled to that ~$10 64 bit installer DVD. Soooo... take that under consideration when it comes to the purchase. If you choose an OEM version, make it the 64 bit because that's the only way you'll get that 64 bit DVD - if you pay for it.

Hope this helps...
 
Wow, so many things about Vista that I never knew since I haven't been able to keep up with stuff. Thanks for the informative post, I'll definetly be looking into getting Vista now. I've got a lot of money to spend for this, so I have room to get the fancy stuff.
 
OK it looks like it's time to bump this thread and get this thing built.

I've made a wish list of all the things I think I'll need for this build... you can view it here:

Wish List

I am open to different brands on the motherboard, CPU, and memory... I mostly went with what looked like a good value that wouldn't slow me down. However if there is something I should change, let me know.

Is there anything I'm missing from this build? Small things I might want? I know I should have all the cables and such included with the parts, so hopefully I'm OK there. I guess I forgot to add an aftermarket CPU cooler, but I would like something that is quiet.

Also, I didn't spend a ton of time making this wish list, since I'm getting ready to head out of the house, so I'm sure it needs some review. Any help that could be offered would be appreciated.
 
Go with either the Tuniq Tower 120 or Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme w/ Scythe S-Flex fan. Don't forget some Arctic Silver 5.
 
Consider grabbing an XFX 8800 Ultra from ZipZoomFly for $600 - $50 MIR if you want one, though the GTX is a very good deal.

Looks fine, really.
 
Sucks... looks like they sold out of the Quad 6600. Guess I'll be waiting now (or possibly ordering it elsewhere)

Well, I ended up ordering it from Mwave thanks to the [H]otDeals forum here.

I also added a Tuniq Tower 120 and some Arctic Silver 5 to the Newegg order, so hopefully that's gonna be everything I will need.

Thanks to everyone that contributed to my thread/build... it's always nice to have advice when spending such a large amount of money. Maybe if I would have been better advised on my first build, I wouldn't have a freaking toaster in my computer now (P4) :)
 
Back
Top