Need Help Choosing Processor

[TooncesLives]

I was recently budgeted funds to replace 15 of our 20 workstations in our main office at the University (the remaining 5 were replaced last year). The only guideline is they need to be OptiPlex GX620's, and if I go with a straight P4 I have to choose the 3.4ghz processor. When looking at the configuration options, I see that I can either go with the 3.4, or I can a Pentium D 3ghz for the same price (few bucks less actually). The head of computing said it's up to me with what I want, so I'm asking here. The machines will be used for day-to-day receptionist activities (word, powerpoint, access and visio), and two will be used for Rails development. Any input as to the better processor would be appreciated.

 

[Stugots]

...word, powerpoint, access and visio...

Either of those processors will be more than enough. As long as the systems have at least 512mb of ram they will be fine.

 

[TooncesLives]

I figured that either would cut it....they will have a gig of ram. They will be in place for 4 years, and will be running Vista (if it's ever released), so I guess I'm wondering if one processor would be better than the other once that happens. I don't think it's going to make a serious difference one way or the other, but I didn't think it would hurt to ask.

 

[Eva_Unit_0]

I'd go with the pentium D. Dual core for less than the single core sounds like a great idea, especially since that 400mhz will never be missed. I think dual core is the way to go if they're going to be in place for 4 years...hopefully things will be decently multithreaded by then.

 

[wee96]

The Pentium D will give you some extra oomph when programs start to become more multi-thread friendly and it will make a much nicer computing experience for the employees, id definately go with that vs. the 3.4ghz p4 if it were my choice.

 

[ICE_9]

Pent D vote here.