Need help choosing a MB

Snoozer

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 2, 2009
Messages
205
Been thinking of a new project and thus need a new MB. My requirements are as follows:

  1. I'm looking for future upgradability (Socket 775 looks doable), but I don't need a cutting edge board.
  2. Pricing up to about $300 is okay.
  3. AMD vs Intel: Not sure which way to go as I have been an AMD fan boy for 20 years and currently am running a dual core Opteron. What's the fastest with the mostest?
  4. Has to be fairly easy to get off the stock cooling hardware as I will be water cooling.
  5. As I am water cooling I'm not overly concerned about chipset overheating problems.
  6. Has to have decent OC capability and good stability. A new MB is to be avoided just like a version 1 of anything MS makes. ;)
  7. Has to have lot's of SATA ports as I will be running three (3) 10,000 rpm Raptor drives and three (3) SATA optical drives.
  8. I like ASUS boards, but am open to other high quality brands.
  9. Will probably end of with a single 280 class board.

I was looking at this ASUS Striker II Formula MB because someone makes a nice chipset water block for it. Was also thinking of this set of OCZ RAM modules to power the thing.
I would like to retain my present PCP&C Turbo-Cool 510 SLI if at all possible.
 
775 is dead... so I wouldnt bet on much 'upgradability' other than whats out there already. Intel claims they will keep 775 going, but thats just so we keep buying their back stock (Asus in particular) so they dont get stuck with it. Intel says the same thing every time they change sockets, and those who believe it always get screwed. Look at it this way... they canned socket 1066 plans, and dropped the price on the i7 920's well enough that they arent likely looking at splitting up the line into two platforms, and if they arent even going to develop that, you can pretty much count on 775 being a dead end. If you want an upgradable intel, you need to look at socket 1366. Unless you want to pay $$$, ir you see yourself really wanting SLi, I would suggest waiting for the P55 chipsets instead.
 
Thanks for the reply. After reading your post and doing some sniffing around I'm inclined to sit back a while. Let the trees shake a bit and see what falls out in the market.

My dual core Opteron 180 running at 3Ghz is looking better and better. Perhaps what I should do is just upgrade my 6600 GT video card. :D
 
I dont know what you use your computer for, but for games, yes, I would say a 6600GT is well-aged. BFGtech has a couple nVidia GTX 280/285 cards that already have the waterblock on them. These cards would get you up to top speed on every game out there.

Otherwise, if you like AMD, bang for the buck, a 790GX motherboard ($110-140) and a phenom 2 940 ($220) is a great combo. The Phenom2 is an AM2+ OR AM3 chip, so if you decide you want to step up to DDR3 later on when prices come down, you can do that with the same proc... turn the 790GX into a home theater PC or something (it has on-board DX10 graphics so you dont even need a video card). Dont let the integrated graphics fool you though... the 790GX is the latest and highest overclocking chipset for the Phenoms. IMO, they just added the integrated GPU to eliminate the need for seperate products... the board also supports crossfire for dual video cards... so its more that they wanted it to be the most flexible (attractive to the broadest range of customers) motherboard possible. At least thats how I see it... rather than having 3 or 4 'levels' of chipsets available, and the seperate development of each one, just concentrate on making one that covers everything and drive costs down by only concentrating on that one chipset... a good idea in todays economy as well. This also adds into why I find Intel's claims that the 775 isnt going to be killed off to be nothing more than an attempt to clear out existing stockpiles... further development of the 775 CPU's wouldn't make any economic sense... not with the i7's pricing dropping so fast (negating the need for 1066 sockets as well), right into 775 range.
 
I went from a 3.0Ghz opty 165 to a 4.0Ghz Core i7 920.

Using the same video card, I saw FPS in my games go up dramatically. I'd say go core i7 if you like to do video encoding and stuff.

Otherwise, if you're just in it for games, wait for AM3. Phenom 2 is holding it's own against core i7 in games (even if it gets mauled in other applications and benchmarks).

Either way, I think that waiting is the best idea. Core i7 is not selling as well as Intel wants, and AMD has a product that will be competitive in games. If I were you, I'd just sit still until spring, when tax rebates come back, and then go for it. By then, AM3 should be out, and prices on core i7 should be lower. You will have much better options.
 
If I were you, I'd just sit still until spring, when tax rebates come back, and then go for it. By then, AM3 should be out, and prices on core i7 should be lower. You will have much better options.

I like options and my Fed tax refund is getting deposited in 10 days. :D California refund is probably going to be a while... :mad:

Am thinking of an AM3 with a 790GX or better chipset or perhaps an i7 if they drop a whiole lot of money. :D

Otherwise, if you like AMD, bang for the buck, a 790GX motherboard ($110-140) and a phenom 2 940 ($220) is a great combo. The Phenom2 is an AM2+ OR AM3 chip, so if you decide you want to step up to DDR3 later on when prices come down, you can do that with the same proc... turn the 790GX into a home theater PC or something (it has on-board DX10 graphics so you dont even need a video card). Dont let the integrated graphics fool you though... the 790GX is the latest and highest overclocking chipset for the Phenoms. IMO, they just added the integrated GPU to eliminate the need for seperate products... the board also supports crossfire for dual video cards... so its more that they wanted it to be the most flexible (attractive to the broadest range of customers) motherboard possible.

How does the AMD solution OC on water?
 
I like options and my Fed tax refund is getting deposited in 10 days. :D California refund is probably going to be a while... :mad:

Am thinking of an AM3 with a 790GX or better chipset or perhaps an i7 if they drop a whiole lot of money. :D



How does the AMD solution OC on water?

Be advised the amd 920 and 940are only ddr2 compatable..the next release of cpu's due out any day are am3 and have 2 memory controllers onboard,ddr2 and ddr3 so they can be used in an am2+ board or an am3 motherboard using ddr3 ram...
Myself im waiting on the these cpu's as it gives me the ability to use it in my current am2+ board and upgrading to the am3 boards and only have to buy motherboard and ram at one time......
 
Good point... the current 920 and 940 phenom II's are only DDR2 compatible... the future ones will be DDR2/3.

The AMD 940 is reported to hit 4.4GHz on water.

As for tax refunds... got all mine back last month!

I also can no longer suggest the Asus 790GX...
http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1392207

That heatsink is major FAIL (pivots like a teeter-totter and pins popped right off!). If I could do it all over again, I would get the MSI MSI DKA790GX Platinum instead.

My original intent was to simply take a small step from my 590SLi mobo... I had planned on i7/X58, but then I found out my dual 8800GTS 512's wouldnt be supported in SLi by the x58 chipset... so that kills that idea. My upgrade to an x58 would mean either only using one 8800 GTS, or a whole new card. Being that the price of x58's is pretty high to start, plus the DDR3 ram... Im waiting as well. So in the meantime, I have extra AM2+ chips, so I decided to 'take it in the pants' and ditch the 8800GTS's for a single GTX 285... so my future options dont hinge on needing SLi (something I cant honestly say is worth paying more for... more for the PSU, more for the mobo, etc.)

Being that I find my 590 SLi 'buggy', at least in its current form, I planned on giving that to the woman with just one card (it operated fine with a single card and the x2 4400 CPU), and 'side step' to a 790GX board (picked over the 780G board for phenom II and x2 6400 power requirements that many G's dont have). DDR2 ram is dirt cheap, and it would allow me to upgrade to an AM3 P2/x4 later on to eek out some more life.

Well, the Asus board might not have been the best idea for this... shoulda gone MSI instead. Still... its a dirt cheap upgrade path... 790GX, some 1066 ram, x2 CPU for now, GTX 285 is more $$$ than all of that. Then, later in the year, swap out the x2 6400 for a phenom x4. By the time that cheap upgrade runs out of steam, P55's should be out, or x58's and DDR3 should be so cheap I can upgrade to i7 for much less than now (1/2 as much?). Thats what makes me hesitate on i7's at least... I dont want to buy something that expensive knowing its most likely going to drop like a rock in the next few months (i7's arent selling well).

Advice to intel: Shoulda started out with lesser 1366 chipsets rather than starting with the x58 (the axe came down on the socket 1066 already... a good indicator). The x58's might drop so much by the time P55's come out that it isnt even worth having two lines (cheaper to focus on making just x58's). People are strapped for cash right now after all.
 
The Phenom2 is an AM2+ OR AM3 chip, so if you decide you want to step up to DDR3 later on when prices come down, you can do that with the same proc...
Wrong. AM2+ CPUs are not forwards-compatible. The AM3 chips will work with AM2+, but not vice-versa.
 
I also can no longer suggest the Asus 790GX...
http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1392207

That heatsink is major FAIL (pivots like a teeter-totter and pins popped right off!). If I could do it all over again, I would get the MSI MSI DKA790GX Platinum instead.

Since I plan on WC all the chips and voltage regulators this sounds like a positive. Less work getting the little buggers off the board. ;)
 
Back
Top