Need advice : Upgrade or Build new?

jEnkinsX

Limp Gawd
Joined
Apr 23, 2005
Messages
282
Ignore that rig in my sig.. that was an OLD rig i had last year :(

Ok currently, i have an:
AMD Athlon 64 3500+ Venice
eVGA mATX SLI motherboard
2x512MB Corsair Value ram
ATI Radeon X850XTPE

Obviously im upgrading to play all the new games that are out.. or coming out soon.. so..

Should i get an Opteron 165, 2x1024MB OCZ Platinum Ed 2-3-2-5 and 8800GT?

or upgrade to a DDr2 system?

well i guess cheaper is better.. but will i be okay with a S939 system?
 
That depends... whats your budget?

An upgrade should involve a dual core CPU ($65 for an X2 4200+, $20 for an AC Freezer 64Pro), another 1GB of RAM ($50), and an 8800GT vidcard (~$250). What motherboard do you have (specific model)? Also, what PSU do you have? What HDDs and optical drives do you have?

If you had around $600 or more, I'd say upgrade everything, lol.
 
That depends... whats your budget?

An upgrade should involve a dual core CPU ($65 for an X2 4200+, $20 for an AC Freezer 64Pro), another 1GB of RAM ($50), and an 8800GT vidcard (~$250). What motherboard do you have (specific model)? Also, what PSU do you have? What HDDs and optical drives do you have?

If you had around $600 or more, I'd say upgrade everything, lol.

my motherboard is this one right here : eVGA 131-K8-NF44

Isnt it bad to be running 4x512MB of ram compared to running 2x1024MBs?

yeah i am planning to go dual core reason i chose the opteron 165..

but if i can sell my stuff.. im planning on getting an AMD 64 X2 5000+ B.E., M2N-SLI, 2x1024MB RAM and a 8800GT but of course that'll cost more :(
 
my motherboard is this one right here : eVGA 131-K8-NF44

Isnt it bad to be running 4x512MB of ram compared to running 2x1024MBs?

yeah i am planning to go dual core reason i chose the opteron 165..

but if i can sell my stuff.. im planning on getting an AMD 64 X2 5000+ B.E., M2N-SLI, 2x1024MB RAM and a 8800GT but of course that'll cost more :(

If you can sell your old stuff and afford new I would do that. You can pick up a 3600+ (which is probably about the same performance as a Opty 165) for next to nothing. Also DDR2 RAM has gotten really cheap. If you can reuse your case, optical drives, fans, etc and just get a new graphics card, CPU, MB, and RAM. That would be ideal.

On the other hand, if you dont need the absolute cutting edge an upgrade to a dual core would be much better performance than a single core. If you run 4 sticks of RAM you most likely will have to turn your memory's command rate from 1T to 2T. This will cost you just a little memory performance. Nothing you cant live with. It would be worth it to have 2GB of RAM.

I still use a Socket 939 system with a Opty 170, 2GB OCZ Platnum RAM, and an 8800GTS everyday. It does everything that I need it to do currently, plus still does pretty well in games. Although the next generation of games may be hard on it. Think about the future as well.;)
 
The 4200+ would be cheaper than the opty 165, and it's also easier to OC since it has a higher multiplier.

If you can end up with over $600 after you sell all your stuff, I'd look into an Intel system if you plan on OC'ing. If no OC'ing, then go with AMD.
 
i agree with the 4200+ X2 for $65 and AC Freezer Pro 64 for $20, i just got the Toledo core 4200+ X2 and that same heatsink from the egg and it runs right at 3Ghz on that Freezer Pro 64 at just a touch over stock voltage!!

a dual core 939 at 2.5-3Ghz is going to be just about as fast as most anything out there except for uber overclocked Core 2 Duo's, but then you're talking going from $65 for a CPU to $165 or so....then you need a new mobo, memory, etc.......

hopefully you can get a mint for your old stuff, i took that chance recently, sold an old P4 3.06Ghz CPU and motherboard on ebay, got $81 for the CPU and $125 for the P4C800 Deluxe mobo...those CPU's had been consistently selling for $150 on ebay, i just timed it bad i guess, its a crapshoot on old hardware as far as what you get for it

if you are really into next gen games, you might want to consider selling it all and adding some cash to build a new system.....i got tired of the cycle myself
 
i'd say save your money, unless you need it in the next 5 weeks or so, you should save your money, build a completely new system and use the old one to play music or something, thats what i'm doing, and i end up with like 3 computers and a laptop, instead of selling them all and making an insane computer now, when it might take a bit longer, but at least you will have a pretty darn good computer later as well as another one to do other things while you play games on the main one.
 
Oh, and the larger cache of the Opty isn't as effective as a higher clock speed. Higher clockspeed seems to produce better performance than a larger L2 cache -- of course, at the same speed, the larger L2 cache will win... but like I said, the 4200+ is easier to OC than the Opty 165.
 
you currently have a 939 setup, so we are suggesting the 4200+ X2 in 939 flavor

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16819103543
(manchester core, looks like the egg is out of Toledos)

here's a Toledo

http://www.directron.com/ada4200daa5cd.html

will it be the same performance if i get a AM2?

some guy from a canadian BST site.. is selling a M2N-E + 4200+ = $165 CDN or M2N-SLI Deluxe = $200 CDN..
so im guessing if im spending that much i should just get a C2D cpu/mobo right? Im thinkin E4400 or E6320
but wats a good motherboard thats SLI ready?
 
little to no difference in 939 and AM2, the biggest difference is in the use of DDR2 memory where 939 uses DDR memory, but even then real world performance difference is nil, sure, you can show some bigger numbers in benchmarks, but you'll never feel the difference between comparable 939 and AM2 setups and it's definitely not worth buying a whole new mobo and memory for

if 939/AM2 performance is not enough you might as well go C2D or wait to see what Phenom brings at what price....since you are considering replacing everything, i would wait for now, at least until the holiday season when Phenom is out and we see it in action, i dont expect too much, but the pricing might make it worth it

i have no idea about SLI, never went there, dont plan to
 
You currently have an ATI vidcard with an SLI mobo... do you really need SLI? What size monitor do you have?

SLI is only needed for high resolution 3D rendering. So, if you have or plan on getting a 1920x1080 LCD or higher, and want to game on it at native resolution, then keep SLI as an option. Otherwise, theres no need for it. SLI as an upgrade path isn't worth it unless, again, a large LCD is in the future plans. There should always be a better single card solution, and you could sell your old card to help offset the cost.

The 8800GT is an exception to this rule, BUT the other updated cards aren't out yet.

If you want Intel and SLI, go with either the eVGA NF67-A1/T1 or NF68-A1/T1.

If you don't need SLI, then stick to a P35 board, since they're more stable and OC better. Some P35 boards to check out are the Abit IP35-E, IP35, IP35 Pro (crowd favorite), Asus P5K, P5K-E, and Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3L, DS3R, DS3P, DS4.
 
You currently have an ATI vidcard with an SLI mobo... do you really need SLI? What size monitor do you have?

SLI is only needed for high resolution 3D rendering. So, if you have or plan on getting a 1920x1080 LCD or higher, and want to game on it at native resolution, then keep SLI as an option. Otherwise, theres no need for it. SLI as an upgrade path isn't worth it unless, again, a large LCD is in the future plans. There should always be a better single card solution, and you could sell your old card to help offset the cost.

The 8800GT is an exception to this rule, BUT the other updated cards aren't out yet.

If you want Intel and SLI, go with either the eVGA NF67-A1/T1 or NF68-A1/T1.

If you don't need SLI, then stick to a P35 board, since they're more stable and OC better. Some P35 boards to check out are the Abit IP35-E, IP35, IP35 Pro (crowd favorite), Asus P5K, P5K-E, and Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3L, DS3R, DS3P, DS4.

oh shit u listed alot! thanks bro.. been hearing this motherboard GA-P35-DS3L have problems? correct me if im wrong.. i was actually considering on getting this gigabyte board since its like 100 bucks! cheapest out of all the ones u listed i think.. well in canada anyways.. and aE4400 (local BST site lists for $120 same with a E6320)

well right now i have a 19inch LCD so 1280x1024.. but ill defintly move to a 22inch or 24 if prices go down by then.. I want to build this PC and just hold of upgrading for a year.. ive lost so much money buying and reselling stuff.. but thats how technology goes.. i just want to build something right now.. and stick with it until really necessary.. i dont want to go back to my old ways.. P35 is a crossfire chipset? if yes, will that hinder a nvidia card's performance? ive lost track of hardware lol my last good system was a 4200+ SLI DR and 2x7900GTOs..

what im really contemplating on doing is to sell my 3500+.. get an OEM 4200+ from Tigerdirect (only one in canada that has it) and a good 2G kit.. hopefully that'd be a good move.. most FPS games are more gfx right? less on the CPU.. but RTS games are more CPU? im more into FPS for sure.. but of course occasional C&C and SC2 of course when it comes out
 
The DS3L is a good board... no more problems than other boards. No company has perfect quality control. A good alternative to the DS3L is the Abit IP35-E, which is priced similarly. Make sure the board you choose has the features you need. Don't buy a board with features you'll never use unless you don't mind needlessly spending the money.

I think the 4200+ s939 would last you at least another year. You're right about games/cpu usage/gpu usage -- but the trend may be changing in the future.

If you think you'll get a 24" LCD, be prepared to spend a bit more for better vidcards in the future. 22" LCDs are the sweet spot right now for price and not needing as much GPU power.

You have to decide if you want to sell your old stuff and use that money for a new build, or just upgrade your old stuff. You could still sell the parts you plan on replacing, to help offset the cost. However, I don't think that dual core will last you much longer than a year, as far as gaming goes -- though, I may be wrong.
 
The DS3L is a good board... no more problems than other boards. No company has perfect quality control. A good alternative to the DS3L is the Abit IP35-E, which is priced similarly. Make sure the board you choose has the features you need. Don't buy a board with features you'll never use unless you don't mind needlessly spending the money.

I think the 4200+ s939 would last you at least another year. You're right about games/cpu usage/gpu usage -- but the trend may be changing in the future.

If you think you'll get a 24" LCD, be prepared to spend a bit more for better vidcards in the future. 22" LCDs are the sweet spot right now for price and not needing as much GPU power.

You have to decide if you want to sell your old stuff and use that money for a new build, or just upgrade your old stuff. You could still sell the parts you plan on replacing, to help offset the cost. However, I don't think that dual core will last you much longer than a year, as far as gaming goes -- though, I may be wrong.

i think ill just do the AM2 upgrade :( i found a 4200+ for $60.. then i need a board and ram and reuse my other stuff

that'll be good for now..

thanks for everyone that have helped! greatly appreciated
 
Back
Top