Need Advice on Moderate Gaming Rig

Trepidati0n

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Oct 26, 2004
Messages
9,269
Lets see how does this go...My wife's mother's best friend mom's son wants me to build him a rig. His last one just went poof (7 years was enough I guess). They were about to do the foolish thing and buy a pre-built rig in that price range which I well know is a gold mine…for the vendors that is (i.e. charging nearly $150 for a 8600 GT).

The criteria:

1. Do not need keyboard/monitor/mouse/printer
2. Must have DVD burner
3. Must be less than $1k (well, didn't I make this easy).
4. Should have moderate gaming ability (only a 1280x1024 LCD monitor via VGA).
5. NO OC'ing.

However I have two problems.

1. It is her money (not his)
2. He is a computer user and not an enthusiast (i.e. would he actually realize the diff between a $1k rig and a $600 rig?).
2. My focus is usually in the $1000-$1500 range for a home rig.

What I came up was:

Cooler Master Centurion = $71 shipped
CORSAIR 450W = $60 (after rebate)
500GB HDD = $100

Intel Core 2 Duo E6750 Conroe 2.66GHz = $190
GIGABYTE GA-P35-DS3 = $90
2GB of DDR 800 Memory = $40 (or 1066 for $50)

9600GT = $140 (after rebate)
Random DVD Burner = $40

Vista 32 Prem OEM = $100

Total = ~$700

Is there anything I could reasonably shave off this to reduce cost and still maintain similar performance? My typical shopping place is the egg just for simplicity (i.e. my time is pretty valuable) but I will buy at other locations. Thanks in advance.
 
hell you can get 8800gt for a few bucks more AR these days, why not go for it? You could probably go with a smaller hd, a 4x00 series cpu maybe, but thats all I can think of.
 
Out of curiosity, which Centurion case did you choose?

Actually, what you have so far looks pretty good.
 
Intel Core 2 Duo E6750 Conroe 2.66GHz = $190

Just say no to that one. If you are in the $200 range, get a Q6600 or a E8400. Buying an E6750 is a horrible waste of money.

I would also reccomend getting 4GB of RAM. Vista performs much better with 4GB (however on a 32 bit OS, you will only get ~3.5GB, however its still much better). Especially since the person who will be getting the system sounds like a pretty average PC user, Vista turns into a slow pile of crap once you load it up with various software then game on it.
 
hell you can get 8800gt for a few bucks more AR these days, why not go for it? You could probably go with a smaller hd, a 4x00 series cpu maybe, but thats all I can think of.

At 1280x1024...I think the 8800GT might jsut be too much. And a few more bucks is about $40 IIRC. It is tempting..something I would definately do. But in terms of a value proposition to the person with the money..I can't quite do that.

Out of curiosity, which Centurion case did you choose?

Actually, what you have so far looks pretty good.

This --> http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16811119106

And Thanks

Just say no to that one. If you are in the $200 range, get a Q6600 or a E8400. Buying an E6750 is a horrible waste of money.

I would also reccomend getting 4GB of RAM. Vista performs much better with 4GB (however on a 32 bit OS, you will only get ~3.5GB, however its still much better). Especially since the person who will be getting the system sounds like a pretty average PC user, Vista turns into a slow pile of crap once you load it up with various software then game on it.

Thanks for the headsup on the E8x00 series...For some reason I totally glossed over that (i.e. brain farted). The value proposition is much better on those especially considering he would like to make some DVD's.

Also good call on the RAM. I think you are 100% correct. I have no doubt he will "bloat" his system overtime. The extra 2GB should keep the phone calls away for a bit longer.

----------

EDIT: Is the faster RAM worth it if not OC'ing?
 
Good choice on the case. If you need additional fans (or want to replace the stock ones) for the case, pick up some Yate Loon low-speed or medium-speed fans.

And if you're not overclocking, don't worry about getting RAM faster than DDR2 800. You can find a decent 4GB kit of DDR2 800 RAM for as low as $70. However, to fully utilize all 4GB of memory, you'll need a 64-bit operating system. (Vista Home Premium is the same price for both the 32-bit and the 64-bit versions.)

Here's a relatively inexpensive DVD burner -- the Samsung SH-S203B ($27 with free shipping).

And to save you some more money, here are some deals on some good 400W-550W power supplies:

Antec EarthWatts 430W PSU - $59.99 (free shipping) or $69.99 (free shipping)
Corsair VX450 450W PSU - $69.99 (free shipping) or $74.99 ($15 mail-in rebate)
Seasonic SS-500ES 500W PSU - $69.99 (free shipping)
PC Power & Cooling Silencer 470 470W PSU - $74.99 (free shipping)
Antec EarthWatts 500W PSU - $74.24 (free shipping) or $79.99 (free shipping & $30 mail-in rebate)
Corsair VX550 550W PSU - $84.99 (free shipping) or $88.90 (free shipping & $10 mail-in rebate)
Seasonic S12 II SS-500GB 500W PSU - $85.99 (free shipping)
 
At 1280x1024...I think the 8800GT might jsut be too much. And a few more bucks is about $40 IIRC. It is tempting..something I would definately do. But in terms of a value proposition to the person with the money..I can't quite do that.
orly? at that rez, the smaller memory size versions would be perfect for him. the 512mb versions have several deals up right now for 159 ar.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814130082
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814125089


I guess I thought you were trying to spend less money on this thing, or I would have suggested more ram :) I can't believe I didn't have 4gb sooner myself
 
Thanks for the comments....very much appreciated.

For the 64 bit OS...I have that myself personally. However, my guess is this PC will be replaced in about 3 years or so. If I had to put my thumb out and guess whether or not he will go beyond 4GB of RAM...my answer would probably have to be a no.

As for the DVD burner, added to the cart.

As for the video card...it is an interesting proposition. Guess I should be happy that there are so many good cards with a decent strata of prices with corresponding performance.
 
IIRC, you'll need an additional 120mm fan for the Centurion 534. Pick up a Yate Loon linked in tiraides' post above.

He's not an enthusiast, not really an avid gamer, and you describe him as an avg user. Therefore, a pre-built would be good for him if he scores a good deal. Here's an example:

gotapex.com said:
Inspiron 530 Mini Desktop with Core 2 Quad Q6600, 3GB DDR2, 500GB HD, and Vista Home Premium for $499 w/ Free Shipping

If he wanted better gaming performance, he could just add a 9600GT for ~$150. It comes with a 300W PSU which should be enough for such a setup; worst case is he needs a better PSU, which is only around $50. Thats $650 or $700 for a quad core gaming system for an avg user. A quick reinstall of the OS or use PC Decrapifier and he's ready to go. I'm pretty sure the Dell will last 3+ years. So, by going with a Dell, he gets 2 more CPU cores and an extra 1GB of RAM (compared to the build in your OP). The drawback is he can't OC, but you said he won't be OC'ing anyhow.
 
He's not an enthusiast, not really an avid gamer, and you describe him as an avg user. Therefore, a pre-built would be good for him if he scores a good deal. Here's an example:

Snip

Excellent points. will definately be a factor. BTW, could you PM me a link to the Dell rig. Thanks in advance.
 
You might as well follow through with your original plans (plus our suggestions, of course...). ;)
 
Yah, the Fry's deal on the Q6600 makes it very affordable, IMO. So, just build it... unless of course you bought that CPU for yourself. :p
 
Back
Top